Street art in Israel
Israeli street art and graffiti refer to the various forms of visual art found on public walls, buildings, and other surfaces throughout Israel. Sparked in the 1990s following the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, Israeli street art has evolved into a diverse and vibrant expression of urban culture, with a variety of styles and themes reflecting the country's unique cultural, historical, and political landscape.[1] Street art in Israel often addresses social and political issues, as well as Israeli identity and cultural heritage. In addition to contemporary street art, Israel is also home to ancient graffiti, such as inscriptions and drawings found in archaeological sites throughout the country, which provide a fascinating insight into the everyday lives of ancient civilizations.[2] From Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, Israeli street art has gained recognition both locally and internationally for its creativity, impact, and contribution to the urban art scene. There is also a substantial amount of street art made by Palestinians to criticize the Israeli occupation of the West Bank, most prominently on the Israeli West Bank barrier. Notable Israeli street artists include Dede, AMNESIA, Addam Yekutieli, Pilpeled, and Solomon Souza.[3][4][5]
Ancient graffiti
Graffiti written by Jews in this area can be traced back to the 8th century BCE in places such as Beit She'arim. While the most common graffiti were phrases like "Good luck in your resurrection" and “My beloved was here”, more outlandish graffiti was found too, such as "You will come to an evil end if you rob this grave” and "Lasius is a pervert."[6] And while ancient graffiti was most commonly found near tombs, it also was used in everyday ancient life for various purposes such as advertising a store or mark rows of theater seats to claim ownership. However, as professor Karen B. Stern notes, creating these markings was not an easy task, as “powders and fragments would cover one’s face and fill one’s lungs with dust; hardened dirt, rock, and plaster could push back and split fingernails; and carving implements, including metal nails, blades, and stones, surely drew blood when the lighting faded or surfaces grew unwieldy”.[7] Ancient graffiti in this area has been found in many languages including Aramaic, Hebrew, Syriac, and Greek.[2]
Street art after Rabin's assassination
In 1995, then Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin was assassinated by an ultranationalist who was opposed to Rabin's peace initiative.[8] This assassination had profound impacts on Israeli society as a whole, and shattered the sense of political stability. In the aftermath of Rabin's death, graffiti and street art emerged as a powerful form of expression for many young Israelis.[9] Professors Avigdor Klingman and Ronit Shalev argue that the graffiti following this assassination can be seen as a form of "ritual bereavement" and that "the graffiti produced immediately after Rabin's assassination created a kind of collectivism that allowed individuals to cope in the face of a bleak situation by actively developing an expressive ritual of fellowship, which affirmed that one was not alone in grief, anger, shame, or sense of helplessness".[1] These professors also conducted a study on the graffiti found near the assassination site in Tel Aviv, filing each piece of art into a category. Set 1 was done immediately after the assassination, and set 2 was done around 10 months later.
Frequency | ||
Content | Set 1 | Set 2 |
Relating to loss of Rabin | 125 | 163 |
Shock at murder act | 80 | 90 |
Reference to future of peace process (as a missed opportunity) | 52 | 52 |
Anger (in general) | 42 | 42 |
National loss (of historical dimensions; fear for democracy and so forth) | 22 | 38 |
Reference to violence (in general) | 11 | 16 |
Hope for a better world | 9 | 12 |
Political protest | 8 | 8 |
Guilt feelings | 8 | 8 |
Revenge (anger at the murderer) | 4 | 4 |
Emotional writing modality | 268 | 278 |
Intellectual writing modality | 93 | 155 |
Metaphorical writing | 128 | 131 |
An important part of the graffiti following the assassination was how the youth combined both Rabin's past as a military leader with his more recent desire for peace. For example, one piece of graffiti found in the square reads "In memory of the peace leader. We will always be with you in fire and water—I salute you, General," while another says "you were our leader in time of war, a prophet in time of hope and the Messiah in time of peace—and our dream was murdered." Researchers Diana Luzzatto and Yehuda Jacobson explain that "The gap between the characteristics of Rabin’s image on the two axes [military and peace] is bridged within the graffiti. The realm of the graffiti reunites, by written expression, Rabin’s contradictions, or those aspects of his existence perceived as being contradictory. The written word and its power to construe reality allow for the devising of the image of the ‘leader of peace’ as both a family man and a military leader."[10]
Demographically, about 63% of the names attributed to graffiti around the square were female names. Some of the graffit was also written in English, and the most commonly drawn symbol was the Peace sign, with the Star of David in second.[1] Unlike many other acts of graffiti or street art, the ones surrounding Rabin's assassination were legitimized. Most of the art existed without problem for 15 months, and when the government announced their plans to erase it from the walls of the square, public uproar and media attention was able to stop the action. [10]
Street art in the West Bank
The Israeli West Bank barrier has become known for its political graffiti. It first began to garner international attention in 2005, after the anonymous British graffiti artist Banksy visited and left nine works on the barrier. This inspired other acclaimed international street artists to paint on the wall, such as Blu, Paul Insect and Sam3. These efforts, and subsequent exposure in the media, resulted in almost one million dollars being raised for Palestinian charities. The art on this barrier is often referred to as a form of Sumud, what literary scholar Tahrir Hamdi calls "creative resistance."
