Edmonton Radial Railway

A parade at Jasper Ave and 101 St, looking north, in 1913. An observation streetcar is in the centre of the street, and elephants are in the distance.

The ERR was hard-pressed for employees during the First World War, because a number of its staff joined the military after war broke out; at least four of-whom died while overseas.[6] Service was further hampered during this time by a major flood in 1915, an influx of European refugees, and the rise of jitneys (shared taxis).[6] The ERR was forced to contend with a rising deficit, leading to the Edmonton Property Owners' Association demanding that the ERR be led by an independent board elected by residents, rather than unelected city staff.[6]

In September 1915, H. Milton Martin chaired an investigation which found that the ERR had suffered from notable financial mismanagement which created its deficit.[6] The Martin Report made several recommendations, including a reduction of assets, lowering its operating expenditures, and transferring the ERR to an independent commission.[6] Several changes were made to accounting practices, but key recommendations, such as the standing of an independent commission, were not implemented.[6]

The ERR was paralyzed by a severe blizzard on January 30, 1916; the poor conditions were exacerbated by reductions in track inspections due to budget cuts, and only one of the two snow sweeper cars working.[6] All streetcar service was cancelled at noon that same day.[6] The next day, a Monday, much of the streetcar system was still out of action, in what was called "the greatest winter crisis of the ERR to that point."[6]

Calls to privatize the ERR peaked in late 1916, but Mayor William Henry countered that newer extensions had already recouped their costs.[6] As a concession, the city delayed planned extensions to Elm Park, Calder, and West Edmonton.[6] The ERR began to implement single-ended streetcar operations in that same year, which entailed removing the doors on one side of the streetcars, taking the driving vestibule out of one end, and—in most cases—replacing the conductor with a farebox mounted near the entry door.[5] The ERR believed that single-ended streetcars would be cheaper to purchase and maintain since they only required a controller and brake valve on one end, rather than both ends.[7] Since these streetcars could only be driven from one end, turning loops were required on lines that used single-ended streetcars so that they could turn around.[5]

On August 31, 1917, ERR employees voted to strike after the city offered only minor concessions in response to their demands for increased wages, in the wake of one-man streetcar service commencing.[6] The city refused to recognize the transit union, and it ordered all employees to turn in their uniforms, while simultaneously hiring new staff.[6] Streetcar service was gradually re-introduced during the strike, but strikers were reportedly halting operations by grounding wires.[6] The strike ended on September 11, when most employees agreed to the city's terms and returned to work; Edmonton still refused to recognize the union, or to negotiate an agreement with it.[6] The labour disputes were gradually addressed over the coming year, and by mid-1918 the ERR began to generate a profit.[6]

Edmonton streetcar No. 40 going northbound across the High Level Bridge, on the left-hand track, in 1920.

The end of World War I brought another influx of complains about the ERR, as residents criticized overcrowding, dirty streetcars, routes perceived as inefficient, and the prevalence of one-man streetcars.[6] The ERR's Superintendent argued that these issues were caused by a number of factors out of his control; it was hard to obtain parts during the war, service was slowed by the number of railway crossings streetcars had to stop at, and two-man streetcar service was too expensive.[6] This was on top of an increase in the number of passengers, as veterans began returning from the war.[5]

Most streetcars were converted to allow for single-man operations by 1920, .[5] In 1917 or 1918, crossovers were installed at both ends of the High Level Bridge, so that streetcars could cross the bridge on the left-hand track.[5] Single-ended streetcars only had doors on their right side, and in the event that people had to evacuate a streetcar while it was on the bridge, driving on the left-hand track allowed for the doors to open onto the middle of the bridge deck, instead of its edge.[5] Some streetcars remained double-ended, but were only operated by one person.[5]

The radial railway reached its greatest extent in 1920, with six full lines and two stub lines serving almost all sections of the city, and totaling 90.4 kilometres (56.2 mi) in length.[8] The railway's busiest confirmed year of service was in 1929, during-which it served approximately 14.1 million passengers; Edmonton had approximately 74,000 residents at the time.[8][9] In subsequent years, transit officials did not distinguish between streetcar and bus passengers when tallying ridership figures.[1] Three years later, in 1932, trolleybus service replaced streetcars on the 102 Avenue stub line.[1]

