Gravier v City of Liège
Françoise Gravier v City of Liège (C-293/83) was an important freedom of movement case in European law concerning non-discrimination in access to vocational education. It held that an education institution may not discriminate against students in terms of the fees they charge on grounds of nationality.
| Gravier v City of Liège | |
|---|---|
 | |
| Submitted 23 December 1983 Decided 13 February 1985 | |
| Full case name | Françoise Gravier v City of Liège |
| Case number | C-293/83 |
| ECLI | ECLI:EU:C:1985:69 |
| Language of proceedings | French |
| Court composition | |
| President Lord Mackenzie Stuart | |
| Advocate General Gordon Slynn | |
| Keywords | |
| Non-discrimination | |
The judgment did not concern maintenance grants from the government. In order to claim those, the European Court of Justice's (ECJ) decisions in R (Bidar) v London Borough of Ealing[1] and Förster v Hoofddirectie van de Informatie Beheer Groep[2] state that a person can be required to have lived in a country for five years prior to a claim.
Facts
Françoise Gravier, a French national, applied in 1982 to study cartoon drawing at the Académie Royale des Beaux-Arts in the Belgian city of Liège.[3] Gravier was requested to pay a fee of 24,622 Belgian francs (approximately 610 euros) as a Minerval (enrolment fee) which was only demanded from foreign students. After refusing to meet the fee, Gravier was rejected by the Académie and her Belgian study visa was revoked.[3]
Case
Gravier argued that the fee breached Article 7 of the 1958 Treaty of Rome (discrimination on the grounds of nationality) and Article 59 (equality in the provision of services).[3] Gravier took the City of Liège to the tribunal of first instance in Belgium. The court ruled that the matter concerned European Community law and that a judgment could not be produced until two points of law had been ruled on by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in Luxembourg.[3] The case was tried in 1985.
Judgment
On 13 February 1985, the ECJ ruled that:
The imposition on students who are nationals of other members states of a charge, a registration fee or the so-called Minerval, where the fee is not imposed on students who are nationals of the host member state, constitutes discrimination on grounds of nationality contrary to Article 7 of the Treaty [of Rome].[3]
It also ruled that learning cartoon art counted as "vocational training" and thus qualify for the same legal status.[3]
Gravier v. City of Liège is acknowledged as a precedent in European case law. The ECJ further ruled that, although higher education was outside European laws and regulations, the access to it was not. As a result, non-discriminatory access had to be applied by member states for access to professional education. With the later case in 1988, Blaizot v. University of Liège, the ECJ decreed that any education at universities can be counted as professional education.
Notes
- European Court of Justice 15 March 2005, Case C-209/03, ECLI:EU:C:2005:169, 62003CJ0209, Dany Bidar v London Borough of Ealing and Secretary of State for Education and Skills
- European Court of Justice 18 November 2008, Case C-158/07, ECLI:EU:C:2008:630, 62007CJ0158, Jacqueline Förster v Hoofddirectie van de Informatie Beheer Groep (IB-Groep). (See ECLI:NL:CRVB:2009:BJ1015, the Dutch ruling based on this judgment)
- ECJ Judgment 1985.
References
- European Court of Justice (13 February 1985), Case 293/83, Françoise Gravier v City of Liège, ECLI:EU:C:1985:69
- Sacha Garben, EU Higher Education Law: The Bologna Process and Harmonization by Stealth (2011)
- Dr. Walter Demmelhuber, The European Court of Justice advancing Student Mobility, CEDEFOP, Vocational Training Nr. 21 (PDF)
- Watson, Philippa (1987). "Case 293/83, Gravier v. City of Liège, Judgment of 13 February 1985. Reference to the Court by the Tribunal de Première Instance, Liège, for a preliminary ruling on the interpretation of Articles 7 and 59 of the EEC Treaty. Case 293/85R, Commission of the European Communities v. Kingdom of Belgium: Order of the President of the Court of 25 October 1985". Common Market Law Review. 24 (1): 89–97. ISSN 0165-0750.
External links
- European Court of Justice 13 February 1985, Case 293/83, ECLI:EU:C:1985:69, Françoise Gravier v City of Liège