Local Palestinian artists also have a large presence on the wall, whether that is creating their own art or "Palestinizing" the wall art made by others. For example, as a local youth explained, "Someone bricked up the window Banksy painted on the wall. Maybe they didn't like his work, or the idea of a beautiful landscape. For me, the issue is not about rejecting the view but whether it's the right time to imagine it".
The Israeli government often has tried to censor Palestinians from using graffiti and street art as a form of resistance or communication. During the First Intifada, graffiti “became a way to organize protests, strikes, and rallies; to affirm allegiances; to warn against collaboration; and finally, to demarcate political boundaries.”[11] To stop this, Israeli forces imposed fines, threatened imprisonment, and collaborated with local Palestinians to remove the works they found the most troubling, such as those with heavy references to the Nakba.[12]
Some Palestinian critics view these pieces of art as further eroding their sovereignty over their space. Others accuse artists of beautifying the wall and creating artistic tourism that actually helps legitimate its presence. There are also concerns that such murals do not actually challenge Israeli authority.
Recently, with the rise of the so-called "electronic Intifada", graffiti has taken a step back in terms of prominence for Palestinian resistance. There even was an website with a virtual separation barrier, where users could "tag" or "bomb" it with protest art.[11][13]
Florentin
Florentin, a neighborhood in Tel Aviv, is known for its vibrant street art scene. Historically one of the more impoverished areas in Tel Aviv, thanks to the low rent in recent years it has become a popular spot to live amongst Israeli youth.[14] Because of its run-down nature, Florentin has long been the subject of urban renovation plans, with many of its buildings being marked for demolition. These abandoned buildings have become canvasses for the area's youth -- resulting in a flourishing graffiti culture at the local level.[15] Researcher Caroline Rozenholc notes that "its 'dark' reputation accumulated through years of poverty and lack of municipal concern is nowadays dissolving into a sense of 'authenticity.'”[16]
As many of Florentin's residents are familiar with economic hardship, the common theme amongst the street art is one of "absence". Even "smiles, when they appear, can be distorted and twisted, or bordering on lunacy."[15]
Often, the graffiti found in Florentin is politically charged, and often made between rival political groups. For example, one piece of graffiti that read "The infiltrators [African migrants and refugees] are a cancer" had the word "infiltrators" changed to "racism" so it now read "racism is cancer." These graffiti wars are quite common, with some pieces having their meanings change over and over again.[17]
Clashes with art tourism
Recently, there has been a fear amongst scholars and residents that Florentin, through the process of gentrification, is losing its culture. As photographer and author of Street Art Tel Aviv Lord K2 writes, "with Florentin’s ongoing, fast-paced gentrification, the art on its streets is dwindling. In several parts of the neighborhood, in fact, street art was recently painted over by the municipality...They are stripping away the neighborhood’s soul, driving real estate prices even higher, while offering little to the public — apart from more living quarters in an overcrowded section of a city that is in dire need of cultural spaces...Artists are being pushed out of their familiar territories. One obvious exodus is occurring to the more rundown parts of South Tel Aviv whose walls are crying out for art."[18]
