Utah Lake

Utah Lake (Shoshone: Paa-Kateten “Water Sitting”)[6] is a shallow freshwater lake in the center of Utah County, Utah, United States. It lies in Utah Valley, surrounded by the Provo-Orem metropolitan area. The lake's only river outlet, the Jordan River, is a tributary of the Great Salt Lake. Evaporation accounts for 42% of the lake's outflow, which leaves the lake slightly saline. The elevation of the lake is at 4,489 feet (1,368 m) above sea level. If the lake's water level rises above that, the pumps and gates on the Jordan River are left open. Recently the lake has been at a lower level because of a drought.

Utah Lake and Utah Valley
Utah Lake
Paa-Kateten
Satellite photo of Utah Lake
Utah Lake is located in Utah
Utah Lake
Utah Lake
Location of within Utah
Utah Lake is located in the United States
Utah Lake
Utah Lake
Location within the United States
LocationUtah County, Utah,
United States
Coordinates40°13′12″N 111°48′00″W
Typeslightly saline Eutrophic[1]
Primary inflowsAmerican Fork, Provo River, Hobble Creek, and Spanish Fork
Primary outflowsJordan River and evaporation
Catchment area3,846 sq mi (9,960 km2)[2]
Basin countriesUnited States
Managing agencyState of Utah
Max. length24 mi (39 km)[3]
Max. width13 mi (21 km)[3]
Surface area95,000 acres (380 km2)[4]
Average depth10.5 ft (3.2 m)[5]
Max. depth14 ft (4.3 m)[5]
Water volume870,000 acre⋅ft (1.07×109 m3)[4]
Surface elevation4,489 ft (1,368 m) (compromise)[4]
Islands1
SettlementsProvo-Orem metropolitan area
Websiteutahlake.org

The first European to see Utah Lake was Father Silvestre Vélez de Escalante in 1776. He stayed with the Timpanogots band of Ute Tribe for three days. Mormon settlers later settled near the lake beginning in 1849, with the Timpanogots becoming mostly displaced from the area by 1872. The native fish species of the lake were overharvested by the settlers and subsequently restocked with non-native species.

Although thirteen species of fish were native to the lake, only the Utah sucker[7] and the critically endangered June sucker[8] remain. The dominant species in the lake is the common carp, introduced in 1883 as an alternative to the overharvested native fish. The carp is now estimated at 90% of the biomass of the lake and contributes to a decline in native fish populations by severely altering the ecosystem. Pollution has also caused problems with the lake's ecosystem. Raw sewage was dumped into the lake as late as 1967. Pollution problems still remain; the lake's phosphorus and mineral salt levels are in violation of the Clean Water Act. In recent years, the lake has been prone to harmful algal blooms or HABs.[9][10]

Utah Lake is managed cooperatively by the Utah Division of Forestry, Fire & State Lands and the Utah Lake Commission. The Division manages public use and issues a permit for commercial users of the lakebed and shoreline while the Commission facilitates development. The lakebed and surrounding shoreline are made up of State Sovereign Lands. Utah Lake is one of three lakes in the state that were deemed "navigable" at statehood and granted to the State of Utah.[11] Sovereign lands are managed under the public trust doctrine.

The Utah State Legislature has designated the Division of Forestry, Fire & State Lands as the executive authority for the management of sovereign lands and the state's mineral estates on lands other than school and institutional trust lands. Sovereign lands are defined by the Utah State Legislature as "those lands lying below the ordinary high water mark of navigable bodies of water at the date of statehood and owned by the state by virtue of its sovereignty."[12]

The Commission was created by State statute in Utah's 2007 General Legislative Session, House Concurrent Resolution 1, under the authority of the Interlocal Cooperation Act. The Commission is funded and empowered by 17 area governments, including; Utah County and its municipalities, the Central Utah Water Conservancy District, and three state agencies. Founded in 2007, the Commission seeks to promote multiple public uses of the lake, facilitate orderly planning and development in and around the lake, and enable individual Commission members to govern their own areas.

Name

The lake was originally named after the Timpanogos band of the Shoshone tribe.[13] A Utah state lawmaker, Brady Brammer, has stated that he is considering proposing a bill to rename Utah Lake to Lake Timpanogos.[14]

Geography

Utah Lake is within Utah Valley in north-central Utah. Mountains surround Utah Valley on three sides: the Wasatch Range to the east, Traverse Mountains to the north, and the Lake Mountains to the west. Mount Nebo reaches an altitude of 11,863-foot (3,616 m),[15] and Mount Timpanogos reaches an altitude of 11,745-foot (3,580 m),[16] nearly 7,250 feet (2,210 m) above the valley floor. Jutting into the south portion of the lake is 6,805-foot (2,074 m) West Mountain,[17] which divides Goshen Bay and Lincoln Beach. Utah Lake is situated on the western edge of the valley and covers more than 25% of Utah Valley's floor.[4] Because of its location on the western side of the valley, the eastern shore has a gentle slope and the western shore rises abruptly against the Lake Mountains. Connected to the main body of the lake are two large, shallow bays: the aforementioned Goshen Bay (north Goshen Valley) to the south and Provo Bay to the east. Major cities such as Provo and Orem are located between the lake's eastern shore and the Wasatch Range.

