Higher education bubble in the United States

The higher education bubble in the United States is the possibility that excessive investment in higher education could have negative repercussions in the broader economy. Although college tuition payments are rising, the supply of college graduates in many fields of study is exceeding the demand for their skills, which aggravates graduate unemployment and underemployment while increasing the burden of student loan defaults on financial institutions and taxpayers.[1][2][3] Moreover, the higher education bubble might be even more serious than load of student debts.[4] Without safeguards in place for funding and loans, the government risks creating a moral hazard in which schools charge students expensive tuition fees without offering them marketable skills in return.[5][6] The claim has generally been used to justify cuts to public higher education spending, tax cuts, or a shift of government spending towards law enforcement and national security.[7][8][9][10] There is a further concern that having an excess supply of college graduates exacerbates political instability,[11][12][13] historically linked to having a bulge in the number of young degree holders.[14][15][16]

This article is part of a series on
Education in the
United States
Summary
Issues
Levels of education
icon Education portal
flag United States portal

Some economists reject the notion of a higher education bubble, noting that the returns on higher education vastly outweigh the cost,[17][18][19][20] while others believe that the number of institutions of higher education in the United States will fall in the 2020s and beyond, citing reasons of demographic decline, poor outcomes, economic problems, and changing public interests and attitudes.[21][22][23][24][25] According to the U.S. Department of Education, by the late 2010s, people with technical or vocational trainings are slightly more likely to be employed than those with a bachelor's degree and significantly more likely to be employed in their fields of specialty. The United States currently suffers from a shortage of skilled tradespeople.[26] The Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis noted in 2019 that investment in higher education has reached a point of diminishing marginal returns.[27] Undergraduate and graduate enrollments have both been in decline,[28][29] while trade schools continue to attract growing numbers of students.[30][31] White men are a major group opting for alternatives to higher education.[22][32] Many faculty members are leaving academia,[33] especially those from the humanities.[34] At the same time, university graduates are likely to regret having studied the humanities and liberal arts.[35][36] While academics maintain that certain subjects are worth studying for their own sake, students are more concerned with increasing their earning potential.[37][38] So far this century, numerous institutions of higher learning have permanently closed,[39] especially community colleges,[40] and for-profit institutions.[41][42]

It is possible that the bubble will not burst, but rather deflate.[41]

Discussion
Tuition cost of college
Tuition cost of college

Thanks to the GI Bill and the population boom after World War II, demand for higher education grew significantly during the late twentieth century, making it one of the major sectors of growth in the economy of the United States.[41][42] Historically, high schools separated students on career tracks, but all this changed in the late 1980s and early 1990s, when the mission of high schools became preparing students for college.[43] In 1987, U.S. Secretary of Education William Bennett suggested that the availability of loans may be fueling an increase in tuition prices and an education bubble.[44] This "Bennett hypothesis" claims that readily available loans allow schools to increase tuition without regard to demand elasticity. College rankings are partially driven by spending levels,[45] and higher tuition is also correlated with increased public perceptions of prestige.[46] From the 1980s to the 2010s, demand has increased despite the business cycle as institutions improved facilities and provided more resources to students.[47] In the aftermath of the Great Recession of 2007-2009, Americans flocked back to school in order to adapt to the new economy.[42] A 2011 study from the Labor Department found that a bachelor's degree "represents a significant advantage in the job market."[48] In 2011, The Chronicle of Higher Education ran an article saying that the future is bright for college graduates.[49] The data also suggests that, notwithstanding a slight increase in 2008–09, student loan default rates have declined between the mid-1980s and 1990s and early 2010s.[50][51] The management consulting firm McKinsey & Company projected in 2011 that a shortage of college-educated workers and a surplus of workers without college degrees, which would cause the wage premium to increase and cause differences in unemployment rates to become even more dramatic.[52]

