All the Broken Places

All the Broken Places is a sequel to Boyne's 2006 book The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas and follows the now 91-year-old older sister of Bruno from that book, Gretel. Gretel has lived in London for decades, never speaking of her childhood in Nazi Germany as the daughter of a concentration camp commandant. Her life is upended when a new family moves in next door whose circumstances force her to confront her own past.[1]

Following the events of the previous novel, Gretel's father Ralf is executed soon after the end of World War II. In 1946, 15-year-old Gretel and her mother immigrate to Paris and using false identities to claim French nationality. They clash over the Holocaust: Gretel believes they share responsibility, while her mother disagrees. Seeking security, Gretel’s mother courts Rémy Toussaint, a wealthy man and former resistance member in the hope that their eventual marriage will guarantee their future. Gretel, however, becomes infatuated with Emil, an assistant in his father’s haberdashery shop, whose older brother was a resistance fighter executed by the Germans. Gretel senses something peculiar in Emil and Rémy’s behavior.

On a night out with their lovers, Gretel and her mother face furious neighbours who’ve lost loved ones in the war. During the altercation, their heads are forcibly shaved. They soon flee to Rouen, where Gretel becomes a seamstress. Her mother’s bitterness about the attack eventually drives her towards pro-Nazism sentiments. In 1952, Gretel’s mother dies from grief and alcoholism. Gretel moves to Australia, befriending Kate Sophy, a lesbian Irishwoman who was physically abused by her father for falling pregnant; the beatings then resulted in her suffering a miscarriage. They rent a place together in Sydney, with Gretel working at a dressmaker’s shop and Kate as a barmaid. Gretel learns about Kate’s relationships and her own past.

At the pub where Kate, Gretel spots Lieutenant Kurt Kohler, a former German soldier who served under her father. She starts observing him, discovering his new life as a banker in Australia. One day, Gretel kidnaps his son Hugo, planning a murder-suicide but eventually agreeing to meet Kurt. They discuss her anger and his support for the Nazi regime, with Kurt pointing out that Gretel is angry with him as a means of escaping from her own guilt.

Gretel migrates to England soon after the kidnapping. She moves to London where she finds work in Selfridges. She begins a romantic relationship with a coworker David liking his easygoing nature. She learns from his friend Edgar that he is a Jew.

Following the kidnapping, Gretel relocates to London, where she finds work at Selfridges. She falls for a coworker, David, initially unaware he’s Jewish until his friend Edgar tells her so. Nevertheless, she begins a romantic relationship with him. However, after attending a showing of a film about the Holocaust and seeing footage of her family in the film, Gretel runs out of the theatre and jumps in front of a bus in an unsuccessful attempt to commit suicide. In the hospital, Edgar informs her about David’s past; how he was born in Prague and escaped with his grandparents after the occupation, and that parents and sister were delayed and disappeared, ultimately being murdered in Treblinka extermination camp. Gretel also learns in hospital that she is pregnant with David's child. After being discharged, she comes clean and tell David the story of her life. He is disgusted and abandons her despite that she is carrying his child. Eventually, Gretel marries Edgar and gives up her and David’s daughter (whom she names Heidi) for adoption.

In 1961, she and Edgar have a son named Caden. Struggling with motherhood, Gretel distances herself and largely leaves the responsibility of bringing up her son to Edgar and his mother. One day, when he is nine-years-old, Caden briefly disappears after crawling through a hole in the fence behind their home. The parallelism of this experience with that of her late younger brother Bruno leads her to suffer a breakdown. She spends a year in the hospital, reliving her childhood and fantasising that she is a child again. Her doctor, who was evacuated as a child in World War II, reflects on their shared trauma, which frustrates Gretel as she feels she has suffered much more than the doctor.

In 2008, her husband Edgar, who had become a respected historian specialising in World War II, passes away. By 2022, Gretel lives in Winterville Court, a block of flats in Mayfair. She lives next to her abandoned daughter Heidi, who is prone to confusion and memory loss. Meanwhile, Caden is getting married for the fourth time and his construction business is faltering, leading him to pressure Gretel to move into a retirement village. Despite her refusal, she agrees to help him financially.

However. the arrival of film producer Alex Darcy-Witt’s family in a flat downstairs disrupts their lives. Alex is abusive and very controlling of his wife Madelyn and his 9-year-old son Henry; seeing them as his property. This behaviour proves to be too much for Gretel, who eventually calls the police on Alex in an attempt to safeguard his wife and son, but unfortunately nothing comes of their investigation. In retaliation, Alex has tells Gretel that he knows her true identity and threatens to reveal it if she draws attention to him again. This leads Gretel to take drastic action; by inviting Alex into her flat, slitting his throat and handing herself over to the police following Caden's wedding. The novel ends with her imprisoned in a comfortable, low security facility knowing that her secret will die with her and her expected grandchild will grow up unaware of its ancestry.

All the Broken Places received mixed reviews from critics upon release.[2] The novel received praise in The Guardian and the Star Tribune, with the former praising Gretel's characterization and the latter describing the story as "an essential one" and "darkly compelling".[3][4] Booklist's Margaret Quamme praised Boyne's engagement with the novel's main themes of guilt and complicity with violence but criticized the plot for containing too many coincidences and chance encounters.[5] Martina Devlin, writing in the Irish Independent, said that the historical material of the novel was handled well and that the novel remained fast-paced throughout.[6]

Negative reviews of All the Broken Places focused on its handling of the Holocaust and many of its characters' complicity in the events. The Sunday Times criticized the novel's structure and described the plot as not being believable.[7] The Daily Telegraph's Tanya Gold gave the book a 2 out of 5 star rating, writing that the novel could only be described as skillful if "you know nothing about the Holocaust, and if you wish to know nothing." She writes that the storyline about Gretel's life in the 1940s and '50s was the "valuable part of novel" but that other parts of the story become "a thriller". She concludes that "parallel narratives – one promising, one insulting – combine into a pulpy denouement that shames the author and the reader both."[8] The New Statesman's Ann Manov was even more blunt, describing the novel as "childish drivel" and as having "utterly fail[ed] in its stated purpose" of furthering genocide education. Manov wrote that the novel is "so self-indulgent, so grossly stereotyped, so shameless and insipid that one is almost astonished that [Boyne] has dared."[9]

Publishers Weekly wrote that the novel served as an acceptable sequel to The Boy in the Striped Pajamas but that it wasn't capable of fully standing on its own.[10] Kirkus Reviews was more positive, praising Boyne's character work throughout the book.[11]

• All the Broken Places at BookMarks