HBF Dalgety Ltd v Morton

HBF Dalgety Ltd v Morton [1987] 1 NZLR 411 is a leading case in New Zealand regarding accord and satisfaction; it reinforces the English case of Foakes v Beer[1] in New Zealand.[2][3][4]

HBF Dalgety Ltd v Morton
CourtHigh Court of New Zealand
Full case nameHBF Dalgety Limited v John Gilbert Morton & Eleanor Dianne Morton
Decided26 June 1987
Citation(s)[1987] 1 NZLR 411
Transcript(s)High Court judgment
Court membership
Judge(s) sittingHillyer, J
Keywords
accord and satisfaction

Facts

HBF Dalgety, a real estate agency, sold on behalf of Mr Morton his farm, for which he was later charged the standard fee of $9,768.98. Two weeks after being invoiced this amount, Mr Morton sent back the invoice with the note attached of "my estimate of costs on a 'work done' basis, $2,450", and attached a cheque for $2,450, which was duly banked. HBF Dalgety then wrote a letter to Mr Morton saying they had not accepted his cheque as full settlement, and demanded he pay the balance of its fee of $7,318.98 ($13,645 in 2011 adjusted for inflation), which Mr Morton subsequently refused to pay, claiming accord and satisfaction.

Decision

As the court ruled that there was no genuine dispute on this debt, there was neither any "accord" nor any "satisfaction" and so Mr Morton was ordered to pay the full amount claimed. Hillyer J said

It seems to me as a matter of ordinary common sense, that if at the time a person receives a cheque he writes a letter saying that he is not accepting the cheque in full settlement, it would be hard to hold that he was behaving in such a way as to make people believe that he was

References
  1. Foakes v Beer [1884] UKHL 1, 9 App Cas 605, (1883-84) LR 9 App Cas 605, (1884) 9 App Cas 605 (16 May 1884)
  2. Chetwin, Maree; Graw, Stephen; Tiong, Raymond (2006). An introduction to the Law of Contract in New Zealand (4th ed.). Thomson Brookers. p. 220. ISBN 0-86472-555-8.
  3. Gerbic, Philippa; Lawrence, Martin (2003). Understanding Commercial Law (5th ed.). LexisNexis. ISBN 0-408-71714-9.
  4. Walker, Campbell (2004). Butterworths Student Companion Contract (4th ed.). LexisNexis. p. 195. ISBN 0-408-71770-X.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.