Commentary on Edward Snowden's disclosure

Commentary on Edward Snowden's disclosure is part of the reactions to global surveillance disclosures made by Edward Snowden.

Executive branch

On June 8, 2013, Director of National Intelligence (DNI) James R. Clapper denounced as "reckless" the disclosures of "intelligence community measures used to keep Americans safe."[1] He condemned the leaks as having done "huge, grave damage" to the U.S. intelligence capabilities.[2]

Later that month, U.S. President Barack Obama was dismissive of Snowden, saying, "I'm not going to be scrambling jets to get a 29-year-old hacker."[3][4] In early August, Obama said that Snowden was no patriot and that Americans would have been better off if they had remained unaware of the NSA surveillance activities that Snowden revealed.[5] Obama also said that he had "called for a thorough review of our surveillance operations before Mr. Snowden made these leaks.... My preference, and I think the American people's preference, would have been for a lawful, orderly examination of these laws; a thoughtful fact-based debate that would then lead us to a better place."[5]

On August 4, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Martin Dempsey said on the weekly ABC interview show This Week that Snowden "has caused us some considerable damage to our intelligence architecture. Our adversaries are changing the way that they communicate."[6]

In September, DNI Clapper acknowledged that Snowden may have done a public service and started a needed debate about the balance between privacy and security. "As loath as I am to give any credit for what's happened here, which was egregious, I think it's clear that some of the conversations that this has generated, some of the debate, actually probably needed to happen," he said. "It's unfortunate they didn't happen some time ago, but if there's a good side to this, that's it."[7][8]

On January 29, 2014, DNI Clapper gave public testimony to a session of the Senate Intelligence Committee. He asked that "Snowden and his accomplices" return the purloined NSA documents. When Clapper was asked whether the word "accomplices" referred to journalists, Clapper's spokesperson Shawn Turner responded, "Director Clapper was referring to anyone who is assisting Edward Snowden to further threaten our national security through the unauthorized disclosure of stolen documents related to lawful foreign intelligence collection programs."[9]

Former executive branch officials

In late June 2013, Former US President Jimmy Carter said: "He's obviously violated the laws of America, for which he's responsible, but I think the invasion of human rights and American privacy has gone too far ... I think that the secrecy that has been surrounding this invasion of privacy has been excessive, so I think that the bringing of it to the public notice has probably been, in the long term, beneficial."[10]

Earlier that month, former Vice President Dick Cheney suggested that Snowden might be a spy working for the Chinese government.[11]

Some former U.S. intelligence officials speculated that Chinese or Russian intelligence agents might have gleaned additional classified material from Snowden,[12][13][14] a view shared by some former Russian agents.[15] Snowden, however, told journalist Glenn Greenwald in July, "I never gave any information to either government, and they never took anything from my laptops."[16]

Stewart Baker, a former NSA general counsel in the early 1990s, said at a July 18, 2013 hearing, "I am afraid that hyped and distorted press reports orchestrated by Edward Snowden and his allies may cause us – or other nations – to construct new restraints on our intelligence gathering, restraints that will leave us vulnerable to another security disaster."[17]

Former CIA and NSA chief General Michael Hayden in late June 2013 welcomed the public debate about the balance between privacy and security that the leaks had provoked: "I am convinced the more the American people know exactly what it is we are doing in this balance between privacy and security, the more they know the more comfortable they will feel."[18][19] In September 2013, Hayden stressed the indisputable legality of "what the NSA is doing" and called Snowden a "troubled young man", albeit "morally arrogant to a tremendous degree"; he also said about his prospects in Russia: "I suspect he will end up like most of the rest of the defectors who went to the old Soviet Union: Isolated, bored, lonely, depressed -- and most of them ended up alcoholics."[20]

Speaking at the University of Connecticut on April 23, 2014, former U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton insinuated that she found Snowden's motives suspicious. "When he emerged and when he absconded with all that material, I was puzzled because we have all these protections for whistle-blowers. If he were concerned and wanted to be part of the American debate, he could have been," she said. "But it struck me as—I just have to be honest with you—as sort of odd that he would flee to China, because Hong Kong is controlled by China, and that he would then go to Russia—two countries with which we have very difficult cyberrelationships, to put it mildly." Clinton added, "I think turning over a lot of that material—intentionally or unintentionally—drained, gave all kinds of information, not only to big countries, but to networks and terrorist groups and the like. So I have a hard time thinking that somebody who is a champion of privacy and liberty has taken refuge in Russia, under Putin's authority."[21]

Congress

Reactions to Snowden's disclosures among members of Congress initially were largely negative.[22] Speaker of the House John Boehner[23] and senators Dianne Feinstein[24] and Bill Nelson[25] called Snowden a traitor, and several senators and representatives joined them in calling for Snowden's arrest and prosecution.[24][26][27]

Representative Thomas Massie was one of few members of Congress to question the constitutional validity of the government surveillance programs and suggest that Snowden should be granted immunity from prosecution.[28] Senator Rand Paul[29] offered tentative support for Snowden, saying they were reserving judgment on Snowden until more information about the surveillance programs and about Snowden's motives were known. Senator Paul said, "I do think when history looks at this, they are going to contrast the behavior of James Clapper, our National Intelligence Director, with Edward Snowden. Mr. Clapper lied in Congress in defiance of the law, in the name of security. Mr. Snowden told the truth in the name of privacy."[30] Paul later called Snowden a "civil disobedient", like Martin Luther King Jr., but who faced life imprisonment.[31] Representative John Lewis made comparisons between Snowden and Gandhi, saying the leaker was appealing to a "higher law".[32]

