Jack Critchley

Critchley c. 1930

Upon returning from the war, Critchley gained employment with the South Australian Railways (SAR) at Peterborough (the renamed Petersburg)[12] as a carpenter, and married Alice Cave on 6 August 1919. Joining the Australian Labor Party (ALP),[2] he became president and then secretary of the local party committee, and was later the assistant secretary of the electorate committee for the federal Division of Grey.[12] Critchley was an unsuccessful candidate for South Ward in the 1922 town council election,[13][14] but went on to serve two terms – 1923–1924 and 1928–1929 as a councillor,[15][16] and was an unsuccessful candidate for mayor in 1925.[17] He was on the board of the local hospital,[12] was president of the local sub-branch of the Returned Soldiers' Association (later the Returned Sailors' and Soldiers' Imperial League of Australia),[18] and was a justice of the peace.[19]

At the 1930 state election held on 5 April, Critchley contested the three-member seat of Burra Burra in the South Australian House of Assembly as an ALP candidate, and was elected first, alongside two other ALP candidates, with Critchley receiving 41 per cent of the votes.[1][20] The election saw the ALP, under the leadership of Lionel Hill, resoundingly defeat the Liberal Federation under Richard Layton Butler.[21] Labor had committed to address high unemployment, which Critchley had described during a speech at Jamestown on 27 March as "the biggest curse—second only to war".[22] Critchley's first speech to the assembly was brief, and urged action on the provision of rations to unemployed men in country towns, praised government protection offered to railway employees providing evidence to the royal commission on railways, and was critical of the reforms to the railways by the American Chief Commissioner of SAR, William Alfred Webb.[23]

Critchley was sensitive to the situation faced by workers during the Great Depression, deriding as "wretched" the call of the conservative opposition for "work for rations", and sought a tax on wages for employers and employees alike of three shillings. He also argued for fertile land in the south east of the state to be compulsorily acquired and used to settle unemployed people, sought to reduce the number of members of the assembly and to abolish the state upper house, the Legislative Council.[2] In 1931, splits within the ALP were inflamed over the Premiers' Plan – a deflationary and austere economic policy which sought to combat the effects of the Great Depression. When the Hill cabinet agreed to the plan, a schism occurred in the ALP which hardened the divisions. The ALP state council expelled Hill, Critchley and others in August,[24] and Critchley became a member of the Parliamentary Labor Party – also known as the Premiers' Plan Labor Party,[1] which retained government in a minority, with Lang Labor and state ALP members sitting separately.[24] Critchley was a member of the royal commission on betting in 1932–1933.[25] He ran for re-election in Burra Burra in the 1933 state election held on 8 April, but the divisions in the Labor movement saw the Parliamentary Labor Party swept from power, with Critchley defeated, attracting only 21.8 per cent of the votes.[26] He and the other members of the Parliamentary Labor Party were readmitted to the ALP after a "unity conference" in 1934, and Critchley became president of the electorate committee for the state seat of Goodwood, for which he ran unsuccessfully for preselection in 1938.[27] Critchley worked as a motor registration clerk,[2] and during World War II he worked in Adelaide as a manager of clothes rationing for industrial occupations,[28] which he later described as "a most unpleasant task".[29] During this period he was active in establishing sub-branches of the ALP in the suburbs of Adelaide.[2]

Critchley was an ALP candidate for the Australian Senate in the 1946 Australian federal election, in the second position on the ALP senate ticket after Fred Beerworth, and was duly elected. Critchley's six-year senate term commenced on 1 July 1947.[30] His first speech in the Senate urged haste in settling returned servicemen on agricultural land, sought the implementation of soil and water conservation schemes, supported social services and child immigration, and lauded the Chifley government's plans to standardise the railways and improve the road transport system. Having previously served on the state parliamentary committee assessing the value of land for settlement, he was critical of the long delays caused by differences between the federal Labor government and the conservative government in South Australia.[31] He was a member of the standing orders committee from 1947 to 1949.[32] On 10 December 1949, in the wake of its attempt to nationalise the banks, the federal ALP government of Ben Chifley was defeated by the Liberal–Country coalition, and went into opposition.[33] On 1 July 1950, Critchley was appointed opposition whip in the Senate – responsible for managing business and maintaining party discipline,[34] a position he retained until September 1957.[2]

A keen advocate for returned service personnel,[35][36] Critchley was particularly concerned for the mental health needs of those suffering from what was then known as "war neurosis" – now known as combat stress reaction. He urged the inclusion of psychiatric wards in military hospitals, and argued that it should not be necessary for returned service personnel to prove that their mental health condition was war-caused in order to be admitted to such wards. When these developments occurred interstate but had not yet happened in South Australia, he closely questioned the then Minister for Repatriation, Senator Walter Cooper.[37][38][39] Critchley was appointed to the joint committee on war gratuity in 1951.[40] A practising Catholic,[2] he nevertheless opposed the Communist Party Dissolution Bill when it was presented by the government of Prime Minister Robert Menzies in 1950.[41] A vehement supporter of the ALP's banking policies,[42] in 1951 Critchley was a member of the select committee on the Commonwealth Bank Bill 1950 (No. 2),[40] on which government senators refused to serve.[43] When the bill was defeated in the Senate, Menzies called a double dissolution election.[44]

Held on 28 April 1951,[45] the election resulted in the ALP losing control of the Senate.[46] Critchley was in third position on the ALP senate ticket for South Australia, and was elected sixth of the ten seats available.[45] He was a member of the House Committee from 21 November 1951 to 4 November 1955.[40] At the 1953 Australian Senate election, Critchley was first on the ALP senate ticket, and was elected first of the five seats available.[47] According to his family, when the ALP split over the issue of communism in 1955, Critchley refused to join the Catholic-dominated breakaway Australian Labor Party (Anti-Communist) – later the Democratic Labour Party – despite being offered the position of party leader in the Senate.[2] In 1956, Critchley and his South Australian Labor colleague Senator John Ryan advocated for a national serviceman, Private F. S. Luxton, who had been hospitalised for three months after the expiry of his training obligation period, to be compensated for the physical disabilities he had suffered.[48] In November 1957, the Menzies government brought fourteen banking bills to the evenly-matched Senate, and despite ill health, Critchley attended the chamber to ensure the bills were defeated.[49]

Jack Critchley's grave at Centennial Park Cemetery, Pasadena, South Australia

Long periods of absence from the Senate due to illness in his latter years resulted in his resignation as opposition whip in September 1957,[2] and he did not contest the 1958 Australian federal election. He was replaced in the first position on the ALP ticket by Jim Toohey, who was elected.[50] Critchley retired from the Senate on 30 June 1959 at the conclusion of his term.[40]

• Kwan, Elizabeth (1995). Which Flag? Which Country? An Australian Dilemma, 1901–1951 (PhD). Australian National University. Retrieved 28 December 2022.