Pushin' Against a Stone

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	81/100[3]
Review scores
Source	Rating
Allmusic	[4]
The Austin Chronicle	[5]
Blurt	[6]
Exclaim!	9/10[7]
The Independent	[8]
Mojo	[9]
PopMatters	8/10[10]
Q	[11]
Rolling Stone	[12]
Spin	8/10[13]

Pushin' Against a Stone garnered critical acclaim from music critics. Metacritic assigned an averaged Metascore of fourteen selected mainstream critics to the album of an 81, meaning it has attracted "universal acclaim".[3] The Independent's, Andy Gill rated the album a perfect five stars, and said her music defies classification, which makes her music so stimulating.[8] Jason Schneider of Exclaim! rated the album nine out of ten, and noted this was "a rare case when a young artist's natural instincts are spot-on."[7]

At Mojo, Lois Wilson rated the album four stars, and she felt the music could be perfectly called "'organic moonshine roots music'".[9] Tom Speed of Blurt rated it the same, and affirmed the release as being "an impressive calling card to the rest of the world".[6] At The Austin Chronicle, Doug Freeman rated it the same, and highlighted her vocal as being different but remarkable.[5] Jem Aswad of Spin rated the album eight out of ten, and evoked that the music on the release comes from a place of "studied looseness that's never contrived, and it shows a poise and clarity of vision which her earlier efforts barely suggested."[13] At PopMatters, Brent Faulkner rated it the same, and felt that the music might not be of the "innovative" kind; however, he claimed the music to be "a truly worthwhile alternative" from the copy-cat era we live in today.[10]

Thom Jurek of Allmusic rated the album three-and-a-half stars, and affirmed that the music was rather long; however, he proclaimed the effort to be a "solid" one on which she "asks many questions".[4] At Rolling Stone, Will Hermes rated the release the same, and said "Credit June's vinegary, slightly oddball vocals, equal parts Diana Ross and Dolly Parton, which guide each song like an old tractor retrofit with LED high beams: luminous, ancient, unstoppable."[12] At Q, Rupert Howe provided the only mixed review at three stars, and noted how the outdated production was not good for the music; however, he did mention "There's little doubt, though, that June could work moonshine magic on anything she puts her voice to."[11]