Senator Bill Nelson, "What Edward Snowden did amounts to an act of treason."[33] Similar comments have also been made by Rep. Peter T. King, Rep. John Boehner, and Sen. Dianne Feinstein.[34]

On July 25, the US Senate Committee on Appropriations unanimously adopted an amendment by Senator Lindsey Graham to the "Fiscal Year 2014 Department of State, Foreign Operations, and Related Programs Appropriations Bill"[35] that would seek sanctions against any country that offers asylum to Snowden.[36][37][38]

In response to the information release by Snowden, Rep. Justin Amash (R-Mich.) and Rep. John Conyers (D-Mich.) proposed an amendment to the National Defense Authorization Act[39] to curtail the NSA gathering and storage of the personal records, but the House rejected it by a narrow margin of 205–217.[40] Amash subsequently told Fox News that Snowden was "a whistle-blower. He told us what we need to know."[41]

On the Sunday ABC interview show This Week, Rep. Dutch Ruppersberger, D-Maryland, of the United States House Select Committee on Intelligence was asked by Raddatz, "Are efforts being thwarted in trying to get information for members of Congress?" He replied,

...[S]ince this incident occurred with Snowden, we've had three different hearings for members of our Democratic Caucus, and the Republican Caucus, where General Alexander has come with his deputy, Chris Inglis, to ask any questions that people have as it relates to this information. And we will continue to do that because what we're trying to do now is to get the American public to know more about what's going on....But we can do better. I have to educate my caucus more, the Democratic Caucus. And we're trying to declassify as much as we can.[42]

U.S. Senator John McCain (R-AZ) said on the August 11 edition of Fox News Sunday that Snowden had become a hero to young Americans, as he reminded them of the Jason Bourne character. McCain attributed it to generation change and a lack of confidence in the federal government. "Right now there's kind of a generational change," he said. "Young Americans do not trust this government."[43]

Gordon Humphrey, the conservative Republican senator for New Hampshire from 1979 to 1991, expressed support for Snowden.[44] Glenn Greenwald revealed that Humphrey, a former member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, had been in contact with Snowden via email. Humphrey told Snowden, "Provided you have not leaked information that would put in harms way any intelligence agent, I believe you have done the right thing in exposing what I regard as massive violation of the United States Constitution."[45] Humphrey cited Snowden as a "courageous whistle-blower".[46]

Tom McClintock (R-Calif) came out in favor of amnesty for Snowden, saying

I think it would be best if the American government granted him amnesty to get him back to America where he can answer questions without the threat of prosecution... We have some very good laws against sharing secrets and he broke those laws. On the other hand, he broke them for a very good reason because those laws were being used in direct contravention of our 4th Amendment rights as Americans.[47]

Arizona Senator John McCain criticized politicians who voted in favor of the PATRIOT Act, but were outraged by the NSA spying on phone calls by saying, "We passed the Patriot Act. We passed specific provisions of the act that allowed for this program to take place, to be enacted in operation. Now, if members of Congress did not know what they were voting on, then I think that that's their responsibility a lot more than it is the government's."[48]

Public

Glenn Greenwald, one of the journalists who received the documents, praised Snowden for having done a service by revealing the surveillance on the American public.[49][50] John Cassidy of The New Yorker called Snowden "a hero" and said that "in revealing the colossal scale of the US government's eavesdropping on Americans and other people around the world, [Snowden] has performed a great public service that more than outweighs any breach of trust he may have committed."[51] CNN columnist Douglas Rushkoff also called Snowden's leak an act of heroism.[52] Amy Davidson, writing in The New Yorker, was thankful for the "overdue" conversation on privacy and the limits of domestic surveillance.[53]

American political commentators and public figures such as Noam Chomsky,[54] Chris Hedges,[55] Michael Moore,[56] Cornel West,[57] Glenn Beck,[56] Matt Drudge,[58] Alex Jones, Andrew Napolitano, Oliver Stone,[59] Michael Savage,[60] and Stephen Walt[61] praised Snowden for exposing secret government surveillance.

Other commentators were more critical of Snowden's methods and motivations.[62] Jeffrey Toobin, for example, denounced Snowden as "a grandiose narcissist who deserves to be in prison".[63] Writing in The New Yorker, Toobin argued that the programs exposed were not illegal, therefore Snowden was not a whistleblower. Further, Toobin questioned "whether the government can function when all of its employees (and contractors) can take it upon themselves to sabotage the programs they don’t like".[63]

The editors of Bloomberg News argued that, while the government ought to prosecute Snowden, the media's focus on Snowden took attention away from issues of U.S. government surveillance, the interpretations of the Patriot Act, and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) court actions, all of which are "what really matters in all this."[64] Greenwald accused the media in the U.S. of focusing on Edward Snowden instead of on wrongdoing by Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper and other U.S. officials.[65] In an op-ed, author Alex Berenson argued that the federal government should have flown a representative to Hong Kong to ask Snowden to give testimony in front of the U.S. Congress and offer him a fair criminal trial, with a view to preventing further unintended disclosures of classified information to other countries.[66]

