Australian Survivor (season 1)
The first season of Australian Survivor is the inaugural Australian adaptation of the popular reality game show Survivor. The season was filmed in Whaler's Way, an Eyre Peninsula coastal nature reserve near Port Lincoln, South Australia in the Great Australian Bight, where numerous ships had sunk off the coast in the past, setting up the season's nautical theme.
Australian Survivor | |
---|---|
Season 1 | |
Presented by | Lincoln Howes |
No. of days | 39 |
No. of castaways | 16 |
Winner | Rob Dickson |
Runner-up | Sciona Browne |
Location | Whaler's Way, Eyre Peninsula, South Australia |
No. of episodes | 13 (plus 2 specials) |
Release | |
Original release | 13 February – 15 May 2002 |
Additional information | |
Filming dates | November – December 2001 |
Season chronology |
Hosted by 60 Minutes journalist Lincoln Howes, the program consisted of 16 Australian castaways competing for 39 days for a grand prize of A$500,000 and a Ford V6 Escape. The series was filmed in November and December 2001 and aired weekly between February and May 2002 on the Nine Network, culminating in a live finale on 15 May 2002, where former Victorian Football League player Robert "Rob" Dickson was crowned the "Sole Survivor" over former test pilot Sciona Browne in a jury vote of 5–2.
The program was criticised by fans and critics for poor casting and lower production values than the popular American edition (which also aired on Nine) and was not renewed due to low ratings.[1] However the series did return (albeit on a different network) in 2006 with a celebrity edition.
Production
Conception
In 2000, Nine began airing Survivor: Borneo, the first season of the American Survivor production. The agreement for Nine to air the American series included the condition that they must produce their own local Australian edition of Survivor. The local edition was announced publicly during the night of the local airing of the finale of Survivor: The Australian Outback in early May 2001. This announcement also began the casting call for Australians willing to compete on the show.
Filming and development
The people included for consideration for host included Grant Kenny, Jamie Durie and Richard Hatch, the "Sole Survivor" of Survivor: Borneo. Eventually, Lincoln Howes, a journalist from Nine's 60 Minutes, was named as host.[2]
The production scouted locations across Australia to be used for the series. Locations considered included Uluru/Ayers Rock in the Northern Territory and the Kimberley region in Western Australia. However production settled on Whaler's Way, on the South Australian coastline, 30 km (19 mi) from the town of Port Lincoln, where the production crew was based. This location set up a nautical/shipwreck theme for the series. A majority of the challenges centred around the water (many of which were originally created by the show and not derived from the American series), Tribal Council was located on a shipwreck called "The Great Beyond", tribal immunity was in the form of a bell, and individual immunity was in the form of a rope necklace with shark's teeth. The theme song incorporated an Irish jig in a nod to Australian history – First Fleet arriving. An extended version of the main theme was played during the closing credits of the live finale and reunion show.
Broadcast
The show was broadcast by the Nine Network in the Wednesday 8:30 pm time slot and was rated PG. In addition to 12 regular hour-long episodes and the 3-hour long finale/reunion show, two specials for the series were produced. An auditions special hosted by Ben Dark aired the day before the main series aired, showing some of the highlights and lowlights from the 8,500 audition submissions sent into the show before revealing the 16 people who would compete on the series. Additionally, the program included an interview with Ethan Zohn; the "Sole Survivor" of Survivor: Africa.[3] The other special was a behind-the-scenes show that aired a few weeks after the series ended and was titled Surviving Survivor. Among other things, this special revealed that the final four wanted to quit the show due to the dramatic turn of events concerning Katie's behaviour (her mental breakdown right before the Tribal Council on Day 37) as well as the threat of an unknown change in rules impacting the game's endgame, intended to make the castaways reassess their solidified strategies. The producers threatened to give the prize money to the last eliminated contestant (Sophie) if the contestants continued to defy production. The contestants eventually complied, and the threat of a rule change was unfounded, with the game continuing as intended.