As of the early 2010s, however, whether or not the "higher-education bubble" existed became a topic of debate among economists. Data shows that the wage premium, the difference in incomes between those with a four-year college degree and those with only a high school diploma, has increased dramatically since the 1970s, but so has the 'debt load' incurred by students due to the tuition inflation.[17][18][19] By 2019, the total college debt exceeded US$1.5 trillion, and two out of three college graduates were saddled with debt.[24] Glenn Reynolds argued in his book, The Higher Education Bubble (2012), that higher education as a "product grows more and more elaborate—and more expensive—but the expense is offset by cheap credit provided by sellers who are eager to encourage buyers to buy."[53] Reynolds called university degrees a marker of socioeconomic status.[54] Economists Michael Spence and Joe Stiglitz suggest that much of the worth of a university degree lies not in the skills acquired, but rather market signaling.[55] Because a university degree still had considerable value despite its cost, higher education might be an example of a Veblen good, albeit a subtle rather than a conspicuous one.[56][57][58] Research from the Center for Household Financial Stability of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis presented in 2018 predicts a declining but still positive income premium for completing college but a declining wealth premium, which is almost indistinguishable from zero for the most recent cohort.[59] Those with college degrees are much less likely than those without to be unemployed, even though they are more expensive to employ (they earn higher wages).[60] By the 2010s, as institutions of higher education came under heightened skepticism due to high costs and disappointing results. People became increasingly concerned about debts and deficits, forcing institutions to prove their worth by clarifying how much money from which industry and company funded research, and how much it would cost to attend.[61] By the 2020s, graduating from a prestigious university no longer guarantees gainful employment immediately after graduation.[62] According to Gallup, public confidence in higher education has declined "sharply" between 2015 and 2023; even those with bachelor's or advanced degrees were less approving than before.[25]

Healthcare and STEM, especially computer science, grew in popularity while the liberal arts and social studies, especially history, have declined due to market forces.[63][38]

An alternative proposal suggests that there is no general bubble in higher education because, on average, higher education really does boost income and employment by more than enough to make it a good investment, but that degrees in some specific fields may be overvalued because they do little to boost income or improve job prospects, and degrees in other fields may in fact be undervalued because students do not appreciate the extent to which these degrees could benefit their employment prospects and future income. Proponents of this hypothesis have noted that schools charge equal prices for tuition regardless of what students study, but the interest rate on federal student loans is not adjusted according to risk, and there is evidence that undergraduate students in their first three years of college are not very good at predicting future wages by major.[17] Indeed, student interest has shifted away from low-paying programs towards those of greater value in the job market.[37][5] (See chart above.) Among graduates of the early 2020s, the most regretted majors are journalism, sociology, liberal arts/general studies, communications, and education; the least regretted majors are computer science and information technology, criminology, engineering, nursing, and health.[35] Music and the visual arts are the most likely to offer a negative return on investment.[38] At the same time, graduates with the highest expected income studied chemical engineering, aerospace engineering, chemistry, economics, and the life sciences.[36] Prospective employers and state governments have gotten pickier in the collegiate programs they are willing to finance.[37] As of 2023, seven states have passed legislation requiring the disclosure of data on the worth of a university, such as students' loan payment and post-graduation employment.[6] Another reason for the decline of interest in the humanities and liberal arts is the fact that many prospective students avoid them for fear of loss of parental support,[64] and the perceived intolerance towards conservatives on college campuses, which tend to be dominated by left-wing faculty members,[64] though the details are not as simple as they first appear.[65] On the other hand, in the life sciences, the number of students or researchers interested in a postdoctoral fellowship has plummeted thanks to a boom in the biotechnology industry, which has an insatiable appetite for talents and is willing to pay much higher than universities.[66][67] In physics and engineering, which are traditionally male-dominated fields, enrollments have also fallen since 2020, as white men lose their interest in higher education.[32]

U.S. population pyramid in 2022. The number of Americans of college age will drop by the late 2020s,[68] at a faster rate by the late 2030s.[69]

