Comparison of neurofeedback software
Within the field of neurotechnology, Neurofeedback (NFB), also called neurotherapy, neurobiofeedback or EEG biofeedback (EEGBF) is a therapy technique which presents the user with real-time information about activity within their brain, as measured by electrical or blood-flow sensors on the scalp.
Brain activity is monitored and processed to provide feedback to the user in one of several ways, for example a video game rocket ship might accelerate when desired brainwaves are produced (positive feedback), or a film or music might pause when undesired brainwaves are produced (negative feedback). The user then uses this feedback to develop the brainwaves they wish to create and as a consequence, learn to gain more control over their brainwaves and therefore how they think and feel in every day situations. Neurofeedback has been used to help a range of conditions including ADHD and addictions.
General
Software | Type | Version | Operating systems | Developer | License | FDA cleared | Supported Devices | Under Active Development | ~Price Bracket |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BetterFly | Neurofeedback | Clinic 2.0; Home 2.0 | Windows | BetterFly Neurofeedback | Proprietary | Classification by device | GENIUS, U-WIZ | ||
BioEra | Biofeedback: visual designer | 2.0 | Windows, Android | PROATECH LLC | Proprietary | No (but basis of Cygnet and others) | Pocket Neurobics,[1] BrainQuiry,[2] NeuroAmp,[3]
Neurobit Optima, Neurobit Optima+, Brainmaster,[4] QDS[2] | ||
BioExplorer | Neurofeedback | 1.5 | Windows | Cyberevolution, Larry Janow | Proprietary | No "Intended for personal use..." | Brainmaster,[4] BrainQuiry,[2] NeuroAmp,[3]
Neurobit Optima, Neurobit Optima+, J&J,[4] NeuroSky,[2] Pocket Neurobics,[1] QDS,[2] Telediagnostic Systems[4] | ||
BioGraph Infiniti | Neurofeedback/Biofeedback | 6.1.0 | Windows | Thought Technology Ltd, Dr. Hal Myers | Proprietary | Yes | Thought Technology[4] | ||
BioTrace+ | Neurofeedback, Biofeedback, QEEG | 2015 | Windows | Mind Media B.V. | Proprietary | Medical class II | NeXus by Mind Media[2] 4, 10 (MKII), 32 | ||
Brainathalon | Game | ? | Java | Amy Palke | Open source | No | |||
BrainBay | Neurofeedback: MIDI, particle display | ? | Windows | Chris Veigl and Jeremy Wilkerson | GPL | No | Neurobit Optima,
Neurobit Optima+ and more | ||
BrainFeedback Pro | Neurofeedback | v12 | Windows | Deymed Diagnostic | Proprietary | Yes | Deymed | ||
BrainMaster | Neurofeedback, Biofeedback, and QEEG; optional live z-scores (ANI or BrainDX), Live sLORETA Projector. | various including BrainAvatar. Third-party SW includes: NeuroGuide, BioExplorer, BioERA, BrainPaint, SKIL, LENS, EEGer, BrainTrain, OpenVibe, EEGStudio | Windows | BrainMaster Technologies, Inc. Thomas F. Collura | Proprietary; includes optional no-cost Application Programming Interfaces (API) | FDA 510(k) clearance, ISO 13485 certification, and CE marking in Europe | Brainmaster[4] 2E, 2EW, 2EB, Atlantis, Discovery, MINI-Q | ||
BrainPaint | Evidence Based Neurofeedback, with a validated[5] and replicated[6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21] symptom based evaluation tool. |
2.0 Includes BrainPrint, Alpha Theta, Brain-Heart Coherence, Couples Synchrony, Nonlinear, Slow Cortical Potential, Coherence training and all other frequency rewards and inhibits. |
N/A | BrainPaint, Inc. William C. Scott | Proprietary | FDA 510(k) clearance, ISO 13485 certification, and CE marking in Europe | Brainmaster[4] 2E, 2EW, 2EB, Atlantis, Discovery | ||
