Susanna Calkins

Calkins' first four novels, the Lucy Campion series, are set in 17th-century London. Mystery author Stefanie Pintoff says of the first novel, A Murder at Rosamund's Gate, "Susanna Calkins makes Restoration England come alive... Murder, romance, and flawless social history combine into a beautifully crafted mystery...".[3]

Critic Bethany Latham finds Calkins' second novel, From the Charred Remains, disappointing. The protagonist, Campion, is naive in matters of love, the other characters are "unevenly crafted", and the plot is too often contrived, she says.[4]

The third novel, The Masque of a Murderer, won the Sue Feder Historical Mystery Award (a Macavity Award) in 2016 for Best Historical Novel.[5] Writing for the Historical Novel Society, reviewer Rebecca Henderson Palmer praises the novel for its historical detail. "The printing presses, the Quakers’ struggles with the king, the searcher with her bell, the scold's bridle, the societal upheaval after both the plague, and then the fire – all provide a setting that becomes another character in the tale."[6]

Publishers Weekly gives a mixed review of the fourth novel in the series, Death Along the River Fleet. "Calkins deftly evokes period attitudes toward mental illness," the reviewer writes, "but with a pivotal character too impaired to generate much suspense or action, the first half of the story doesn’t do justice to Lucy’s resourcefulness or the author’s full gifts."[7]

Kirkus Reviews says of Calkins' Murder Knocks Twice, "A spunky sleuth and plenty of period flavor enliven the first in a new series...", which is set in a speakeasy in Chicago.[8]