Fear of a Blank Planet

Steven Wilson started writing the album in early 2006 in Tel Aviv, while he was recording the second Blackfield album. One of the first songs that Wilson wrote for the album during this period, called "Always Recurring" (which is an unreleased track), would later be recycled lyrically and sonically, for use in the track "What Happens Now?". In the meantime, while Wilson was in Tel Aviv, Richard Barbieri wrote most of the music for the song "My Ashes". "Cheating the Polygraph" was a Harrison/Wilson composition whilst "Way Out of Here", "What Happens Now?" and "Nil Recurring" were written by all four band members. The Blackfield album was finished in June, so Wilson travelled back to London and met the other band members to work on the material he had been writing. These sessions took place between July and August and produced a good number of songs from which just six were picked for the record.[4]

Porcupine Tree's first DVD, entitled Arriving Somewhere..., was released in August of the same year. The band started a short tour in September to promote it, during which the six new songs selected for the forthcoming album were performed at the first half of the shows.[1] Along the tour, which lasted until November, the band began recording the album, eventually rejecting the song "Cheating the Polygraph" since they felt it was somewhat weak when compared to the other five of the live set list; they wrote a new song called "Way Out of Here" to replace it.[5] "Way Out of Here" was a collaboration between all band members and resulted in the only full-band composition of the record. They contacted King Crimson's guitarist Robert Fripp, who provided soundscapes to the song[6] as well as lead guitar for the track "Nil Recurring", an instrumental song not included in the album but later released in the EP of the same name (which also included "Cheating the Polygraph").[7]

Around the time of the recording, Wilson read an interview in Classic Rock magazine in which Rush's guitarist Alex Lifeson had mentioned he was a big fan of Porcupine Tree. Wilson quickly got in touch with Alex to ask him if he would like to play on the album. Lifeson was pleased to contribute[6] so Wilson wrote a section of the song "Anesthetize" for him to play a solo on. Alex recorded the solo in his own studio and sent it to Wilson.

The album recording process was finished in December of the same year.[4] In January 2007 it was revealed that the album title would be Fear of a Blank Planet.[3]

The concept of the album was heavily influenced by Bret Easton Ellis' novel Lunar Park.[8] The novel is told from the perspective of a father, who bears the name of the novel's author himself, whereas the album is mostly from his son's perspective, an eleven-year-old kid named Robby.[9] Many of the lyrics for Fear of a Blank Planet are lifted directly from the novel; this is particularly evident in "My Ashes", which is a homage to the last chapter, in which the ashes of Bret's father are scattered and cover the memories of his life.

The lyrics deal with two typical neurobehavioural developmental disorders affecting teenagers in the 21st century: bipolar disorder and attention deficit disorder. It also deals with other common behaviour tendencies of youth like escapism through prescription drugs, social alienation caused by technology, and a feeling of vacuity—a product of information overload by the mass media. In an interview with Revolver magazine, Wilson described the main character of the story as "...this kind of terminally bored kid, anywhere between 10 and 15 years old, who spends all his daylight hours in his bedroom with the curtains closed, playing on his PlayStation, listening to his iPod, texting his friends on his cell phone, looking at hardcore pornography on the Internet, downloading music, films, news, violence..."[10]

The songs on Fear of a Blank Planet seem to have a connection not just between the lyrics but also musically; every track flows into the next, comprising a single fifty-minute piece of music.[11] Wilson said the idea was to make an album that could be listened to in one sitting, in contrast to some bands tendency to make very long records that do not maintain the attention of the listener.[10] He described Fear of a Blank Planet as a homage to 1970s records, whose moderate length helps the listener maintain focus:

"It was very much conceived in the way bands used to conceive records in the '70s, where you've got two sides of vinyl, and you can lay down a piece of music which is around the 50-minute mark, which plays in a continuous way, and deals with the same subject matter, and tried to kind of immerse you in a world for that time. That's always been the Porcupine Tree way, but we've definitely taken it to the next level."[12]