The format of the Finale and Reunion shows of Nine's Australian Survivor was rather different to the American edition's finales at the time. The finale/reunion program featured reunion show host, Eddie McGuire, introducing each segment of the show live from the finale venue as the night progressed. The American production adopted this format starting with its 28th season, Survivor: Cagayan, in 2014, until the practice of a studio reunion show was dropped, with the last studio reunion being a part of the 39th season, Survivor: Island of the Idols.
Promotion
The evicted contestant from each episode was featured for an interview on the Today show on the following day. These interviews were conducted by Richard Wilkins just before the 8:00 AM news. This paralleled the American edition, where evicted Survivor contestants were interviewed on CBS' The Early Show during its time on air.
The program had several sponsors who were involved in product placements spots on the show (most as rewards for reward challenges). Sponsors included Cadbury, IBM, Jetset travel agencies, Schweppes, Fa deodorant for men, Lays potato crisps, Telstra, Ford and Intel Pentium (which was also used in producing the show's graphics).
Contestants
The sixteen players were initially separated into two tribes, Kadina and Tipara, both named after ships that traveled in the area. On Day 19, the ten remaining players merged into the Aurora tribe. The final nine players made up the two finalists and the seven members of the Tribal Council jury, who ultimately decided who would be the "Sole Survivor".
Contestant | Age | From | Tribe | Finish | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Original | Merged | Placement | Day | |||
Lucinda Allen-Rhodes | 43 | Byron Bay, New South Wales |
Kadina | 1st voted out | Day 3 | |
Tim Dugan† | 51 | Green Point, New South Wales |
2nd voted out | Day 6 | ||
David Haas | 34 | Sydney, New South Wales |
3rd voted out | Day 9 | ||
Jeff Brown | 52 | Canberra, Australian Capital Territory |
Tipara | 4th voted out | Day 12 | |
Deborah Peart | 26 | Sydney, New South Wales |
Kadina | 5th voted out | Day 15 | |
Sylvan Dorney | 25 | Sydney, New South Wales |
6th voted out | Day 18 | ||
Caren Shaw | 28 | Darwin, Northern Territory |
Aurora | 7th voted out | Day 21 | |
Naomi Knight | 22 | Melbourne, Victoria |
8th voted out 1st jury member |
Day 24 | ||
Craig Abbott | 27 | Point Lonsdale, Victoria |
9th voted out 2nd jury member |
Day 27 | ||
Lance Brooks | 39 | Sydney, New South Wales |
Tipara | 10th voted out 3rd jury member |
Day 30 | |
Jane Dalton | 18 | Newcastle, New South Wales |
11th voted out 4th jury member |
Day 33 | ||
Sophie Woods | 30 | Sydney, New South Wales |
12th voted out 5th jury member |
Day 35 | ||
Katie Gold | 24 | Melbourne, Victoria |
13th voted out 6th jury member |
Day 37 | ||
Joel Betts | 22 | Sydney, New South Wales |
14th voted out 7th jury member |
Day 38 | ||
Sciona Browne | 49 | Perth, Western Australia |
Runner-up | Day 39 | ||
Robert "Rob" Dickson† | 37 | Traralgon, Victoria |
Sole Survivor |
Season summary
The sixteen players were divided into two tribes: Kadina in green, and Tipara in blue. Tipara won more immunity challenges, and their members stuck together to systematically eliminate the Kadina members after the merge. A final three alliance of Rob, Sciona, and Joel emerged, and Rob eliminated Joel after winning the final immunity challenge. The jury respected Rob's leadership over Sciona's quieter gameplay, naming the former as Sole Survivor.