With the rise of private street art tours in the neighborhood, locals and artists in Florentine sometimes are frustrated with urban art tourism. This is shown in many ways, with some graffiti even displaying the message "FUCK UR TOURS." Residents take issue with the loudspeakers tour guides have, and the crowding on the sidewalks as a result of large tours. One resident observed that "The tours may be keeping this area alive, but the large amount of dense graffiti creates a sort of layer of makeup on an area that is actually dead. Something about the tours causes me, as a resident, to feel like an animal in the zoo". This also has caused veteran graffiti artists to stop creating pieces in this neighborhood, favoring less touristy spots in the center of the city.[19]
Jerusalem
Street art in Jerusalem is different than it is in other parts of the country. There have been multiple deliberate projects designed to bolster the presence of graffiti in the capital, mainly by the director of the Jerusalem Center Development Company, a branch of the Jerusalem Development Authority. To be legal, before implementation the designs are subject to approval by both the local authorities and the adjacent residents and business owners who may be impacted by the artwork. Moreover, there are official guidelines in place that prohibit any depictions of political ideologies, violent content, or other unsuitable imagery.[20]
Mahane Yehuda
Spearheaded by Solomon Souza (grandson of artist F. N. Souza), the Mahane Yehuda Market has turned into one of the most impressive spots in Jerusalem for street art. Souza has spray-painted over 250 works on the shuttered stalls in the market, depicting well-known contemporary and historical figures.[21] During the week, when the market is open, most of the art is not visible. However, on Shabbat, the market is generally closed and any passerbys can admire the work. Notable figures depicted are:
- Hannah Szenes -- Jewish World War II hero
- Abraham Joshua Heschel -- American Rabbi and civil rights activist
- Gracia Mendes Nasi -- Sephardi woman who helped Jews flee the Inquisition
- Mahatma Gandhi -- Indian nationalist leader and nonviolence advocate
- Steven Spielberg -- Jewish-American filmmaker
- David Ben-Gurion -- first Prime Minister of Israel
- Moses -- prophet and leader of the Jewish People
- Rabbi Ovadia Yosef -- Sephardi Chief Rabbi of Israel and spiritual leader
- Ada Yonath -- Israeli Scientist
- Jonathan Pollard -- Israeli-US spy who sold US state secrets
- Sophie Scholl -- German anti-Nazi resistance fighter
- Sheikh Farid al-Jabari -- a senior clan leader in Hebron
- Golda Meir -- first female Prime Minister of Israel[22]
So far, Souza has completed these murals without any help from the city or third parties, although he is open to working with the municipality or foundations in the future. Souza has said that it has been easy to get permission from the shop owners to paint their shutters, with some even requesting a favorite rabbi or the family patriarch.[23]
Tabula Rasa
Akin to Florentin, the historic Beit Ya'akov neighborhood became run-down in recent years. That is why, according to Hila Smolyanski, director of the visual arts department at the Jerusalem Municipality, this neighborhood was selected by the city to undergo a cultural project. The project, named Tabula rasa (meaning blank slate), was done by 30 artists to create murals and other street art on poles, walls, balconies, shops and doors to revitalize the area. Some of the artists are well-known and have frequented galeries, other are more notorious local graffiti artists.[24] Then Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat explained that the project is “a joint venture between the merchants, the Student Union and the municipality.”[25]
Penalties
The penalty for illegal street art in Israel can be a fine or up to a year in prison.[26] In April of 2023, a Bnei Brak resident was arrested for graffitiing “Rabin is a terrorist, war criminal” on a Rabin memorial in Tel Aviv. [27]
See also
References
- Klingman, Avigdor; Shalev, Ronit (June 2001). "Graffiti: Voices of Israeli Youth Following the Assassination of the Prime Minister". Youth & Society. 32 (4): 403–420. doi:10.1177/0044118X01032004001. ISSN 0044-118X. S2CID 220353663.
- Lyden, Jacki (2011-06-11). "Archaeologists Unscramble Ancient Graffiti In Israel". NPR. Retrieved 2023-05-01.
- Weisberg, Noa (2022-09-25). "Meet Tel Aviv's Best Street Artists". DailyArt Magazine. Retrieved 2023-05-01.
