West Park United Reformed Church, Harrogate

During the early 19th century, Nonconformist meetings were held in private houses. Places of worship were later fitted out or built at Hope Chapel Skipton Road around 1813, Cross Chapel Smithy Hill around 1821 or 1823,[2] and Providence Chapel James Street around 1831. Providence Chapel was built on the corner of James Street and John Street from the fabric of the demolished St John's Church on whose site Christ Church was built in 1831.[3] By 1859 the size of the congregation had outgrown the James Street chapel.[4]

This is a Grade II listed building[5] facing The Stray at the junction of Victoria Avenue and West Park Street in Harrogate. When completed as West Park Congregational Church in 1862 the building could be seen from all of Low Harrogate;[6] it was listed primarily for the "townscape value of [the] spire."[5] The original idea to build the church was mooted by Robert Milligan JP,[nb 1] who died before the church was completed.[7] Harrogate (Brunswick) railway station had brought visitors to the town since 1848, but in 1862 it was to be replaced by Harrogate railway station, and this promised to bring visitors from much further afield.[8] To take advantage of this, the developers Victoria Park Company bought up a tract of land, including the new railway station site and abutting The Stray, and called it Victoria Park. The company made Victoria Avenue its main thoroughfare and planned to line it with churches to attract the visitors. The two most prestigious plots, at the gates of Victoria Park and facing onto The Stray, were given to West Park Congregational Church and to "rich banker" John Smith for his new Belvedere Mansion.[3] The church building was designed by Lockwood & Mawson of Bradford, to accommodate 700 Congregationalists, visiting during the Harrogate spa season. The new building was designed with "ample and well ventilated class and school rooms."[4]

When visiting Harrogate in 1894 and 1911, Tsarina Alexandra of Russia worshipped at the Congregational Church and stayed in the neighbouring hotel (now Cathcart House).[9][10]

In 1972 the church was renamed West Park United Reformed Church, having joined a new amalgamation of Presbyterians, Congregationalists and Churches of Christ.[11] Between 1991 and 2005 the church formed a Joint Pastorate with Bilton Grange Church.[1]

• 
  Original building with two front doors and two pinnacles, 1862
• 
  Church still has one pinnacle, 1900–1914
• 
  One front door (moved to tower) and no pinnacle, 2020

The works had already started when the foundation stone was laid on Wednesday 14 August 1861, in front of a large crowd of Harrogate spa visitors and residents, by Frank Crossley MP.[12] Following a service and a sermon "remarkable for the power and elegance of its diction" by Reverend G.W. Conder,[nb 2] at the Independent Chapel, the company including twenty priests and three judges processed to the new site. A "large concourse of persons ... including a considerable number of ladies" awaited them. Under the cornerstone was placed a time capsule in the form of a sealed bottle, containing documents, newspapers and coins. Using his presentation silver trowel, Crossley laid the cornerstone over the cavity and sealed bottle. The company was treated to an address on the history and benefits of Nonconformism. A feast then took place for 130 ladies and gentlemen, followed by speeches and fund-raising for the church; they had so far raised about half of the estimated cost of £5,000.[4]

• 
  Francis Crossley MP
• 
  Rev. George William Conder

The church opened at 11.00 a.m. on 13 August 1862.[13][14] At the opening service, the church was full to the extent that extra seating was included in the aisles. Present were "a number of the leading Nonconformist gentlemen of the county [of Yorkshire]." These included John Crossley,[nb 3] Edwin Firth,[nb 4] Judge William Willans,[nb 5] Thomas Freeman Firth,[nb 6] Henry Brown,[nb 7] William Milnes,[nb 8] John Wade, William Scholefield, Dr John Greenwood, Miles Illingworth,[nb 9] John Peele Clapham JP,[nb 10] John Northorp,[nb 11] William Hartley Lee,[nb 12] John Shaw,[nb 13] Jabez Howell [nb 14], George Brown, R. Gallsworthy, Henry Francis Lockwood, Rev. Dr Thomas Raffles, Rev. S. Martin,[15] Rev. J.G. Neall, Rev. G.W. Conder,[nb 15] Rev. J.H. Morgan,[nb 16] Rev. W. Howes,[nb 17] Rev. R. Harris,[nb 18] Rev. F. Barnes,[nb 19] Rev. Henry Simon,[nb 20] Rev. Joseph Croft,[nb 21] and Rev. Horrocks Cox.[nb 22][16] Rev Raffles preached a "powerful sermon" which brought in a respectable collection of £89 6s. 3d.[7]

The building committee and many of the visiting VIPs met in the school room in the afternoon to organise efforts to complete funding of the works. Even after raising £1,290 in the sale of the former chapel, the committee would still owe £1,500. The VIPs brought money gifts and promises totalling £710 towards the debt. The evening service, bringing in a collection of £51. 9s. 9d., was conducted by Rev. S. Martin of Westminster.[7]