Episode | Challenge winner(s)[4] | Eliminated | Finish | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
No. | Episode Title | Air date | Reward | Immunity | ||
1 | "Journey To Whaler's Way" |
13 February, 2002 | None |
Tipara | Lucinda | 1st voted out Day 3 |
2 | "Violent Weather and Violent People" |
20 February, 2002 | Kadina | Tipara | Tim | 2nd voted out Day 6 |
3 | "The Losing Streak" | 27 February, 2002 | Kadina | Tipara | David | 3rd voted out Day 9 |
4 | "The Struggle of Both Tribes" |
6 March, 2002 | Tipara | Kadina[lower-alpha 1] | Jeff | 4th voted out Day 12 |
5 | "It's Just Too Hard!" | 13 March, 2002 | Kadina | Tipara | Deborah | 5th voted out Day 15 |
6 | "This Game is Way Different Then it Looks" |
20 March, 2002 | Tipara[lower-alpha 2] | Tipara[lower-alpha 3] | Sylvan | 6th voted out Day 18 |
7 | "It's Time to Merge" | 3 April, 2002 | None |
Craig | Caren | 7th voted out Day 21 |
8 | "Pick Off" | 10 April,2002 | Naomi [Craig] |
Craig | Naomi | 8th voted out 1st jury member Day 24 |
9 | "I Just Feel So Bad" | 17 April, 2002 | Lance [Jane, Joel, Katie, Rob, Sciona, Sophie] |
Sophie | Craig | 9th voted out 2nd jury member Day 27 |
10 | "He's a Threat, She's A Threat, We're all Threats!" |
24 April, 2002 | Jane | Joel | Lance | 10th voted out 3rd jury member Day 30 |
11 | "Cockiness Comes to an End" |
1 May, 2002 | Joel | Sciona | Jane | 11th voted out 4th jury member Day 33 |
12 | "Who's the Odd Man Out?" |
8 May, 2002 | Katie [Joel, Rob, Sciona, Sophie] |
Katie | Sophie | 12th voted out 5th jury member Day 35 |
13 | "Finale/Reunion" | 15 May, 2002 | Katie [Joel, Rob, Sciona] |
Rob | Katie | 13th voted out 6th jury member Day 37 |
None | Rob | Joel | 14th voted out 7th jury member Day 38 | |||
Final vote | ||||||
Sciona | Runner-up Day 39 | |||||
Rob | Sole Survivor Day 39 |
- In the case of multiple tribes or castaways who win reward or immunity, they are listed in order of finish, or alphabetically where it was a team effort; where one castaway won and invited others, the invitees are in brackets.
- Notes
- In addition to winning Immunity, Kadina also won the right to participate in a special reward draw for the car used in the challenge. Sylvan drew the right key and won the car.
- Tipara felt Kadina lost due to bad luck, and shared their reward.
- This challenge was a one-on-one duel, with Joel and Sylvan being chosen to participate by their respective tribes. Joel won the challenge and won immunity for his entire tribe.
Episodes
No. overall | No. in season | Title | Timeline | Original air date | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 1 | "Journey To Whaler's Way" | Days 1-3 | 13 February 2002 | |
The 16 castaways arrived and were divided into two tribes. The youngest contestant, Jane, was asked to select heads or tails for a coin toss on behalf of the Tipara tribe; she lost, so Kadina were given the choice of whether they wanted the camp closest to the ocean and the food source, or the camp closest to a windmill, the water source for the duration of the competition. They chose the camp closest to the water source. Opinions were immediately voiced about how to build the shelters with the correct angle away from the sun and cold. Lucinda was notably vocal about using their tarp on the ground and sleeping with themselves inside it, much to everyone else's annoyance. Both teams struggled to set up their camps and light a fire, but Tipara was able to find some fish and start a fire before Kadina.
