McCallum and Tarry

Perhaps one of McCallum + Tarry's most well-known projects, Evidence of Things Not Seen, uses 104 painted portraits of protesters who were arrested during the January 1956 Montgomery bus boycott to conceptually re-examine the history of the Civil Rights Movement.[14] McCallum and Tarry constructed each portrait with two layers: an oil painting on linen overlaid by a photographic image printed on sheer silk, both based on the original police "mugshots" of each protester.[15] The double overlay effects a contrast between portraiture as a mark of dignity and photography as a form of documentation and evidence.

Art critic Joyce Youmans described the images as having a "ghostly quality", writing:[14]

This effect makes the subjects seem both present and absent: the identity of each individual is undeniable, even though their arrests have reduced them—and their allegedly unlawful actions—to a mere ID number…the formal brilliance and conceptual complexity of The Evidence of Things Not Seen is almost as dizzying as the hazy figures imaged in the portraits themselves.

The final installation, which was presented in the New Orleans African American Museum, was part of the Prospect.1 New Orleans Biennial in 2008. Art critic Roberta Smith remarked that the exhibition was "one of the most haunting matchups of art and site" at the Biennial.[16]

McCallum + Tarry were commissioned by the non-profit organization Atlanta Celebrates Photography to create a site-specific installation in an abandoned water tower in Atlanta's Fourth Ward, the neighborhood where Dr. Martin Luther King lived and worked. Building on the archival research they had undertaken for Evidence of Things Not Seen,[5] the artist team converted the tower, which had once been used to supply water to a neighboring cotton mill.[5] They created a cathedral-like space illuminated by three simultaneous projections of Civil Rights-era footage and two contrasting audio pieces: a recording of Governor George Wallace's speech, "The Civil Rights Movement: Fraud, Sham and Hoax" given on July 4, 1964, and artist Imani Uzuri’s chilling repetition of the word "freedom". The final video and audio installation, titled Within Our Gates, filled the space above a wooden pier constructed over a reflecting pool of circulating water.[17]

"We're really interested, not just in the heroic footage that exists of the Civil Rights movement," said Jacqueline Tarry during an interview conducted at the water tower, "but the gesture, the quiet gesture of silent and subtle resistance that everyday people took to make the Civil Rights movement successful."[18]

In 2003, the Seattle Arts Commission commissioned McCallum + Tarry to work with Peace on the Street by Kids from the Streets to create a work that gave voice to homeless youth in Seattle.[6] The project they ultimately created, Endurance, was installed at Conner Contemporary Art in Washington, D.C. It featured a video of 26 homeless youth standing on a street corner staring into the camera. The video used time-lapse photography to compress an hour of real time to five minutes, incorporating audio testimonials of the youth to capture their theoretical invisibility as cars and people zoom around them.[7] Art critic Michael O'Sullivan commented that the work induced a sense of "discomfort" that "raises McCallum and Tarry's work from the level of sociology or documentary to richly disturbing art".[19]

The New York Times reviewer Holland Cotter commented that the artwork constituted "a ritual dance, a morality play and a mortality play".[7] Cotter continued,

The story is primal. It's about being singular and at home in the world at the same time, and how difficult, but possible, that is. The homeless people in Endurance are living the story. The collaboration with Mr. McCallum and Ms. Tarry gives them a chance to perform it—that’s the art part, the distancing and clarifying part—and lets us participate as witnesses.

In 2010, the Baltimore Contemporary Museum organized a mid-career survey of McCallum + Tarry's work, Bearing Witness, curated by Irene Hoffman. The exhibition was hosted by multiple venues in Baltimore, including the Maryland Institute College of Art, the Walters Art Museum, Carroll Mansion, and the Reginald F. Lewis Museum of Maryland African American History & Culture.[12]

The Burchfield Penney Art Center in Buffalo, New York organized McCallum + Tarry's second mid-career survey, Intersections, in 2013. According to the Buffalo News,[20]

The two have dedicated their impressive careers to exploring the painful and murky history of race in the United States. McCallum + Tarry's work spans all media. And this show contains multitudes: videos pieced together from footage and photographs of the civil rights movement; large, color portraits of young homeless people; audio loops from victims of police brutality, embedded in old-fashioned phone boxes; shrouded gravestones honoring dead slaves, and well over 100 haunting portraits created using an inspired amalgam of oil painting and photography.