West Farms Soldiers Cemetery

The earliest known cemetery in the vicinity was the Lawrence Family Burial Ground, located on the south side of Samuel Street (now 180th Street). The Lawrence family maintained a farm in the area.[2]

In 1814 The First Presbyterian Church of West Farms (also known as the West Farms Presbyterian Church) was formed. The Lawrence family donated a 295 ft × 100 ft (90 m × 30 m) lot (which included the burial ground) to the new church, retaining burial rights for the Lawrence family.[3] At the same time, the church acquired a 80-by-175-foot (24 m × 53 m) parcel opposite the Lawrence property on the north side of Samuel Street. A church with a surrounding graveyard was built atop a hill on the north parcel the next year.[4]

In 1827 John Butler, a farmer, purchased a 100-by-200-foot (30 m × 61 m) parcel directly to the east of the northern churchyard, to be used for private burials.[3] Butler's property, originally known as the Butler Cemetery became the West Farms Cemetery, later renamed the West Farms Soldiers Cemetery.[4] Butler sold the property to his son, John Butler, Jr. in 1872.[3]

John Jr sold the cemetery to undertaker Alfred Pettit in 1873. In 1882, Pettit sold the land to another undertaker, Isaac Butler (not related to the original owners) who owned it until his death in 1913, after which the property was inherited by his son, William. When William died in 1925, the undertaking business was inherited by his sons Frank and Roy. Ownership of the cemetery itself passed to Frank, Roy, and their sister, Florence Crooker.[3]

The New York Evening Telegram reported in 1908 that the cemetery, “abandoned and almost forgotten”, contained the graves of a dozen or more civil war soldiers. These graves were reported to be covered by “thick brambles and the accumulated litter of the city’s streets”.  The paper noted the “almost indescribable conditions of neglect and desecration into which [the graves] have fallen”. One grave, that of William J. Raspberry, was reported to be spoiled by “rusty tin cans, bottles, and worse”.[5]

By 1927, vegetation was growing over the cannons and the Civil War monument. Community groups such as the Boy Scouts and the Veterans of Foreign Wars undertook periodic cleanup efforts.[3]

The portion of the property which was not owned by the West Farms Presbyterian Church was transferred to New York City in 1954[3] after a period of time when the ownership of the property was uncertain. The ownership question was cleared by a year-long research project undertaken by Tony Marotta, a Bronx resident an past commander of Frank H. Corbett Post 1144 of the American Legion.[6]

Corbett's research through municipal records found a letter by Henry Bruckner, Bronx borough president from 1819 to 1934, which referenced a deed which had conveyed the property to the city. A 1935 letter from the New York City controller's office to the city corporation counsel's office asked about the legality of the deed. A reply in 1936 stated that since the Board of Estimate had not officially accepted the deed, the city did not own the property. A further search located the heirs of previous owners; Florence T. Crooker, Franks R. Butler, and Roy E. Butler, who were all still living in the area. At the urging of Marotta and several other representatives of the American Legion, the heirs agreed to transfer the property to the city in 1954.[7]

As of 2022, the property is under the control of the Parks Department.[6]

After the church bought the Lawrence property on the south side of Samuel Street, it was used as "a graveyard for strangers and black slaves". In 1905, the church built a new building on this lot, converting the original building on the north property into a gymnasium and recreation hall. This building was lost to fire in 1948.[4] The new building on the south side of the street became known as the Beck Memorial Presbyterian Church.[4][8][9] Charles Bathgate Beck had left $100,000 (equivalent to $160,000,000 in 2022) in his will to fund the construction as a memorial to his mother, Janet B. Beck.[10] In 1908, the Presbyterian Historical Society wrote:[11]

Some have questioned the economic wisdom of building this particular type of church in West Farms, where there is a rapidly growing population, largely of the class for which institutional effort is effective. Be that as it may, the new West Farms church stands as a fine example of the family church, and it has also facilities for much aggressive work in its neighborhood

— William T. Demarest, A Great Year of Presbyterian Church Building in New York City, Journal of the Presbyterian Historical Society

In 1815, Samuel Adams, a veteran of the War of 1812 from a landowning family in the area, was the first person buried in the cemetery.[12] Burials continued until after World War I when Pvt. Valerie Tulosa was buried.[1] On May 28, 1916, the remains of six unclaimed bodies which had previously been buried on Hart Island (Bronx) were reinterred at West Farms.[13]

In 1909, a cemetery committee erected a monument consisting of a bronze statue of a Union Army soldier on a pedestal. Three nineteenth-century field pieces were also placed on the grounds at the same time. The statue suffered from the weather and vandalism and was removed around 1950. It was in an unknown location for the next several years. It was repaired and restored to the monument on November 18, 1959. A Civil War Memorial Committee made additional improvements.[1]