A few days after the mixing and recording processes were finished, Wilson unveiled the 5.1 mix edition of the album at two listening parties at New York's Legacy Studios,[2] and at London's Abbey Road Studios,[3] where the official track list was finally unveiled. Additionally, there was a third pre-release listening party without the presence of Steven Wilson in the Club Phoenix of Brisbane later on 14 April, organised by OzProg.com along with Roadrunner Records.[13] A medley of the album tracks was posted to the band's MySpace page and the Fear of a Blank Planet microsite on 21 February. Then on 6 March, the title track was released in the US iTunes Store as a bonus track with Blackfield II, the second album from Wilson's side-project Blackfield. On 12 April, the CD came out in parts of Europe four days earlier than intended, and was soon leaked onto the internet.[6]

"Sentimental" was NPR's "Song of the Day" on 4 June.[14]

On 6 August, on their official website, Porcupine Tree announced a new EP was going to be released on 17 September the same year named Nil Recurring, featuring four tracks (just under 30 minutes of music) that were written during the Fear of a Blank Planet sessions, including the title track featuring Robert Fripp on guitar, and "Cheating the Polygraph".

The song "My Ashes" was featured in the American television series The Shield in episode #81, entitled "Animal Control", which originally aired on 7 October 2008.[15]

On 18 April 2007, two days after the European release of the album, the band embarked on an extensive tour until the end of the year, with a short break during August and September resuming in October. During the first run of shows, the band played all of the album either in one go, or spread throughout the set. For the second run of shows (after the release of Nil Recurring) this was stopped. Once again, Lasse Hoile worked with the band creating a video to accompany the performance of the whole album.

Porcupine Tree performing at Hamburg, Germany, in 11/29/2007.

Starting in Glasgow, the tour led the band through many major international music festivals such as the twins Hurricane Festival and Southside Festival in Germany, the Download Festival at Donington Park, the Voodoo Music Experience of New Orleans, and the Ilosaarirock Festival in Finland (their first show ever in this country); a radio broadcast from this performance was recorded and later remastered by the band for a release in March 2009 under the title Ilosaarirock, given away to members of the Residents of a Blank Planet ticketing club. Support acts included Pure Reason Revolution,[16] Amplifier[17] and Absynthe Minded[18] across Europe, and 3 for the US.[19] The second leg started in October in North America. Head>>Fake (only in New York City)[20] and 3 (rest of the US and Canada)[21][22] were the supporting bands during this month; that stretch of the tour included their first performance ever in Mexico at the Teatro Metropolitan of Mexico City.[23] Alternative rock band Anathema joined them on tour from November as support for the European gigs[24] that lasted until December (except for Finland were Hidria Spacefolk opened the show).[25] Along 2007, they played 92 dates in total.

The tour continued in April 2008, with their first appearance ever in Australia, where they played three consecutive dates from 25 to 27 April in Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane respectively. They performed at the Dutch Pinkpop Festival on 30 May, the Rocksound Festival of Switzerland on 6 June, the Austrian Nova Rock Festival on 13 June, the Hellfest Summer Open Air in France on 21 June and the Finnish Ruisrock on 4 July 2008. Shortly after they played for the first time in Russia, on 6 July at the B1 Club of Moscow. Thereafter in October the band started a brief European tour, during which a second official DVD was shot. The filming took place along two consecutive shows on 15 and 16 October, in Tilburg, the Netherlands, at the 013 venue.[26] This was the final leg for the Fear of a Blank Planet tour and included their first performance ever as headliners in Portugal. Oceansize opened for the UK shows.

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	82/100[27]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[28]
Aquarian Weekly	A+[11]
Classic Rock	[29]
Drowned in Sound	9/10[30]
Metal Storm	9.2/10[31]
Mojo	[32]
musicOMH	[33]
PopMatters	[34]
Rock Hard	10/10[35]
Sputnikmusic	[36]

The album was critically acclaimed at release, receiving an average rating of 82 out of 100 on Metacritic, based on nine reviews.[37] Q magazine regarded the album as "a dramatic, wide-screen, expertly executed, even genuinely thrilling rock record worthy of an audience way beyond nu-prog's regular constituency."[37] AllMusic, which gave the album a 4.5 out of 5 score, assured that "While there is no "radio single" on the disc most songs transcend their complex structure and feel as provocative as any traditional rock tune".[38] David Fricke from Rolling Stone perceived Porcupine Tree to have evolved into "an aggressively modern merger of Rush’s arena art rock, U.K. prog classicism—especially Pink Floyd’s eulogies to madness and King Crimson’s angular majesty—and the post-grunge vengeance of Tool".[39] Greg Kot from Chicago Tribune described the sound as "stellar in its serpentine mood-shifting".[40] Sound and Vision praised the album as the band's finest work: "Porcupine Tree is at the height of its powers"[41] and voted it #3 CD of 2007.[42]

