William Scott Day

William Scott Day was born on an American military installation in Japan on October 21, 1951, while his family was residing there. From an early age, he showed signs of remarkable intelligence and an affinity for reading authors such as Oscar Wilde, Walt Whitman and Barbara W. Tuchman.[2] After the death of his father during his teens, Day moved to Michigan, where he enlisted in the Marine Corps and was stationed at a boot camp near Flat Rock. While there, he deserted his position and went to the city, where he was later arrested for attempting to rape and kidnap a woman. Day was convicted of this crime and given a 7-year term, served initially at the Richard A. Handlon Correctional Facility and later transferred to the Ionia Correctional Facility, successfully escaping once before being paroled in 1974.[2]

Between 1976 and 1982, Day was repeatedly arrested and incarcerated for various offenses including heroin possession, theft, kidnapping and writing bad checks, successfully escaping on one occasion. In late 1982, Day escaped from yet another prison camp in Caro, and thereafter kidnapped an 80-year-old woman, whom he robbed and then tied to a tree.[2] He was arrested and given an additional 7-year sentence, which he was to serve at the Michigan State Prison in Jackson. However, as he suffered from depression, Day was transferred for temporary treatment at the Center For Forensic Psychiatry in Ypsilanti.[3] During his stay, he was described as a model patient who frequently played chess with employees and even helped break up assaults by other patients. Through these activities, he became friendly with 36-year-old security worker Thomas Frederick Fortunato, a veteran employee of 14 years who was assigned to the center's C-43 ward, which was notorious for housing violent inmates.[4]

After abandoning the rental car in Louisville, Day bought a bus ticket for Nashville, Tennessee. On December 9, he came across 74-year-old Mary Catherine Strobel, a prominent local volunteer worker who was on her way to deliver a sack of potatoes to a rescue mission.[8] After offering to drive her home in her car, a 1981 AMC Concord, which she gladly accepted. After driving her around for some time and narrowly avoiding arrest by a traffic police officer, Day stopped the car and informed Strobel that he intended to tie her up. Frightened she began to scream, causing a panicked Day to draw a knife and stab her, before strangling her to make sure she was dead.[9] He then put the woman's body in the trunk of the car, parked it in front of the rescue mission and then bought a ticket at the nearby Greyhound bus station.[8]

Day then travelled cross-country until he eventually reached San Antonio, Texas, where he met 76-year-old Roberto Arzapalo-Alcoser, a retired Mexican mechanic en route to celebrate Christmas with his daughters, who lived in California. The two men befriended each other and drank beer together at a bar in El Paso.[10] While their bus was en route to Tucson, Arizona, Day noticed that his companion had a sewn pouch on his jacket, which Arzapalo-Alcoser claimed contained $2,000.[10] After they reached Tucson, Day lured Arzapalo-Alcoser to the back of the bus station, where he beat up the elderly man, slamming his body into a nearby metal transformer, before he stole the pouch, leaving him with only $40 in cash and his passport.[8] Arzapalo-Alcoser was still alive when located, but later died from his injuries in the hospital.[8]

After spending Christmas entertaining a group of Taiwanese college students in San Diego, treating them with visits to the zoo and a holiday dinner, Day returned to the East Coast, finding himself in Marianna, Florida in early January.[10] On January 2, he entered a pawn shop on Market Street and killed the clerk, 55-year-old Evan Johnson, then robbed the store of all valuables he could carry. On his way out, while he was turning the sign around to say 'CLOSED', Day was confronted by a police sergeant who inquired about what he was doing. Day claimed that he was Johnson's cousin and that he was temporarily closing the store, as the former was out having lunch with a friend.[10] While the sergeant suspected that something was not quite right, he had no reason to arrest Day and allowed him to leave. Day then got on a bus headed for New Orleans, Louisiana, getting off at a temporary stop in Pensacola to watch a football match at the Fiesta Bowl. On January 6, he passed through Fort Stockton, Texas, where he beat and stabbed to death a woman named Billie Taylor, whose body he left beside the road.[11]

On the following day, Day arrived in New Orleans and went to relax at a lounge in the French Quarter, where he met 27-year-old Andrew McClelland. Originally from Morgan City, McClelland was in New Orleans for a job interview when he came across Day, who offered to share his room at the Sheranton Inn in Gretna.[10] The day after, McClelland's body was found in the room by a housekeeper, having been stabbed numerous times. Day had stolen his car and driven to Mobile, Alabama, where he left it parked next to a bus station.[10]

On January 12, Day went to the trailer home of 53-year-old Stanley Robertson, whom he bludgeoned and stabbed to death before slashing his throat.[11] He then stole his 1985 Ford Merkur and sped off, only for the vehicle's tire to blow off on the highway near Van Horn. The incident was noticed by highway patrolman Jimmy Nail, who stopped to question the driver. Day, presenting himself as one "Tom Wilkins", claimed that he was driving his uncle Stanley's truck to El Paso to look for work, after having dropped the uncle at a local bar. Nail had heard on the police dispatch that a liquor store had been robbed recently and the 67-year-old clerk, Dorothy Alexander, had been pistol-whipped by the assailant.[11] Unmoved by Day's explanations, he arrested him, and upon a closer inspection, he noticed that the driver's clothes were splattered with blood.

Day was interned at the county jail to be questioned by the sheriff, Clifford Bare, about the recent holdup.[12] However, before Bare could begin to ask questions, Day waived his rights to an attorney and confessed not only to the hold-up, but claimed that he had escaped a mental health facility in Michigan and had killed 8 people during his 39 days on the run.[13] After getting into contact with authorities from various neighboring states, Day was conclusively linked to six of the claimed homicides, which in themselves were matched by his travel route and weapons used.[12]

While awaiting murder charges at the jail in Fort Stockton, Texas, Day was indicted by the authorities in Nashville for Strobel's murder.[14] In an exclusive interview with The Nashville Banner, Day admitted to all of the murders, but claimed that he was high on drugs and drunk at the time, rendering him unable to control his actions.[15] Fearing that his client would face the death penalty if he remained in Texas, Day's attorney, John Smith, announced that he would not appeal Tennessee's extradition request, as they had indicated they would pursue a life term instead.[16] Upon his arrival there, Day's attorneys requested a change of venue to a neighboring county, claiming that the extensive coverage of the Strobel murder in Nashville would prejudice the jurors. In response to this, Justice Walter Kurtz expressed skepticism, saying that the attorney's claims of it reaching publicity heights like those of Sam Sheppard or Billie Sol Estes were simply ridiculous.[17] During questionings conducted by the court, several jurors did indeed admit to knowing about Day's other murders, for which they had to be excused from jury duty.[18]

After a two-week long trial, Day was convicted on all counts, but as the jury were unable to come to a unanimous decision on his sentence, he was automatically given three life terms without the chance of parole.[19] The sentence came as a relief to Strobel's family members, who opposed capital punishment due to their religious beliefs.[20] The Strobel family have since dedicated themselves for advocating against the death penalty being used against mentally-ill inmates.[1]

Day died in prison from natural causes at the West Tennessee State Penitentiary on February 4, 2006, at the age of 54.[21]

• List of prison escapes

• State v. Day