Utah Lake is a remnant of a much larger pleistocene lake called Lake Bonneville, which existed from 75,000 to 8,000 years ago.[18] At its peak 30,000 years ago, Lake Bonneville reached an elevation of 5,090 feet (1,550 m) above sea level and had a surface area of 19,800 square miles (51,000 km2), which was nearly as large as Lake Michigan. The weight of the lake depressed sections of the lake bottom by as much as 240 feet (73 m) before the surface rebounded when the lake dried up.[19] About 12,000 years ago, the climate of the region became warmer and drier. As evaporation rates exceeded inflow rates, the lake began to dry up, leaving Utah Lake, the Great Salt Lake, Sevier Lake, and Rush Lake as remnants.[20]

Wasatch Range and ancient shoreline of Lake Bonneville

Over the roughly 65,000 years that Lake Bonneville existed, sediments built up, creating a lacustrine plain over Utah Valley. As a result, the valley floor and lake bed are relatively flat, which causes the lake to be shallow.[21] The lake has a maximum depth of just under 14 feet (4.3 m) and an average depth of about 10.5 feet (3.2 m). This shallowness allows winds to easily stir up sediments from the lake's bottom, contributing to the turbidity or the impression of pollution seen in Utah Lake's water.[5]

Three faults run under Utah Lake. One of the faults, the Bird Island fault, runs under the eastern edge of the lake and helps give rise to hot springs near Lincoln Beach.[22] The other major hot spring is on the northern shore and is called Saratoga Springs. The hot springs mostly result from the development of hydraulic pressure as the ground water slopes toward the middle of the lake.[23]

The lake contains a small island called Bird Island, about 2.25 miles (3.62 km) north of the Lincoln Beach boat ramp, near its south end. The island has a few trees and is somewhat visible from Lincoln Beach. During high-water years, the island may be completely submerged, the trees being the only indication it is there. It is a fairly popular destination among fishermen seeking walleye, white bass, and channel catfish.[24]

Hydrology
Map of the Jordan River Basin.

The Utah Lake watershed drains 3,846 square miles (9,960 km2) over mostly mountainous terrain. The watershed's highest point is at 11,765-foot (3,586 m) Bald Mountain in the Uinta Mountains.[25] 782,335 acres (3,166 km2) (32%) are managed by the United States Forest Service, 249,329 acres (1,009 km2) (11%) are managed by other government entities, and the majority of the rest, 1,263,696 acres (5,114 km2) (51%), are privately owned.[2]

Two major tributaries account for nearly 60% of inflow by streams or rivers into Utah Lake. The Provo River accounts for 36% of the inflow, and the Spanish Fork river accounts for 24%.[26] Other tributaries include the American Fork river, Current Creek, Dry Creek, Hobble Creek, and Mill Race Creek. Additionally, many hot springs and smaller creeks are flowing into the lake. Utah Lake is drained by the Jordan River, which begins at the lake's north end. The river flows north through Utah, Salt Lake, and Davis counties and then into the southeast portion of the Great Salt Lake. Given the lake's semi-arid climate, large surface area, and shallow average depth, evaporation accounts for 42% of Utah Lake's outflow.[27]

Jordan River pumping station at Utah Lake, April 2010

After several years of drought, irrigation companies argued over their share of Utah Lake's water from the Jordan River. Judge Morse of the Third District Court issued his judgment known as the Morse Decree of 1901. The decree stated that the irrigation companies "are entitled to a decree awarding to them, subject to the limitations hereinafter set forth, the right to the use of all the balance of the waters of the Jordan River, for municipal, irrigation, culinary, and domestic purposes, to the extent of the capacity of their several canals, and the right to impound and store all of the waters of said river in Utah Lake."[28] In response to the drought, a pumping plant was installed at the outlet of the Jordan River from Utah Lake. It was the largest pumping plant in the United States at the time. The plant contained seven pumps with a total capacity of 700 cubic feet (20 m3) per second.[29] After the decree was released, Utah Lake essentially became an irrigation reservoir, and the Jordan River's flow was highly regulated.

As a result of the 1983–1984 flooding, a lawsuit was filed for compensation due to flooding based upon breach of contract of the previous compromise level. In 1985, a new compromise level was reached, which governed the maximum level of the lake. The new level was chosen to be 4,489 feet (1,368 m) above sea level. When the water level in Utah Lake exceeds this level, the Jordan River pumps and gates are left open.[30] The new compromise level also meant that the lake's elevation was below Jordan River's stream bed.

Pollution

In 1948, a study showed Utah Lake was being seriously polluted. As a result, Utah County cities decided to plan how and where to build sewage treatment plants instead of dumping raw sewage into the lake.[31] By 1954, many cities had constructed sewage treatment plants, but Provo's was still under construction.[32] Raw sewage was still getting into the lake by 1967.[33]

In the State of Utah, the Utah Division of Water Quality and Utah Division of Drinking Water are responsible for the management and regulation of water quality. Lakes, rivers, and streams that exceed the standard levels are then placed on the DEQ 303d list in accordance with the Clean Water Act. The Act requires states to identify impaired water bodies every two years and develop a total maximum daily load (TMDL) for pollutants that a body of water can assimilate without causing the water body to exceed the water quality standards.[34] Utah Lake was originally put on Utah's 2000 and 2004 303d list for phosphorus and total dissolved solids (TDS) exceeding recommend values. High levels of phosphorus can cause high levels of nuisance algae growth, low dissolved oxygen, and eleTDS tells about the concentration of mineral salts in the water, which can cause problems to agriculture and culinary water supplies.[35] Excess levels of phosphorus come from multiple sources, but namely the wastewater treatment plants, are extremely concerning when it comes to Utah Lake management because high levels can trigger harmful algal blooms and eutrophication[36] There is some discussion as to how much of the phosphorus is the result of anthropogenic causes and how much is the result of historic phosphorus stored in the lake sediment.[37]

