Killing of Damilola Taylor

In 2002, four youths, including two 16-year-old brothers, went on trial at the Old Bailey for the murder of Taylor. The trial led to all four suspects being acquitted. Two were acquitted on the direction of the judge after he ruled that the prosecution's key witness, a 14-year-old girl, was unreliable; the jury found the other two not guilty.[5] As well as questioning the reliability of the witness, the defence presented expert witness testimony from Alastair Wilson, associate clinical director at the Royal London Hospital and one of Britain's top trauma experts, that Taylor's wounds were consistent with his falling on a broken bottle whilst being attacked. This was disputed by the prosecution, who argued that Taylor would have had to "take off and fly through the air like Peter Pan" in order for Wilson's theory to be correct. Wilson also admitted that "he had not seen Damilola's body or been given other information about the death." Pathologist Dr. Vesna Djurovic maintained that Taylor "was stabbed deliberately [with a broken bottle] in the left thigh, probably while he was on the ground."[6][7]

Despite the setback, police vowed to keep the investigation open. New DNA techniques employed by Angela Gallop and her team identified Taylor's blood on the trainers of Daniel Preddie[8][9] and on the sweatshirt cuff of his brother Richard Preddie,[5] neither of whom were among the four original suspects. This led to a re-examination of the evidence obtained at the time of Taylor's death.[5] In 2005, fresh arrests were made, resulting in Hassan Jihad, 19, and the Preddie brothers, aged 16 and 17, being charged with manslaughter. Due to their age, the Preddie brothers were not publicly named at the time of their arrest or during their trial.

On 23 January 2006, Jihad (now 21 years old) and the Preddie brothers (now 17 and 18 years old) appeared at the Old Bailey to face charges of his manslaughter and assault before the start of their imminent trial. The trial commenced on 24 January 2006. Alastair Wilson again testified that he thought that Taylor had died after falling on a shard of glass from a broken bottle.[10] After retiring on 29 March to consider its verdict, on 3 April the jury cleared Jihad of all charges in relation to Taylor's death.[11] They were unable to reach a verdict on the charges of manslaughter against the two brothers, so they were released, but with the possibility of a retrial on those charges.

The retrial of the two brothers began on 23 June. The two brothers, then over 18, were named as Danny and Ricky Preddie, of Peckham, south London.[11] Both defendants were very well known to police, having committed multiple robberies.[12]

On 9 August 2006, Ricky Gavin Preddie (born 1987, Lambeth, London) and Danny Charles Preddie (born 1988, Lambeth), after a 33-day retrial, were convicted of the manslaughter of Taylor.[11]

During the retrial it was noted that, while the police did follow procedure collecting evidence, lapses occurred in the prosecution.[13]

On 9 October 2006, an Old Bailey judge sentenced the Preddie brothers to eight years in youth custody for manslaughter.[14]

Although it was widely reported in the media that Taylor's parents were unhappy that the sentences had not been longer, the judge, Mr Justice Goldring, went to some lengths to explain the factors he was forced to take into account. These included the age of the offenders at the time (12 and 13), and that there was no evidence to suggest that there had been a plan to kill Taylor. In addition, the bottle used had not been carried to the scene of the crime.

Both brothers were set to be paroled in 2010 after serving half of their sentence. Ricky was released on 8 September 2010,[15] subject to probation supervision, and subject to recall to custody if he breached the conditions or if his behaviour indicated that it was no longer safe to allow him to remain in the community. Danny was released in 2011. Ricky was recalled on 13 March 2011 because he was seen in Peckham, and for associating with gang members, both contrary to his parole conditions.[16] He was released again on 25 January 2012.[17] He was again recalled to prison sixteen days later, in February 2012, after again associating with gang members in Peckham, in breach of the terms of his release. Taylor's father called for a public inquiry into the handling of the case.[18] Ricky Preddie was released again in July 2012.