2019 Cherokee Nation principal chief election

Hoskin won the election with 57.93% of the vote. Lay received 27.34% while Walkingstick, whose name was on ballot but was disqualified after absentee and early voting had begun, took 14.73%.[1] Despite being disqualified, votes for Walkingstick were tallied to determine whether or not a runoff would be needed. Nearly 14,000 ballots were cast in the election. In the race for Deputy Chief, Bryan Warner defeated former Tribal Council Speaker Meredith Frailey 58.88% to 41.12%.[9] (Although candidates for principal chief and deputy chief run together, they are voted upon separately.)

Walkingstick controversy

Cherokee Nation elections are officially non-partisan, but the 2019 elections had heavy partisan overtones, with Walkingstick criticizing Hoskin and incumbent Baker's ties to the Democratic Party and calling for the Cherokee Nation to distance itself from Democrats.[10] Walkingstick had early in the campaign expressed concerns about oversight, and called for federal officials to monitor the 2019 elections.[11]

Despite Cherokee law allowing campaign contributions only from individuals, a political action committee, Cherokees for Change LLC, was established by one of Walkingstick's campaign associates. Cherokees for Change argued that its funding and actions were allowed following the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling in Citizens United v. FEC.[12] The Cherokee Nation Election Commission disagreed and on May 6 ordered Cherokees for Change to cease its efforts to influence the election, which it determined to be in violation of tribal law.[13] Although Walkingstick claimed no coordination existed between the PAC and his campaign, election officials determined he had violated tribal law and accepted donations from corporate entities on May 17.[14] Walkingstick was disqualified from the election, although his name remained on the ballot. The Cherokee Supreme Court upheld the disqualification on May 29.[10] Walkingstick subsequently threw his support behind Lay.[4] Because Walkingstick was disqualified at such a late date, his name remained on the ballot; however, votes cast for him were not counted.[10][15]

Cherokee Futures LLC

During the 2019 election, Cherokee Future LLC was an Oklahoma Domestic Limited Liability Company owned by Chuck Hoskin Sr, the father of then Principal Chief Candidate Chuck Hoskin Jr and registered to an empty lot in Hoskin's home town of Vinta. The Hoskin/Warner campaign and several tribal council candidates showed significant spending of their campaign budget to the Cherokee Future. The Hoskin/Warner campaign reported $574,016.42 as miscellaneous campaign expenditures going to Cherokee Future LLC. And of that amount, $375,000 is noted as consultant fees, while the advertisement expenditure for the first two financial reporting periods was $7,499.[16] Despite numerous complaints filed with the Cherokee Nation Election Commission, no action was taken by the Election Commission. Ultimately, the Election Commission's lack of action led to a twin lawsuit before the Cherokee Nation Supreme Court, Lay v CN Election Commission and Frailey v CN Election Commission.[17] Ultimately the twin suits were unsuccessful in overturning the election.

Following the June 1 election, Lay and Frailey petitioned the Cherokee Nation Supreme Court to set aside the results and to order a new election.[18] The petitioners accused the winning candidates of accepting illegal in-kind contributions and other campaign finance violations;[19] however, the Cherokee Supreme Court found the complaints to be without merit.[20]

• Hoskin–Warner campaign site
• Dick Lay for Principal Chief Facebook page
• Walkingstick–Frailey campaign site Archived 2019-06-01 at the Wayback Machine