Chester Weger

On March 14 1960, three women, Frances Murphy (47), Mildred Lindquist (50), and Lillian Oetting (50), wives of prominent Chicago businessmen, took a four-day trip to Starved Rock State Park in LaSalle County, Illinois, along the banks of the Illinois River. They arrived from the Chicago suburb of Riverside, about 90 miles northeast of the park.[2][7] On Monday March 14, after checking into the Starved Rock Lodge, the three took an afternoon hike to St. Louis Canyon, but never returned. Their disappearances went unnoticed by lodge employees, despite repeated attempts to reach them by family members. On March 15 a snow storm dumped nearly a foot of snow over the area. This would hamper the investigation. Then on Wednesday March 16, Robert Murphy, the husband of one of the women, phoned the lodge to inquire about his wife. A check of the rooms revealed the suitcases were still packed and the beds not slept in. Police organized a search of the park which led to the discovery of the women's bodies, bound with twine and partially disrobed, inside a cave in the canyon. All three suffered severe head trauma and a blood stained tree limb found nearby was determined to have been used to bludgeon them to death.[2][7][8]

Weger, a dishwasher at the Starved Rock Lodge, was among those interviewed by Illinois State Police in the aftermath of the discovery. Several employees of the lodge later testified in court that he showed up to work the day after the women's disappearances with scratches on his face. Weger was questioned extensively in the weeks following the murders and was administered six lie detector tests, which he passed. However, investigators continued to pursue him owing to his past brushes with the law. He fit the description of an assailant who bound a teenage boy and girl with twine and then raped her at nearby Matthiessen State Park in September 1959, and was later identified by the girl in a photo line-up. The twine used to bind the murder victims was presented as the same found in the kitchen at the lodge, and he failed a lie detector test given to him in September. Based on this, investigators put him on nonstop surveillance.[2][9][10]

On November 16, the LaSalle County state's attorney ordered Weger brought in for further questioning. After lengthy interrogation, he confessed to the murders the next day and led police in a reenactment at the crime scene.[11] However, just days later, after he was appointed a public defender, Weger recanted his confession, claiming it was made under duress after being threatened by his interrogators.[12] A grand jury returned indictments against Weger for all three murders, as well as the rape and robbery at Matthiessen State Park, however the state chose to only try him for the murder of Lillian Oetting.[9][13]

After calling over 350 veniremen a jury was selected. Weger's trial began on February 13, 1961.[14] His defense relied on the claim that investigators were relentless in extracting a confession from him, that he was told they would convict him on circumstantial evidence if he didn't and send him to the electric chair, accusations the investigators and other witnesses denied.[15] He claimed he was getting a haircut during the time of the murders,[16] and that the scratches seen on his face in the days after the murders were from shaving.[17][18] Bloodstains found on Weger's leather jacket analyzed by the FBI were inconclusive as to whether they were human or animal.[19]

On March 3, 1961, the jury returned a verdict of guilty and fixed a sentence of life imprisonment, rejecting the state's request to sentence him to death.[2][20] Weger was formally sentenced on April 3, and began serving his sentence at Illinois State Penitentiary in Joliet.[2][21] His attorney filed an appeal which made its way to the Illinois Supreme Court, however the verdict was affirmed in September 1962.[9][22]

In prison, Weger repeatedly professed his innocence over the decades, but was consistently denied parole. On November 29, 2018, he fell one vote short of parole in a split vote of 7–7 before the Illinois Prisoner Review Board.[23] One year later, on November 21, 2019, the same board voted 9–4 in granting his release after nearly 59 years in prison.[3] He was released to a Chicago mission that aids parolees with rehabilitation.[24] After a 90-day delay as the Illinois Attorney General sought an evaluation of Weger under the state’s Sexually Violent Persons Commitment Act, he was released February 21, 2020.[4][5]

On August 1, 2022, The results from hair evidence tested from the Starved Rock murders was received from a laboratory – one of several hairs found on a glove worn by one of the victims, Frances Murphy. It was a man’s hair, from which DNA was retrieved. The hair was found not to belong to Weger.[25] This evidence contradicts his confession and the state of Illinois case against him that he acted alone.

Weger attorney Andy Hale said on Friday, February 24, 2023 that they still did not know whose hair it was. An attempt to crosscheck it against a DNA databank has yet to find a match.[26]

On December 14, 2021, HBO Max released a three-part docuseries called The Murders of Starved Rock. The series focuses on the investigation into the murders, Weger's incarceration, and the idea Weger could ultimately be innocent. The series was produced by Mark Wahlberg, directed by Jody McVeigh-Schultz, and focuses on David Raccuglia, son of Anthony Raccuglia, the one of two prosecuting attorneys on Weger's case.[27]

• List of homicides in Illinois
• List of longest prison sentences served
• William Heirens – served 65 years in Illinois detention
• Richard Honeck – served 64 years in Illinois detention

External video
The Starved Rock Murders Feature Film, Hunter James Cox, 2019

• "Ghostly Image of a Ghastly Murder". Life. March 28, 1960. pp. 16–21. Retrieved December 5, 2019.
• Silva, Michel (February 17, 1961). "The Case of the Overlooked Clues". Life. pp. 43–46. Retrieved December 5, 2019.
• Stout, Steve (1982). The Starved Rock Murders. Utica, Illinois: Utica House Publishing Company. ISBN 978-0-9609296-0-3.

• American Hauntings: The Starved Rock Murders – Illinois History and Horror

• Starved Rock Murders Podcast