Cybersecurity scholar Peter Singer divided the material disclosed by Snowden into three categories: "smart, useful espionage against enemies of the United States; legally questionable activities that involved US citizens through backdoors and fudging of policy/law; un-strategic (stupid) actions targeting American allies that has had huge blowback on US standing and US business." It was postulated that these were differing ways people viewed Snowden, which could explain why he was so polarizing.[67] Singer also spoke of a "double legacy" from the NSA revelations released by Snowden: "One, it's hollowed out the American ability to operate effectively in ensuring the future of the internet itself, in the way we would hope it would be. That has huge long-term consequences. And the second is, it's been and will be a hammer-blow to American technology companies. The cloud computing industry, for example, had a recent estimate that they'll lose $36 billion worth of business because of this."[68]

Public opinion polls

Surveys conducted by news outlets and professional polling organizations found that American public opinion was divided on Snowden's disclosures, and that those polled in Canada and Europe were more supportive of Snowden than respondents in the U.S.

2013
  • June 10–11, 2013: Gallup poll showed 44 percent of Americans thought it was right for Snowden to share the information with the press while 42 percent thought it was wrong.[69]
  • June 12–16: USA Today/Pew Research poll found that 49 percent thought the release of information served the public interest while 44 percent thought it harmed it. The same poll found that 54 percent felt a criminal case should be brought against Snowden, and 38 percent disagreed.[70]
  • June 12–16: The Washington Post-ABC News poll cited 43 percent of respondents saying Snowden ought to be charged with a crime, while 48 percent said he ought not.[71]
  • June 17–18: Rasmussen Reports asked Americans to describe Snowden in a single word. Twelve percent said he was a hero, 21 percent called him a traitor, 34 percent said he fell somewhere in between, and 29 percent said it was too early to tell.[72]
  • June 15–July 1: The Economist/YouGov poll tracked public opinion over three consecutive weekends, comparing results from June 15–17, June 22–24 and June 29–July 1. Asked their view of Snowden, respondents indicating "favorable" rose from 40 percent to 42 percent then down to 36 percent. "Unfavorable" grew steadily from 39 percent to 41 percent to 43 percent. Those supporting his prosecution increased from 27 percent to 34 percent and held there; those opposed steadily declined from 32 percent to 31 percent to 25 percent.[73]
  • July 1–2: The Huffington Post/YouGov poll found that 38 percent of Americans thought Snowden did the wrong thing, 33 percent said he did the right thing, and 29 percent were unsure.[74]
  • July 17–21: NBC News/The Wall Street Journal Survey found that 11 percent of Americans viewed Snowden positively while 34 percent had a negative view.[75]
  • June 28–July 8: Quinnipiac University Polling Institute survey found that 55 percent of Americans regarded Snowden as a whistleblower while 34 percent saw him as a traitor.[76] When Quinnipiac repeated the poll from July 28–31, the results were unchanged.[77]
  • July 28–29: Among likely U.S. voters surveyed by Rasmussen Reports, 32 percent considered Snowden a traitor who endangered lives and national security, whereas 11 percent called him a hero.[72]
  • November 14–17: The Washington Post-ABC News poll found a significant shift in opinion as to whether or not Snowden ought to be charged with a crime. In contrast to the same organizations' June poll, November's results showed 52 percent favoring his prosecution (up from 43 percent) and 38 percent opposed (down from 48 percent). Similarly, when asked whether, irrespective of his being charged with a crime, Snowden was right or wrong to disclose the NSA intelligence-gathering efforts, 37 percent said he was right and 55 percent said he was wrong. All told, nearly two to one (60 percent versus 32 percent) thought Snowden's disclosures had harmed U.S. national security.[78]
2014
  • January 15–19: USA Today/Pew Research poll reported little change from the previous June on the question of the government pursuing a criminal case against Snowden, with 56 percent in favor and 32 percent opposed. The poll found that people younger than 30 offered the least support for prosecution, being evenly divided at 42 percent in favor and 42 percent opposed. Over all age groups, opinion was also nearly equally divided as to whether or not Snowden's disclosures had served the public interest: 45 percent said yes, while 43 percent said Snowden harmed the public interest.[79]
  • January 18–20: The Economist/YouGov poll likewise found Americans evenly split, with 43 percent viewing Snowden favorably and 41 percent unfavorably; 46 percent approving his leaks and 43 percent disapproving; 28 percent supporting his prosecution and 29 percent opposed.[80]
  • January 22: CBS News poll revealed a larger split (almost 3:1) as to whether or not Snowden ought to stand trial for his actions, with 61 percent in favor and 23 percent saying he should be granted amnesty. CBS News also differed from Pew Research on the issue of whether or not Snowden's disclosures had been good for the country, with 40 percent saying yes and 46 percent saying it had been bad. When asked to come up with a word that best describes Snowden, nearly a quarter of respondents volunteered either "traitor" or a similar word questioning his loyalty to his country, while 8 percent said he is "brave" or "courageous" or "a hero." Just 2 percent volunteered that he is a "patriot" or "patriotic," and another 2 percent said "terrorist."[81]
  • January 22–25: NBC News/The Wall Street Journal Survey found continued low public approval for Snowden, with 23 percent supporting what he did, 37 percent opposing it, and 39 percent expressing no opinion.[82]
  • March 26–28: The Huffington Post/YouGov poll found that 31 percent thought Snowden was right to leak top-secret information about government surveillance programs to the media, while 33 percent believed he was wrong; 45 percent favored his prosecution, with 34 percent opposed; and 35 percent would support a presidential pardon, with 43 percent opposed.[83]
  • May 20: NBC News asked viewers to weigh in via Twitter on whether they thought Snowden was a "patriot" or "traitor."[84] Prior to airing its Snowden interview, viewers were closely split on the matter; after the program aired, 60 percent said they considered him a patriot.[85]
  • May 29: A YouGov survey found that 55 percent of Americans thought Snowden was right to leak details of the PRISM program. Twenty percent of Americans aged 16–34 thought Snowden's actions were wrong, while 41 percent of those 55 and over held this view.[86]
  • June 1: An NBC News poll of registered voters found that 34 percent opposed Snowden's leaks, 24 percent backed him and another 40 percent had no opinion. Among those who closely followed the story, 49 percent opposed his actions and 33 percent supported them. "These overall numbers," said NBC News, "are essentially unchanged from a January 2014 NBC News/Wall Street Journal [poll], when 23 percent of registered voters said they supported Snowden's actions, versus 38 percent who opposed them."[87]
  • July 2: A poll conducted by cloud storage service Tresorit, showed that 55% of all Americans supported Edward Snowden's disclosures, whereas only 29% were against them.
  • July 14: Pew Research Center found worldwide opposition to U.S. eavesdropping and a decline in the view that the U.S. respects its people's personal freedoms, but little evidence that America's overall image had been severely damaged. While the majority of Americans and others condoned spying on suspected terrorists, they agreed it is unacceptable to spy on American citizens.[88]