Krissy Wilson of Utah's Division of Wildlife Resources stated in 2010 that water quality is now improving, with greater flows of water, among other things, contributing to the improvement. However, the presence and activity of carp, which stir up solids in the water, makes it difficult to appreciate the improvement without conducting scientific measurements.[38]

Harmful algal blooms in Utah Lake

There are several cyanobacteria species that are especially common when phosphorus levels and temperature, among other unknown criteria, are favorable for harmful algal blooms.[36] These are Aphanizomenon flos-aquae and Dolichospermum flosaquae species, both of which produce cyanotoxins.[39] If levels are high enough for either species and others, the lake is closed to the public.[40]

History

Pre-European

The first inhabitants of the area were nomadic hunter-gatherers of the Desert Archaic Culture.[41] An archeology site, called the Soo'nkahni Village, has been explored next to the Jordan River in Draper. The site dates back 3,000 years, and over 30,000 artifacts have been found.[42] The next recorded inhabitants were the Fremont people who lived in the Utah Lake area from about 400 AD to about 1350 AD. They consisted of small villages of hunters and farmers. They farmed corn, squash, and beans.[43] When climatic conditions changed, they caused trouble for farming. Also, the ancestors to the Ute, Paiute, and Northwestern Shoshone moved into the area. As a result, the Fremont people left the area.[44]

The third group inhabited the area was the Utes of central Utah and eastern Colorado. The Timpanogot (also called Timpanogos, Timpanogotzi, Timpannah, and Tempenny) band of the Utes inhabited Utah Valley.[45] They were the most dominant band of Utes due to the relative ease of gathering the plentiful local food supply.[46] It was a sacred meeting place for the Timpanogos, Ute and Shoshone tribes.[47] During the spring spawning season, these tribes would meet at Utah Lake for the annual fish festival. At the festival, there was dancing, singing, trading, horse races, gambling, and feasting on the plentiful fish the lake provided. It was also an opportunity to find a mate from another clan.[48] In 1826, Jedediah Smith visited a camp along the Spanish Fork river that had 35 lodges with about 175 people.[49]

European explorers

Franciscan missionary Silvestre Vélez de Escalante, while on his expedition in late summer and early autumn of 1776, was trying to find a land route from Santa Fe, New Mexico to Monterey, California. Two Timpanogots from Utah Valley acted as guides for his party. On September 23, 1776, the party traveled down Spanish Fork Canyon and entered the Utah Valley.[50] From Escalante's journal, he describes Utah Lake: "The lake, which must be six leagues wide and fifteen leagues long, extends as far as one of these valleys. It runs northwest through a narrow passage, and according to what they told us, it communicates with others much larger. This lake of Timpanogotzis abounds in several kinds of good fish, geese, beaver, and other amphibious animals which did not have an opportunity to see. Round about it is these Indians, who live on the abundant fish of the lake, for which reason the Yutas Sabuaganas call them "Come Pescados" (Fish Eaters). Besides this, they gather in the plain grass seeds from which they make atole, which they supplement by hunting hares, rabbits, and fowl of which there is great abundance here."[51] Escalante named the lake Lake Timpanogos, after the tribe living in the area. Escalante's record clearly distinguishes between this Lake Timpanogos, a body of freshwater that he saw and sized, and the Great Salt Lake, which he did not see or name but was described to him as a river "communicates with others much larger." The next recorded European visitor was Étienne Provost, a French-Canadian trapper who visited Utah Lake in October 1824.[52] The city of Provo and the Provo River are named after him.

Early settlement by members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints
Illustration of Fort Utah in 1850

The settlement of Utah by members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints began in July 1847, when pioneers entered the Salt Lake Valley.[53] Under the direction of Parley P. Pratt, an exploration of Utah Valley was conducted. The party brought a small boat in which they explored Utah Lake and caught fish with their nets.[54] The first battle between settlers and Indians occurred in early March 1849. A company of forty men was sent into Utah Valley to stop the stealing of cattle from the Salt Lake Valley. The company met in the village of Little Chief, who told them where the people responsible for the stealing were located. A skirmish took place in which four Timpanogots were killed. The settlers named the site of the skirmish Battle Creek, which was later renamed Pleasant Grove.[55][56]

In April 1849, a group of about thirty families came into Utah Valley and settled on the Provo River, very close to the main Timpanogot village on the Provo River. The settlers built a stockade called Fort Utah and armed it with a twelve-pound cannon to intimidate the Timpanogots.[57] In August, a Timpanogot named Old Bishop was murdered by three settlers over a shirt they wanted from him.[57][58] Some Timpanogots shot at cattle or stole corn in response. Winter was especially hard, and Timpanogots stole cattle for food. By January 1850, settlers of Fort Utah reported to officials in Salt Lake City that the situation was getting dangerous. They wanted a military party to attack the Timpanogots. A militia was sent from Salt Lake City, and on February 8 and 11, they engaged the Timpanogots in battle. On February 14, eleven Timpanogots surrendered but were later executed while their families watched. A government surgeon went to the execution site and cut off the Timpanogots' heads for later examination. One militia man and 102 Timpanogots were killed.[59] Over the ensuing years, fewer and fewer Timpanogots lived in Utah Valley, and by 1872, all Timpanogots had moved to the Uintah and Ouray Indian Reservation. However, some Timpanogots occasionally returned to fish on Utah Lake into the 1920s.[56]

