1888–89 Everton F.C. season

Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules. Players may hold more than one non-FIFA nationality.

No. Pos. Nation Player — GK  ENG Robert Smalley, 18 appearances — DF  ENG George Dobson, 18 appearances — DF  SCO Nick Ross, 19 appearances — MF  SCO John Weir, 16 appearances — MF  ENG Johnny Holt, 17 appearances — MF  WAL George Farmer, 21 appearances — FW  WAL Joe Davies, 8 appearances at outside right — FW  ENG Robert Watson, 18 appearances at inside right — FW  ENG Frank Sugg, 9 appearances at centre forward — FW  ENG Edgar Chadwick, inside left — FW  ENG James Costley, 6 appearances at outside left

Teams at the time played a 2–3–5 formation. Thus, Dobson and Ross were "full-backs" while Weir, Holt, and Farmer were "halfbacks". However, Everton fielded by far the most unsettled side of all the twelve original Football League members, using thirty-five players in their twenty-two game campaign. Indeed, the club have never fielded more players in any season since, despite having played as many as twenty league games more in over fifty subsequent seasons. So inconsistent was their team selection that at no time did the above combination actually take the field. Not surprisingly Everton's best result of the season, a 6–2 victory over Derby County on 20 October 1888 was achieved with ten of the above players on the field. Robert Watson missed that game while his deputy, Alex McKinnon scored the only hat-trick obtained by an Everton player all season. This was the only game in which ten of the first eleven featured.

• Alec Dick (9 appearances – right back)
• David Waugh (7 apps – inside right)
• William Brown (6 apps – outside left)
• Alex McKinnon (6 apps – outside right)
• Alf Milward (6 apps – centre forward)
• Jack Angus (5 apps at outside left)
• George Fleming (4 apps – outside right)
• Charles Jolliffe (4 apps – goalkeeper)
• Wiliam Lewis (3 apps – centre forward)
• William Briscoe (3 apps – inside left)
• Albert Chadwick (2 apps – left back)
• Jas Coyne (2 apps – inside right)
• George Davie (2 apps – centre forward)
• Mike Higgins (1 app – centre half)
• Robert Jones (1 app – centre back)
• Bob Kelso (1 app – centre back),
• Jack Keys (1 app – centre forward)
• R Morris (1 app – centre forward)
• Henry Parkinson (1 app – centre half)
• Hugh Pollock (1 app – centre back)
• Roberts (1 app – centre back)
• George Stephenson (1 app – centre back)
• Harry Warmby (1 app – centre back)
• Walter Wilson (1 app – left back)

Note that position listed is that filled most commonly by the player during this season and may not always have been the role played.

• http://www.evertonfc.com/stats/?mode=players&era_id=1&season_id=2&seasons=2 Archived 17 February 2012 at the Wayback Machine
• http://www.allfootballers.com