Canada and Europe

In a June 2013 Emnid survey, 50 percent of Germans polled considered Snowden a hero, and 35 percent would hide him in their homes.[89]

In October 2013, 67 percent of Canadians polled considered Snowden a hero, as did 60 percent of UK respondents.[90]

In an April 2014 UK YouGov poll, 46 percent of British people thought that newspapers reporting on the materials given to them by Snowden was good for society, while 22 percent thought it was bad for society and 31 percent didn't know.[91]

Media

On January 1, 2014, the editorial board of The New York Times praised Snowden as a whistleblower and wrote in favor of granting him clemency, arguing that while Snowden may have broken the law, he had "done his country a great service" by bringing the abuses of the NSA to light. "When someone reveals that government officials have routinely and deliberately broken the law," they wrote, "that person should not face life in prison at the hands of the same government." The Times cast doubt on the claim made by Snowden's critics that he had damaged national security, and concluded with a request to President Obama to discontinue the "vilification" of Snowden and to give him "an incentive to return home."[92][93] The article garnered an unusual amount of blowback for an editorial, with responses from multiple media outlets.[94] The Guardian called for a pardon in an editorial coincidentally published the same day, saying Snowden should be allowed to return home with dignity.[95][96]

In a January 4, 2014 article, Peter Baker of The New York Times laid out the polarization of opinions throughout the U.S. and the impetus toward clemency gained by public reaction to Snowden's revelations. Yet despite a growing backlash against government surveillance, Baker noted, calls for leniency had made little headway in the White House, Justice Department, or national security establishment.[97]

In September 2016, the editorial board of The Washington Post characterized the issue of whether Snowden deserved a presidential pardon as "a complicated question" to which the president's answer should be "no".[98] The editors of the Post credited Snowden for "necessary reforms" brought about by his revelations of en masse collection of telephone data by the NSA, but stressed Snowden's separate leak of information about the agency's PRISM program and other "basically defensible" intelligence operations as reasons why he should face trial, saying that Snowden hurt his credibility as "an avatar of freedom" by accepting asylum in Russia.[98] The editors of the Post dismissed calls from human-rights organizations for clemency because of Snowden's "noble purposes" and the policy changes resulting from the leaks, and urged the president not to pardon Snowden despite the Post itself being responsible for publishing some of the leaked material.[99] According to The Guardian, the editorial stunned many American journalists.[99] Glenn Greenwald, one of the journalists to whom Snowden had initially leaked the classified documents, characterized the Post editorial as "an act of journalistic treachery" and "cowardice", noting that the Post had accepted a Pulitzer Prize for publishing Snowden's leaks concerning PRISM and the other operations mentioned in its editorial.[100]

Non-governmental organizations
Navi Pillay, the United Nations' High Commissioner for Human Rights, said: "Without prejudging the validity of any asylum claim by Snowden, I appeal to all States to respect the internationally guaranteed right to seek asylum."[101]

After Amnesty International met Edward Snowden in Moscow in mid July 2013, the organization said:

What he has disclosed is patently in the public interest and as a whistleblower his actions were justified. He has exposed unlawful sweeping surveillance programmes that unquestionably interfere with an individual’s right to privacy. States that attempt to stop a person from revealing such unlawful behaviour are flouting international law. Freedom of expression is a fundamental right.[102]

