Ashes & Fire

In January 2009, while touring in support of Cardinology (2008), Adams announced that he was planning to retire from music, due to ongoing problems with Ménière's disease. Posting on his website, Adams wrote: "I am excited to finish this wonderful time I have had with the Cardinals. [...] I am grateful for the time we have had, and maybe someday we will have more stories to tell together. I am, however, ready for quieter times, as I think it is very evident I am struggling with some balance and hearing issues. [...] Maybe we will play again sometime, and maybe I will work my way back into some kind of music situation, but this is the time for me to step back now, to reel it in."[5] At this time, Adams had written a planned studio album, entitled Dear Impossible, which was subsequently abandoned.[6]

The band played their final show on March 20, 2009 at the Fox Theatre in Atlanta and dissolved. Drummer Brad Pemberton noted, "Everyone was a bit fried, so it was the right time to step back for a minute. I encouraged Ryan to go and get married, and have a life and find some peace; the guy hasn’t really slowed down in ten years, and he needed it as much as we did."[7] On December 15, 2009, Cardinals bassist Chris Feinstein was found dead in his New York City apartment.[8]

During his hiatus from music, Adams married singer and actress Mandy Moore and relocated from New York City to Los Angeles. Adams released two books of poetry, Infinity Blues and Hello Sunshine, and, in late 2009, began issuing unreleased recordings through his label, PAX AM. Two studio albums, Orion and III/IV, an EP, Class Mythology, and various singles, were released between 2009 and 2010. Regarding his struggles with Ménière's disease, during this time, Adams noted, "It took me a little bit of time to get it under control and get my life under control. I was very, very sick. I was very ill. I had screaming loud noises in my left ear from the tinnitus, and I just felt sick all the time."[9]

In October 2010, Adams began making sporadic live performances around Los Angeles, and subsequently embarked upon a European tour in June 2011, performing new songs alongside older material. Regarding the tour, Adams noted, "[It] was the most fun I’ve had ever. I couldn't have imagined it being any better than it was. [...] I just felt really connected and it seemed to me that the people that I was playing for also felt really connected, and it was nice that there wasn’t anything getting in the way of the music."[10] Following the tour's completion, Adams announced that a new studio album, produced by Glyn Johns, father of Ethan Johns (Heartbreaker, Gold and 29) was scheduled for release in October 2011.

Regarding the album's title track, Adams noted, "I thought it was implying the reference of a phoenix in a song."[11] Adams ultimately decided to name the album after the song, stating, "I wanted it to sound hot, as in temperature-wise, windows-rolled-down, middle-of-summer, driving-through-California, hot. In all honesty, it was the right title. [...] I was trying to paint this picture of somebody not destroyed by change. I got the idea from the arcade game, Phoenix."[12] Adams does not refer to his struggles with Ménière's disease on the album, noting, "[It] is a personal thing, and I decided it didn't have to have anything to do with my creative life, it didn't need to be a record about recovery."[9]

According to Adams, Laura Marling's second studio album, I Speak Because I Can, inspired him to re-write the majority of the album's material. After receiving a copy from former producer Ethan Johns, Adams noted, "I thought: 'For fuck's sake.' I literally threw out 80% of what I had. And it felt good, to ask: 'What am I really capable of?' I felt competitive again to write great songs."[13]

Ashes & Fire was recorded at Sunset Sound Studios in Hollywood California, using analog equipment.[13] Amongst the album's contributors are Norah Jones, Benmont Tench, and former Cardinals guitarist Neal Casal. Casal later commented on working with Adams again, noting, "He’s in fine form. I will always have a connection with him. It doesn’t go away just because you don’t play in the same band anymore."[14]

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
AnyDecentMusic?	7.2/10[15]
Metacritic	76/100[16]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[17]
The A.V. Club	B[18]
The Daily Telegraph	[19]
Entertainment Weekly	B+[20]
The Guardian	[21]
Los Angeles Times	[22]
NME	8/10[23]
Pitchfork	6.5/10[24]
Rolling Stone	[25]
Spin	7/10[26]

So far the album holds a score of 76 out of 100 from Metacritic based on 38 "generally favorable reviews".[16]

Most of the reviews were positive. IGN gave the album a perfect score of ten out of ten and said, "Adams' latest is the focused masterpiece fans have been waiting for, holding your undivided attention with an enchanting set of acoustic-based treasures that rival anything the songsmith has ever crafted."[27] The Phoenix gave it a score of three-and-a-half stars out of four and called it "as close as it gets to the brilliance of his first post-Whiskeytown offering, Heartbreaker."[28] Paste gave it a score of 8.2 out of ten and called it "pretty damn good".[29]

Uncut gave it four stars out of five and called it "an understated gem".[16] The Boston Globe gave it a favorable review and called it a "lovely, low-key effort".[30] NME gave it a score of eight out of ten and called it "an album worth celebrating now."[23] The Quietus also gave it a favorable review and said it has "a softer collection of songs, harnessing more sincerity than his last two general-release LPs (as opposed to Orion, which was online-only), Easy Tiger and Cardinology."[31] Clash also gave it a score of eight out of ten and called it "a haunting album that truly reveals Adams' bruised soul."[32] musicOMH also gave it a score of four stars out of five and said "It may put people off who were more attracted to Adams' more tortured side, but Ashes & Fire makes for a compelling reboot for a man who could, once more, become a contender."[33] Alternative Press gave it a similar score of four stars out of five and said, "The recordings have the warmth and pop of a vinyl record, creating a perfect environment for Adams to honor his influences."[34] Consequence of Sound also gave it a score of four out of five and said it "remains compelling throughout thanks to its peaks and valleys."[35] BBC Music also gave it a favorable review and called it "an album that delivers more and more with every listen, showcasing an artist maturing with grace and poise."[36]

Beats Per Minute gave it a score of 79% and said, "Ryan Adams has delivered the goods right now and he appears to be more focused and in a better creative space than he has at any other point in his career."[37] The A.V. Club gave it a B and said it was "everything Ryan Adams records usually aren't: uniform in sound and mood, emotionally centered, and straight-arrow consistent, sometimes to its detriment."[18] Spin gave it a score of seven out of ten and said that Adams is "purely elegant throughout".[26]

Other reviews are average or mixed, however: Sputnikmusic gave it a score of three out of five and said, "For an album heavily predicated on Adams' historically hit-or-miss songwriting, Ashes & Fire is surprisingly steady."[38] Under the Radar gave it a score of six stars out of ten and called it "a delightful Saturday-morning House-cleaning music."[16] The Observer gave it a score of three stars out of five and said, "It hasn't the shiver factor of his debut but there's pleasure in such smooth, elegantly crafted songs after his recent strainings."[39] Drowned in Sound also gave it a score of six out of ten and said, "While it might not be a consistent classic like Heartbreaker or Gold, there's flashes of those earlier triumphs from Adams' career on Ashes & Fire."[40] Now gave it a score of three out of five and called it "a typical Ryan Adams release."[41] American Songwriter also gave it a score of three out of five stars and called it "a solid, not spectacular album with a few very fine songs."[42] Blurt gave it a score of five stars out of ten and said, "Despite the obvious care for craftsmanship, no standouts emerge."[43] Tiny Mix Tapes gave it a score of two stars out of five and said, "Its total lack of affectation is the album's biggest problem. It feels like it's sequenced to fit some expectation of what types of songs an album should have."[44]

Japanese Edition (SICP-3322)

As of 2014 it has sold 160,150 copies in United States according to Nielsen SoundScan.[48]

• Ashes & Fire at Metacritic