Captain Howard Stansbury of the United States Army's Corps of Topographical Engineers was ordered to map, survey, and explore Utah and Salt Lake Valleys. In 1850, Captain Stansbury explored Utah Lake and Utah Valley,[60] surveyed[61] and made observation of the local wildlife.[62]

Ecosystem

Historically, there have been four species of amphibia, twelve species of reptiles, thirteen species of fish, 152 species of birds, and forty-two species of mammals found in the environs of Utah Lake.[63][64] The dumping of raw sewage, destruction of natural habit, hunting, and the introduction of non-native fish species have taken a toll on the native species in and around the lake.[65][66]

Some of the mammals that live around the lake are the big brown bat, the silver-haired bat, mule deer, Botta's pocket gopher, desert woodrat, and striped skunk. There are seventeen known native mollusca to Utah Lake. Only three were reported in the lake ecosystem in 1969, and one species is extinct.[67] The last living example of the thickshell pondsnail (Stagnicola utahensis), a freshwater snail, was reportedly seen in the early 1930s. Four specimens were sent to the Smithsonian Institution in 1911 and the only known location for the snail was Utah Lake.[68]

Birds

During the 1800s and the 1930s, killing fish-eating birds were seen as a fish conservation measure. Local government entities gave bounties, and upon presenting evidence of offending dead birds, game officers paid the bounties.[65] A report by a hunter states, "There was a bounty paid on cranes and heron in 1895. Two men could make as high as $66 a day. Wading into the rookeries with their pants off they would crack the heron over the head. When the bounty was paid on pelican we would use a fish float tide to a wad of rushes. Gulls were also caught. There has been 10,000 slaughtered. At the Big Channel gidls have been shot and there are four or five hundred pelicans which have been shot. In 1928 I killed 1,240 mudhens [coot]. We would eat the hearts and gizzards, take the feathers and oil and discard the rest."[65]

Pelicans and ducks at Utah Lake, April 2010

The Utah Lake wetland ecosystem is an important breeding area and stopover for migratory birds in the Pacific Flyway. Today, about 226 species of birds use the lake as their permanent home or as a stopover on their migration. The Utah Lake Wetland Preserve has been established at the south end of Utah Lake. It contains two units, one at Goshen bay with more than 21,750 acres (88.0 km2) of land preserved, and another unit at Benjamin Slough.[69] Birds seen at Utah Lake include sandhill crane, double-crested cormorant, pheasant, great horned owl, turkey vulture, golden eagle, cinnamon teal duck, and mallard duck.[70]

Fish

Parley P. Pratt visited Fort Utah in June 1849 and saw thousands of fish caught by settlers and Timpanogots. He estimated that 5000 barrels of fish could be secured annually from the fishery.[71] The winter of 1885–1886 caused much of the livestock to die. Leaders of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints elders sent members in the Salt Lake Valley to Utah Lake to obtain fish; an estimated 96,000 pounds (44,000 kg) of fish were brought back.[72] The first commercial fishery also started the same year. At the 1870 General Conference of the LDS Church, a committee was appointed to develop fish culture because of the declining fish harvest in Utah Lake. By 1904, it became illegal to commercially catch any fish except for non-native species.[73]

At least 25 species have been introduced into Utah Lake's waters. Thirteen introductions were unsuccessful. Carp, largemouth bass, white bass, black bullhead, channel catfish, walleye, goldfish, yellow perch, blue gill, and black crappie are found in abundance.[74] The golden shiner and the fathead minnow are rarely found.[75]

Of the thirteen species of fish native to Utah Lake, one species is extinct (the Utah Lake sculpin), one is no longer present in the lake and is under review to see if it qualifies for protection under the Endangered Species Act (least chub),[76] one is already listed as endangered (the June sucker), and one is found in relative abundance throughout Utah (the Utah sucker). All other native fish are no longer extant in the lake.[64]

The Bonneville cutthroat trout was historically the top predator fish in the ecosystem but is now restricted to tributary streams.[64] A review in 2008 indicates that viable populations are distributed throughout its historic range and do not merit listing as a threatened or endangered species.[77]

The Utah Lake sculpin was last found in 1928 and likely became extinct in the 1930s after severe drought lowered the lake levels, allowing much of the lake to freeze, overcrowding fish in unfrozen portions of the lake. This overcrowding and pollution from agricultural runoff are probable causes of the fish's extinction.[78]

The Bonneville redside shiner, mottled sculpin, leatherside chub, Utah chub, speckled dace, longnose dace, mountain whitefish and mountain sucker are no longer in the lake, but still exist in tributaries.[64]

The June sucker was federally listed as an endangered species in 1986. The lower 5 miles (8.0 km) of the Provo River is the only known spawning location for the species.[79] Biologists have been rearing the June sucker in Red Butte Reservoir and releasing them into Utah Lake to help build the population. During the summer of 2005, over 8,000 June sucker were released into Utah Lake.[80] The June Sucker Recovery Implementation Program (JSRIP) coordinates and implements recovery actions for the June sucker.[81]

Common carp, such as these in Lake Powell, are the dominant species of fish in the lake.