Tipara was first to strike their bonfire shortly followed by Kadina. As teams started to wait, however, the wind was too severe and the fire would not light, causing the challenge to be cancelled after 40 minutes. The next day, there was a tie breaker quiz about the history of Whaler's Way; with Lucinda and Jane being the people to answer the 4th question alone, Lucinda was incorrect, giving the first immunity win to Tipara. Back at the Kadina camp, Lucinda admitted that she was struggling in such a harsh environment and told the tribe that she would be okay with being voted out and was expecting it. She was voted out at the first Tribal Council that night with all eight votes, giving her the distinction of being the first person in any edition of Survivor to vote for herself. | |||||
2 | 2 | "Violent Weather and Violent People" | Days 4-6 | 20 February 2002 | |
At the Kadina camp, everyone was having a tough time with the dirty environment and cooked fish in their water pot causing everything to taste and smell of fish. Negotiations were still being made in both tribes about how to better their shelter, hoping to be warmer in the cold harsh nights. At Tipara, Jeff's snoring also caused people to have little sleep throughout the night.
Tipara won when David touched the ground. After the immunity challenge, it was unclear who would be voted out, unlike the easy unanimous decision the first time around. Caren, Deborah, Naomi, and Sylvan felt that Tim was the weakest link and he was the next to go. Craig voted for David, David voted for Caren, and Tim voted for Deborah, but Tim was eliminated. | |||||
3 | 3 | " The Losing Streak" | Days 7-9 | 27 February 2002 | |
After Tribal Council, David criticised his tribe for voting out a strong tribe member and not putting the tribe before personal agendas. He was also visibly upset at receiving a vote from Craig, though he was not aware who cast the vote. Craig later approached David and informed him about his vote; David was understanding but stated in his confessional that he would "do something about it".
Kadina won reward. At Tipara, Katie and Sciona went fishing, with the former solidifying a Final 2 deal with the latter. Sciona suggested they bring Joel and Rob into their alliance to have a better chance with numbers, much to the pleasure of Katie. Sciona rubbed the other tribe members the wrong way with her opinion about leaving fish in the sun. She later went for a walk alone and spoke emotionally of her late father. At Kadina, David felt that Craig, Sylvan and Naomi were tightly aligned. He also felt that Deborah and Caren were more approachable since they were left out by others regarding the previous vote.
Tipara won their third straight immunity challenge. At their camp, everyone celebrated and went for a swim in the ocean. The next day, Katie and Rob talked strategy, with Katie saying she wanted to set up a strong core alliance, considering Sophie an ally also. At Kadina, everyone expressed their frustration at losing another immunity challenge and Jeff's poor attitude at the challenge. With Kadina continuing to win rewards and lose immunity challenges, the tribe had low morale. Sylvan had redeemed himself at the challenges. David asked Deborah if she would vote for him as he believed they were the next to be voted out. Deborah did not want to make herself more vulnerable and told the rest of the tribe. At Tribal Council, David voted against Craig, but everyone else voted out David, believing that it was not acceptable to attempt to make alliances for a later part of the game. | |||||
4 | 4 | "The Struggle of Both Tribes" | Days 10-12 | 6 March 2002 | |
The remaining five Kadina members expressed their desperation to win an immunity challenge, in fear of being picked off by Tipara at the merge.
Tipara won reward. They went out fishing for food and came across a beehive. Sciona and Joel broke the beehive, and the tribe was able to acquire honey. Deborah and Naomi talked about the coincidence of the remaining five Kadina members being in their twenties and Deborah expressed her fears of losing another immunity challenge and having to vote someone out yet again after the "Famous Five" had become so close.
Kadina won their first immunity challenge, and one person from their tribe won a car. Sylvan drew the correct key to the car and won. Kadina expressed their happiness at finally winning an immunity challenge, while back at Tipara, talk about whom to vote out immediately arose with Jane being the most obvious choice because she was the driver in the challenge. Jeff's name also arose due to him being the physically weakest and oldest person in the game. At Tribal Council, Katie and Sciona were the only ones to vote with Jeff against Jane, while the rest of the tribe sent Jeff home. | |||||
5 | 5 | "It's Just Too Hard!" | Days 13-15 | 13 March 2002 | |
The day after Tipara's first Tribal Council, Joel was emotionally upset after voting out Jeff instead of Jane. The Kadina tribe went to their fishing spot and were all exhausted just from trekking there. Sylvan was suffering the most, stating that he was too tired to even think and couldn't fish for more than twenty minutes without becoming fatigued. Sylvan expressed his desire for different food in his belly other than fish and hoped they would win the next reward challenge.