A streetcar drives along 101 Street, winter 1933

The Edmonton Radial Railway seldom turned a profit, despite its large ridership. This was largely because passengers tended to remain on the streetcars for long periods of time, and many routes went through sparsely populated parts of Edmonton, such as single-track portions that served meatpacking plants in the city's fringes.[5] These factors limited the turnover rate of passengers, and thus capped the amount of fares that routes could generate.[5] Edmonton could not afford to properly maintain the streetcar system during the Great Depression. Although maintenance crews did their best to keep the streetcars in good condition, old tracks and streetcars could not be replaced, and the system could not be expanded to keep up with the Edmonton's growth.[5]

City Council received a report from City Commissioner R.J. Gibbs in 1937 that detailed the deteriorating state of the streetcar system due to neglect during the 1930s, as a result of the city's poor financial state during the Great Depression.[6] According to Gibbs, the city would need to invest a significant amount of money into replacing old streetcars, repairing and replacing streetcar infrastructure across the city, and expanding the service to newer parts of Edmonton.[6] The report recommended that Council instead raise fares by 20%, invest the increased transit revenue to transition from streetcars to trolleybuses, and all future investments into the streetcar network.[6] Gibbs also recommended that Council hire transportation exports to review his report before making a final decision.[6]

Engineering consultant Norman F. Wilson was hired later in 1937, and he confirmed Gibb's findings in a 1938 report to Council.[6] The ERR had failed to break even during most of its existence, and Wilson found that an increase in the fare from five rides for 25 cents down to four rides for 25 cents could not only cover the ERR's operational costs, but also provide a surplus to fund future service expansions.[6] However, Wilson warned that "streetcars everywhere are a declining industry," predicting that the rising number of privately owned automobiles would slow the growth of transit usage.[6] The report recommended that Edmonton begin its switch to trolleybuses by purchasing six of them to serve a route between Whyte Avenue and downtown.[6] The city ordered six trolley buses in 1939, prior to the start of the Second World War.[6]

Wilson also recommended that the streetcar tracks on the upper deck of the High Level Bridge be removed, and the deck repurposed for trolley buses.[6] The city sent an engineer to Montreal and Toronto to discuss the idea with CPR and Canadian Bridge Company engineers, but nothing further happened immediately. In 1949, voters approved a plebiscite for the streetcar tracks to be replaced by four lanes of road for vehicles.[10] Project delays caused the capital costs to increase, and the proposal went back to voters with a larger budget in a 1950 plebiscite.[10] A majority of voters approved it once again, but the approval threshold fell below the two-thirds minimum needed for the plebiscite to pass, and the project was cancelled.[6]

Opponents to the abandonment of streetcars argued that the trolley buses were less comfortable for riders, not more comfortable as Council had been told by experts, and that trolley buses only provided faster service than streetcars because the distance between stops was increased.[10] Commissioner Gibbs and ERR Superintendent Thomas Ferrier opted for a gradual shift away from streetcars; both to make sure ridership was positively impacted by the change, and also to see how riders reacted to the trolley buses.[10] The trolley buses proved highly successful when they began service, with the peak passenger load increasing by 100% instead of 50% as planners had anticipated.[6] This unanticipated demand forced the ERR to order three additional trolley buses, and make the route shorter than planned to reduce the number of people using use it.[10]

Librarian Jack Fearon helps a young visitor inside the streetcar library, while two other children play with a dog

During the Second World War, Edmonton became a key air hub for the Allied cause.[6] Blatchford Field was chosen by the British Commonwealth Air Training Plan to host an observer school and an elementary flight training school, and Edmonton served as a key stopping point for Lend-Lease aircraft traveling from the United States to the Soviet Union; thousands of Edmontonians became employed in the aircraft repair sector.[6] An influx of Americans called Edmonton home starting in 1942, when Edmonton became the southern hub of the Alaska Highway and the Canol pipeline. Local workers and American soldiers alike primarily relied on the Edmonton Radial Railway to get around the city, and the ERR's ridership spiked by 40% between 1940 and 1942.[6]

