1883 Scottish Cup final

Notes

Both clubs were short of their first choice XI for the final; left-wing forward M'Kinnon was missing for Dumbarton, which resulted in Dumbarton changing to a 2–3–5 formation,[4] while Vale was without forwards Brown and Logan. Hampden had temporary stands for the expected big crowd, but the attendance of 15,000 was beyond expectation, and at one end of the ground, just as the game kicked off, a railing collapsed, throwing several fans onto the pitch.

A strong wind affected the game, making it less open than anticipated. Dumbarton kicked with the wind in the first half but tended to overshoot, not having gauged the full effect of the wind, although a long shot from Lindsay struck the post and went wide. The deadlock was broken on the half-hour, a free-kick for a McLeish handball 4 yards from the posts being knocked back to Paton, who chipped over McLintock's head. Dumbarton only held the lead for five minutes, failing to play to the referee's decision after claiming a foul, which allowed Johnstone to run through with little opposition and score with ease.

Dumbarton took the lead just before half-time, McArthur scoring in high off the right-hand post,[5] but Vale, now playing with the wind, dominated the second, only the excellence of M'Aulay keeping the goal clear until the Vale "by a combined rush" equalized in the 70th minute, the goal being credited to Gillies,[6] and although Vale pressed for the remainder of the game, the match ended 2–2. Friel was considered the best of the Vale forwards, while the Dumbarton weak link was James Miller, who "shows an unfortunate disposition to quarrel".[7][8]

M'Kinnon was expected to have recovered enough from injury to take his place in the forward line,[9] but in the end had not recovered enough, and Dumbarton shuffled tactics, bringing in Anderson from the reserves to revert to 2–2–6, Lang being the unlucky man to lose his half-back place.

With a slight wind behind them in the first half, the Vale used the accurate long passing of Forbes to keep pressure on Dumbarton, but the first half had few chances, most of the threats to goal coming from scrimmages; the closest however anyone came to scoring was a McPherson shot that went so close to the post that many spectators thought it had gone the right side, but the umpires turned down an appeal for a goal.

Almost straight from the kick-off though Dumbarton took the lead; Anderson justified his inclusion by mugging a tardy McPherson, and, after an exchange of passes with R. P. Brown, the latter finished off with a shot in off the post. Dumbarton kept the pressure on with a series of corners, and Johnstone nearly equalized when McCrae led a break and centred to Johnstone, who sent the ball just wide. Shortly after that chance Dumbarton doubled the lead, R.S. Brown putting in a long and speculative shot, which McLintock tried to kick out without handling, but missed the ball entirely.

Rattled, the Vale lost its composure in front of goal, poor passing amongst the forwards preventing it from taking any advantage, until with five minutes remaining Friel scored with a shot that went in off the bar. Johnstone brought out an excellent save from McAulay soon afterwards, but Dumbarton held possession for the final couple of minutes, and were chaired off the field at the call of time.[10][11]

7 April 1883

15:00

Dumbarton	2–1	Vale of Leven
R. P. Brown 47' R. S. Brown 50'	Report	Friel 85'

Hampden Park

Attendance: 15,000

Referee: Thomas Lawrie

One unfortunate aftermath was that the Dumbarton players went on an celebratory excursion to Luss on the following Monday, which saw their vehicles pass through the Vale's home village of Alexandria, the wagons decorated with flags and colours, and accompanied by the sound of trumpets; forewarned of their return, some of the Alexandria locals attacked the vehicles, ripping up the flags and throwing two pails of animal blood taken from Mr Johnstone's butchery at the occupants.[12] What could have been a more dangerous scene was relieved by the arrival of the Vale players, who acted as protection.[13]