Natalie Suleyman

In June 2008, Suleyman contested ALP preselection for the state seat of Kororoit. The Victorian Ombudsman found that in order to ensure her preselection, she organised a deal with former Keilor state Member George Seitz whereby she would arrange for the funding of certain soccer-ground works, in return for his support at preselection. This gambit failed when Seitz unexpectedly withdrew his support, and the preselection was instead won by Marlene Kairouz. The Ombudsman found that Suleyman then attempted to cancel funding for the project associated with Seitz, a move that would have cost the council more than $300,000.[13]

These events led to Seitz invoking Parliamentary privilege to criticise Suleyman on the floor of the Victorian Parliament. Seitz's comments, widely reported, included an accusation that Suleyman was the "Robert Mugabe of Brimbank", and had improperly interfered with local sporting clubs associated with Seitz; in response to her lost preselection.[8]

Resultant reporting prompted an investigation by the Victorian Ombudsman into alleged misconduct at Brimbank Council.[14] Regarding the allegations made by Seitz in parliament, the Ombudsman found that Natalie had indeed directed the council CEO to withdraw funding from development works at the Keilor Lodge Reserve, which 'had the CEO complied with the direction, (would have put the council) in breach of contract and at significant financial risk'. Natalie's explanation to the ombudsman that she was not involved in the issuing of the direction was found by the ombudsman to have been 'an attempt to mislead',[15] with a finding made that 'the direction was issued in retaliation for Suleyman's pre-selection loss'.[16] This led to a further finding that Suleyman had breached s76B(3) of the Local Government Act, having made improper use of her position. The ombudsman recommended that the breach be investigated by the Victorian department responsible for local government.[17]

The other significant finding within the report, was that Suleyman had made an improper and informal demand that $680,000 be allocated to a project at Cairnlea Park, at a facility in which clubs to which Suleyman's family were linked.[18] The ombudsman found that after the budget had been finalised at a council workshop, Suleyman had approached council staff and threatened to prevent the budget from being adopted unless her projects were funded. The council executive were found to have altered in scope several council items to ensure the demand could be accommodated. The ombudsman found that:

"The alleged actions of Cr Suleyman appeared to breach the councillor oath of office, which requires that councillors act in the best interests of the community. It is also clearly a misuse of Cr Suleyman's position as a councillor. In addition, I was concerned that the Brimbank officers acceded to Cr Suleyman's ‘demand’ without referring the matter to the whole council."[18]

Other findings regarding Suleyman's conduct included:[19]

• A misuse of council processes to further harass Seitz.[20]
• Findings of abuse and aggression toward Council officers.[19]
• An improper insistence that council spend $572 on library membership cards bearing her signature.[19]
• Inappropriate disposal of confidential council documents.[19]
• Enabling the rent-free access of her father to a council building with an ordinary annual lease value of over $15,000 (since 1999); and improperly accessing council files relating to that building. In 2006, following public scrutiny of this arrangement in a local newspaper, the property's $1,700 per year peppercorn lease (drawn up by the council in 2002) was then complied with.[21] The ombudsman also found that Natalie had been involved in procuring $11,000 worth of building works for the benefit of her father at the property, writing 'It is apparent that Mr Suleyman received favourable treatment due to his daughter's influence'. Natalie denied these findings.[22]
• An Engagement of 'subterfuge' against the Ombudsman, by having manipulated another councillor to sign a complaint letter to the Ombudsman in their name, when the letter had in fact been written by Natalie and another councillor.[23]

The Local Government Inspectorate took no action against Natalie in the wake of the report.[24] In a letter seen by the local newspaper Brimbank Weekly the inspectorate claimed to have found 'insufficient evidence to support a prosecution'.[13]

The Ombudsman's report led to the passage of new laws banning councillors from working as staffers to members of Parliament. It also played a role in the eventual sacking of Brimbank Council in 2009.[25]

Natalie has received the Order of Merit of the Republic of Poland,[26] and an award from the Australian Society of Polish Jews and their descendants named after Henryk Sławik.[27]

Her father, Hakki Suleyman, is the Chair of the Migrant Resource Centre North West and the convenor of the Turkish Cypriot program on 3ZZZ community radio.[4]

• Official website
• Natalie Suleyman on Twitter
• Parliamentary voting record