The transition away from streetcars was slowed by the war, as Edmonton struggled to procure buses in the face of wartime supply restrictions.[6] Edmonton was forced to build new tracks to provide high-in-demand streetcar service to Aircraft Repair Ltd, which employed approximately 3,000 residents.[6] When streetcar No. 28 caught fire in 1943, the ERR opted for a lengthy three-year refit instead of scrapping it, due to the severe shortage of rolling stock.[6] Also in 1943, the ERR reintroduced conductors, many of whom were women, to sell tickets and issue transfers on streetcars that served busy routes; conductors were originally phased out in the 1930s when the ERR switched to single-ended streetcars.[1]

Despite the difficulties encountered by Edmonton during the war, it still managed to replace some streetcar lines with bus service.[5] Streetcar operations along 95 Street, Scona Hill, and the Low Level bridge were replaced by buses in 1939; this was followed by Bonnie Doon in 1940, Whyte Avenue (between 104 and 94 Street) in 1944, and Highlands, along with the Rossdale stub line, in 1945.[5]

The ERR tried to find ways to help improve the spirits of local residents during the war. Librarian H.C. Gourlay proposed the introduction of a library car, and streetcar No. 14 was converted into a mobile library to serve residents in outlying neighbourhoods.[6] The royal blue streetcar, which had a capacity for 2,000 books and was fitted with wooden bookcases that were secured to its walls, entered service in October 1941.[6] The ERR constructed short sidings in certain neighbourhoods so that the streetcar could park without blocking transit services.[6] On its first day of service, 700 residents visited it in Calder; more than half of them were first-time borrowers, and three quarters were children.[11] By early December, 1941, the streetcar library lent more than 9,500 books, and signed up over 4,000 adults and 1,000 children with new library memberships.[11]

After the war ended, Edmonton's transition from streetcars to buses continued to be hampered by further increases in ridership, and difficulties in procuring buses.[6] The city constructed more streetcar tracks as late as 1946, as streetcars continued to serve as an important backbone for the transit service. The Edmonton trolley bus system gradually replaced streetcar service on most Edmonton Radial Railway routes, and gas and diesel buses filled the remaining gaps.[1] The Edmonton Radial Railway's name was changed to Edmonton Transportation Service in July 1946 to reflect the shift away from streetcars, and just one year later it was renamed to Edmonton Transit System.[12]

Streetcar service in Calder became isolated from the rest of the streetcar system in May 1948, when the tracks on 124 Street, south of 118 Avenue, were paved over.[5] A small temporary storage yard was constructed at 118 Avenue, and seven passenger cars, a sweeper car, and the library car were parked there before the paving occurred.[5] Buses were used to transport passengers between the Calder stub line, and the northern terminus of the Red-and-Green line — which previously ran uninterrupted into Calder.[5] A streetcar was always parked at 118 Avenue to serve as a heated shelter for people waiting either for a bus, or a Calder streetcar.[5] The library streetcar was parked at a small spur on 127 Street, south of 125 Avenue, to serve the neighbourhood of Sherbrooke.[5] Streetcar ridership across the city steadily rose during this time, but noticeably fell after City Council approved a fare increase to address the operating deficit.[5]

A crowd gathers by streetcar No. 1, left, after it made its ceremonial "last run" on September 1, 1951

The Calder stub line closed permanently in August 1949, and all nine streetcars on this stub line were scrapped.[5] In that same month, streetcar service on Whyte Avenue was replaced by bus service, and the new south terminus for streetcars was at 84 Avenue and 109 Street.[5] After these closures, only the Blue Route and the Blue & White Route remained in service, totaling 17 miles (27 km) in length.[8] In its final configuration, the service went between a loop at 109 Street and 84 Avenue, and another loop at 66 Street and 124 Avenue, via the High Level Bridge.[8]

On September 1, 1951, Edmonton streetcar No. 1 – one of the first two streetcars ordered by Edmonton – performed a ceremonial 'last run' across the High Level Bridge at around 8:00 PM.[1] It carried Mayor Sidney Parsons and other invited guests from Jasper Avenue and 97 Street, to the loop at 84 Avenue and 109 Street.[1] A number of the dignitaries on board took turns driving No. 1, including Lieutenant Governor John J. Bowlen, who had once been a Conductor in Boston's street railway system. From there, they took a bus to the opening ceremony for the new Strathcona bus garage, which was built at a cost of $500,000.[5] Around 1,000 people watched the streetcar trip, which marked the closure of the Edmonton's streetcar system.[5]

