William Joseph Taylor

Taylor was a prolific engraver of medals, producing commemorative medals for over sixty organisations.[8] His firm appears to have produced virtually all the medals in London during the mid-nineteenth century.[6] He also issued a medal for the Melbourne Regatta in 1868.[9]

British Archaeological Association Medal, engraved by W J Taylor

He produced commemorative medals for the first congress of the British Archaeological Association in 1844 in silver (12 shillings) and bronze (6 shillings).[8][10] He designed a prize medal for the Royal Photographic Society.[11] This medal featured a bust of Prince Albert on the obverse, with a motif of the 'Chariot of the Sun' on the reverse.[12] He produced prize medals for the Royal Microscopical Society, featuring John Quekett on the obverse and a wreath with a blank space for a name on the reverse.[13] Smaller organisations included: Crystal Palace Choir;[14] the Arial Club, featuring a swimmer on the obverse;[15] for the London Swimming Club;[16] for John o'Gaunt's Bowmen;[17] for Sydenham Industrial Exhibition.[7]

Taylor also worked internationally, engraving a medal for the Timaru Agricultural & Pastoral Association, New Zealand, which featured a cow, a horse, a sheep and a pig on the obverse.[18]

Medal commemorating Charles Green's aeronautics

Taylor designed the medal commemorating the opening of the Thames Tunnel in 1843,[19] as well as a medal commemorating Charles Green's balloon flight from London to Weilberg in 1836.[20] He also produced a bronze medal commemorating the coronation of Queen Victoria.[21]

In 1851, Taylor produced commemorative medal for the Great Exhibition by striking them inside Crystal Palace itself and supposedly producing 400,000.[22]

Memorial medals were also produced by Taylor - he produced one such piece, in the style of Pistrucci, as a memorial to Taylor Coombe, who was Keeper of Antiquities at the British Museum.[23] He engraved a medal of William Carey[24] for another London medallist, W Griffin, who he also produced a temperance medal for,[25] as well as another featuring St Luke.[26] He engraved a medal of James William Gilbart, banker, who appears to have commissioned the work as a form of publicity to celebrate both his and the banks achievements.[27][28]

Thames Regatta medal

Taylor also produced general medals, which could be engraved by the purchaser. One example is a school prize medal issued by Palmer House School in Margate.[29][30] Another is a medal engraved by Taylor, ordered by the London Corporation as the Mathematical Prize for the City of London School.[31] One design was used and adapted for both the Arial Club and the Thames Regatta,[32] as well as for the Alliance Club whose competitions took place in the Serpentine.[33] He also re-issued medals at the request of benefactors, such as a Trafalgar, initially commissioned by industrialist Matthew Boulton.[34]

Gold Kangaroo Office token, engraved by W J Taylor

Taylor also produced tokens for a variety of businesses and organisations, in Britain and abroad including: taverns, the military, railways and auctioneers.

Kangaroo Office token

The Kangaroo Office was intended to be Australia's first privately run mint.[35][36] Taylor had realised that gold could be purchased from the Ballarat goldfields at reduced prices and potentially used to mint gold coins and release them for their higher value in London.[37] These coins looked more like weights, so they could bypass currency laws and restrictions; their dies were dated 1853.[35] In order to raise the money for the venture, Taylor formed a partnership with colleagues Hodgkin and Tyndall - together they raised £13,000 to cover costs and initial outlay.[35] They chartered a vessel, called The Kangaroo, to transport the press, the dies and two employees, Reginald Scaife and William Brown to Australia.[35] They arrived at Hobsons Bay on 25 October 1853,[38] unfortunately the press was too heavy to move and Scaife and Brown had to dismantle it in order to transport it to the site of the new mint.[35]

The office began minting gold coins in May 1854.[35] These coins featured a kangaroo on the obverse and the words PORT PHILLIP and AUSTRALIA on the rim; the reverse showed the weight and the words PURE AUSTRALIAN GOLD.[35] One complete set was displayed at the Melbourne Exhibition in 1854, but it is unknown how many sets were produced.[35]

One of the issues that beset the enterprise was the fact that the price of gold increased in Australia, after the beginning of the venture.[35] This was coupled by an increase in the number of sovereigns in circulation in England, which meant there was less demand for gold there than had been anticipated.[35] In 1855, Taylor changed course and minted a sixpence in gold, silver and copper.[35] He then produced a four pence coin and a two pence coin in copper.[35] The two pence featured Britannia on the obverse and a kangaroo on the reverse, under which was signed "W J Taylor Medallist to the 1851 Exhibition".[5] Despite this, the office had substantial losses and closed in 1857.[35] The press was purchased by Thomas Stokes and remained in Australia.[9]

However, Taylor did retain some trade in Australia and New Zealand, issuing private tokens for companies, including Melbourne businessmen John Andrew and A.G. Hodgson.[9]

The above is what is known as the false numismatic story. It is part of a story that elevates medals, not coins, to the pinnacle of Australian coin collecting.[39]

The Kangaroo Office was intended to be a colonial supplies store in Port Phillip that included a press for tokens and bullion rounds (the Kangaroo Office pieces).[40] The bullion rounds described as the “Gold Business” by Office manager R Scaife in a letter dated 9 Sept 1854.[41] The Kangaroo Office had more than the one objective numismatics focuses on.[42] A syndicate of Dr. Thomas Hodgkin, Peter Tindall (Jnr) and William Joseph Taylor funded the venture. The trio purchased a vessel called The Kangaroo (660 nrt), owned by Peter Tindall (Snr),[43] to transport significant amount of colonial supplies to Port Phillip along with the press, the dies and two employees and a prefabricated building, Reginald Scaife, the step son of Dr Hodgkin after Hodgkin's 1850 marriage to Sarah Scaife,[44] and William Morgan Brown.[37]