The common carp was introduced in 1883 as a source of food after native species had been depleted by overfishing. It is now the most prevalent fish found in Utah Lake.[82][83] Carp makes up about 90% of the lake's biomass,[84] with an adult population numbering around 7.5 million. The average carp in the lake is about 5.3 pounds (2.4 kg), for a total of nearly 40,000,000 pounds (18,000,000 kg) of carp in the lake.[85]

As early as 1901, fish and wildlife representatives noted that carp were causing the trout population in the lake to collapse.[38] Due to their habit of grubbing through bottom sediments for food, carp stir up sediments and increase the turbidity of the water. In addition, they destroy submerged vegetation that holds sediments in place and provides shelter for native fish populations. Without vegetation, winds can more easily stir up sediment from the bottom of the lake, which is already a problem due to the lake's shallowness, resulting in greater turbidity and less sunlight reaching the remaining vegetation. Without cover for their young, native fish, such as the June sucker, become easy prey for white bass, walleye, and other predators.[86]

Efforts are underway to reduce the population of carp in Utah Lake by employing local commercial fishermen, led by Bill Loy, Jr., to remove 5 million pounds of carp each year as part of the June Sucker Recovery Implementation Program's efforts to restore Utah Lake to a habitat in which the June sucker can survive. The intent is to cause a crash in the carp population which will allow the ecosystem to begin to rebuild and the June sucker to reestablish dominance in the lake.[87]

The Utah Lake Commission has previously stated its goal is to remove 32 million pounds of carp from the lake, and more than 17 million pounds have been removed as of November 2019.[88]

Recreation

Due to its proximity to the Provo-Orem metropolitan area, Utah Lake is a fairly popular destination. From the 1880s to the 1930s, up to twelve resorts offering boat rentals, picnic facilities, dance halls, swimming pools, and bathhouses served tourists at the lake.[4] Saratoga Springs, on the north shore, was the most popular and longest-lived resort. Saratoga Springs was best known for its natural hot springs but also had waterslides and amusement park rides. It lasted from the 1860s until the floods of 1984.[89][90] In the summer, fishing, water skiing, boating, camping, and picnicking are the most popular activities. During the winter, ice fishing, ice hockey, and ice skating are popular on the lake, especially at Utah Lake State Park, and Lincoln Beach. The main marina for Utah Lake is at Utah Lake State Park on the lake's eastern shore. Other marinas are at Saratoga Springs, American Fork, Lindon, and Lincoln Beach.[91]

The ownership of lands along the shoreline of Utah Lake has been in dispute between the State of Utah and farmers for many years. The bed of Utah Lake, along with other natural lakes, was granted to the state upon admission to the Union in 1896. However, due to the lack of an exact definition and significantly fluctuating lake levels, intermittently dry areas, and wetlands, including all of Provo Bay, have been claimed and farmed by surrounding land owners.[92] The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1987 that the State of Utah owned the land beneath Utah Lake.[93]

In January 2018, the Utah Department of Natural Resources received a project proposal as a potential solution to the lake's nutrient pollution, invasive species, and murky water.[94] The project proposal involved dredging the lake bottom of all nutrient-loaded sediment, replacing invasive plant and animal species with native species, and restoring the water quality before building and developing housing on arch-shaped islands. The proposal became known as the Utah Lake Restoration project,[95] and had an estimated cost of $6.4 billion which would be obtained through private investors.[96] The proposal led to the creation of the House Bill 272 - Utah Lake Amendments (HB 272), which asserted that Utah Lake faced serious challenges, that conservation and restoration were possible, and in the interest of the state, and authorized "the Division of Forestry, Fire, and State Lands to dispose of state land in exchange for the execution of a project for the comprehensive restoration of Utah Lake," an act which would otherwise be prohibited. On March 21, 2018, Governor Gary Herbert signed HB 272 into law.[97]

Critics of the project include ecologists and other scientists raising hydrologic and ecological concerns with the project. Specific issues include the fact that the project would likely lead to the creation of anoxic waters due to lake stratification, the destruction of the lake's unique hydrology and biogeochemistry, the release of toxins and nutrients, altering the lake from its natural state, and geology unsuitable for supporting inhabited islands.[98][99] Other critics disputed the passing of HB272 as an attempt to trade sovereign lands in exchange for a service.[100] The ability of the developer to maintain the alterations to the lake after the completion of the project has also been brought into question.

In October 2022, permitting for the Utah Lake Restoration project was put on hold, according to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, because of a lack of documentation required to win federal permits under the Clean Water Act.[101]

On October 27, 2022, Utah's Division of Forestry, Fire & State Lands rejected the proposal by Lake Restoration Solutions. The division director Jamie Barnes said that the lake bed is sovereign state land and cannot be privatized.[14]

As of June 14, 2023 the company that had proposed the project to develop Utah Lake has been dissolved. [102]

Environmental concerns

In 2008, Utah Lake's carp and channel catfish were found to be contaminated by polychlorinated biphenyls, also known as PCB's. After an investigation, no originating source for the PCBs was found.[103]

The lake was closed due to contamination from toxic algae in 2016, 2018,[104] and 2019.[105]

Recovery efforts

June Sucker Recovery Implementation Program (JSRIP)

The June Sucker is a species of fish endemic to Utah Lake and its tributaries. The June Sucker is a key indicator species for the overall health of the ecosystem. Though listed as endangered in 1986 after ecosystem degradation and invasive species concentration, thanks to the efforts of the JSRIP, the June Sucker was downlisted to “threatened” on February 3, 2021. Actions taken to recover the June Sucker include non-native species removal, specifically carp and Northern pike; increasing the population through stocking and monitoring; and restoring and maintaining habitat, including the tributaries Hobble Creek and the Provo River.[106] https://www.junesuckerrecovery.org/

Provo River Delta Restoration Project

In an effort to recover the June Sucker and restore the area's natural ecosystem, the Provo River Delta Restoration Project is an ongoing process in which a large portion of the lower Provo River flow is diverted into a series of channels and wetlands before reaching Utah Lake. The restored delta area provides a habitat for juvenile June Suckers to grow to a survivable size.[107] The project also provides for improved trail and river access, fishing platforms, and other recreational facilities.[108] The project began in 2020 and is expected to be completed in 2024.