BWView | Brainwave viewer | 1.0.5 | Linux, Windows | Jim Peters | GPL | No | |||
Cygnet | Neurofeedback/Biofeedback
|
2.0 | Windows (any version) | Developer: BEE Systems GmbH Manufacturer: Corscience GmbH&CoKG Distribution: BEE Medic Europe, BEE Medic EMEA, BEE Medic USA |
Proprietary | FDA class II, CE class IIa; including Cygnet Bio/Neurofeedback Software | NeuroAmp[3] Bio/Neurofeedback device plus add-ons:
| ||
Dual Drive Pro | Biofeedback GSR & Temp | 3.0 | Windows | Somatic Vision Inc. | Proprietary | Unknown (not EEG) | |||
eBioo | Neurofeedback & Analysis one-, two- and four channel training, |
1.5 | Windows | Soft-dynamics, Geoffrey Arens | Proprietary | No – not stated or in FDA database | Pocket Neurobics,[1] Neurobit Optima,[2] Brainmaster[4] | ||
EEGDigiTrack | Neurofeedback & Analysis | 15.0.5.0 | Windows | ELMIKO Biosignals Ltd. | Proprietary | Safety class according to EN60601-1 - Class IIa, type BF | Manufactured by ELMIKO Biosignals Ltd.:
EEG-2, EEG-3, EEG-4, EEG-5, ExG-32 Manufactured by Braintronics: EEG-1166 Amplifier, EEG-1142 Amplifier, EEG-1042 Amplifier, | ||
EEGer4 | Neurofeedback & Analysis | 4.3.0 | Windows | EEG Software LLC | Proprietary | FDA Class II | J&J,[4] Telediagnostic Systems,[4] Phoenix Neuro Systems,[4]
Thought Technology,[4] Brainmaster,[4] Brainquiry,[2] Pocket Neurobics,[1] external analog amplifiers | ||
eProbe | Neuro-Biofeedback | Clinic 7.0; Home use 7.0 | Windows | ScienceBeam | Proprietary | CE, ISO 13485 | eWave, eLab, , QEEG, EEG2-EEG128 channels
eWave, eLab, eWave+, | ||
ElectricGuru | Neurofeedback | 0.4 | Windows | Rob Sacks | Open source | No | |||
EventIDE | Visual environment for designing behavioral experiments and mental games with real-time neurofeedback control and signal processing. | 1.0 | Windows | Okazolab Ltd | Proprietary | No | The majority of popular bio-amplifiers | ||
LENSware | Neurofeedback &Analysis | 3 | Windows | OchsLabs | Proprietary | FDA Class II Exempt | Ochslabs A200 amplifier | ||
Mind WorkStation | Neurofeedback, Biofeedback, and EEG-Driven Entrainment | 1.3 | Windows | Transparent Corporation | Proprietary | No but can use Bioexplorer, Biograph, BioEra links | See Bioexplorer, Biograph, BioEra | ||
MindReflector | Neurofeedback | 1.1 | Windows | MindReflector Technologies, LLC | Proprietary | No | NeuroSky[2] | ||
Narbis | Neurofeedback - Electrochromic Smart Glasses[22] | 1.0 | Android | Narbis | Proprietary | "FDA Class II 510(k) Exempt
CE, IEC 62368-1:2014 (Second Edition), CFR 47 FCC Part 15 Subpart B EN 61000-3-2:2014 EN 61000-3-3:2013 EN 61326-1:2013" |
Narbis Bluetooth Smart Glasses [23] | ||
NeuroField | Neurofeedback & Analysis | 8.7.5 | Windows | NeuroField, Inc. | Proprietary | FDA Class II[24] | X3000 Plus[25] and Q20 EEG[26][27] | ||
neuromore Studio | Customizable Biofeedback, protocol designing and automated therapy solution | 1.2.0 | Windows, Mac OS, Linux, Android, iOS | neuromore Inc. | Proprietary | No | |||
NeurOptimal | Neurofeedback | 3.0 | Windows | Valdeane W. Brown, Ph.D. | Proprietary | Unknown – not stated or in FDA database | zAmp[2] from Zengar | ||
NeuroRT Suite
Koala Modulo |
Real-time Processing, Self Neuromodulation, Bio/Neurofeedback | 2.2 | Windows, Linux, Android | Mensia Technologies | Proprietary | Medical device CE class IIa |
| ||
NeuroServer | Raw EEG to TCP/IP + EDF converter | 0.7.4 | Linux, Windows | [Rudi Cilibrasi] | GPL | No | |||