Widney Brown, Senior Director of Amnesty, feared that Snowden would be at "great risk" of human rights violations if forcibly transferred to the United States,[103] and urged no country to return Snowden to the US. Michael Bochenek, Director of Law and Policy at Amnesty International deplored the US pressure on governments to block Snowden's asylum attempts, saying "It is his unassailable right, enshrined in international law".[104]

Human Rights Watch said that if Snowden were able to raise the issue of NSA mass surveillance without facing espionage charges, he would not have left the United States in the first place.[105] Human Rights Watch writes that any country where Snowden seeks asylum should consider his claim fairly and protect his rights under international law, which recognizes that revealing official secrets is sometimes justified in the public interest.[106]

Navi Pillay, the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, said: "Snowden's case has shown the need to protect persons disclosing information on matters that have implications for human rights, as well as the importance of ensuring respect for the right to privacy".[101]

Transparency International, International Association of Lawyers against Nuclear Arms and Vereinigung Deutscher Wissenschaftler awarded Snowden the German Whistleblowerpreis 2013.[107]

The Humanist Union awarded him the Fritz Bauer Prize 2013.[108]

Whistleblowers

Daniel Ellsberg, the whistleblower and leaker of the top-secret Pentagon Papers in 1971, stated in an interview with CNN that he thought Snowden had done an "incalculable" service to his country and that his leaks might prevent the United States from becoming a surveillance state. He said Snowden had acted with the same sort of courage and patriotism as a soldier in battle.[109] In an op-ed the following morning, Ellsberg added that "there has not been in American history a more important leak than Edward Snowden's release of NSA material ... including the Pentagon Papers."[110] Ray McGovern, a retired CIA officer turned political activist, agreed with Ellsberg and added, "This time today I'm feeling much more hopeful for our democracy than I was feeling this time yesterday."[111]

William Binney, a whistleblower who disclosed details of the NSA's mass surveillance activities, said that Snowden had "performed a really great public service to begin with by exposing these programs and making the government in a sense publicly accountable for what they're doing." After Snowden cited a conversation with a "reliable source" about allegations that the US was "hacking into China", Binney felt he was "transitioning from whistle-blower to a traitor."[112]

Thomas Drake, former senior executive of NSA and whistleblower, said that he feels "extraordinary kinship" with Snowden. "What he did was a magnificent act of civil disobedience. He's exposing the inner workings of the surveillance state. And it's in the public interest. It truly is."[112][113]

WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange hailed Snowden as a "hero" who has exposed "one of the most serious events of the decade – the creeping formulation of a mass surveillance state."[114] After charges against Snowden were revealed, Assange released a statement asking people to "step forward and stand with" Snowden.[115] Following President Obama's assurances that changes are planned for the NSA surveillance program, Assange said in a written statement that Obama had "validated Edward Snowden's role as a whistle-blower".[116][117]

Shamai Leibowitz, who leaked details about an FBI operation, said that the legal threats and "smear campaign" against Snowden are a "grave mistake" because "If the government really wanted to keep more secrets from coming out, they would do well to let this man of conscience go live his life in some other country."[118]

In October 2013, four US whistleblowers and activists visited Moscow to present Snowden with an award for truth-telling titled The Sam Adams Award for Integrity in Intelligence.[119][120]