Kadina won reward. Deborah and Craig instantly trekked to their fishing spot to set up their newly acquired lobster trap. The next morning, Deborah was in pain due to rolling her ankle on the way to the fishing spot the night before.
Tipara edged out Kadina for immunity. Over at Tipara, Katie mapped out a plan for the rest of the game and showed it only to Rob, with the plan being to vote out Kadina one by one in the merge, then vote for Jane, Lance and Joel being in the minority of Tipara. Deborah was immediately targeted by Craig for being the slowest and having sustained an injury, while Caren thought that Deborah ran the obstacle course well even with an injury. Deborah thought that Caren was the weakest physically, and they discussed at the campfire that they would both like to be told if they were the one being voted out. After a trek to their fishing spot, the tribe could no longer see the buoy for their lobster trap, due to the strong currents. Later that night, Deborah was voted out due to her injury. | |||||
6 | 6 | "This Game is Way Different Then it Looks" | Days 16-18 | 20 March 2002 | |
Sylvan approached Caren and apologised for his vote against her. Caren told him that she knew he voted for her, which caused Sylvan to suspect that there was an alliance consisting of Caren, Craig and Naomi. While both tribes were struggling at this point of the game, Kadina was becoming emotional and missing home, while Tipara were struggling with rationing their food; each member only consumed around one fish per two days, causing some tribe members to begin snapping at each other.
Tipara won the challenge. At the end of the challenge, Tipara volunteered to have shorter calls with their loved ones to give time to Kadina, because if Kadina had not lost one of their nails in the sand in the challenge, they might have won.
Joel won immunity for Tipara. The day after the challenge, Tipara had their first decent meal in five days, feasting on fish: the tribe members consumed two fish each. With Tribal Council looming for Kadina, Caren, Craig and Naomi were leaning towards voting for Sylvan, with the loss of the immunity challenge resting on his shoulders. Sylvan was not in any alliance, but tried to convince Caren and Naomi to vote out Craig, thinking he would be a huge threat in the merge. The women decided to stick with getting Sylvan out, while Sylvan changed his vote to Naomi. | |||||
7 | 7 | "It's Time to Merge" | Days 19-21 | 3 April 2002 | |
The morning after voting out Sylvan, Naomi and Caren were praying for a merge, and suspected it would happen on this day. After receiving tree mail, both tribes were told to gather everything they wanted and leave in five minutes. The Tipara and Kadina tribes were no more, and Aurora was formed. The new tribe hiked to their new camp, picking up fruits and nuts on the way, arriving at their new camp with fresh water and a hot shower. Sciona, Katie and Craig went fishing and caught enough fish for the consumption of two per tribe member, much to everyone's happiness. Katie expressed how Craig was the first Kadina who would be voted off in the merge and that she was beginning to double think the pecking order.
Craig lit the torch first and won immunity. After the immunity challenge, Katie immediately approached the three remaining Kadina (Naomi, Caren and Craig), and proposed to them that they vote out Lance first, ensuring their safety for another round. All three were suspicious of Katie's motives and questioned her as to why. She stated that Lance was a threat physically, mentally and socially. However, at Tribal Council, the Tipara seven stuck together, and with Craig having immunity and not being able to be voted for, Caren was voted out. She and Naomi voted against Lance, but Craig voted against Rob. | |||||
8 | 8 | "Pick Off" | Days 22-24 | 10 April 2002 | |
Rob was paranoid about the one vote cast against him at the previous Tribal Council. Questioning who it was, he assumed that it was a member of the old Kadina tribe, but remained wary that it could well be one of the Tipara seven. Sciona expressed her frustration at people taking too long to wake up in the morning and get ready to go fishing (mainly Jane). Katie also stated that Jane was useless and was just there looking pretty.
