Shattered set

Suppose A is a set and C is a class of sets. The class C shatters the set A if for each subset a of A, there is some element c of C such that

${\displaystyle a=c\cap A.}$

Equivalently, C shatters A when their intersection is equal to A's power set: P(A) = { c ∩ A | c ∈ C }.

We employ the letter C to refer to a "class" or "collection" of sets, as in a Vapnik–Chervonenkis class (VC-class). The set A is often assumed to be finite because, in empirical processes, we are interested in the shattering of finite sets of data points.

We will show that the class of all discs in the plane (two-dimensional space) does not shatter every set of four points on the unit circle, yet the class of all convex sets in the plane does shatter every finite set of points on the unit circle.

Let A be a set of four points on the unit circle and let C be the class of all discs.

The set A of four particular points on the unit circle (the unit circle is shown in purple).

To test where C shatters A, we attempt to draw a disc around every subset of points in A. First, we draw a disc around the subsets of each isolated point. Next, we try to draw a disc around every subset of point pairs. This turns out to be doable for adjacent points, but impossible for points on opposite sides of the circle. As visualized below:

• 
  Each individual point can be isolated with a disc (showing all four).
• 
  Each subset of adjacent points can be isolated with a disc (showing one of four).
• 
  A subset of points on opposite sides of the unit circle can not be isolated with a disc.

Because there is some subset which can not be isolated by any disc in C, we conclude then that A is not shattered by C. And, with a bit of thought, we can prove that no set of four points is shattered by this C.

However, if we redefine C to be the class of all elliptical discs, we find that we can still isolate all the subsets from above, as well as the points that were formerly problematic. Thus, this specific set of 4 points is shattered by the class of elliptical discs. Visualized below:

• 
  Opposite points of A are now separable by some ellipse (showing one of two)
• 
  Each subset of three points in A is also separable by some ellipse (showing one of four)

With a bit of thought, we could generalize that any set of finite points on a unit circle could be shattered by the class of all convex sets (visualize connecting the dots).

To quantify the richness of a collection C of sets, we use the concept of shattering coefficients (also known as the growth function). For a collection C of sets ${\displaystyle s\subset \Omega }$, ${\displaystyle \Omega }$ being any space, often a sample space, we define the n^th shattering coefficient of C as

${\displaystyle S_{C}(n)=\max _{\forall x_{1},x_{2},\dots ,x_{n}\in \Omega }\operatorname {card} \{\,\{\,x_{1},x_{2},\dots ,x_{n}\}\cap s,s\in C\}}$

where ${\displaystyle \operatorname {card} }$ denotes the cardinality of the set and ${\displaystyle x_{1},x_{2},\dots ,x_{n}\in \Omega }$ is any set of n points,.

${\displaystyle S_{C}(n)}$ is the largest number of subsets of any set A of n points that can be formed by intersecting A with the sets in collection C.

Here are some facts about ${\displaystyle S_{C}(n)}$:

1. ${\displaystyle S_{C}(n)\leq 2^{n}}$ for all n because ${\displaystyle \{s\cap A|s\in C\}\subseteq P(A)}$ for any ${\displaystyle A\subseteq \Omega }$.
2. If ${\displaystyle S_{C}(n)=2^{n}}$, that means there is a set of cardinality n, which can be shattered by C.
3. If ${\displaystyle S_{C}(N)<2^{N}}$ for some ${\displaystyle N>1}$ then ${\displaystyle S_{C}(n)<2^{n}}$ for all ${\displaystyle n\geq N}$.

The third property means that if C cannot shatter any set of cardinality N then it can not shatter sets of larger cardinalities.

The VC dimension of a class C is defined as

${\displaystyle VC(C)={\underset {n}{\min }}\{n:S_{C}(n)<2^{n}\}\,}$

or, alternatively, as

${\displaystyle VC_{0}(C)={\underset {n}{\max }}\{n:S_{C}(n)=2^{n}\}.\,}$

Note that ${\displaystyle VC(C)=VC_{0}(C)+1.}$

If for any n there is a set of cardinality n which can be shattered by C, then ${\displaystyle S_{C}(n)=2^{n}}$ for all n and the VC dimension of this class C is infinite.

A class with finite VC dimension is called a Vapnik–Chervonenkis class or VC class. A class C is uniformly Glivenko–Cantelli if and only if it is a VC class.

• Sauer–Shelah lemma, relating the cardinality of a family of sets to the size of its largest shattered set

• Wencour, R. S.; Dudley, R. M. (1981), "Some special Vapnik–Chervonenkis classes", Discrete Mathematics, 33 (3): 313–318, doi:10.1016/0012-365X(81)90274-0.
• Steele, J. M. (1975), Combinatorial Entropy and Uniform Limit Laws, Ph.D. thesis, Stanford University, Mathematics Department
• Steele, J. M. (1978), "Empirical discrepancies and subadditive processes", Annals of Probability, 6 (1): 118–227, doi:10.1214/aop/1176995615, JSTOR 2242865.

• Origin of "Shattered sets" terminology, by J. Steele