References
  1. Gardner, Timothy; Hosenball, Mark (June 9, 2013). "Spy agency seeks criminal probe into leaks". Reuters. Retrieved June 9, 2013.
  2. Blake, Aaron (June 9, 2013). "Clapper: Leaks are 'literally gut-wrenching,' leaker being sought". The Washington Post. Retrieved August 8, 2013.
  3. "Obama downplays Snowden case, says US not 'scrambling jets' to get 'hacker'". Fox News. June 27, 2013.
  4. Pecquet, Julian (June 27, 2013). "US won't 'scramble jets' to capture 'hacker' Snowden, Obama says". The Hill.
  5. Wolf, Z. Byron (August 13, 2013). "Fact-checking Obama's claims about Snowden". CNN.
  6. Raddatz, Martha (August 4, 2013). "Transcript for Joint Chiefs Chairman Gen. Martin Dempsey on 'This Week'". ABC News 'This Week'. Retrieved August 14, 2013.
  7. Waterman, Shaun (September 12, 2013). "Congress will rein in NSA's domestic snooping, predicts top U.S. intel official". The Washington Times. Retrieved September 16, 2013.
  8. Dilanian, Ken (September 12, 2013). "Clapper: Snowden case brings healthy debate; more disclosures to come". The Los Angeles Times. Retrieved September 15, 2013.
  9. Ackerman, Spencer (2014-01-29). "James Clapper calls for Snowden and 'accomplices' to return NSA documents". The Guardian.
  10. Watkins, Tom (June 30, 2013). "Father proposes deal for Snowden's voluntary return", CNN
  11. "Edward Snowden is a 'traitor' and possible spy for China – Dick Cheney". The Guardian. Retrieved September 18, 2013.
  12. Schindler, John R. (June 27, 2013). "Snowden in the U.S.-Russian 'SpyWar'". National Affairs.
  13. Ross, Brian (June 26, 2013). "Edward Snowden Steps Into Secret U.S.-Russia Spy Scuffle". ABC News
  14. Ewing, Philip (June 25, 2013). "What Russian intel might ask Edward Snowden". Politico.
  15. Simon Schuster (July 10, 2013). Snowden in Moscow: What Russian Authorities Might Be Doing With the NSA Whistle-Blower Time
  16. Snowden: I never gave any information to Chinese or Russian governments, Glenn Greenwald, July 10, 2013
  17. Branigin, William (July 17, 2013). "Lawmakers of both parties voice doubts about NSA surveillance programs". The Washington Post.
  18. Former CIA, NSA chief Michael Hayden: Open spy programs to reassure U.S. public, The Washington Times, June 30, 2013. Retrieved Jul 9, 2013.
  19. Former CIA, NSA director sounds off on PRISM, spying tools, Network World, July 1, 2013. Retrieved Jul 9, 2013.
  20. Peterson, Andrea. "Former NSA chief: 'Morally arrogant' Snowden will probably become an alcoholic". The Washington Post. Retrieved September 18, 2013.
  21. "Hillary Clinton: Edward Snowden's Leaks Helped Terrorists". NationalJournal.com. April 25, 2014.
  22. Reeve, Elspeth (June 10, 2013). "Washington turns on the NSA blinders to target weird 'IT guy' leaker instead". The Atlantic Wire.
  23. LoGiurato, Brett (June 11, 2013). "John Boehner: Edward Snowden Is A 'Traitor'". San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved June 11, 2013.
  24. Herb, Jeremy; Sink, Justin (June 10, 2013). "Sen. Feinstein calls Snowden's NSA leaks an 'act of treason'". thehill.com.
  25. Nelson, Bill (June 11, 2013). "This man is a traitor". Daily News. New York.
  26. "Edward Snowden: Ex-CIA leaker drops out of sight, faces legal battle". The Chicago Tribune. Reuters. June 10, 2013. Retrieved June 12, 2013.
  27. Blake, Aaron (June 11, 2013). "DNC chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz: Snowden is a coward". The Washington Post. Retrieved June 13, 2013.
  28. Dumain, Emma; Lesniewski, Niels (June 10, 2013). "Snowden Has a Few Defenders on the Hill". Roll Call. Retrieved June 11, 2013.
  29. Sink, Justin (June 11, 2013). "Rand Paul 'reserving judgment' on NSA leaker". The Hill. Archived from the original on October 13, 2013. Retrieved February 10, 2014.
  30. Sullivan, Sean (June 23, 2013). "Rand Paul: Snowden will face problems if he 'cozies up' to Russia, China". The Washington Post.
  31. "Rand Paul: Edward Snowden 'civil disobedient' – Tal Kopan –". Politico.com. June 18, 2013.
  32. "John Lewis compares Edward Snowden, Gandhi – James Arkin –". Politico.com. August 8, 2013.
  33. "This man is a traitor". senate.gov. Archived from the original on December 3, 2013. Retrieved September 18, 2013.
  34. "John Boehner: Edward Snowden Is A 'Traitor'". The Huffington Post. Retrieved September 18, 2013.
  35. S. 1372 at Congress.gov. S. 1372 at GovTrack. S. 1372 Archived 2013-12-03 at the Wayback Machine at OpenCongress.
  36. Zengerle, Patricia (July 25, 2013). "U.S. lawmakers want sanctions on any country taking in Snowden". Reuters.
  37. "U.S. Senate advances law pressuring Russia not to give Snowden asylum". Xinhua. July 26, 2013. Archived from the original on July 29, 2013.
  38. "FY14 Full Committee Markup of State-Foreign Operations, and Financial Services General Government Bills" (Podcast). United States Senate Committee on Appropriations. July 25, 2013. Event occurs at 1:10:08.
  39. Max Ehrenfreund. "House proposal to curtail NSA in response to Edward Snowden's leaks fails narrowly". The Washington Post.
  40. "The Amash Amendment Fails, Barely – Abby Ohlheiser and Philip Bump". The Atlantic Wire. July 24, 2013.
