David S. Pumpkins

Pumpkins first appeared in the fourth episode of SNL's 42nd season in a skit later uploaded to YouTube with the title "Haunted Elevator (ft. David S. Pumpkins)".[8] In it, a couple (played by Beck Bennett and Kate McKinnon) enters an attraction named 100 Floors of Frights in which a "Hellevator" operator (Kenan Thompson) opens elevator doors to reveal various characters that scare the couple with traditionally scary scenes. On the 49th floor, the doors open to reveal two dancing skeletons alongside David S. Pumpkins wearing a black and orange pumpkin-themed suit.[9] Instead of being scared, the couple is mystified and asks what Pumpkins is meant to represent and why he is part of the ride. In response, Pumpkins says that he is "his own thing" and that the skeletons (Moynihan and Day) standing next to him on most floors (73 out of 100) of the elevator are "part of it".[10][11] Pumpkins insists that he is there to "scare the hell out of you", but manages only to confuse the passengers.[9] The elevator visits several other floors, at some of which Pumpkins continues to appear, until the ride stops at the final level. The door opens on just the skeletons, whereupon Pumpkins appears right behind the guests and shout-asks "Any questions?", successfully giving them a fright.[9]

Two episodes later, SNL host Dave Chappelle made a reference to David S. Pumpkins in a sketch titled "Jheri's Place". After the "sketch gone wrong", Chappelle jokingly says that he thought his failed character "was going to be the next David S. Pumpkins".[12][13]

In the season's finale hosted by Dwayne "the Rock" Johnson, Pumpkins reappears in a prerecorded music video called "Rap Song", using the name David S. Pimpkins and wearing a furry hat and jacket.[14] Alongside other fictional featured artists,[15] Pimpkins pesters the character played by Kenan Thompson,[16][17] in a pastiche of "overstuffed all-star rap videos" like DJ Khaled's "I'm the One".[18] David S. Pumpkins' parts of the segment are solo, he never appears with any of the other characters in the sketch.

In 2022, Hanks and Moynihan returned in the season 48 episode hosted by Jack Harlow. Viewers began speculating on social media that there was going to be a David S. Pumpkins sketch when Hanks cameoed in an earlier sketch and Moynihan reprised his role as Drunk Uncle on Weekend Update. These suspicions were confirmed when Hanks and Moynihan reprised their roles alongside Day (still a regular cast member) as Pumpkins and the skeletons in one of the final sketches of the night. As in the original sketch, the three repeatedly show up in a jump scare–themed attraction hosted by Thompson, now set in a prison populated by famous horror movie characters. Thompson's operator explains that the ride spent most of its budget on characters like Freddy Krueger and Pennywise the Clown, so Pumpkins was needed to fill the rest of the attraction. The patrons in this sketch are a group of friends played by Harlow, Ego Nwodim, and Andrew Dismukes. Unlike in the first sketch, Nwodim's character expresses a neutral opinion of Pumpkins, while Harlow outright enjoys him—only Dismukes expresses bewilderment and frustration, particularly at the revelation that Pumpkins is apparently from Ibiza. Once again, Pumpkins delivers on his promise to "scare [the group] stupid" by surprising them at the end of the sketch.[19]

On September 28, 2017, NBC announced that Pumpkins would star in a 30-minute animated special to be produced by Bento Box Animation.[20] Hanks, Day and Moynihan reprised their roles, with Seidell and Peter Dinklage joining the cast.[21] Two weeks prior to the announcement, Hanks posted a picture of the special's script, titled "The David S. Pumpkins Song", on social media.[22][23][24]

The David S. Pumpkins Halloween Special aired October 28, 2017.[25] It starts with a live-action address from Hanks dressed as Pumpkins. In the story, Kevin (Dinklage) is embarrassed to take his younger sister trick-or-treating. After choosing the "magic pumpkin" at a pumpkin patch, David S. Pumpkins and the skeletons take them on an adventure and sing-along. The siblings ride in Pumpkins' "pumpkinmobile" (a strawberry car) while the mysterious villain named the Raincoat Man is stealing all the Halloween candy. Pumpkins and the skeletons rescue the candy from what turns out to be pre-teens who had bullied Kevin. Pumpkins uses magic to deliver the candy around the neighborhood inside of pumpkins.[26][27]