The Reynolds Girls

The sisters grew up in Litherland, a suburb of Sefton, Liverpool, and were of Irish descent.[1] The duo's younger sister, Debbie (no relation to the late American actress Debbie Reynolds),[2] played the original Katie Rogers, in Brookside, from 1987 to 1989.

"... AM/FM, all that jazz, we'd rather sing along with Yazz, what happened to the radio, they never play the songs we know ...." " ... No heavy metal rock and roll, music from the past, I'd rather jack, than Fleetwood Mac, I'd rather jack ...".

The sisters signed to the PWL record label after giving Pete Waterman a demo tape,[1] and their single "I'd Rather Jack" was produced by Stock Aitken Waterman.[3] The song started out as a response to music critics who ignored the younger pop acts in the UK at the time, and to radio DJs who continued to play older bands on their playlists rather than Stock Aitken Waterman songs.[3] It was also a response to a perceived snub at the Brit Awards, where SAW acts lost out to more "mature" acts such as Enya and Steve Winwood.[3]

"I'd Rather Jack" reached the top ten in all the European countries it was released. It peaked at number 8 on the UK Singles Chart in April 1989 where it remained for 12 weeks,[4][5] number 6 in Ireland,[6] number 6 in Finland,[7] number 8 in the Netherlands,[8] number 7 in the Flanders region of Belgium,[9] and number 43 in Australia.[10] The single also reached a peak of number 24 on the Eurochart Hot 100.

In a public poll conducted by Channel 4 in 2003, "I'd Rather Jack" was voted number 91 in a list of the 100 Worst Pop Records of All Time,[11] and has been called "the beginning of the end for Stock Aitken Waterman."[3] By contrast, in 2021, British magazine Classic Pop ranked the song number 38 in their list of 'Top 40 Stock Aitken Waterman songs', presented the song a "pure-pop apes Chicago house in a track squarely aimed at the teen market. [...] A bubbling, squelchy momentum carries the tune skywards as the two jettison music's old guard".[12]

After their brief success in 1989 with "I'd Rather Jack", The Reynolds Girls had a public falling out with Pete Waterman, who accused them of being difficult.[3] They parted ways with PWL, saying they wanted to direct their own careers. The girls self-released a second single, "Get Real", funded by their parents remortgaging their family house, but the song failed to chart.[3]

The duo have not made any real media appearance since.[1] In a documentary about PWL that aired in 2012, the people interviewed admitted that the single was indeed a tongue-in-cheek response to the critics, and in part did ruin the siblings' career after they'd recorded it.[13] It is unknown what happened to them after that and they could not be traced for a 2012 PWL reunion concert.[14]

In 2013, ITV started a search for the sisters, so they could appear in a commemorative documentary about Stock, Aitken and Waterman.[15] As of 2022, their whereabouts remain unknown.[16]