Naomi won the challenge. She was allowed to select one person to take with her on the reward; she selected fellow ex-Kadina tribemate Craig. While Naomi and Craig enjoyed their reward, the rest of the Aurora tribe sat in their shelter through a large thunderstorm. The next day, Joel told Rob that Craig had approached him before the last Tribal Council and told him of Katie's attempt to vote out Lance. Katie then told Sciona and Lance that Craig was the one to approach her and inform her of an alliance between Lance and Joel.
Craig won immunity for the second straight time, beating Rob after one hour and three minutes. Naomi was immediately targeted as being the only vulnerable Kadina member left in the game. Certain members of the Tipara seven were questioning if they wanted to vote off Naomi and instead target Jane, being the weakest left in the game and viewing it as a good strategic move. Despite their conflicts, the Tipara seven stuck together to send Naomi to the jury. | |||||
9 | 9 | "I Just Feel So Bad" | Days 25-27 | 17 April 2002 | |
Both Craig and Jane caused controversy and ruffled feathers at Aurora. Katie was specifically vocal about her distaste of Jane being on the show, stating that she didn't think she represented a good image for the show and that she was always complaining and lazy. Katie also called Craig a "weasel" and an "asshole", saying that she wouldn't be able to contain her excitement when he was voted off. Sciona discussed with Rob that she had become very fond of Craig and she wasn't ready to vote him out, suggesting that they bring him into their alliance with Katie and Sophie and vote out one of the other Tipara. Rob agreed with Sciona but later told the cameras that he was wary of Craig, as he was a smart guy who knew what he was doing.
Lance won the reward and decided to give each tribe member a slice of pizza.
Sophie beat Katie in the final round and was awarded immunity. After the challenge, Craig continued to campaign against Katie. Joel approached him and asked again if Katie really was in an alliance, with Craig giving his word that she was in a secret alliance. Down at the fishing spot, Sophie approached Rob and offered to go to the final two with him, telling him that she knew Sciona and Katie had already approached him with the same offer. Rob accepted the offer but was wary and later told the cameras that he believed Sophie was playing the game the hardest. Whilst on a walk, Craig and Sciona discussed a possible alliance with the two Tipara members on the outs (Joel and Lance). Craig later approached Rob and informed him that he would indeed be voting for him at tribal council and he would receive a total of three votes. Katie was visibly uneasy at this after Rob approached her and second guessed her loyalty. Ultimately, the Tipara seven stuck together again to send Craig to the jury. | |||||
10 | 10 | "He's a Threat, She's A Threat, We're all Threats!" | Days 28-30 | 28 April 2002 | |
Sophie expressed her disdain for Katie, calling her sneaky and untrustworthy. Katie did some damage control with Rob and tried to make sure they were still in a tight bond. Rob forgave Katie but remained doubtful.
Jane won reward and was the only person to score in the challenge. Joel started to rub the rest of his tribemates the wrong way by being loud and boisterous while they were becoming increasingly fatigued and famished.
Joel won immunity. Despite having no former Kadina members left to vote out, the remaining original Tipara were somewhat laid back considering they would have to vote one of their original members out for the first time since Day 12 in the game. Not much strategy was talked about, but almost every member was concerned it could be their name written down. In the end, Lance was voted out and became the third jury member. | |||||
11 | 11 | "Cockiness Comes to an End" | Days 31-33 | 1 May 2002 | |
Joel won reward. Sophie was emotionally distraught after not being able to see her young children on webcam, who could not yet read. Joel wrongfully suspected that Rob, Jane, Sophie and Katie were in an alliance of four. Sciona expressed her concern for Joel and his mental health, as he was suffering from mood swings, and Rob also mentioned that Katie was visibly becoming more exhausted. After Jane asked Sciona how to cook rice on the campfire, and Joel struggled to rebuild the fire the next morning, Sciona was frustrated at living with a younger generation.