  41. "Amash: Snowden a whistle-blower, 'told us what we need to know'". Fox News. August 4, 2013. Retrieved October 6, 2013.
  42. Raddatz, Martha (August 4, 2013). "'This Week' Transcript: Gen. Martin Dempsey, Reps. Ruppersberger and King, and Glenn Greenwald". ABC News 'This Week'. Retrieved August 14, 2013.
  43. "McCain: Young Americans admire Snowden, see him as 'some kind of Jason Bourne'". The Washington Times. Retrieved August 11, 2013.
  44. Johnson, Luke (16 July 2013). "Edward Snowden Receives Support From Former GOP Sen. Gordon Humphrey". Huffington Post. Retrieved August 11, 2013.
  45. Greenwald, Glenn (16 July 2013). "Email exchange between Edward Snowden and former GOP Senator Gordon Humphrey". The Guardian. Retrieved August 11, 2013.
  46. Gold, Hadas. "Former Sen. Gordon Humphrey emails with Edward Snowden". Politico. Retrieved July 17, 2013.
  47. "Rep. McClintock Says the US Should Grant Snowden Amnesty – Hit & Run". Reason. July 24, 2013.
  48. "Senators should have known about snooping, says McCain".
  49. Greenwald, Glenn (June 22, 2013). "On the Espionage Act charges against Edward Snowden". The Guardian Security and Liberty blog. London. Archived from the original on August 22, 2013. Retrieved June 23, 2013.
  50. Guariglia, Matthew (June 10, 2013). "Edward Snowden: Traitor or Hero?". heavy.com. Retrieved June 11, 2013.
  51. Cassidy, John (June 10, 2013). "Why Edward Snowden Is A Hero". The New Yorker.
  52. Rushkoff, Douglas (June 10, 2013). "Edward Snowden is a hero". CNN. Retrieved June 16, 2013.
  53. Davidson, Amy (June 9, 2013). "Edward Snowden, The N.S.A. Leaker, Comes Forward". The New Yorker.
  54. Harvey, Fiona (June 19, 2013). "NSA surveillance is an attack on American citizens, says Noam Chomsky". The Guardian. London. Retrieved July 4, 2013.
  55. "New Yorkers Declare 'I Stand With Edward Snowden': Dozens Rally & Draw Massive Media Attention for NSA Whistleblower (updated)". the sparrow project. June 10, 2013. Retrieved June 11, 2013.
  56. Gold, Hadas (June 10, 2013). "Glenn Beck, Michael Moore call Edward Snowden a hero". Politico. Retrieved June 11, 2013.
  57. "Cornel West Calls Edward Snowden the 'John Brown' of National Security". colorlines. June 28, 2013. Retrieved July 4, 2013.
  58. Budowsky, Brent (June 7, 2013). "Matt Drudge, Bernie Sanders and Ron Paul versus Barack Obama, George W. Bush and Big Brother". The Hill. Washington DC. Retrieved June 11, 2013.
  59. "Oliver Stone calls National Security Agency secret-leaker Edward Snowden 'a hero'". July 4, 2013.
  60. Kirell, Andrew (June 11, 2013). "Michael Savage Rants Against Fox News' 'Empty Skirts' & 'Lipstick With Legs' For Condemning NSA Leaker". Mediaite. Retrieved June 12, 2013.
  61. Walt, Stephen (July 8, 2013). "Snowden deserves an immediate presidential pardon". Financial Times. Retrieved July 8, 2013.
  62. Reeve, Elspeth (June 10, 2013). "These Pundits Have Decided Snowden Deserves to Go to Jail". The Atlantic Wire. Washington DC. Retrieved June 12, 2013.
  63. Toobin, Jeffrey (June 10, 2013). "Edward Snowden is no hero". The New Yorker.
  64. The Editors (June 24, 2013). "This Is Not About Edward Snowden". Bloomberg News. New York. Retrieved June 25, 2013. {{cite news}}: |author= has generic name (help)
  65. Greenwald, Glenn (July 3, 2013). "James Clapper, EU play-acting, and political priorities". The Guardian Security and Liberty blog (London). Retrieved July 3, 2013.
  66. Berenson, Alex (June 25, 2013). "Snowden, Through the Eyes of a Spy Novelist". The New York Times. Retrieved June 26, 2013.
  67. Fisher, Max (January 3, 2014). "The three types of NSA snooping that Edward Snowden revealed". The Washington Post. Retrieved January 4, 2014.
  68. Blogguest, TED (November 30, 2013). "Obama's 'outside experts' surveillance review panel has deep ties to gov't". TED. Drones, warfare, science fiction and cybercrime. A conversation with P.W. Singer
  69. Newport, Frank (June 12, 2013). "Americans Disapprove of Government Surveillance Programs". Gallup.
  70. "Public Split over Impact of NSA Leak, But Most Want Snowden Prosecuted". Pew Research Center. June 17, 2013. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  71. "Poll: Public wants congressional hearings on NSA surveillance". The Washington Post. June 19, 2013.
  72. "12% See NSA Leaker Snowden As Hero, 21% As Traitor". Rasmussen Reports. June 19, 2013. Retrieved April 11, 2015.
  73. "As Snowden Stays In Russia, He Slips In Public Opinion". YouGov. July 3, 2013.
  74. Emily Swanson (July 5, 2013). "Edward Snowden Poll Finds More Americans Now Think He Did The Wrong Thing". Huffington Post. Retrieved July 9, 2013.
  75. Rebecca Ballhaus (July 24, 2013) WSJ/NBC Poll: Most Americans View Snowden Negatively The Wall Street Journal
  76. Salant, Jonathan D. (July 10, 2013). "Snowden Seen as Whistle-Blower by Majority in New Poll". Bloomberg News. Retrieved July 10, 2013.
  77. Nelson, Steven (August 1, 2013). "As Edward Snowden receives asylum in Russia, poll shows Americans sympathetic to NSA 'whistle-blower'". U.S. News & World Report.
  78. "Snowden and the NSA - November 2013". The Washington Post. November 20, 2013.