Streetcar service actually continued into September 2, when Car No. 52, operated by Motorman George Evans, made the final trip across the High Level Bridge at approximately 1:00 AM.[13] Transit Superintendent Thomas Ferrier and his wife, who kept themselves awake after the official ceremony ended, were among the five passengers on board – marking the final revenue streetcar trip operated by Edmonton Transit. The agency continues to operate bus and light rail lines as Edmonton Transit Service.[3]

A baby named Peter Budnyk, was born on Streetcar No. 42 on June 19, 1914.[6] His mother was on her way home from work, and went into labour during the commute.[6] She whispered something into the ear of the Conductor, and, blushing, he promised to try and hurry the streetcar to the doctor as quickly as he could. Despite the crew's best efforts, the woman gave birth while she was still on the streetcar.[6] At Kirkness and Alberta Avenue, two women carried the mother and her baby into the nearby ERR waiting room, and an ambulance later took them to a hospital.[6] Peter was healthy, and remained in the Edmonton area; he later rode Streetcar No. 1 during its ceremonial last run on September 1, 1951.[6]

The remains of Edmonton Streetcar No. 21, after derailing and falling down a ravine.

The morning of October 22, 1919, saw residents unexpectedly contending with snow and freezing temperatures.[5] As streetcar No. 21 approached the bridge spanning a ravine at 132 Street, which only had one streetcar track, Motorman McLennan slightly applied the brakes.[5] Snow and ice were compacted into piles by the skidding wheels, causing the streetcar to leave the track and lurch over the right-hand side of the bridge.[5] The streetcar fell 10 metres (33 ft) down the ravine, and landed on its roof.[14] McLennan and his five passengers all survived, but received various injuries — ranging from scratches and bruises, to fractured ribs and a broken sternum.[14] Four factors played a large role in their survival: The streetcar fell just over half the total depth of the ravine, the trucks—which were among the streetcar's heaviest components—detached before it landed, its sides caved outward instead of inward, and the frame stopped the roof from caving in.[14]

Emergency services arrived within 15 minutes, by-which time everyone was out of the streetcar.[14] After four passengers and the Motorman were admitted into the General Hospital, it was realized that a sixth person who was in the streetcar was now missing.[14] Passenger A.J. Adams was located later that same day; he sustained only a few minor injuries in the crash, helped other victims leave the wreck, then departed the scene after glancing at his watch and remarking "Goodbye, I have to get to work."[14]

The investigation into the incident was marred by controversy, after the Mayor barred city-employed witnesses from testifying at an inquiry; he claimed that this was to protect the city in case it was sued by the injured victims.[14] The 142nd Street Community League passed a motion praising Motorman McLennan, but the league also criticized the city for failing to respond to earlier complaints about the track's conditions.[5] City staff countered that this was one of 12 derailments that the ERR suffered on October 22, because of the unseasonably early winter conditions.[5]

The destroyed front vestibule of Edmonton streetcar No. 12, after it collided with streetcar No. 8

On December 6, 1930, Motorman Clarence Ostrander, age 43, died after his streetcar collided with a parked streetcar.[15] Ostrander, an 18-year veteran of the ERR, was told that morning to cover for another motorman on the 102 Avenue stub line, which he did not normally operate on.[15] While driving streetcar No. 12 west on Jasper Avenue at around 6:30 AM, to reach the start of the route, Ostrander hit the rear of streetcar No. 8, which was parked at the north-east corner of Jasper Ave and 109 Street, facing west, while servicing the red (3A) route.[16] A witness said that the streetcar, which was traveling at between 32 and 40 km/h (20–25 mph), did not slow down before the crash – the ERR's third serious collision in 1930.[17]