• 
  John Crossley MP
• 
  William Scholefield MP
• 
  John Greenwood MP
• 
  Henry Francis Lockwood, architect
• 
  Rev. Thomas Raffles
• 
  John Peele Clapham JP

The site of the church was at one of the entrances to the development estate of Victoria Park, which was created at about the same time, and faced west towards The Stray.[7] "The site [was originally] inclosed by a low fence-wall and handsome Gothic railing and gates, and the flagged footpath [was] five yards in width."[6] The total cost of land, materials and labour was £5,871 19s. 5d, the building alone costing £4,339.[7] The contractor for the works was R. Ellis Junior of Harrogate.[4] John P. Clapham J.P. led the building committee and superintended the works.[6]

It was described in 1863 by the Illustrated London News as a "beautiful Congregational Church."[6] It is built of "rusticated gritstone ashlar with strings, buttresses and pairs of gargoyles,[nb 23] between bays."[5] It was designed for 700 people, and has a tower and a "very elegant" spire 130 feet (40 m) high,[7][4] the whole being inspired by the Decorated Gothic style.[4] The belfry and spire are octagonal.[5] The building originally had three main trefoiled doorways, giving access to the vestibule, and thence to the aisles, the ground floor, and the staircase to the west gallery.[6][14] The two west-front entrances are now windows, and the tower contains the single main entrance, which has been moved to the west side.[17] The west end of the building has a five-light window and a small belfry. The two-light windows on the south side have coped gables above, and on the exterior of those gables are the twelve sculpted heads of historical characters,[14] including Isaac Watts, John Bunyan, John Milton and Oliver Cromwell.[1] These sculptures appear to be late 19th or early 20th century replacements, and the church website says they may have been carved by a Roman Catholic artist.[1] The roof has fishtail slates.[5] At the back of the building are the chapel, and the minister's and deacon's vestries. At right angles to the building are the school and classrooms to seat 200 children,[14] and these were built with separate entrances for boys and girls.[6]

In 1999 an outside ramp was added along the southern wall for wheelchair access. In 2000, as a millennium project, floodlights were installed to light up the exterior.[1]

• 
  John Bunyan
• 
  John Calvin
• 
  Oliver Cromwell
• 
  Philip Doddridge
• 
  John Dryden
• 
  Thomas Fairfax
• 
  John Locke
• 
  Andrew Marvell
• 
  John Milton
• 
  Joseph Priestley
• 
  Isaac Watts
• 
  Charles Wesley

The main interior ground floor space is a 72 by 44 feet (22 m × 13 m) parallelogram and is 38.5 feet (11.7 m) high, the lack of transepts and side-aisles being conducive to good acoustics.[7] The roof is supported internally by iron columns with foliated capitals, and the five traceried lights of the west window are visible above the gallery.[6] The original open pews (destroyed in 2019) had leaning backs, and were wide so as to accommodate the wide skirts - or perhaps figures - of rich visitors in the spa season.[14] The interior was originally lit by "two handsome brass coronas, each of thirty lights."[6] There are three First World War memorials: two stained glass windows with figures of St Michael with St George, and David and Jonathan, and a brass wall plaque. There are also plaques in memory of John Peel Clapham who chaired the building committee 1861–1862,[nb 24] and the church's first minister Rev. John H. Gavin.[1]

Considerable modernisation has taken place here. In 1993 the pulpit was removed and the sanctuary adapted for use by drama and music groups. The Communion table was moved to the centre of the dais, and the organ was rebuilt at this time. The old lavatory known as the ladies' parlour became a suite of renovated toilets and the Raglan Room, which is now used for meetings. In 1994 the original school rooms at the east end of the building were modernised and adapted for use by various organisations. In 1999 floor levels were adapted for accessibility. At some point the interior was split vertically so that it had a first floor hall with a stage and kitchen. In 2002 this upstairs space was fully modernised with a badminton court, and named the West Park Hall in 2003.[1] Between 2012 and 2014 the heating was repaired, the sanctuary refurbished and the pews removed.[18] As of 2020 the church is considering "further major alterations."[1]

• 
  False hammer beam roof
• 
  Gallery staircase
• 
  Cast iron column
• 
  Binns organ
• 
  Carving on organ arch
• 
  Gallery with original pews

The church's first organ was installed by Booth of Wakefield at a cost of £350 in 1869. On 7 July 1869 organist W.T. Best opened the instrument by playing "airs, solos, recitatives, quartets and choruses."[19] The second pipe organ was obtained from Forster and Andrews in 1899.[20][21] The current 1894 James Jepson Binns organ was obtained from the much larger St. Paul's Church, Semilong, Northampton,[nb 25][22][23] in 1993 and installed inside the original Forster and Andrews casing by Peter Wood.[nb 26][24]

There is one Mears 3 cwt bell in G in the tower. It was cast in 1812.[25] The inscription on the bell says: "IB: THOS EMMATT CHAPEL WARDEN 1812 THOS MEARS OF LONDON FECIT."[26] When Christ Church was built in 1831, St John's, the previous church on that site, was demolished and its bell taken by the Nonconformists to their chapel in James Street, and later in 1862 to the present building.[27] As of February 2020 the bell was still rung on Sundays.[1]