Phragmites removal

Phragmites is an aggressive, invasive plant species that dominates a large portion of the Utah Lake shoreline. Since 2014, a large-scale collaborative effort has been underway to mitigate the negative effects of the species through the use of herbicides and crushing techniques. Reports in 2020 indicated a 70% decrease in phragmites.[109][110]

Utah Lake Water Quality Study (ULWQS)

The purpose of the ULWQS is to gather data on the nutrient concentrations (particularly nitrogen and phosphorus) in Utah Lake and develop nutrient criteria to protect the ecosystem. Phase 1 of the project, Data Gathering, was completed in 2018.[111] Phase 2, Developing Criteria, is currently underway and will be followed by Phase 3, Implementation.

Utah Lake folklore

In the late 1800s and early 1900s, there were several reported sightings of strange creatures in the lake, leading to tales of a lake monster with descriptions of the cryptid's appearance varying from being reptilian with an alligator's head to being seal-like.[112]

See also

References
  1. Fuhriman et al. 1981, p. 43
  2. Utah Lake Watershed, Great Salt Lake Basin Hydrologic Observatory, retrieved April 7, 2010
  3. Utah Lake, June Sucker Recovery Implementation Program, archived from the original on October 12, 2009, retrieved April 10, 2010
  4. Jackson & Stevens 1981, p. 3
  5. Brimhall & Merritt 1981, pp. 30–31
  6. "ArcGIS Web Application". mlibgisservices.maps.arcgis.com. Retrieved 2023-03-31.
  7. COLE, D. D.; MOCK, K. E.; CARDALL, B. L.; CROWL, T. A. (December 2008). "Morphological and genetic structuring in the Utah Lake sucker complex". Molecular Ecology. 17 (24): 5189–5204. doi:10.1111/j.1365-294x.2008.03990.x. ISSN 0962-1083. PMID 19067800. S2CID 34427341.
  8. Strohm, Deanna D.; Budy, Phaedra; Crowl, Todd A. (2017-05-22). "Matching Watershed and Otolith Chemistry to Establish Natal Origin of an Endangered Desert Lake Sucker". Transactions of the American Fisheries Society. 146 (4): 732–743. doi:10.1080/00028487.2017.1301994. ISSN 0002-8487.
  9. Randall, Matthew C.; Carling, Gregory T.; Dastrup, Dylan B.; Miller, Theron; Nelson, Stephen T.; Rey, Kevin A.; Hansen, Neil C.; Bickmore, Barry R.; Aanderud, Zachary T. (2019). "Sediment potentially controls in-lake phosphorus cycling and harmful cyanobacteria in shallow, eutrophic Utah Lake". PLOS ONE. 14 (2): e0212238. Bibcode:2019PLoSO..1412238R. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0212238. PMC 6375609. PMID 30763352. S2CID 67857832.
  10. "Utah Lake Study 2018 State of the Environment Report (WQ)". Utah Department of Environmental Quality. 2019-01-02. Retrieved 2020-03-25.
  11. "Utah State Code".
  12. State of Utah. "Utah Division of Forestry, Fire & State Lands". Utah DNR.
  13. Maffly, Brian (31 March 2022). "How Utah Lake once sustained tribes and Mormon pioneers and why it needs help". Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved 31 October 2022.
  14. Winslow, Ben (27 October 2022). "Utah Lake islands project is rejected by state officials". Fox 13 Salt Lake City. Retrieved 31 October 2022.
  15. "Feature Detail Report for: Mount Nebo", U.S. Board on Geographic Names, United States Geological Service, retrieved April 7, 2010
  16. "Feature Detail Report for: Mount Timpanogos", U.S. Board on Geographic Names, United States Geological Service, retrieved April 7, 2010
  17. "Feature Detail Report for: West Mountain", U.S. Board on Geographic Names, United States Geological Service, retrieved April 7, 2010
  18. Brimhall & Merritt 1981, pp. 25–26
  19. Major_Levels_of_Great_Salt_Lake_and_Lake_Bonneville 1984, pp. 1–2
  20. Lake_Bonneville_fluctuations_and_global_climate_change 1997, pp. 155–158
  21. Jackson & Stevens 1981, p. 5
  22. Brimhall & Merritt 1981, pp. 36–38
  23. Brimhall & Merritt 1981, p. 39
  24. Utah Lake's Bird Island, Utah Outdoors, archived from the original on July 17, 2010, retrieved April 7, 2010
  25. "Feature Detail Report for: Bald Mountain", U.S. Board on Geographic Names, United States Geological Service, retrieved April 7, 2010
  26. Utah_Lake_TMDL 2007, p. 9
  27. Utah_Lake_TMDL 2007, p. 12
  28. Utah_Lake_and_Jordan_River_Water_Management Plan 1989, p. 10
  29. Utah_Lake_and_Jordan_River_Water_Management Plan 1989, pp. 8–9
  30. Utah Lake interim water distribution plan, Utah Division of Water Rights, April 16, 1993, retrieved April 9, 2010
  31. "Probe Slated In Pollution Of Utah Lake", Deseret News, Salt Lake City, July 21, 1948, retrieved April 9, 2010