Ostrander was thrown into the passenger area of his streetcar by the force of the impact, and crushed against a wall by debris.[16] He suffered two fractured legs, multiple broken ribs, punctured organs, and lost consciousness.[17] Ostrander never regained consciousness, and died in hospital one hour after the collision, leaving behind a wife and two children[17] The passenger in Ostrander's streetcar, as well as the motorman in the other streetcar, escaped without injuries.[17] Streetcar No. 12's front end was completely missing after the crash, with wood and electrical equipment scattered on the road around the site.[16]

An investigation concluded that Ostrander most likely misjudged his speed, and the distance between the two streetcars, on account of the morning darkness.[17] He was also recognized for his bravery by remaining at the controls when the collision was imminent, applying the air brakes, and attempting an emergency stop by putting the streetcar into reverse with full power applied.[17] Some witnesses reported seeing a blue flame shoot from the rear of streetcar No. 12 just prior to the collision, and a witness observed Ostrander reaching for the motor breaker switch to reset it. Officials speculated that Ostrander could have tripped his streetcar's electric circuit by performing an emergency stop while the air brakes were still applied.[18]

Motorman Peter Packham

Two men attempted to rob a streetcar with a rifle on December 6, 1938.[19] Motorman Peter Packham was reversing his empty streetcar on a wye in order to start a new run on the Red and White route when one of the suspects, estimated to be between 18 and 20 years old, pulled the trolley pole off of the overhead wire.[19] When Packham, who had approximately $60 in cash and tickets, disembarked to put the pole back, he saw a man standing on the track; the suspect pointed a sawed-off .22 caliber rifle at him and told him to "stick them up."[19]

Instead of raising his hands, Packham swore and knocked the rifle out of the man's hand, kicked the gunman in his abdomen, then slipped while trying to grab the gunman.[19] It was only then when he noticed a second man standing just out of sight around the side of the streetcar.[19] Both suspects began to flee, and Packham grabbed the rifle and shot at the first suspect, but missed.[19] One man ran east on 114 Ave, and the other went south on 82 St.[19]

Packham drove his streetcar for around five more minutes before phoning police about the incident at the first open store he encountered, which was located at 92 St. and 114 Ave.[19] He continued to pick up passengers while looking for an open store.[19] Transit Superintendent Thomas Ferrier lauded Packham for his "courage and coolness" during the incident.[19] When Pakham, a veteran of the First World War, was later asked by a reporter what we would have done if he successfully shot one of the men, he responded:[19]

"Gee! I don't know. Never thought of it. But if I had, I guess I'd be worried a lot more about the whole thing than I am right now."

This was the fourth recorded violent incident in the ERR's history.[19] At the same location on April 7, 1934, Motorman George Ferguson was hit on the head and knocked unconscious while he was raising his trolley pole; the assailant was not found, nor was any money stolen.[19] In 1930, Motorman Davidson, who was elderly, was stopped by a man brandishing a gun at 127 St. in Calder.[19] After the man demanded to be let on board, Davidson opened the door, started to get underway, and shoved the man off the streetcar. On November 5, 1930, Motorman John McAllister was held up at 118 Ave. and 124 St.[19] Three youth suspects were later arrested and convicted, having been caught with $21 in stolen cash and tickets.[19]

Wreckage of streetcars 34 and 17 after the collision which killed Motorman William McKinnon

Another Motorman was killed on Friday, August 4, 1944, just before 7:00 AM.[20] Motorman William McKinnon was driving Streetcar 34 north on 124 Street, while serving the Calder route, and when his tram was near 114 Avenue it rear-ended Streetcar 17, which was on the World War Two-era "Aircraft Loop" that served local aviation facilities.[20] It was speculated by officials that McKinnon, a new Motorman who was involved in another collision earlier that summer, did not notice the streetcar ahead of him.[20] Both streetcars had a large number of passengers, but nobody else was seriously injured.[20] The force of the collision sent a button from one of the streetcars onto a porch around 35 feet (11 m) away.[20]

McKinnon was pinned under heavy debris from both streetcars, including his controller.[20] Onlookers and passengers tried to free him, but it took street railway employees using large jacks, and a crane contributed by members of a nearby Jesuit college, until 7:30 AM to release him from the wreckage.[20] McKinnon was conscious for the duration of his rescue, and begged nearby people to get him out of the wreckage. However, he died in hospital just over five hours after the collision.[20]