Christmas to Christmas

Roch Parisien of AllMusic reviewed the album favorably, stating that "The playing is casual, back-porch rootsy. It is first and foremost a collection of good songs, well performed, that just happen to be about Christmas."[1]

1. "Santa, I'm Right Here" (Ron Reynolds) - 4:39
2. "Bethlehem in Birmingham" (Weston Harvey, Scott Lynch) - 3:18
3. "Christmas Rock" (Lewis Anderson) - 2:33
4. "Blame It on the Mistletoe" (Toby Keith) - 3:06
5. "Santa's Gonna Take It All Back" (Keith, Reynolds) - 3:18
6. "The Night Before Christmas" (Sam Hogin, Nelson Larkin, Jim McBride) - 3:42
7. "Hot Rod Sleigh" (Keith) - 3:38
8. "Christmas to Christmas" (Ron Hallard, Alan Rhody) - 3:23
9. "Jesus Gets Jealous of Santa Claus" (Vernon Rust, Keith Urban) - 3:35
10. "Mary, It's Christmas" (Keith, Reynolds) - 3:19
11. "All I Want for Christmas" (Ronnie Rogers) - 3:35
12. "What Made the Baby Cry?" (William Golay) - 4:00

• Michael Black - background vocals
• Duncan Cameron - electric guitar
• Tom Flora - background vocals
• Sonny Garrish - steel guitar
• Felipe Chele Gonzalez - harmonica
• Owen Hale - drums
• Clayton Ivey - keyboards
• Toby Keith - lead vocals
• B. James Lowry - acoustic guitar
• Gary Lunn - bass guitar
• Ron "Snake" Reynolds - electric guitar, percussion
• Russell Terrell - background vocals
• Dennis Wilson - background vocals
• Reggie Young - electric guitar