Christian Connection

James O'Kelly

James O'Kelly was an early advocate of seeking unity through a return to New Testament Christianity.[2]^: 216 In 1792, dissatisfied with the role of bishops in the Methodist Episcopal Church, he separated from that body. O'Kelly's movement, centering in Virginia and North Carolina, was originally called the Republican Methodist Church. In 1794 they adopted the name Christian Church.[3]

During the same period, Elias Smith of Vermont and Abner Jones of New Hampshire led a movement espousing views similar to those of O’Kelly.[4]^: 68[5]^: 190 They believed that members could, by looking to scripture alone, simply be Christians without being bound to human traditions and the denominations that had been brought over from Europe.[4]^: 68[5]^: 190 Working independently at first, Jones and Smith joined together in their efforts and began exclusively using the name Christian.

In 1801, the Cane Ridge Revival led by Barton W. Stone in Kentucky would plant the seed for a movement in Kentucky and the Ohio River valley to disassociate from denominationalism. Stone and five other ministers published The Last Will and Testament of the Springfield Presbytery in 1804, giving up denominational ties to the Presbyterian Church and preferring to be known simply as Christians. Stone was influenced by his earlier involvement with O'Kelly and knew of the Republican Methodist practice of simply using the name Christian.

Ideologically, the New England movement displayed an extreme form of republicanism. Convinced that the American Revolution demanded a thorough and utter break with European modes of operation, members tended to demand radical reform of politics, the legal system, medicine and religion. Elias Smith's career particularly emphasized medical and spiritual reform. All visible forms of church government were to be rejected, he argued, because they were inherently “British”. The movement's nativist approach to theology and church polity imparted a unique flavor to the movement, placing them distinctly on the fringe of early nineteenth-century North American spirituality.

Elias Smith

Elias Smith had heard of the Stone movement by 1804, and the O'Kelly movement by 1808.[5]^: 190 Although not formally merged, the three groups were cooperating and fellowshiping by 1810.[5]^: 190 At that time the combined movement had a membership of approximately 20,000.[5]^: 190 This loose fellowship of churches was called by the names "Christian Connection/Connexion" or "Christian Church."[4]^: 68[5]^: 190

By 1808, O'Kelly's followers and the Smith/Jones movement were cooperating closely, and Stone's Christians in Kentucky would soon follow suit. Adherents' anti-organizational commitments prevent one from referring to “union” per se, at least before the middle of the century. Stone's concept of unity grew from a belief that Christians could extract the Bible's truths by reason, if they approached it without presuppositions. These truths, in turn, would displace human forms of order, leading to the inevitable result that Christians would start “flowing together” and others would come to faith because of the model of unity.[6]

The Connection soon became international, with churches planted in New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Quebec (1811) and Ontario (1821). In each case, the missions were extensions of preaching tours from neighboring American states. Thus all of the Canadian congregations were related to the New England movement. The failed Rebellions of 1837 (led principally by Louis-Joseph Papineau and William Lyon Mackenzie) severely undercut the Connection's Canadian wings. Churches survived solely in Ontario, and mostly north and east of Toronto, Ontario. Conflict between the Connection and the Disciples of Christ also disrupted the former's Canadian growth.

Smith proved to be a controversial figure in the Christian Connection, leaving the denomination for several years to become a Universalist. He publicly renounced Universalism in 1823, but was not well received and reverted to it for a couple of years. Smith tried to re-enter the Connection in 1827 by repudiating Universalism. His brethren were understandably hesitant to accept him, but his home congregation of Portsmouth, New Hampshire received him back in fellowship in 1840.[7]

Barton W. Stone

In 1832, many of the Christian Churches in Kentucky and Tennessee led by Stone united with the churches led by Alexander Campbell. A minority continued to operate within the orbit of the Connection. Of the majority of churches that aligned with the Stone-Campbell movement, many continued to use the name Christian Church, even though they no longer considered themselves part of the Christian Connection. The confusion over names which this created continues. Much of the historiography of this period is driven by the current needs and issues of the successor denominations.