OpenViBE | BCI, Visual Designer, Analysis, Neurofeedback | 0.18 | Linux, Windows | INRIA | AGPL-3 | No | List of compatible systems | ||
SmartMind | Neurofeedback | v2010 | Windows | BrainTrain, Inc. | Proprietary | Unknown – not stated or in FDA database | Smartmind,[2] Brainmaster,[4] Thought Technology,[4] J&J,[4]
Pocket Neurobics,[1] NeuroSky[2] | ||
Myndlift | Neurofeedback: Single-active channel, amplitude training - home-based remote training | ? | Android, iOS | Myndlift LTD | Proprietary | No | Muse | ||
Vilistus | Neurofeedback/Biofeedback | v5.2.5 | Windows | Stephen Clark | Proprietary | No | Vilistus |
- 1 2 3 4 5 Multiple NON-FDA-cleared devices
- 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Status Unknown
- 1 2 3 FDA-cleared device
- 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 Multiple FDA-cleared devices
- ↑ Scott, William C.; Kaiser, David; Othmer, Siegfried; Sideroff, Stephen I. (7 July 2009). "Effects of an EEG Biofeedback Protocol on a Mixed Substance Abusing Population". The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse. 31 (3): 455–69. doi:10.1081/ADA-200056807. PMID 16161729. S2CID 6931394.
- ↑ Keith, Julian R.; Rapgay, Lobsang; Theodore, Don; Schwartz, Jeffrey M.; Ross, Jae L. (March 2015). "An assessment of an automated EEG biofeedback system for attention deficits in a substance use disorders residential treatment setting". Psychology of Addictive Behaviors. 29 (1): 17–25. doi:10.1037/adb0000016. PMC 5495545. PMID 25180558.
- ↑ Dehghani-Arani, Fateme; Rostami, Reza; Nadali, Hosein (20 April 2013). "Neurofeedback Training for Opiate Addiction: Improvement of Mental Health and Craving". Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback. 38 (2): 133–141. doi:10.1007/s10484-013-9218-5. PMC 3650238. PMID 23605225.
- ↑ Arani, Fateme Dehghani; Rostami, Reza; Nostratabadi, Masoud (July 2010). "Effectiveness of Neurofeedback Training as a Treatment for Opioid-Dependent Patients". Clinical EEG and Neuroscience. 41 (3): 170–177. doi:10.1177/155005941004100313. PMID 20722354. S2CID 35834162.
- ↑ Egner, T; Gruzelier, JH (January 2004). "EEG biofeedback of low beta band components: frequency-specific effects on variables of attention and event-related brain potentials". Clinical Neurophysiology. 115 (1): 131–9. doi:10.1016/S1388-2457(03)00353-5. PMID 14706480. S2CID 5855076.
- ↑ Dalkner, Nina; Unterrainer, Human F.; Wood, Guilherme; Skliris, Dimitris; Holasek, Sandra J.; Gruzelier, John H.; Neuper, Christa (26 September 2017). "Short-term Beneficial Effects of 12 Sessions of Neurofeedback on Avoidant Personality Accentuation in the Treatment of Alcohol Use Disorder". Frontiers in Psychology. 8: 1688. doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01688. PMC 5622970. PMID 29018397.
- ↑ Lackner, Nina; Unterrainer, Human F.; Skliris, Dimitris; Wood, Guilherme; Wallner-Liebmann, Sandra J.; Neuper, Christa; Gruzelier, John H. (27 September 2015). "The Effectiveness of Visual Short-Time Neurofeedback on Brain Activity and Clinical Characteristics in Alcohol Use Disorders". Clinical EEG and Neuroscience. 47 (3): 188–195. doi:10.1177/1550059415605686. PMID 26415612. S2CID 34971632.
- ↑ Horrell, Timothy; El-Baz, Ayman; Baruth, Joshua; Tasman, Allan; Sokhadze, Guela; Stewart, Christopher; Sokhadze, Estate (16 August 2010). "Neurofeedback Effects on Evoked and Induced EEG Gamma Band Reactivity to Drug-Related Cues in Cocaine Addiction". Journal of Neurotherapy. 14 (3): 195–216. doi:10.1080/10874208.2010.501498. PMC 2957125. PMID 20976131.