  32. "Storage Project, Sewage Disposal Would Aid The Future Of Utah Lake", Deseret News, Salt Lake City, May 20, 1954, retrieved April 9, 2010
  33. "Sewage Fouls Utah Lake", Deseret News, Salt Lake City, November 2, 1967, retrieved April 9, 2010
  34. Total Maximum Daily Loads (TMDL), Utah Division of Water Quality, archived from the original on June 30, 2010, retrieved April 1, 2010
  35. Utah_Lake_TMDL 2007, pp. 5–6
  36. Descy, J.P. et al. Identifying the factors determining blooms of cyanobacteria in a set of shallow lakes. Ecol. Informatics, vol. 34, pp. 129-138, 2016
  37. Abu-Hmeidan, Hani Yousef, Gustavious P. Williams, and A. Woodruff Miller. "Characterizing Total Phosphorus in Current and Geologic Utah Lake Sediments: Implications for Water Quality Management Issues." Hydrology 5, no. 1 (March 2018): 8. https://doi.org/10.3390/hydrology5010008.
  38. Haddock, Marc (September 26, 2010). "Save the June sucker, save Utah Lake?". Deseret News. Retrieved November 26, 2012.
  39. Rosen, B. H., Amand, A. S., & Rosen. (2015). Field and Laboratory Guide to Freshwater Cyanobacteria Harmful Algal Blooms for Native American and Alaska Native Communities. Open-File Report. doi: 10.3133/ofr20151164
  40. USU Water Quality Extension. (2016, February). Utah Water Watch HAB Monitoring Program. Retrieved October 2019, from https://extension.usu.edu/utahwaterwatch/ou-files/Instructions/HAB.pdf.
  41. The_Aboriginal_Peoples 1960, pp. 211–222
  42. "Tribal leaders say UTA 'ignores' them", Salt Lake Tribune, March 4, 2010, retrieved April 1, 2010
  43. Jackson & Stevens 1981, p. 11
  44. Madsen 2002, pp. 13–14
  45. Janetski 1991, p. 32
  46. Cuch 2000, p. 177
  47. Fort Utah and Battle Creek 1849-50
  48. History of the Timpanogos Tribe
  49. Janetski 1991, pp. 34–36
  50. "Dominguez-Escalante Expedition", Utah History to Go, Utah State Historical Society, retrieved March 27, 2010
  51. "Derrotero y Diario", Early Americas digital archive, Maryland Institute for Technology in the Humanities, archived from the original on September 28, 2011, retrieved March 27, 2010
  52. Journal_of_W.A._Ferris 1941, pp. 105–106
  53. Bancroft 1889, p. 262
  54. Jensen 1924, p. 31
  55. Farmer 2008, p. 62
  56. Holzapfel 1999, p. 41
  57. Farmer 2008, pp. 64–65
  58. "Murdered Ute's Ghost Haunts Utah History", Salt Lake Tribune, November 5, 2000, retrieved April 10, 2010
  59. Farmer 2008, pp. 70–76
  60. Stansbury 1852, pp. 215
  61. Stansbury 1852, p. 297
  62. Stansbury 1852, pp. 307–397
  63. Pritchett, Frost & Tanner 1981, p. 128
  64. "Native fish community", Utah Lake, June Sucker recovery and implementation program, archived from the original on December 10, 2010, retrieved April 9, 2010
  65. Pritchett, Frost & Tanner 1981, p. 135
  66. Heckman, Thompson & White 1981, p. 108
  67. Utah_Lake_Comprehensive_Management_Plan 2005, p. 75
  68. Rare,_Imperiled,_and_Recently_Extinct_or_Extirpated_Mollusks_of_Utah 1999, pp. 90–92
  69. Utah Lake Wetlands Preserve, Utah Reclamation Mitigation Conservation Commission, retrieved April 9, 2010
  70. Utah_Lake_Comprehensive_Management_Plan 2005, pp. 77–78
  71. Heckman, Thompson & White 1981, p. 119
  72. "In hungry times, Utah Lake was a Savior", Daily Herald, Provo, Utah, December 28, 2003
  73. Heckman, Thompson & White 1981, pp. 113–116
  74. Heckman, Thompson & White 1981, pp. 109–110
  75. Utah_Lake_Comprehensive_Management_Plan 2005, p. 78
  76. 90-Day_Finding_on_a_Petition_To_List_the_Least_Chub 2008, pp. 1–9
  77. Bonneville_Cutthroat_Trout_as_Threatened_or_Endangered 2008, pp. 1–22
  78. Utah Lake sculpin, Utah Conservation Data Center
  79. Final_Rule_Determining_the_June_Sucker 1986, pp. 1–7
  80. "Red Butte fish transfers", Red Butte Dam Rehabilitation Project, Central Utah Water Conservancy District, archived from the original on July 8, 2011, retrieved April 9, 2010
  81. June Sucker Recovery Implementation Program — Utah Lake. Junesuckerrecovery.org. Retrieved on 2013-07-21.
  82. "Isciculture in Utah", Deseret News, Salt Lake City, November 9, 1889, retrieved March 29, 2010
  83. Carp_In_Utah_Lake_Impacting_Ecosystem 2004, p. 1
  84. Effects_of_common_carp 2006, p. 87
  85. Utah Lake is overrun with carp, Salt Lake City: Deseret News, September 22, 2005, retrieved April 10, 2010
  86. Effects_of_common_carp 2006, pp. 85–86
  87. Utah Lake's carp catch could reach 6 million pounds, Salt Lake City: Deseret News, October 10, 2009, retrieved April 10, 2010