Alexander Campbell

When Stone and Alexander Campbell's Reformers (also known as Disciples and Christian Baptists) united in 1832, only a minority of Christians from the Smith/Jones and O'Kelly movements participated.[5]^: 190 Those who did were from congregations west of the Appalachian Mountains that had come into contact with the Stone movement.[5]^: 190 The eastern members had several key differences with the Stone and Campbell group: an emphasis on conversion experience, quarterly observance of communion, and nontrinitarianism.[5]^: 190

Through the 1830s and 1840s, practical difficulties associated with the movement's attempt at radical reform led to an erosion of the anti-organizational principles developed by Jones, Smith and others. David Millard and Joseph Badger provided leadership towards a more stable form of inter-congregational relationship. Both, at differing times, were editors of the Christian Palladium, a New York State-based religious newspaper that vied with the Herald of Gospel Liberty as the movement's leading periodical. Many of the movement's publications were produced by the Christian Publishing Association, based in Dayton, Ohio.[8]

A disproportionate number of Christian Connection preachers in New England were involved in the eschatological stir fueled by speculations of William Miller. No fewer than seven of the 16 signatories to the 1840 call for an Adventist general conference were Connection preachers. Many members left the Connection in the mid-1840s, populating emerging denominations such as the Seventh-day Adventists and the Advent Christians.

In 1850, the General Convention of the Christian Church passed a resolution calling for the establishment of Antioch College. The college opened in 1852. Notable for its time, the Christian Connection decided that the college "shall afford equal privileges to students of both sexes." The Christian Connection sect wanted the new college to be sectarian, but the planning committee decided otherwise. Antioch College was one of the nation's first colleges to offer the same curriculum to men and women, as well as to admit blacks and operate on a non-sectarian basis.

For the second half of the nineteenth-century, leaders of the Connection pursued a policy of alignment with the mainstream. What had been birthed as a strident protest against staid religiosity was drifting back in that direction. The temperance movement, the Sunday School movement and the Bible societies all served as avenues of service through which Connection members could demonstrate to other denominations the many similarities this cluster of once fringe bodies now shared with the major religious organizations.

The Christian Church merged with the National Council of the Congregational Churches of the United States in 1931 to form the Congregational Christian Churches.[5]^: 191 In 1957 after twenty years of discussion and work, the Congregational Christian Churches and the Evangelical and Reformed Church, itself the product of the merger of two German-American denominations, forged the United Church of Christ.[5]^: 191 In 1989, the UCC and Disciples of Christ agreed to participate in full communion with each other, while remaining separate denominations.

• Restoration Movement

• Centennial of Religious Journalism Dayton, Ohio: Christian Publishing Association, 1908
• Fulop, Timothy Earl “Elias Smith and the Quest for Gospel Liberty: Popular Religion and Democratic Radicalism in Early Nineteenth-Century New England.” Unpublished Doctor of Philosophy thesis, Department of Religion, Princeton University, 1992
• Hammond, Gilbert Romine Album of Christian Ministers, churches and lay workers and colleges, Marshalltown, Iowa: Arme Printing Co., 1915
• Hatch, Nathan O. The Democratization of American Christianity, New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1989
• Humphreys, E.W. Memoirs of Deceased Christian Ministers; or, Brief Sketches of the Lives and Labors of 975 Ministers, Who Died Between 1793 and 1880, Dayton, Ohio: Christian Publishing Association, 1880
• Jennings, Walter Wilson Origin and Early History of the Disciples of Christ, Cincinnati: Standard Publishing, 1919.
• Kenny, Michael G. The Passion of Ansel Bourne: Multiple Personality in American Culture, Washington, District of Columbia: Smithsonian Institution Press, 1986
• Kenny, Michael, G. The Perfect Law of Liberty: Elias Smith and the Providential History of America, Washington and London: Smithsonian Institution Press, 1994
• Kilgore, Charles Francis. The James O'Kelly Schism in the Methodist Episcopal Church, D.F. [Federal District], Mexico: Casa Unida De Publicationes, 1963
• Morrill, Milo True. History of the Christian Denomination in America, Dayton: The Christian Publishing Association, 1912.
• Murch, James DeForest Christians Only. Cincinnati: Standard Publishing, 1962.
• A Short Course in UCC History: The Christian Churches
• Steinacher, C. Mark An Aleatory Folk: An Historical-Theological Approach to the Transition of the Christian Church in Canada from Fringe to Mainstream 1792-1898, Unpublished Doctor of Theology thesis, Wycliffe College, University of Toronto, 1999

Wikisource has original text related to this article:

Last Will and Testament of The Springfield Presbytery

• UCC-Disciples Ecumenical Partnership
• A Short Course in UCC History: The Congregational Christian Churches
• A Short Course in UCC History: The Evangelical and Reformed Church
• "Christian Connection" . Encyclopædia Britannica (11th ed.). 1911.