- ↑ Unterrainer, Human F.; Lewis, Andrew J.; Gruzelier, John H. (2013). "EEG-Neurofeedback in psychodynamic treatment of substance dependence". Frontiers in Psychology. 4: 692. doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2013.00692. PMC 3787602. PMID 24098295.
- ↑ Fattahi, Samineh; Naderi, Farah; Asgari, Parviz; Ahadi, Hassan (27 June 2017). "Neuro-Feedback Training For Overweight Women: Improvement of Food Craving And Mental Health". NeuroQuantology. 15 (2). doi:10.14704/nq.2017.15.2.1067.
- ↑ Rostami, R.; Dehghani-Arani, F. (19 April 2015). "Neurofeedback Training as a New Method in Treatment of Crystal Methamphetamine Dependent Patients: A Preliminary Study". Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback. 40 (3): 151–161. doi:10.1007/s10484-015-9281-1. PMID 25894106. S2CID 42223626.
- ↑ "Quantitative Electroencephalography-Guided Versus Scott/Peniston Neurofeedback With Substance Use Disorder Outpatients" (PDF). www.aapb.org/files/publications/biofeedback/2007/biof_winter_pilot_study.pdf.
- ↑ Nooner, Kate B.; Leaberry, Kirsten D.; Keith, Julian R.; Ogle, Richard L. (17 May 2016). "Clinic Outcome Assessment of a Brief Course Neurofeedback for Childhood ADHD Symptoms". The Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research. 44 (3): 506–514. doi:10.1007/s11414-016-9511-1. PMID 27189699. S2CID 7386924.
- ↑ Ros, T.; Frewen, P.; Théberge, J.; Michela, A.; Kluetsch, R.; Mueller, A.; Candrian, G.; Jetly, R.; Vuilleumier, P.; Lanius, R. A. (12 September 2016). "Neurofeedback Tunes Scale-Free Dynamics in Spontaneous Brain Activity". Cerebral Cortex. 27 (10): 4911–4922. arXiv:1512.09133. doi:10.1093/cercor/bhw285. PMID 27620975.
- ↑ Nicholson, Andrew A.; Ros, Tomas; Frewen, Paul A.; Densmore, Maria; Théberge, Jean; Kluetsch, Rosemarie C.; Jetly, Rakesh; Lanius, Ruth A. (February 2016). "Alpha oscillation neurofeedback modulates amygdala complex connectivity and arousal in posttraumatic stress disorder". NeuroImage: Clinical. 12: 506–516. doi:10.1016/j.nicl.2016.07.006. PMC 5030332. PMID 27672554.
- ↑ Kluetsch, R. C.; Ros, T.; Théberge, J.; Frewen, P. A.; Calhoun, V. D.; Schmahl, C.; Jetly, R.; Lanius, R. A. (August 2014). "Plastic modulation of PTSD resting-state networks and subjective wellbeing by EEG neurofeedback". Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica. 130 (2): 123–136. doi:10.1111/acps.12229. PMC 4442612. PMID 24266644.
- ↑ Mazur, L. M.; Campbell, A.; Comitz, E.; Planting, D.; Lowen, S.; Mosaly, P. R.; Belger, A.; Chera, B. S.; Marks, L. B. (2017). "Positive effects of neurofeedback intervention on radiation oncology physicians' workload during go/no-go performance test". Le Travail Humain. 80 (1): 113–32. doi:10.3917/th.801.0113.
- ↑ "Neurofeedback - Electrochromic Smart Glasses".
- ↑ "Narbis Bluetooth Smart Glasses".
- ↑ "Establishment Registration & Device Listing". www.accessdata.fda.gov. Retrieved 2015-09-22.
- ↑ "X3000 Plus – NeuroField – The Energetic Wave of the Future". Retrieved 2015-09-22.
- ↑ "Q20 EEG – NeuroField – The Energetic Wave of the Future". Archived from the original on 2015-09-10. Retrieved 2015-09-22.
- ↑ "X3000 Plus and Q20 EEG – NeuroField – The Energetic Wave of the Future". Archived from the original on 2015-08-11. Retrieved 2015-09-22.
See also
- Neurofeedback
- Brainwave synchronization
- Comparison of brainwave entrainment software