  88. The success story behind conserving the endangered June sucker in Utah Lake, Salt Lake City: KSL TV, November 30, 2019, retrieved December 31, 2019
  89. Utah_Lake_Comprehensive_Management_Plan 2005, pp. 52–53
  90. Utah_Lake_Comprehensive_Management_Plan 2005, p. 55
  91. Utah_Lake_Comprehensive_Management_Plan 2005, pp. 60–61
  92. Supreme Court to decide who owns Utah Lake bed, Salt Lake City: Deseret News, October 15, 1986, retrieved April 9, 2010
  93. Court, United States Supreme (1987), 482 US 193 Utah Division of State Lands v. United States, vol. US, Open Jurist, p. 193, retrieved April 9, 2010
  94. Known for toxic algae, Utah Lake could become a housing development for half a million people. The Salt Lake Tribune Available at: https://www.sltrib.com/news/politics/2018/01/20/why-this-developer-believes-it-makes-sense-to-build-a-city-in-the-middle-of-utah-lake/
  95. ULRP. "Utah Lake Restoration Project". Utah Lake Restoration. Retrieved 2020-03-25.
  96. Utah Lake Restoration – A Comprehensive Solution. Available at: http://utahlakerestoration.com/
  97. ULRP. H.B. 272 Utah Lake Amendments. Utah Lake Restoration Available at: http://utahlakerestoration.com/2018/03/h-b-272-utah-lake-amendments/
  98. News D. 2018. Op-ed: The present, future, and past of Utah Lake. Deseret News Available at: https://www.deseret.com/2018/3/8/20641364/op-ed-the-present-future-and-past-of-utah-lake
  99. Commentary: Keep Utah Lake shallow and wet. The Salt Lake Tribune Available at: https://www.sltrib.com/opinion/commentary/2018/03/10/commentary-keep-utah-lake-shallow-and-wet/
  100. Commentary: HB272 should be vetoed because Utah Lake is not for sale. The Salt Lake Tribune Available at: https://www.sltrib.com/opinion/commentary/2018/03/21/commentary-hb272-should-be-vetoed-because-utah-lake-is-not-for-sale/
  101. Maffly, Brian (13 October 2022). "Army Corps pauses Utah Lake dredging permit, citing lack of documentation supporting the project". Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved 19 October 2022.
  102. "LRS has officially dissolved | Conserve Utah Valley".
  103. Speckman, Stephen "No Smoking Gun Found In Utah Lake PCB Study", Deseret News, Utah, 28 October 2008.
  104. Maffly, Brian (9 August 2018). "Stay out of Utah Lake, health officials warn, as algal danger spreads Stay out of Utah Lake, health officials warn, as algal danger spreads". The Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved 7 December 2020.
  105. Donaldson, Sahalie (27 June 2020). "Officials begin pilot testing treatments to combat Utah Lake's issues with harmful algal blooms". Deseret News. Retrieved 7 December 2020.
  106. Belk, Mark C.; Tuckfield, R. Cary (2019). "Demography of an endangered, long‐lived fish: Informing management options in the face of cyclic and stochastic climate variation". Population Ecology. 61 (3): 349–360. doi:10.1002/1438-390X.12005. S2CID 164771775.
  107. Ellsworth, C. M.; Belk, M. C.; Keleher, C. J. (2010). "Residence time and drift patterns of larval June sucker Chasmistes liorus in the lower Provo River as determined by otolith microstructure". Journal of Fish Biology. 77 (3): 526–537. doi:10.1111/j.1095-8649.2010.02701.x. PMID 20701638.
  108. "Project Map".
  109. "Utah Lake Phragmites Control". 14 February 2022.
  110. "Phragmites | Utah Lake Official Website". 19 March 2019.
  111. Water Quality Locations. Utah Lake 2019
  112. Carter, D. Robert (27 June 2020). "Fishermen find Utah Lake Monster". Deseret News. Retrieved 7 December 2020.

Bibliography

Books
  • Bancroft, Hubert Howe (1889), History of Utah: 1540–1886, San Francisco: The History Company, hdl:2027/uc1.$b41674, ISBN 978-0-913814-49-9, retrieved March 27, 2010
  • Farmer, Jared (2008), On Zion's Mount: Mormons, Indians, and the American Landscape, Boston: Harvard University Press, ISBN 978-0-674-02767-1
  • Janetski, Joel C. (1990), The Ute of Utah Lake, Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, ISBN 978-0-87480-343-3
  • Jensen, Jens Marinus (1924), History of Provo, Utah, Provo, Utah: New Century Press, ISBN 978-0-9601656-1-2
  • Madsen, David B. (2002), Exploring the Fremont, Salt Lake City: Utah Museum Natural History, ISBN 978-0-940378-35-3
  • Stansbury, Howard (1852), Exploration and Survey of the valley of the Great Salt Lake of Utah, United States Senate, retrieved March 27, 2010

Journal articles

PDF documents
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Utah Lake.
Wikisource has the text of the 1905 New International Encyclopedia article "Utah Lake".
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.