Just Another Girl on the I.R.T.

The idea for the film generated from a short film Leslie Harris made for Planned Parenthood titled “Another Girl”,[2] as well as a personal experience Harris had as a teenager when her friend became pregnant. "And we were actually, like, the kind of smart kids at school. It really profoundly affected me when I found out she was pregnant—just how it changed her life, the whole responsibility of it," said Harris.[3]

Harris knew she wanted to make a film that centered on a Black woman, explaining she "was just tired of seeing the way black women were depicted, as wives or mothers or girlfriends or appendages. All from the point of view of male directors. [In I.R.T., Chantel's] the central character. There's no male character to validate her."[4] Because Harris "wanted to avoid the clichéd drug obsession accompanying male violence of most 'street' films," she ran into resistance from potential producers and financiers.[5] She said "I knew I always wanted to do a feature-length film...but for a woman… I really wasn’t encouraged. People feel that a woman can’t handle a feature-length. I was told, ‘Hey, why don’t you make it into a documentary?’"[5] At that time, the only prior feature-length film to be directed by a Black woman and get theatrical distribution was 1991's Daughters of the Dust by Julie Dash.[3][5]

Of her film's central character, Harris said "I wanted a 17-year-old, and from a creative stand point, I wanted to avoid delineating bad girl or good girl. It’s as if you can’t have a central character who’s not good at all, and from my experience I think people are a combination of bad and good.”[5] Harris also chose to shoot the film in a cinéma-vérité style, giving the audience "the feeling that you’re experiencing this girl’s life along with her. I wanted to have the film very bright, not dark and bleak, just a difference in perspective of how life goes on.”[5]

Ariyan A. Johnson was cast in the role of Chantel from over 200 hopefuls.[2]

The film was shot entirely in New York City. With a budget of only $130,000,[6] the entire film was reportedly shot in just 17 days.[7] Funds came from grants through organizations such as the American Film Institute, the National Endowment for the Arts, and Women Make Movies.[4][3] Author Terry McMillan and filmmaker Michael Moore helped to finance the post-production when it was running low on funding.[5]

On the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, 67% of 49 critics' reviews are positive, with an average rating of 6/10.[10]

Positive reviews praised Ariyan Johnson's performance as Chantel, with Hal Hinson of The Washington Post stating she "seizes the camera's attention like no other performer since John Travolta strutted into Saturday Night Fever."[11] Though some critics described the film as "awkwardly staged"[12] and said the second half loses its footing,[13] many agreed the film was groundbreaking for featuring the perspective of a teenage girl, in comparison to other Black coming-of-age films like Boyz n the Hood, Juice, and Straight Out of Brooklyn.[14]

Peter Travers of Rolling Stone wrote "Harris offers an adrenalin rush of energy and talent. Her artfully stylized, explosively funny film also manages to be deeply moving without jerking easy tears", and that Harris represents "a bracing new voice; she keeps her big little movie brimming with the pleasures of the unexpected."[15] Marjorie Baumgarten of The Austin Chronicle wrote Just Another Girl on the I.R.T. is "a faithful portrait of teenage emotional life" and "ultimately offers a welcome glimpse of one of the individuals behind the sea of faces racing by in the subway cars -- the kind of face and individual that Hollywood customarily has never given a second look."[16]

Since its release, Just Another Girl on the I.R.T. has been praised as a pioneering film about Black Americans, in particular a film directed by a Black woman, and is regularly screened at film festivals.[17][3] Jim McKay's 2000 film Our Song, a coming-of-age film starring Kerry Washington, was inspired by I.R.T.[3] Writer Tyler Young has argued the film "open[ed] the door" for films such as Crooklyn, Akeelah and the Bee, and The Hate U Give.[18] In 2020, a retrospective article in The New Yorker, stated the film captures the complex social pressures facing a Black teenage girl and argued filmmakers have "dared not do another film like it."[19]

Leslie Harris has spoken of the difficulty of producing any further feature-length films despite positive reviews of her directorial debut. Her career has drawn comparisons to other Black women directors such as Julie Dash, who similarly premiered a film at Sundance but struggled to green-light future projects. According to Harris, despite the success of Black directors such as Spike Lee and John Singleton, the film industry has been hostile to Black women, and she could not arrange funding for any other projects.[6][20]

On the 30th anniversary of the film's premiere at Sundance, Just Another Girl on the I.R.T. was given a digital restoration in 4K and was shown on the 2022 Sundance Film Festival's digital platform.[8]