Not Another B Movie

Released in anamorphic widescreen DVD format. Extras include two featurettes: The first with the cast sharing anecdotes about low-budget filmmaking, and the second sharing footage from the film's original premiere. Also included are the distributor's trailers for other Troma films and two short-length comedy sketches.[1][2][3][4]

DVD Verdict praised the film, writing it was "one of the most pleasant surprises I've come across in a long time. No, really."[1] Noting that the film's re-release cover art made the DVD appear as one of the films it was intended to spoof, remarked that the film's being re-titled and released under a different title and with the Troma cover was "either unfortunate or hilariously ironic,"[1] but offered that despite the audio and video being "mediocre, with hazy, grainy colors and flat sound,"[1] the film was "hilariously funny, while also emotionally honest and heartfelt,"[1] and that it stood out as one of the best films the reviewer had seen in the realm of films about filmmaking.[1]

Panning the film, Unrated Magazine asked "how the hell did they cast Ed Asner?"[9] The review stated that the film was so bad it was difficult to watch. Continuing, they argued that the plot was pointless, the humour poor, and the cinematography terrible. They noted that among the product's few positive points was the box cover artwork and the superb job Troma did with marketing something otherwise valueless. They felt the scenes with David Faustino showed promise, but were importunely and repeatedly interrupted by the plotline returning to the three leads arguing and debating over production and marketing in the restaurant. The one scene the reviewer admits to enjoying was the appearance of Ed Asner holding a knife in a manner reminiscent of Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho.[9]

Mondo Digital felt the film was less respectable that others in its genre, though "certainly more star-studded,"[2] writing it was "an exercise in random spoofery most notable for its roster of supporting actors: Ed Asner, Robert Z'Dar, Erin Moran, Larry Thomas (aka the Soup Nazi from Seinfeld), Reggie Bannister, Joe Estevez, and David Faustino."[2] In noting the plot device of three filmmakers arguing on how best to create and market a film project, wrote that the concept was "all very arbitrary and sometimes amusing".[2]

DVD Talk noted that while the new title of the film might lead viewers to "expect the film to be a lowbrow spoof of B horror,"[3] and while it in some parts is so, it actually comes off as "a thoughtful dramatic meditation on the seamier side of exploitation horror production, and the people who are involved in it."[3] They expanded that the dual themes presented in this manner "don't mesh very well, and leave us with two disparate halves that don't work as well as they should."[3] They also noted that there is genuine humor within the film, and a "lot of good performances."[3] In their being able to draw from personal experiences, filmmakers Byron Thames, Larry Thomas and James Vallo were "quite convincing as the cynical filmmakers",[3] and actress Lindsay Gareth was "able to reach emotional levels that are genuinely moving."[3] Even while suggesting the film to readers, they offered that the filmmakers might have been better served to have made a self-aware B movie or a sharp satire into filmmaking, as "mixing them together diluted both, and came up wanting."[3] They concluded that the film tried to do too much, and as a result, while still viewable, did nothing with complete success.[3]

10,000 Bullets made note of many other films having been made about making films, and wrote "that few, if any approach this subject in the way"[4] that did this films, describing it as a celebration of schlocky cinema."[4] They also noted that as it is intended as a film to spoof bad films, it was expected that the actor's performances would be "over the top area and not in a good way."[4] The performances described as easiest to digest were those of David Faustino and Joe Estevez as bumbing cops and their inclusion of "some much needed comic relief."[4] They concluded that while the film attempted to be what it claimed, "the end result is a underwhelming experience that never fully reaches its potential."[4]

Genre review sites noted both positive and negative traits in general. Some samples conclude that "the acting is good, the movie looks nice, and it has a few chuckle moments, but the concept isn't all that intriguing and the thing feels more like a broke-ass episode of Family Guy the way it jumps to flashbacks and the movie-within-a-movie".[10] Online reviewer Upchuck Undergrind of Corazine.com was highly favorable stating that "it's a VERY well-written film. Given that much of its running time is conversation, a lot of sharp writing chops were necessary to give us characters and dialogue to keep our attention, since this isn't a tits-and-gore affair" but also noting that the title and packaging are "misleading, more likely to draw fans of the dumb, endless parodies rather than the kind of viewer such a thoughtful film requires".[11] Craig McGee of Horrornews.net had this to say: "It isn’t for everyone, but not for the usual reasons – it’s a talky dramatic humorous satire with bits and pieces of a horror movie sprinkled in between via the described scenes of the movie the main characters are discussing over dinner"..."If you loathe character development, intelligent satire, and in-joke movie references, do not watch this flick. But if you don’t mind those things…if you DO wanna cheer for people to make the right choices and win in their lives while enjoying a viciously eloquent satirical skewering of the movie making process, then like me, NOT ANOTHER B MOVIE is exactly what you need."[12]

The film was recipient of award nominations at the 2012 'Indie Horror Film Festival' in Chicago: film nomination for 'Best Comedy', nomination of Lindsey Gareth for 'Best Supporting Actress', and a nomination of David Faustino for 'Best Supporting Actor'.[13]