India Conquered
India Conquered: Britain's Raj and the Chaos of Empire is a 2016 book by British historian Jon E. Wilson, Professor of Modern History at King's College, London.[1]
Author | Jon E. Wilson |
---|---|
Country | United Kingdom |
Language | English |
Subject | British Raj |
Published | London |
Publisher | Simon & Schuster |
Publication date | 2016 |
Pages | 576 |
ISBN | 978-1-4711-0126-7 |
954.03 |
Background and synopsis
India Conquered is a comprehensive history of British colonial rule in India. The book aims to lay bare that "beneath the veneer of pomp and splendour, British rule in India was anxious, fragile and fostered chaos." It demonstrates that while British colonial rulers projected themselves as heroes and nation-builders, the reality for those under occupation was "a precarious regime that provided Indian society with no leadership, and which oscillated between paranoid paralysis and occasional moments of extreme violence."[2]
India Conquered is critical of the idea that British rule was a coherent and powerful force of control in India, noting the chaotic violence of authorities and the lack of development in India during the Raj.[3]
The British innovations brought to India, civil services, education, and railways had beneficial side effects according to Wilson, but were not designed for development of India, but rather to maintain political power.[3] The book explores infrastructure programmes built by British authorities, such as the railways, and contends they were constructed late by global standards and in the face of "colonial indifference" - with an insistence that construction follow British military priorities rather than local economic priorities.[2]
Literacy rates in India rose from an estimated 3.2% in 1872, to 16.1% in 1941.[4] By the time the 155,000 British citizens living in the Raj[5] left India in 1947, only 12%[2] of the 390 million people living in India was literate.
Wilson challenges the assumption, made by many on the left, that British rule in India was an efficient structure of profit-making, arguing instead that the Raj's power was piecemeal and unsystematic.[6][7]
Reception
In The Financial Express (India) India Conquered is described as an "extensively researched" work which "proves how the British rule was not beneficial for India and how the British never assimilated themselves with the society, systems and culture of this country," but that the book "lacks proper analysis of the period prior to the British".[8]
India Conquered was praised by the British Financial Times as a "virtuoso takedown of cherished shibboleths of Raj mythology." The reviewer wrote that the book exposed "an arrogant, racist and disdainful attitude towards Indians, and also a belief that British power in India had to be absolute."[9]
In the British Literary Review, David Gilmour notes that "Wilson damages his argument by his insistence on generalisation: the British thought this or felt that...far too many Britons became linguists, historians and other scholars of India to justify the description ‘rarely interested’....There is predictably little room in this narrative for the concept of altruism." Gilmour finds that nuance distracts from Wilson's overall thesis that "‘They were interested merely in defending themselves and maintaining the trappings of authority.’"[10]
References
- "King's College London - Dr Jon Wilson". www.kcl.ac.uk.
- "India Conquered | Book by Jon Wilson | Official Publisher Page | Simon & Schuster UK". simonandschuster.co.uk. Retrieved 2017-08-28.
- Anuj Kumar (10 November 2016). "The job of a historian is to be diagnostic". The Hindu newspaper, est. 1878.
- Jayant Pandurang Nayaka; Syed Nurullah (1974). A students' history of education in India (1800–1973) (6 ed.). Macmillan.
- L.S.Vaidyanathan (1933). "Census of India 1931".
- "A Grand Delusion? - History Today". www.historytoday.com.
- Wilson, Jon (7 September 2016). "Viewpoint: The myth of 'strong' British rule in India" – via www.bbc.com.
- "Book review: India conquered: Britain's Raj and the chaos of Empire by Jon Wilson; world India have been as smart saws lek rule?". The Indian Express [P] Ltd. 9 October 2016.
- Misra, Maria (2016-09-02). "India Conquered by Jon Wilson review — the chaos of empire". Financial Times. Retrieved 2023-09-30.
- David Gilmour (9 August 2016). "Colonial Conundrums India Conquered: Britain's Raj and the Chaos of Empire". Literary Review incorporating Quarto London W1F 0LW ISSN 0144-4360.