• 
  Cross family, 1929
• 
  David, ca.1921
• 
  Good Samaritan, 1960s
• 
  David, 1928
• 
  Angel, ca.1921
• 
  Children, 1940s
• 
  Possible portrait of Clayra Reason, 1901

Although there had been Dissenters in the town before, William Howell (1752–20 May 1842)[nb 27] of Knaresborough began a more formal Nonconformist movement in Harrogate when he held regular meetings in Harrogate residences in the early 1800s.[3] Following Howell, ministers at Hope Chapel Skipton Road (c.1813), Cross Chapel Smithy Hill (1823) and Providence Chapel James Street (c.1831) were: Thomas B. Wildsmith (1820),[nb 28] William Eltringham (1821–1827), John Whitridge (1827–1829),[nb 29][28] H.C. O'Donnohue (1830–1834) and George William Conder (1855–1856).[29]

Gavin memorial, in the nave

Gravestone of John Henry and Mary Gavin

The first minister at West Park Congregational Church was John Henry Gavin B.A. (Bay of Biscay ca.1831 – Douglas, Isle of Man 23 January 1868).[30][31] His father was John Patrick Gavin (d.1864), an army man and railway official from Ireland.[32] As Patrick Gavin in the British Army he was stationed in Portugal and the Ionian Islands, and at Liverpool as a sergeant major recruitment officer until 1848. John Henry's mother was Mary Boleridge, from Wexford (d. before 1843). Mary married John Patrick in 1833 in Santa Maura after John Henry's birth. In 1841, at 10 years old, he was living at Ligionere Barracks, Devonport, with his father and brother.[33] Rev. Gavin married Mary Northcroft (Egham ca.1830 - Harrogate 12 October 1905), on 13 July 1858 at Bangor Cathedral.[32][34] Her father was William Northcroft, a gentleman,[32] in Victorian terms a man of independent means. They had four children: Hamilton Gavin (4 June 1859– 30 December 1874),[35][36] Mary Cotton (1860–1861),[37][38] Maud (1861–1947)[39][40] and Ida Stukeley née Gavin (1864–1957).[41][42][43][nb 30] Hamilton died aged 15 years at the Royal Albert Asylum, an institution for children with learning problems, at Scotforth.[44] He died of "tuberculosis and tubercular meningitis, 7 days, with effusion 24 hours."[nb 31]

Rev. John Henry Gavin was trained at Lancashire Independent College. He was robbed of a silver watch while a student.[45] His first position was at the Congregational Church, Union Street, Hyde, around 1857.[nb 32] By 1861 Gavin was still working as a minister at Hyde, and living at Werneth.[46] Gavin served West Park Congregational Church between 1863 and 1868.[29] He died on the Isle of Man aged 38 years, following some years' suffering with tuberculosis,[47] and a year's leave of absence at Douglas.[48] He had a grand funeral and was buried on 31 January 1868 in Grove Road Cemetery, Harrogate, in plot G1123.[49][50]

Gavin "had endeared himself to the members of his Church by the active, earnest and self-denying zeal of his ministry, and he was highly respected by Christians of all denominations for his readiness at all times to unite with them in all good works."[31]

Unpaid and unofficial, a 19th-century minister's wife's pastoral work frequently equalled her husband's. The death of Gavin left Mary Gavin and the children without support, and a subscription was raised so that she could open a "boarding school for young ladies."[47] The 1871 Census does indeed show Mary Gavin running a boarding school at 7 Park Road, Harrogate.[51] However, by 1881 she was running a boarding house at 100 York Place, Harrogate.[52] In 1887 she was one of the honorary secretaries of the church.[53] By 1901 Mary and Maud had moved back to Hyde, both living on their own means.[54] Mary died of breast cancer on 12 October 1905 aged 84, at 90 Station Parade, Harrogate.[55] In 1879 a black memorial slab with white tablet was dedicated to Gavin, and was fixed above the vestry door inside the church.[56][57]

Other ministers at the church were: Frederick Fox-Thomas (1869–1889),[58] Joseph A. Meeson (1889–1896), Edwin J. Dukes (1898–1899), A. Cooke Hill (1901–1910), W. Henry Pace (1911–1913), W. Morton (1914–1926), Herbert H. Summers (1927–1946), C. Leslie Atkins (1946–1953),[59] and Norman F.W. McPherson (1955–1964). In 1970 the church became West Park URC Church, and the minister who oversaw this change was Hewlett E. Coltman (1965–1981).[60] After Coltman came Ian K. Bird (1981–1990), Richard Kayes (1991–1997), and Robert Heathcote (1998–2004).[29]

Reverend John Campbell was minister of the church from 2011 to 2017.[61] As of 2019 the Elders were running the church, along with interim moderator Rev. Jason McCullagh, minister of Bridge URC Church, Otley.[62] Local guest ministers lead the services.[63]