The standard narrative that permeates the internet is that the venture's prime objective was to profiteer on the difference in gold prices between the gold fields of Victoria and the market in London.[45] That narrative is just part of the false numismatic story as the gold price in Australia was stable, long before the Kangaroo set sail from England, mainly as a consequence of the Bullion Act 1852 in Adelaide.[46]

The standard narrative makes the venture all about the alleged gold price differential that theory was debunked on 2005 and it now seems the store itself or the money in logistics are the drivers of the venture.[47]

The venture is alleged to have been considered in November 1852.[37] By this point in time gold was around 70-71 shilling per ounce in the colonies, had been for a while.[37] The Kangaroo did not leave for another 7 months.[42] The store, the Kangaroo Office, failed as a venture due to a number of factors, lack of customers, lack of copper blanks, lack of diggers selling gold in Melbourne.[37] All this can be found correspondence from Scaife (store manager) in Sharples (of the Victoria Museum) work. The press is for sale by August 1854 and the store closed in 1857.[45]

The Kangaroo Office pieces (bullion rounds) rose to fame after the Coin and Medals section of the British Museum purchased a set of the pieces in 1862/3 from William Morgan Brown, formerly of the Kangaroo Office.[48] Head of the Keeper of Coins and Medals section at the time was W S W Vaux.[49] In a piece in the 1864 The Numismatic Chronicle and Journal of the Numismatic Society, published by the Royal Numismatic Society, Vaux made all sorts of unsubstantiated and false claims when he ‘introduced’ the weights to the numismatic world.[50]

"I have much pleasure in calling your attention to four curious pattern pieces in gold, struck in the year 1853, when it was proposed to erect a separate mint for Port Phillip (Melbourne), in South Australia. They cannot indeed be considered specimens of art, but they will serve hereafter as an interesting record of what the most prosperous colony England ever founded intended as the type of their national coinage….. These pieces are now preserved in the British Museum; and I am informed by Mr. William Morgan Brown, from whom they were purchased during the last year (1863), that twenty-seven sets were originally struck, and that of these all have been melted down except one which is preserved in Melbourne, and the one I have described above”. (Italics added) Vaux 1864[50]

Some of the erroneous claims by Vaux (in italics) include:

Pattern pieces - strange because these are just pieces, bullion rounds, not coins or even tokens and no one at the Kangaroo Office in 1854 was ever calling them patterns. The Kangaroo Office was calling them “mementos of the 1854 Melbourne Exhibition”.[47][50]

Struck in the year 1853 - only if Taylor (the die maker) struck them before the Kangaroo left England.[50]

Erect a mint - a Exhibition medal screw press at a shop in the Victorian colony selling colonial goods.[41][50]

Port Phillip (Melbourne), in South Australia - Vaux is geographically challenged.[51][50]

Intended as…their national coinage – perhaps misled by William Morgan Brown. The dies were English (Taylor) so nobody in Victoria (or Australia) intended anything. And weights aren’t coinage.[50]

Purchased last year – the introduction is in 1864. The Museum website claims they were purchased in 1862. Perhaps Vaux is both geographically and chronologically challenged. Perhaps Vaux is correct with 1863 and the website is wrong.[50]

Vaux's introduction is very removed from the actual facts, it qualifies as deceptive. From this point on the false numismatic story of pattern coinage for national circulation was parroted and embellished to the point where that false narrative is now virtually unchallenged and all but ubiquitous.[45][35]

Although; John Sharples of the Victoria Museum in a paper called the Kangaroo Office a ‘Sting’ [52] said The Kangaroo Office never existed. True, it never existed in terms of the narrative put forward by William Morgan Brown, Vaux and also W Roth a well known coin and token collector and commentators of the late 18th century.[53]

It is fact that the bullion rounds, medals as Sharples calls them, were marketed as mementos of the 1854 Melbourne Exhibition[41] and did not sell. The rounds had no interest until the Museum got duped into buying a set and W S W Vaux subsequently made all kinds of false claims about them. Today the rare gold rounds are highly prized collectables on the back of a completely false narrative generated by some high profile people in positions of trust at forefront institutions and publications.[53][50][35]

We also see institution like the Smithsonian and the British Museum[54] now stepping back from the false Vaux narrative that these rounds were "pattern coinage for national circulation".

St Helena Tavern, Rotherhithe

Indeed, he appeared to have almost had a monopoly on London's tavern tokens in the mid-nineteenth century.[3] Early tokens, produced from 1844-5 were of a higher quality than the standardised form of copper token they became later.[55] Public houses who Taylor issued tokens for included: the Horns & Chequers in Limehouses;[56] St Helena Gardens in Rotherhithe;[57] the General Napier in Pimlico;[58] The Florence - Billiard & Skittle Rooms;[59] Middlesex Music Hall;[60] Marylebone Music Hall;[61] the Old Welsh Harp Inn;[62] Audinet Restaurant;[63] the Traveller's Rest in Shepherd's Bush;[64] the Downham Arms, Islington;[65] the Blue Bull, Grantham.[3] He produced canteen tokens for the Honourable Artillery Company,[66] and for the 37th Middlesex Regiment's Camp.[67] His tokens were used as railway tickets used in the north-east.[68]