Carroll H. Shilling

During his career, Shilling had two mounts in the Kentucky Derby. He finished second aboard Miami in the 1909 running, then in 1912 he rode Worth to victory in what the National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame describes as probably his most dramatic win.

On November 19, 1909, The New York Times reported that Shilling severely stabbed stable owner R. L. Thomas after the two got into an argument at Sheepshead Bay Race Track. In the spring of 1910, The Jockey Club (the New York-based association of racehorse owners) set aside Shilling's application for a jockey license.

The Hart–Agnew Law, legislation outlawing parimutuel betting, was passed by the New York Legislature which resulted in the closure of all New York racetracks between 1911 and 1912. On November 2, 1911, The New York Times reported that Carroll Shilling and trainer Sam Hildreth had sailed to England aboard the RMS Mauretania with the intent of riding there for the stable of American owner Charles Kohler. On January 9, 1912, The New York Times reported that Kohler was sailing to England and would apply for a license for Shilling to ride there. However, that did not work out and the Times then reported on March 10 that Shilling would ride for Kohler's American stable under trainer David J. Leary.

In an era when jockeys commonly used dirty tactics, Shilling was notorious for his actions. In 1912, while riding at Havre de Grace Racetrack in Maryland, he was banned from racing for striking another jockey with his whip during a race. The action resulted in his riding career ending after just six full years plus two partial years when the New York racing shutdown meant there was fierce competition for jockeys at tracks outside New York state.

Following his ban from riding, Shilling remained in racing as a stableman and in 1915 his application for a jockey's license was again denied. He eventually went to work for J. K. L. Ross, a major stable owner from Canada with racing and breeding operations there and in the United States. As an assistant to trainer H. Guy Bedwell, Shilling helped condition Sir Barton for his 1919 Triple Crown championship and tutored a young jockey named Earl Sande, who would go on to a Hall of Fame career of his own. However, Shilling's suspension from riding remained an issue for many years. On November 11, 1920, The New York Times reported that Ross had successfully petitioned the Maryland State Racing Commission to lift the ban on Shilling and grant him a temporary jockey's license. The Maryland Jockey Club revolted against the decision and the matter became a major public embarrassment for racing when a mob at Pimlico Race Course, who wanted Shilling to race, attacked and beat up Maryland racing commissioner Joseph P. Kennedy. The issue soon involved The Jockey Club (of New York), whose powerful president August Belmont, Jr. lined up against the attempt by Ross to have Shilling reinstated. Bedwell, the Ross stable trainer, had testified before the Maryland State Racing Commission in support of Shilling and he too would become a central figure in the controversy. The April 21, 1921 issue of The New York Times quoted from a letter by Belmont to Ross saying "the entries of your stable will not be acceptable to this association if ex-Jockey Carroll Shilling or H. G. Bedwell is in any way connected, directly or indirectly, with the same."

The issue threatened the closure of Pimlico, the only one of the four Maryland racetracks that sided with the New York authorities. Maryland's governor, Albert Ritchie, got involved as did state senator William I. Norris, who acted as legal counsel for trainer Bedwell. Pimlico president Charles E. McLane then supported Bedwell and the Maryland State Racing Commission threatened to ban members of The Jockey Club from competing in Maryland. The Commission stood its ground and on June 30, 1921, amended their temporary order to grant Shilling a permanent jockey's license. However, the Commission gave in to the unrelenting political pressure to end the inter-state dispute and on July 9, 1921 it passed a resolution that The New York Times said had the effect of making any license issued by the Commission of doubtful value because the resolution declared its licenses not to be a mandate to any of Maryland's racetracks. The effect of the resolution was that Carroll Shilling never rode again and his ordeal led to a severe drinking problem. In their May 17, 1948, edition, Time magazine reported that in recent years he had been in and out of sanitariums.[1] Two years later, Shilling was found dead under a horse van at Belmont Park.[2]

In a short career, Carroll Shilling won 969 races and in his final three seasons, had a remarkable thirty-four percent winning percentage. In 1970, the National Museum of Racing at Saratoga Springs, New York, recognized Schilling's talent and inducted him into their Hall of Fame.

• Carroll H. Shilling at the United States National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame
• "New York Racing to Start On May 20; Suspension Lifted on Jockey Thomas McTaggart -- Other Requests Denied". The New York Times. February 12, 1915. Retrieved 2008-08-14.
• "Shilling Gets No License.; Jockey Club Tables Application of Boy Who Stabbed R.L. Thomas". The New York Times. April 5, 1910. Retrieved 2008-08-14.
• "New York Racing to Start On May 20; Suspension Lifted on Jockey Thomas McTaggart -- Other Requests Denied". The New York Times. February 12, 1915. Retrieved 2008-08-14.
• "To Fight New York Tracks to Finish; Maryland Threatens to Bar Jockey Club Members' Entries as Retaliatory Act. Governor is Drawn in High Officials Resent Ultimatum to Ross in Bedwell Case as High-Handed. Pimlico Meet in Danger Closing of its Gates a Possible Outcome of Turf War--Local Interests Define Position". The New York Times. April 15, 1921. Retrieved 2008-08-14.
• "Bedwell Granted License; Maryland Racing Commission Acts in Horse Trainer's Case". The New York Times. July 9, 1921. Retrieved 2008-08-14.