Batman: Two Faces

• Bruce Wayne: A millionaire and celebrated criminologist; he desperately wants to help his now-insane friend Harvey Dent.
• Alfred: Bruce Wayne's butler and confidant.
• The Joker: A grinning homicidal maniac who carves his victims' faces into smiles. He preys on prostitutes, making him akin to Jack the Ripper.
• Selina Kyle: Owner of a brothel and a masked crimefighter who looks out for the girls under her protection. While Selina Kyle is obviously based on Catwoman, her costume is similar to that of the Black Canary and her fate (crippled by the Joker) reflects that of Barbara Gordon, making her something of a composite character.
• Two-Face: District Attorney Harvey Dent was driven into a state of schizophrenic insanity when half of his face was hideously scarred. Described as a theatrical criminal, he has an obsession with dual natures and the number two. He flips a two-headed coin - one side clean, the other scarred - to make any and all decisions for him.
• Peregrine White: In this story, Peregrine White is the proprietor of the Daily Planet.
• Pamela Isley: The Botanical Institute's chief officer. In this story, Pamela Isley is blonde, while she is normally represented as being red-haired.
• Detective Bullock makes a brief appearance in the investigation of Batman.
• Annie: The Joker's fourth victim, she was a friend and employee of Selina Kyle. She may be named after Annie Chapman, who was Jack the Ripper's second victim.

In 1888, at the Iceberg Lounge in Gotham City, Commissioner James Gordon tells his friend Peregrine White, proprietor of the newspaper the Daily Planet, a strange tale that happened two years ago.

In 1886, Bruce Wayne organizes a gala to exhibit the Twilight Orchid, a rare flower that is exquisitely colored and perfumed during the day but becomes a weed at night. Among those in attendance are Commissioner Gordon and Pamela Isley. During the gala, Two-Face storms in and steals the flower. Bruce attempts to stop the criminal, but he easily bests him and takes Pamela hostage. As Two-Face and his thugs escape, they kill Pamela while Bruce watches helplessly.

Bruce blames himself for Pamela's death, and Alfred tries to comfort him. Bruce reveals that he hopes to create a potion derived from the flower, retrieved from Pamela's dead hands, to cure Two-Face of his dual personality. Finalizing the potion, Bruce tests it on himself. He suddenly develops superhuman strength, agility, and a new sense of courage and purpose. He puts together a bat-like costume and tries to battle crime on Two Face's terms.

While Batman destroys Two Face's criminal empire, Annie, a prostitute who works at Selina Kyle's brothel, accompanies a strange gentleman. The man starts laughing hysterically and kills Annie, who is revealed to be his fourth victim.

Commissioner Gordon asks Bruce Wayne for help; the serial killer who calls himself the Joker is murdering women and mutilating them to look like they are smiling. Bruce dons his cape and cowl and prepares to take down the psychopath. Selina Kyle, donning a crimefighting outfit of her own, attacks him. After revealing his true identity to her, they decide to team up to capture the smiling murderer.

Selina comes upon the Joker attacking a group of Two Face's lackeys. Selina tries to stop him, but she is no match for his superhuman strength. She tries to run but is injured by the Joker, and by the time Batman arrives to help her, her condition has gotten worse. She is paralyzed from the waist down and will never walk again.

Alfred tries to convince Bruce to stop drinking the potion, which has some detrimental effects. Bruce dismisses his advice and consumes a more powerful batch than before. He falls into a deep sleep and wakes up with a head full of revelations. He writes a letter to Gordon and another to Two-Face, summoning them to a meeting that will be most revealing.

Batman reveals to Gordon that he is putting himself at the law's mercy and to Two-Face that he has a potion that may cure him of his duality. He handcuffs himself and then transforms into the Joker, the opposite side of Batman. Just as one side was courageous and doing its best to stop crime, the other was bent on destruction and chaos.

Two-Face, Gordon, and the Joker fight, and just as the Joker is about to kill Two-Face, Batman takes control of Bruce's body and falls to his death. After flipping his two-headed coin one last time, Two-Face, acting on Bruce's last wishes, takes the potion and creates a new identity for himself, a superhuman who dons the cape and cowl of Batman, fighting for the side of justice.

At the end of the story, White refers to another story that occurred in Bavaria five years before this tale, one that is filled with "inhuman tragedy and blasphemous outrages against nature". This story is revealed in the sequel, The Superman Monster, a retelling of Frankenstein featuring the Superman cast.

• Batman: Two Faces #1 (paperback, 68 pages, November 1998)

• List of Elseworlds publications
• Gotham by Gaslight
• JLA: The Island of Dr. Moreau
• Wonder Woman: Amazonia