Blue Lakes (California)

The Blue Lakes are in the Cache Creek watershed in northwestern Lake County, about 7 miles (11 km) west of Upper Lake. Their drainage basin comprises the upper northwest section of the Cache Creek basin.[1] They are at an elevation of 1,358 feet (414 m).[2] Upper Blue Lake is about 1,361 feet (415 m) above sea level, covers about 55 acres (22 ha) and contains about 3,960 acre-feet (4,880,000 m³) of water.[1] Lower Blue Lake is shallower and covers 53 acres (21 ha).[3] The Köppen climate classification is Csb : Warm-summer Mediterranean climate.[4]

The Blue Lakes as a whole have a length of about 3 miles (4.8 km) and a breadth of 1⁄2 mile (0.80 km).[5] They form a line running in a northeast direction down to Scotts Creek, which drains into Clear Lake. The upper two lakes are connected by a wide channel, and are known collectively as Blue Lake or Upper Blue Lake. The settlement of Midlakes lies between Blue Lake and Lower Blue Lake, which is connected by a short channel to Scotts Creek. California State Route 20 runs along the northeast shore of the lakes.[6]

Valley holding Cold Creek (NW) and Blue Lakes (SE)

The Clear Lake basin lies between the watersheds of the Sacramento River and the Russian River. When it was formed about 600,000 years ago it drained east into the Sacramento Valley. About 200,000 years ago the Clear Lake Volcanic Field blocked its outlet.[7] The lake rose until it found a new outlet, draining west through the Blue Lakes into Cold Creek and the Russian River.[8] At some time in the last 10,000 years a landslide at the west end of the Blue Lakes blocked this outlet, the lake rose again, and created its present outlet via Cache Creek to the Sacramento River.[9]

The gradual mountain pass between Cold Creek basin and Upper Blue Lake is called Da-no lokj'tam, or "mountain fell-in", by the Northern Pomo.[10] They have a legend that water from Clear Lake once drained west through the Blue Lakes, then through Cold Creek into Coyote Valley and the Russian River. Then there was a great earthquake and a huge landslide blocked the flow out of Clear Lake. The land was forced up, and Clear Lake began to drain to the east through Cache Creek. This is plausible, since there have been tectonic events in the region and Clear Lake is 600 feet (180 m) higher than the Ukiah Valley.[11]

An 1891 account gave more detail: "At the head of the upper lake, just on the western line of the county, is a break in the mountain line which encloses Lake County like the rim of a basin. On the west of this gap Cold Creek heads, and flows down to Russian River, which comes from Potter Valley, twenty miles farther north, and goes on south into Sonoma, turning west to the Pacific. The older Indians tell of a time in the days that were, when the waters of the Blue Lakes, and probably of Clear lake also, pursued this path to the ocean. At present the drainage line is almost due east, by way of Cache Creek and the Sacramento River. The Indians say that the ridge was raised after three days of earthquake. The whole district shows evidences of volcanic action, and has many singular geological features and numerous mineral springs."[12]

According to Professor Ruliff Stephen Holway (1907) the waters of Blue Lakes and Scotts Creek once drained into Russian River by way of Cold Creek, but in recent prehistorical times a large landslide formed a ridge that diverted these waters to Clear Lake.[13][lower-alpha 1] This could account for the relatively mature profile of Cold Creek.[14][lower-alpha 2]

Blue Lakes ca1910 by Michael Rieder (1868-1949)

An 1890 account by the State Mineralogist said,

I observe first, that the canyon itself [Blue Lakes Canyon] is very deep, its sides also being very steep; it is furthermore very narrow. The Blue Lakes themselves are usually called three in number, although the two upper ones are connected by a narrow strait. They are beautiful little sheets of water lying in the bottom of the narrow canyon, whose sides come down almost precipitously to the water's edge. They are said to be very deep. I estimated the lower one to be a little less than a mile in length, with a maximum width of perhaps a quarter of a mile. The two upper lakes are probably each of them from half to three quarters of a mile in length, and as already stated, are connected so as to form in reality a single sheet of water.[16]