  79. "Obama's NSA Speech Has Little Impact on Skeptical Public". Pew Research Center. January 20, 2014. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  80. "Poll Results: Snowden". YouGov. January 22, 2014.
  81. "Poll: Most think Edward Snowden should stand trial in U.S." CBS News. January 22, 2014.
  82. "January 2014 NBC News/Wall Street Journal Survey" (PDF). MSNBC. January 22–25, 2014. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2014-04-11. Retrieved 2014-04-05.
  83. "Poll Results: Snowden". YouGov. March 28, 2014.
  84. "Edward Snowden: #Traitor or #Patriot". NBC. Retrieved May 31, 2014.
  85. "Edward Snowden Is a #Patriot, Twitter Users Say". Mashable. 29 May 2014. Retrieved May 31, 2014.
  86. Wilson, Tim (29 May 2014). "A Year Later, Most Americans Think Snowden Did The Right Thing". Dark Reading.
  87. Todd, Chuck; Murray, Mark; Dann, Carrie (June 2, 2014). "Carbon Combat: Obama Begins Battle Over Environmental Regulation". NBC News.
  88. "Global Opposition to U.S. Surveillance and Drones, but Limited Harm to America's Image". Pew Research Center. July 14, 2014. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  89. Pop, Valentina (July 8, 2013). "Germany defends intelligence co-operation with US". EUobserver. Retrieved July 9, 2013.
  90. Edwardslevy, Ariel (October 30, 2013). "Americans Still Can't Decide Whether Edward Snowden Is A 'Traitor' Or A 'Hero,' Poll Finds". The Huffington Post. Retrieved April 6, 2014.
  91. "Snowden revelations 'good for society'". Retrieved April 24, 2014.
  92. Editorial Board of The New York Times (January 1, 2014). "Edward Snowden, Whistle-Blower". The New York Times.
  93. "Rieder: Why Edward Snowden should get clemency". USA Today. January 2, 2014. Retrieved April 11, 2015.
  94. Sullivan, Margaret (January 2, 2014). "Weeks in the Making, an Editorial on Snowden May Go 'Beyond What Is Realistic'". The New York Times.
  95. "Snowden affair: the case for a pardon". The Guardian. May 17, 2013.
  96. Satter, Raphael. "2 newspapers call for clemency for Edward Snowden". Associated Press. Archived from the original on January 6, 2015.
  97. Baker, Peter, "Moves to Curb Spying Help Drive the Clemency Argument for Snowden," The New York Times, January 5, 2014, page A16
  98. Washington Post Editorial Board (September 17, 2016). "No pardon for Edward Snowden". The Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286.
  99. Greenslade, Roy (September 19, 2016). "Washington Post says Obama should not pardon whistleblower Ed Snowden". The Guardian.
  100. Greenwald, Glenn (September 18, 2016). "WashPost Makes History: First Paper to Call for Prosecution of Its Own Source (After Accepting Pulitzer)". The Intercept.
  101. "UN rights chief urges protection for individuals revealing human rights violations". United Nations. 12 July 2013. Retrieved August 4, 2013.
  102. Amnesty International meets US whistleblower Edward Snowden July 12, 2013
  103. "USA must not hunt down whistleblower Edward Snowden". Amnesty International. Retrieved June 25, 2013.
  104. USA must not persecute whistleblower Edward Snowden July 2, 2013 Amnesty
  105. "US: Protect National Security Whistleblowers". Human Rights Watch. 18 June 2013. Retrieved June 25, 2013.
  106. Countries Should Consider Snowden’s Asylum Claim Fairly". Human Rights Watch, July 2013
  107. Heise Online-Autoren Detlef Borchers, anw (July 23, 2013). "Whistleblower-Preis für Edward Snowden". Heise Online. Archived from the original on July 26, 2013. Retrieved July 25, 2013.
  108. Sven Lüders (July 24, 2013). "Fritz-Bauer-Preis an Edward Snowden". Humanistischer Pressedienst. Archived from the original on July 26, 2013. Retrieved July 25, 2013.
  109. O'Malley, Nick (June 10, 2013). "NSA leaker reveals himself after fleeing US". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved June 10, 2013.
  110. Ellsberg, Daniel (June 10, 2013). "Edward Snowden: saving us from the United Stasi of America". The Guardian. Retrieved June 10, 2013.
  111. Noor, Jaisal (June 11, 2013). "Former CIA Analyst: Snowden Did The Right Thing". The Real News Network.
  112. Eisler, Peter; Page, Susan (June 16, 2013). "3 NSA veterans speak out on whistle-blower: We told you so." USA Today (Washington DC). Retrieved June 19, 2013.
  113. Snowden saw what I saw: surveillance criminally subverting the constitution The Guardian. Retrieved July 10, 2013
  114. Addley, Esther (June 10, 2013). "Julian Assange praises Edward Snowden as a hero". The Guardian. London. Retrieved June 10, 2013.
  115. Dart, Tom (June 22, 2013). "Support NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden, says Julian Assange". The Guardian (London). Retrieved June 22, 2013.
  116. David Jackson. "Assange: Obama 'validates' Snowden". USA Today.
  117. "Assange calls Obama reform plans 'victory of sorts' for Snowden". Reuters. August 10, 2013.
  118. Blowback from the White House's vindictive war on whistleblowers." Leibowitz, Shamai in The Guardian. July 5, 2013. Retrieved July 5, 2013.
  119. The Washington Post
  120. Former National Security Whistleblowers Meet in Moscow and Award Sam Adams Prize to Snowden – Government Accountability Project Archived 2013-12-26 at the Wayback Machine
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.