Sciona lasted 3 hours, 40 minutes and won her first immunity. At camp, Joel pleaded for his life to Rob and Sciona. They later informed him of their alliance of four, consisting of themselves, Sophie and Katie, and emphasised that they were the most loyal to each other in their alliance. Sciona and Rob then made a final three alliance with Joel, on the grounds that he throws the final immunity challenge which would put Rob and Sciona in the final two. Joel happily agreed. Going into the vote, Jane was confident that she would remain to play another day, but due to Rob and Sciona securing a new alliance and voting with Joel, he and Jane each received three votes, causing a tie. In the case of a tie, everyone except for Jane and Joel re-voted. The votes were again tied and a Tribal Council countback was called. Jane was eliminated after having received four previous votes in her time in the game to Joel's zero. | |||||
12 | 12 | "Who's the Odd Man Out?" | Days 34-35 | 8 May 2002 | |
The morning after Jane was voted off, Katie and Sophie discussed how they were going to further themselves in the game, and were shocked and surprised at Sciona and Rob flipping on their alliance. Sciona later lied to Sophie, telling her that their alliance of four still stood strong and Joel would be the next to go.
Katie won reward. Sophie and Katie met in secret to discuss their new strategy. They made a plan to confess everything to Joel about their alliance of four and to have him flip to their side, therefore leaving Rob and Sciona the next two to be voted out. Rob found Katie and Sophie in the bushes talking and immediately confronted them.
Katie won immunity. Sciona was nervous after hearing her name brought up to be voted out. Rob solidified his unity with Sciona and promised her that he would not be voting with Katie and Sophie and that Joel would be voting with them. While Joel was strongly considering both sides, he was still unsure heading into Tribal Council. In the end, Joel decided to stick with Rob and Sciona, sending Sophie to the jury. | |||||
13 | 13 | "Finale/Reunion" | Days 36-39 | 15 May 2002 | |
A visibly overwhelmed Katie immediately attacked Rob verbally, calling him a "gutless wonder", "dishonest" and "dumb as dog shit". The next day, Katie apologised to Sciona, Rob and Joel for her comments from the previous night, only to get into another verbal disagreement with Rob.
Katie won reward.
Rob won immunity. After the immunity challenge, Katie approached Joel and asked him to vote for Sciona, while Sciona and Rob would vote for either of them, then in the case of a tie, a countback of votes would happen and Sciona would be eliminated. Katie also approached Sciona and asked why she was being ousted and Joel had replaced her, asking her to vote for Joel. Sciona then informed her that she, Rob and Joel had a final three deal and insisted that she would not tell Katie any further information. Katie immediately walked up the beach where Joel and Rob were sitting and confronted Rob, asking him if he also thought that she didn't deserve the money. Rob called out Katie and asked her why she had just approached Joel with a deal to vote Sciona, which outraged Sciona. While Joel sat quietly, Rob, Sciona and Katie were involved in a huge verbal blow-up causing Katie to walk back to camp alone, refusing to play, sleep, or eat with them and having an emotional breakdown. None of Katie's plans was taken seriously, and she was voted out in a unanimous vote.