An 1891 description said,

The Blue Lakes are two of the most charming lakes in the State. They lie at the bottom of a long, deep valley which rises with almost precipitous sides from the water; intense blue is surrounded by the perpetual green of the dark coniferous forest about them. No streams flow into these lakes, nor is there any outlet except in the rainy season, when the short mountain torrents cause them to overflow, across a low neck of land, into a small lake, Tulé, and so on into Clear Lake. Springs in the bottom of the lakes doubtless supply them, and they are heavily stocked with speckled trout, perch, "silver-sides," and other species of fish.[17]

A mineral springs resort was founded at Blue Lakes, visited both by the sick for cures and by the wealthy and fashionable as summer resorts.[5] The Blue Lakes Hotel could accommodate 40-50 guests, and had a white sulphur spring on its 320 acres (130 ha) grounds. The neighboring forests had plentiful game, including deer, rabbits, quail and pigeons.[18] Resorts in 1892 included Laurel Dell, a Swiss cottage on a grassy flat on the lower lake with smaller corrages around it, the Blue Lakes Hotel, with a hotel and several pretty cottages, where the upper lake flowed into the lower in a lawn-like expanse of grassland with clumps of gnarled and moss-covered oak, and Le Trianon, a very prettily situated hotel at the upper end of the upper lake.[19]

Map of the lakes, Scotts Creek to the south

The Blue Lakes today are highly altered and have lost the majority of their native fishes.[20] They are surrounded by housing which reduces shoreline habitat and contributes pollutants.[21] In 2019 anatoxin was detected in the Blue Lakes, but later tests showed no sign of the toxin, so warning signs were removed in January 2020.[22] Lower Blue Lake, like Clear Lake, is eutrophic, alkaline with a pH of c. 8, and fairly turbid with a Secchi depth less than 2 metres (6 ft 7 in). Upper Blue Lake, in contrast, is clear and cool.[23]

The aboriginal people of the region had a legend that a monster fish, or water dragon, lived in the Upper Blue Lake, and therefore never camped close to the lake. In the 1870s the newspapers reported various sightings of this monster.[24] Clear Lake prickly sculpin are only found in Clear Lake and in Upper and Lower Blue lakes.[25] Clear Lake tule perch are endemic to Clear Lake, Lower Blue Lake and Upper Blue Lake. Its populations seem to have dropped to very low levels in Clear Lake and they are probably absent from Lower Blue Lake, but they are still common in Upper Blue Lake.[20]

The inland silverside (Menidia beryllina) was introduced from Lake Texoma, Oklahoma, into the Blue Lakes and Clear Lake in 1967 to test its effectiveness in controlling the Clear Lake gnat and chironomid midges. About 6,000 fish were released in Upper Blue Lake and 3,000 in Lower Blue Lake and Clear Lake. Within a year the silversides were abundant in Lower Blue Lake and Clear Lake. They have since been widely distributed in California through experimental introductions by the Department of Fish and Game, illegal introductions by bait fishermen and dispersal via man-made waterways.[26]

A general survey of fish along the shoreline of Upper Blue Lake was conducted in June 2014. Fish collected included common carp (Cyprinus carpio), bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus), largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides), rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss), green sunfish (Lepomis cyanellus), prickly sculpin (Cottus asper) and brown bullhead (Ameiurus nebulosus).[1] Of 376 fish caught, 342 were largemouth bass, followed by bluegill (12), common carp (11), green sunfish (9), and one specimen each of brown bullhead, prickly sculpin and rainbow trout.[27]

The Le Trianon Resort sign at the Blue Lakes in Upper Lake, California in 2023.

Residents of Upper Lake or Lakeport are a short drive away. There are campsites and more upscale lodgings for longer stays.. There is a speed limit of 5 miles per hour (8.0 km/h) on the lakes. Visitors can swim or fish in the lakes, or use kayaks, canoes or paddle boards. Apart from bass and bluegill, the waters are regularly stocked with rainbow trout.[28] Upper Blue Lake is the more popular, since the colder water supports excellent trout and bass fishing, but both lakes hold very large bass. A 12 pounds (5.4 kg) bass has been weighed on a certified scale.[3]