Vacuous truth

A statement ${\displaystyle S}$ is "vacuously true" if it resembles a material conditional statement ${\displaystyle P\Rightarrow Q}$, where the antecedent ${\displaystyle P}$ is known to be false.[1][3][2]

Vacuously true statements that can be reduced (with suitable transformations) to this basic form (material conditional) include the following universally quantified statements:

• ${\displaystyle \forall x:P(x)\Rightarrow Q(x)}$, where it is the case that ${\displaystyle \forall x:\neg P(x)}$.[4]
• ${\displaystyle \forall x\in A:Q(x)}$, where the set ${\displaystyle A}$ is empty.
  • This logical form ${\displaystyle \forall x\in A:Q(x)}$ can be converted to the material conditional form in order to easily identify the antecedent. For the above example ${\displaystyle S}$ "all cell phones in the room are turned off", it can be formally written as ${\displaystyle \forall x\in A:Q(x)}$ where ${\displaystyle A}$ is the set of all cell phones in the room and ${\displaystyle Q(x)}$ is "${\displaystyle x}$ is turned off". This can be written to a material conditional statement ${\displaystyle \forall x\in B:P(x)\Rightarrow Q(x)}$ where ${\displaystyle B}$ is the set of all things in the room (including cell phones if they exist in the room), the antecedent ${\displaystyle P(x)}$ is "${\displaystyle x}$ is a cell phone", and the consequent ${\displaystyle Q(x)}$ is "${\displaystyle x}$ is turned off".
• ${\displaystyle \forall \xi :Q(\xi )}$, where the symbol ${\displaystyle \xi }$ is restricted to a type that has no representatives.

Vacuous truths most commonly appear in classical logic with two truth values. However, vacuous truths can also appear in, for example, intuitionistic logic, in the same situations as given above. Indeed, if ${\displaystyle P}$ is false, then ${\displaystyle P\Rightarrow Q}$ will yield a vacuous truth in any logic that uses the material conditional; if ${\displaystyle P}$ is a necessary falsehood, then it will also yield a vacuous truth under the strict conditional.

Other non-classical logics, such as relevance logic, may attempt to avoid vacuous truths by using alternative conditionals (such as the case of the counterfactual conditional).

Many programming environments have a mechanism for querying if every item in a collection of items satisfies some predicate. It is common for such a query to always evaluate as true for an empty collection. For example:

• In JavaScript, the array method every executes a provided callback function once for each element present in the array, only stopping (if and when) it finds an element where the callback function returns false. Notably, calling the every method on an empty array will return true for any condition.[6]
• In Python, the all function returns True if all of the elements of the given iterable are True. The function also returns True when given an iterable of zero length.[7]
• In Rust, the Iterator::all function accepts an iterator and a predicate and returns true only when the predicate returns true for all items produced by the iterator, or if the iterator produces no items.[8]

These examples, one from mathematics and one from natural language, illustrate the concept of vacuous truths:

• "For any integer x, if x > 5 then x > 3."[9] – This statement is true non-vacuously (since some integers are indeed greater than 5), but some of its implications are only vacuously true: for example, when x is the integer 2, the statement implies the vacuous truth that "if 2 > 5 then 2 > 3".
• "All my children are goats" is a vacuous truth, when spoken by someone without children. Similarly, "None of my children is a goat" would also be a vacuous truth, when spoken by the same person.

• De Morgan's laws – specifically the law that a universal statement is true just in case no counterexample exists: ${\displaystyle \forall x\,P(x)\equiv \neg \exists x\,\neg P(x)}$
• Empty sum and empty product
• Empty function
• Paradoxes of material implication, especially the principle of explosion
• Presupposition, double question
• State of affairs (philosophy)
• Tautology (logic) – another type of true statement that also fails to convey any substantive information
• Triviality (mathematics) and degeneracy (mathematics)

• Blackburn, Simon (1994). "vacuous," The Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, p. 388.
• David H. Sanford (1999). "implication." The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy, 2nd. ed., p. 420.
• Beer, Ilan; Ben-David, Shoham; Eisner, Cindy; Rodeh, Yoav (1997). "Efficient Detection of Vacuity in ACTL Formulas". Computer Aided Verification: 9th International Conference, CAV'97 Haifa, Israel, June 22–25, 1997, Proceedings. Lecture Notes in Computer Science. Vol. 1254. pp. 279–290. doi:10.1007/3-540-63166-6_28. ISBN 978-3-540-63166-8.

• Conditional Assertions: Vacuous truth