- Press, Viva Sarah (2015-05-20). "Are you wearing his art on your sleeve?". ISRAEL21c. Retrieved 2023-05-01.
- Ghert-Z, Renee; Tress, Luke. "Young artist turns Jerusalem's market into gallery of famous faces". www.timesofisrael.com. Retrieved 2023-05-01.
- Kahn, Eve (2018-05-24). "The Wit and Wisdom of Ancient Jewish Graffiti". Atlas Obscura. Retrieved 2023-05-01.
- Stern, Karen B. (3 November 2020). Writing on the wall : graffiti and the forgotten Jews of antiquity. Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-0-691-21070-4. OCLC 1142891334.
- Rabin, Lea (1997). Rabin : our life, his legacy. New York. ISBN 0-399-14217-7. OCLC 35657826.
{{cite book}}
: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) - Engler, Mira (1999-01-15). "A Living Memorial: Commemorating Yitzhak Rabin at the Tel Aviv Square [Speaking of Places]". Places. 12 (2). ISSN 0731-0455.
- Luzzatto, Diana; Jacobson, Yehuda (September 2001). "Youth Graffiti as an Existential Coping Device: The Case of Rabin's Assassination". Journal of Youth Studies. 4 (3): 351–365. doi:10.1080/13676260120075455. ISSN 1367-6261. S2CID 145469207.
- Larkin, Craig (2014). "Jerusalem's Separation Wall and Global Message Board: Graffiti, Murals, and the Art of Sumud". The Arab Studies Journal. 22 (1): 134–169. ISSN 1083-4753. JSTOR 24877902.
- Alim, Eray (2020-06-30). "The Art of Resistance in the Palestinian Struggle Against Israel". Türkiye Ortadoğu Çalışmaları Dergisi. doi:10.26513/tocd.635076. ISSN 2147-7523. S2CID 218957054.
- "Graffiti Studio: Separation Wall - LRPD & Shual.com". 2012-02-23. Archived from the original on 2012-02-23. Retrieved 2023-05-02.
- "Florentin - from Salonika to Soho". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. Retrieved 2023-05-02.
- Shifrin, Elijah (2015-01-20). "The Street Art of Tel Aviv's Florentin Neighborhood". Culture Trip. Retrieved 2023-05-02.
- ROZENHOLC, Caroline (2020-10-01). "The Neighborhood of Florentin: A Window to the Globalization of Tel Aviv". Journal of Urban and Regional Analysis. 2 (2). doi:10.37043/jura.2010.2.2.6. ISSN 2068-9969. S2CID 130113018.
- "Political Graffiti Wars in a Tel Aviv Neighborhood". Haaretz. Retrieved 2023-05-02.
- K2, Lord. "The disappearing street art of Tel Aviv's gentrifying Florentin neighborhood". www.timesofisrael.com. Retrieved 2023-05-02.
- "Tel Aviv Hipster Enclave Draws Gawkers - and Locals Are Pissed". Haaretz. Retrieved 2023-05-02.
- Israel, Tourist (2019-12-10). "Jerusalem Street Art". Tourist Israel. Retrieved 2023-05-03.
- "Solomon Souza follows in the footsteps of his grandfather, F.N. Souza". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. Retrieved 2023-05-03.
- "Graffiti art at Jerusalem's Mahane Yehuda market". the Guardian. 2016-03-18. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 2023-05-03.
- Ghert-Z, Renee; Tress, Luke. "Young artist turns Jerusalem's market into gallery of famous faces". www.timesofisrael.com. Retrieved 2023-05-03.
- Aviva and Shmuel Bar-Am. "A neglected Jerusalem neighborhood illuminated by street art". www.timesofisrael.com. Retrieved 2023-05-03.
- Leichman, Abigail Klein (2011-10-30). "Urban art spices up Jerusalem's famous Machane Yehuda market". ISRAEL21c. Retrieved 2023-05-03.
- שיר-ים (2020-02-22). "סיור גרפיטי בפלורנטין - בירת הגרפיטי של ישראל". Check In/Out (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2023-05-02.
- Staff, ToI. "Man arrested for graffiti vandalism of Rabin memorial in Tel Aviv". www.timesofisrael.com. Retrieved 2023-05-08.