Decibel lauded: "Porcupine Tree prove they can play with the best of 'em".[43] The Phoenix newspaper stated "Fear of a Blank Planet is not only their most vintage-sounding album, it’s also their best",[44] Jim DeRogatis from the Chicago Sun-Times thought the album was "easily as strong as any of the band's previous eight releases, and the most timely", and Revolver magazine proclaimed "England’s prog princes return at their most limber and conceptually relevant".[45] PopMatters placed it at #5 of "The Best Metal Albums of 2007".[46] Reason magazine chose it as one of the "Best Albums of 2007" though they were more severe than other critics about the lyrical content, saying, "lyrically, it's ridiculous" and "if your grandma was theming a prog rock album, it'd come out something like this".[47] Dan LeRoy from Alternative Press announced it "as heavy as P-Tree have ever been" but "wistfully, sprawlingly melodic as well-sometimes in the same tune" and concluded that "if Wilson's vision of today's kids as overmedicated, overstimulated robots seems like a blatant appeal to the over-30 crowd, it's still worth setting the Xbox aside to listen".[48]

Steven Wilson live with Porcupine Tree at Arena, Poznan, Poland. 28 November 2007.

The album did well commercially. With Fear of a Blank Planet, the band broke the selling mark established by Deadwing, and reached the Top 100 of the Billboard 200 for the first time, debuting at #59. The album also entered the European Top 100 Albums at #21,[49] and charted the Top 40 in the UK, Germany, Netherlands, Italy, Finland, Norway, Sweden and Poland. The special edition limited to 10,000 copies was sold out worldwide within the same day of its release.[50] The album has sold 250,000 copies worldwide.[51]

Special edition

In addition to the regular issue, a special two-disc edition was released, containing both Stereo and 5.1 Surround Sound mixes plus a forty-page booklet. This limited edition of 10,000 copies was sold out the day of its release.[50][63]

Vinyl edition

The 2LP vinyl edition was released through Tonefloat Records; there is a standard edition on 180g black vinyl in a gatefold sleeve and a special edition (limited to 1000 copies) on black/blue marbled vinyl packaged in a numbered slipcase with a 12x12" 16-page booklet. The vinyl edition has a slightly different track listing[64] and includes the Nil Recurring EP. There is also a special pink vinyl edition limited to 500 copies released on 1 May 2008, to coincide with the band's recent appearance at the Pinkpop festival in the Netherlands. This was originally provided to Dutch record stores only[65] but was made available for purchase from the band's online store for a very limited run from 14 June 2008. The stock lasted less than five days.

Side one

Side two

Side three

Side four[66]

DVD-A edition

A Grammy nominated special limited edition audiophile 5.1 Surround Sound version released on the band's own Transmission label, featuring the 5.1 mix of the album in advanced resolution/MLP lossless 5.1 surround, DTS 5.1 digital surround sound, and 24 bit stereo, as well as all 4 tracks from the Nil Recurring mini album in surround sound. The disc also includes three video works directed by Lasse Hoile: a special Blank Planet Introduction short film, the uncensored version of the "Fear of a Blank Planet" promo video, and the full length 17-minute film for "Anesthetize" as seen during the band's live shows.

Audio content[67]

Video material[67]

Porcupine Tree

• Steven Wilson – vocals, guitars, piano, keyboards
• Richard Barbieri – keyboards and synthesizers
• Colin Edwin – bass guitars
• Gavin Harrison – drums

Additional musicians

• Alex Lifeson – guitar solo on "Anesthetize"
• Robert Fripp – soundscapes on "Way Out of Here"
• John Wesley – backing vocals
• London Session Orchestra – orchestra

Production

• Porcupine Tree – producers
• Steven Wilson – mixing, audio mastering, string arrangements
• Dave Stewart – string arrangements
• Steve Price – engineer
• Lasse Hoile – photography

• Official Porcupine Tree homepage
• Porcupine Tree's MySpace