Secret Beyond the Door

Celia (Joan Bennett), a rich New York heiress, remembers on her wedding day how she refused all proposals in New York, came to Mexico for a vacation, and instantly fell in love with the architect Mark Lamphere (Michael Redgrave). They have a happy honeymoon until she playfully locks him out of their hotel room, at which point he turns unaccountably cold toward her, and suddenly leaves her to return to his New England home for what he says is business.

She follows him, and when she turns up at the large mansion which he designed and built, she discovers that he is actually a widower with a small son. This boy, David, is being looked after by Mark’s sister Caroline (Anne Revere) and his trusted secretary, Miss Robey (Barbara O’Neil), whose face was scarred saving David’s life in a fire and who wears a scarf to conceal the disfigurement. Celia makes friends with David easily, but is uneasy about Mark’s mood swings, especially when Caroline hints that he caused his first wife Eleanor’s death; was it by making it clear he did not love her after the birth of David so that she pined away, or worse? Caroline also tells of having to lock Mark in his room when he was a boy. Celia is even more uneasy when Mark displays to their party guests the suite of special rooms he has had built on a special gated corridor in the mansion. Each of the first six rooms is an exact reproduction of a famous murder scene, and there is a seventh room which is locked and which Mark refuses to show.

Celia, wondering if the seventh room shows the scene of Mark’s murder of Eleanor, cuts down one of their bedroom candles to soften the wax and make a wax impression of the room’s key. While doing this, she catches Miss Robey without her concealing scarf, and learns that she had plastic surgery and her face is perfect again. She was pretending to be still disfigured to keep Mark and Caroline's gratitude for saving David and avoid being fired from her job, and she was hoping to marry Mark herself until Celia turned up. Celia promises not to tell on her.

Mark is disturbed at the unequal height of the two candles in the bedroom. Celia receives the copy of the key she had made to the seventh room, enters it and recognizes it as an exact duplicate of her and Mark’s bedroom. She concludes that it does indeed commemorate the death of Eleanor until she notices that the dresser candles are uneven in the same way they are in the real bedroom now. The room is to display not Mark’s past murder of Eleanor but his future murder of her. She runs away.

Mark has a daydream of being tried in a shadowy court, where he admits that he has a strong compulsion to kill Celia even though he loves her. He left her in Mexico to avoid doing this, but now the urge is back and he must leave her again. He dismisses Miss Robey for disloyalty, having noticed her deceit about her scar, and he and Caroline have a quarrel where she claims to be furious about having to run everything by herself and he is angry at her controlling him all her life.

Celia returns because she loves Mark, and he is alarmed because it means they will be alone in the house together. He tries to leave her again to save her life, but his compulsion overcomes him and he goes back. He finds Celia sitting waiting for him in the seventh room. She tells him she is there because she’d rather die than live without him. She channels the psychological theories advanced about murderers at the party (by a character billed only as “Intellectual Sub-Deb”), and begs him to remember what happened in his childhood to make him this way. And he does! When he was ten, his adored mother promised to read to him before she left to go dancing, but he found himself locked in his room as she departed. His pounding and screaming were in vain, and his love for his mother was transmuted into hate which was transferred to Celia when she locked the door of their honeymoon room. He advances on her to strangle her with a scarf. Celia reveals that it was Caroline, not their mother, who locked him in; he accepts this, and the scarf falls from his hand. They then notice smoke and fire; Caroline, thinking Celia is in the room alone and really wanting to continue as the dominant woman in Mark’s life, has locked the door and set fire to the house. Mark manages to kick the door open, escape the house, and go back for Celia when she collapses.

On an idyllic terrace, Mark tells Celia that she killed the root of evil in him that night, but he has a long way to go. She tells him they will go that way together.

• Joan Bennett as Celia Lamphere
• Michael Redgrave as Mark Lamphere
• Anne Revere as Caroline Lamphere
• Barbara O'Neil as Miss Robey
• Natalie Schafer as Edith Potter
• Paul Cavanagh as Rick Barrett
• Anabel Shaw as Intellectual Sub-Deb
• Rosa Rey as Paquita
• James Seay as Bob Dwight
• Mark Dennis as David Lamphere

The film recorded a loss of $1,145,000.[1]

Secret Beyond the Door was released in the UK on DVD in November 2011 by Exposure Cinema.[4] Olive Films released the film in the United States on DVD and Blu-ray on September 4, 2012.[5]

When the film was first released, film critic Bosley Crowther of The New York Times was of mixed opinions: "If you want to be tough about it—okay, it's a pretty silly yarn and it is played in a manner no less fatuous by the sundry members of the cast. But Mr. Lang is still a director who knows how to turn the obvious, such as locked doors and silent chambers and roving spotlights, into strangely tingling stuff. And that's why, for all its psycho-nonsense, this film has some mildly creepy spots and some occasional faint resemblance to Rebecca which it was obviously aimed to imitate."[6] Variety called it arty and almost surrealistic. The motivations of the characters were described as occasionally murky.[7]

New York’s PM was highly critical in 1948: “what they [Wanger, Lang, Bennett and Redgrave] have come up with is an utterly synthetic ‘psychological’ suspense incredibility wrapped in a gravity so pretentious it is to laugh, wherein all the actors stalk and stare like zombies while the sound track babbles fancy words.”[8]

Jonathan Rosenbaum of the Chicago Reader called the film's murkiness a strength.[9] Rotten Tomatoes, a review aggregator, reports that 54% of 13 surveyed critics gave the film a positive review; the average rating is 5.5/10.[10]

• Secret Beyond the Door at the American Film Institute Catalog
• Secret Beyond the Door at IMDb
• Secret Beyond the Door at AllMovie
• Secret Beyond the Door at the TCM Movie Database
• Secret Beyond the Door film scene on YouTube