The Romance of Certain Old Clothes

The tale begins in the 18th century in Massachusetts. It features the Willoughby family (called Wingrave in the 1885 revision), consisting of a widowed mother, one son named Bernard, and two daughters. The girls, Perdita and Viola (changed to Rosalind in the 1885 version), are considered by the narrator to be equally beautiful. Respecting her late husband's wish, the mother sends Bernard to England to study at the University of Oxford, where he meets the American, Arthur Lloyd, with whom he becomes friends. After his studies, Bernard returns home, accompanied by Lloyd.

Both sisters fall in love with Mr. Arthur Lloyd, who then feels he must choose between them. The sisters vow not to be envious or angry at his choice. When Lloyd chooses Perdita, Viola is jealous but does not act on it. After the wedding, Mr. Lloyd leaves the now-pregnant Perdita at home when he attends the wedding of his brother-in-law, where he encounters his sister-in-law, Viola. Arthur receives a message that his daughter has been born but his wife's health is failing. Perdita, aware that she is dying and angry that her husband was with Viola on the day their daughter was born, makes Arthur promise to preserve the gowns she has saved in a chest for their daughter. She fears Viola will marry Lloyd and appropriate the dresses for herself. Arthur swears to Perdita that he will protect the chest and its contents until their daughter is old enough to wear them.

After Perdita's death, Viola eventually marries Mr. Lloyd. A series of misfortunes follow, leaving them with significant financial losses and with Viola unable to bear children. At this time, Viola begins to pressure Arthur to open the chest. Arthur argues that he made a promise to Perdita and tells Viola that the matter is closed. However, Viola keeps asking for her late sister's wardrobe until Arthur gives in, in a fit of annoyance, and provides Viola with the key to her sister's chest, which is stored in the attic. When Viola has failed to attend dinner or respond to several of Mr. Lloyd's summons, he climbs the stairs to the attic, where the chest is kept, to look for her. In the attic, he finds Viola dead, on her knees in front of the opened chest, with ten hideous wounds inflicted by ghostly hands.

The tale is considered to be a Gothic tale due to its Freudian uncanny nature. It is something that is familiar while at the same time being repressed. It is possibly something that is hidden, but has been brought to life. Freud describes it as atavistic feelings of death.

Many critics seem to agree this story is a reflection of Sigmund Freud's theory of "the uncanny". Critics say that it is a revenge story about the grudges of the dead combined with sibling rivalry. Some critics also note that James' writing style in this work reflects Nathaniel Hawthorne's.

The story, along with James's The Turn of the Screw, forms the basis for the plot of Mike Flanagan's TV miniseries The Haunting of Bly Manor. Both stories are substantially altered in the adaptation.[1]

• AMERICAN GOTHIC TALES by Joyce Carol Oates (New York,The Penguin Group 1996) ISBN 0-452-27489-3
• AMERICAN GOTHIC FICTION: AN INTRODUCTION by Alan Lloyd-Smith (New York, The Continuum International Publishing Group 2004) ISBN 0-8264-1594-6

Wikisource has original text related to this article:

The Romance of Certain Old Clothes

• Original Debut in The Atlantic Monthly Archived by Cornell University
• Text of 1885
• Bibliography of "The Romance of Certain Old Clothes"
• A Critics Analysis
• The Romance of Certain Old Clothes public domain audiobook at LibriVox