Rob won immunity, and there was an immediate Tribal Council directly after the challenge. He chose to take Sciona to the final two, eliminating Joel. Following Tribal Council, Rob and Sciona participated in the traditional Rites of Passage, paying their respects to each of the eliminated castaways. On day thirty-nine, Rob and Sciona faced the Tribal Council Jury and stated their reasons as to why they should win the title of Sole Survivor. Naomi asked both finalists why, coming from Kadina where loyalty was respected more, she should vote for them. Both replied with a similar outlook, saying they had treated the game like a board game (Rob), or a game of chess (Sciona). Craig asked Rob and Sciona to describe each other's gameplay up until Day 39. Katie asked if both finalists thought that greed, dishonour and cowardice were correct words to describe how they had played to get to where they were. Lance asked what was the single most positive thing they had learnt about themselves in their time in the competition. Jane asked what both would do with their prize money. Sophie asked both Rob and Sciona why their opponents thought they should win the game. Joel asked if they had any regrets about their time in the game. The jury voted and the votes were sealed, to be read live at Melbourne's Crown Casino. When the votes were read, it was revealed that the jury voted for Rob as the first ever Sole Survivor in a 5-2 vote. Rob earned the respect and votes of the jury as he was honest and prepared with his answers to the jury and although he broke a few alliances, he could specify why he did. While Sciona was also shown admiration from the jury for her gameplay and survival skills, she was unable to win the favor of as many jurors as Rob. Following the reveal of the results, the 16 castaways were joined by Eddie McGuire, to talk about their time at Whaler's Way. |
Voting history
|
- The first Tribal Council vote resulted in a tie. Per the rules, a second vote was held where the castaways involved in the tie would not vote and the remaining castaways could only vote for those who tied.
- As the revote could not resolve the tied vote, a Tribal Council countback was called. Joel received no votes from earlier Tribal Councils while Jane received four, eliminating her from the game.
- Joel and Sciona were not eligible to vote as the only eligible players they could vote for were each other, canceling both votes out.
- Joel and Jane were not eligible to vote in the second Tribal Council vote.
Controversy and criticisms
The program received a large amount of criticism from fans of the American series, mainly centred on how this series was of lesser quality when compared to the US series.[5]
The casting process was criticised as the cast lacked diversity, being almost completely composed of 16 white middle class Australian people with very few of the 16 being there to "play the game". This lack of drive was especially evident in contestant Lucinda Allen-Rhodes, who not only asked to be voted off, but also was one of the very few people to cast a vote against herself at Tribal Council. In most other editions of Survivor, contestants cannot vote against themselves.
The nature of the camp life of the castaways was also criticised. The tribes were limited on which days they could go search for food. Tipara could go to the coast and fish while Kadina could only go to the windmill and pump water and on the next day, the tribes swapped. Additionally, the producers were also criticised for giving the contestants too many supplies.
The show also resulted in criticism in how the network aired the American series. Nine advertised that Survivor: Marquesas would air after the Australian series. Australian fans were upset when Nine decided not to broadcast Marquesas. It was skipped and instead, the network aired Survivor: Thailand. In late 2018, Marquesas was made legally available to Australian viewers via the 10 All Access streaming platform, which includes all prior seasons of the American edition.
In New Zealand, both Australian Survivor and Survivor: Marquesas aired concurrently.
Ratings
Although the show started off with satisfying ratings, it eventually declined to dismal ratings (possibly due to the popularity of another reality TV show, The Mole, which aired on Channel Seven an hour earlier at 7:30pm for all but four weeks of the Australian Survivor run). This showed especially when Nine decided to air the special, Surviving Survivor, in a late-night timeslot a fortnight after the conclusion of the series.
References
- Knox, David (7 August 2015). "Could Survivor Australia's torch be lit once more?". TV Tonight. Retrieved 20 November 2015.
- Survivor Oz (1987 Articles) (12 August 2012). "Lincoln Howes Interview". Survivor Oz. Retrieved 17 December 2015.
- Innuyasha20 (27 June 2012), Australian Survivor E00 [Auditions], retrieved 22 June 2016
- Bindley, David (20 March 2010). "Survivor: The Complete Challenge Guide (1st ed.)" (PDF). Retrieved 16 December 2010.
- "Survivor: demise of the clone - theage.com.au". www.theage.com.au. Retrieved 12 June 2017.