Stanley Mogoba

At the PAC's fifth annual conference in Thohoyandou in December 1996, Mogoba was elected unopposed as president of the party. His primary competition for the position had been the incumbent, Clarence Makwetu, who was persuaded to withdraw from the race and accept another position as PAC chairperson.[2] Mogoba had resigned from the church earlier that month in order to be available for the presidency, and he said that he was not worried about unifying the PAC, given the political diversity of the members of his church.[2]

In his capacity as PAC president, Mogoba presided over the official disbanding of the Azanian People's Liberation Army (APLA), the PAC's armed wing during apartheid.[3] He also led the party through its campaign ahead of the 1999 general election, and during that period controversially called for criminals to be punished by amputation.[4] In addition, after his election,[1] he was nominated to fill a PAC seat in the National Assembly.[5]

In September 1997, while Mogoba was serving in Parliament, questions about his integrity emerged after media reports claimed that President Nelson Mandela had advised him not to seek a seat on the Portfolio Committee on Intelligence in order to avoid the "indignity" of a security clearance check. The PAC interpreted the reports as an attempt to portray Mogoba as a security risk and sell-out.[6] Sources told the media that Mogoba was unsuitable for security clearance because he had turned state witness during the 1988 trial of Enoch Zulu, a former APLA commander who was convicted of terrorism by the apartheid state. Mogoba conceded that he had testified during the trial, but said that he had done so on the advice of the PAC after he was subpoenaed. He also said that his testimony had not incriminated Zulu beyond his admission that he had harboured Zulu at his house in Durban.[6] At a PAC press conference in October, Mogoba's account was confirmed by PAC stalwart Johnson Mlambo – who said that Zulu had in fact incriminated Mogoba, by confessing to the police that Mogoba had aided him – and by Zulu himself.[6]

However, later the same week, Zulu changed his story and told press that Mogoba had betrayed him.[7][8] The lawyer who had represented him at the trial, Dikgang Moseneke, labelled his claims as "nonsense", saying that Mogoba was "the real hero" for having harboured APLA commanders at his house.[7] Nonetheless, the PAC reacted furiously, claiming that Zulu was undertaking a character assassination exercise because he supported former PAC president Clarence Makwetu, whom Mogoba had ousted.[7] In addition, PAC MP Patricia de Lille claimed in a parliamentary debate that the ANC was aware that several of its own members had been spies for the apartheid state. She said that the ANC possessed a list of such spies, and she named several serving politicians – including cabinet ministers Joe Modise, Stella Sigcau, and Penuell Maduna – as being on the list.[8]

The PAC's performance in the 1999 election was extremely poor and Mogoba offered to resign from his party office.[9] He was nonetheless nominated to one of the party's three remaining seats in the National Assembly, where he served alongside Patricia de Lille and his deputy, Motsoko Pheko.[10] During his time in Parliament, he was critical of President Thabo Mbeki's HIV/AIDS policy and favoured higher taxation to eradicate poverty.[11]

Although the PAC did not accept Mogoba's 1999 offer to resign from the party presidency, over the next few years he faced continuous internal pressure for leadership change.[12][13] The pressure came to a head in the run-up to the party's 2003 elective congress. Although Mogoba initially said he intended to stand for re-election,[14] he announced in June 2003 that he would step down.[15] His former deputy, Motsoko Pheko, succeeded him as PAC president. In February 2004, he also resigned from the National Assembly, ceding his seat to Pheko's new deputy, Themba Godi.[1] In later years, as the PAC was divided by factionalism, Mogoba was aligned to the faction supported by Pheko, as opposed to the one led by Pheko's successor, Letlapa Mphahlele.[16]