Due to popular demand, the cost of higher education has grown at a rate faster than inflation between the late 20th and early 21st centuries.[70] From the 1990s to the 2010s, tuition and fees rose 440%, as federal loans for students became more generous,[54] and student debt increased as costs went up.[71] As of 2012, 29% of student debtors never graduated, and those who did could take decades to pay back the money they owed.[54] The 2010s were a turbulent period for higher education in the United States, as small private colleges from across the country face deep financial trouble due to higher tuition discounts in order to attract students at a time of expensive higher education costs, tougher regulation, and the fact that the college-aged population in many regions has declined,[72] even if the percentage of young people attending colleges and universities did not change significantly.[41] By the early 2020s, enrollments are declining at a growing rate as the number of high-school graduates continues to fall.[69] Pew Trusts projected in 2022 that most U.S. states will see a decline in grade-school enrollments during the 2020s, which would help curb of the cost of higher education going forward.[73] A 2019 analysis by Moody's Investor Services estimated that about 20% of all small private liberal arts colleges in the United States were in serious financial trouble.[23] Between the early 2000s and early 2020s, hundreds of institutions permanently closed their doors.[39] In fact, they were closing at an accelerating rate, and for-profit institutions were the hardest hit, as they were targeted by stricter regulations from the Obama administration.[41][42] Public universities had to downsize or to merge.[68] Rural ones have closed majors across the board, from the humanities to the sciences.[74] More than half of the colleges and universities that remained saw substantial reductions in the number of students attending.[41] Such institutions have adapted to the new reality by dropping programs with low student interest, including many in the liberal arts and the humanities, like gender studies and critical race theory,[63] creating majors for emerging fields, such as artificial intelligence,[72] and professional programs, like law enforcement,[39] investing in online learning programs,[72] and addressing untapped demands, such as mid-career training or continuing education.[68] By the early 2020s, the rate of growth of tuition fees has dropped, and some schools are even freezing to cutting theirs.[68] If affordable or free online learning continues to grow, then non-elite institutions would struggle to justify their physical infrastructure.[4] On the other hand, prestigious universities continue to see growth in the number of applicants and as such are in no danger of closing.[75] This is due partly to students sending their applications to more schools for a chance of getting admitted[76] and because (elite) institutions have not significantly expanded their capacities.[77]

The arrival of COVID-19 in the United States in 2020 merely accelerated the process.[78] The novel coronavirus not only wrought havoc on the nation but also caused a severe economic downturn. Consequently, families chose to either delay or avoid sending their children to institutions of higher education altogether.[79] Undergraduate enrollments dropped even after the return of in-person classes.[80] Worse still for colleges and universities, they have become dependent on foreign students for revenue because they pay full tuition fees and the international restrictions imposed to alleviate the spread of the pandemic mean that this stream of revenue will shrink substantially.[78][81] Several permanently closed their doors by the end of the 2019–20 academic year.[82] Numerous institutions, including elite ones, have suspended graduate programs in the humanities and liberal arts due to low student interest and dim employment prospects.[83][12] Various polls indicate that growing numbers of Americans have become skeptical of the value of higher education relative to the cost[84][85] and would like to see K-12 education being less focused on college preparation.[86] Having witnessed the Millennials accumulating large amounts of student debts, members of Generation Z tend to be more skeptical of the value of higher education[87] and more open to alternative educational routes and career options.[88] Young men, especially whites, are increasingly looking elsewhere due to the hostility of identity politics on campus towards them, viewing them as a "privileged" group.[22] Meanwhile, the number of women's colleges continues to fall, following a decades-long trend.[89] But community colleges have fared the worst of all, losing 37% of enrollments between 2010 and 2023. Prospective students have been shunning them in large numbers due to the low quality of education and student services.[40]

Some employers are now hiring fresh graduates from high school,[29] offering them generous bonuses, high wages, and apprenticeship programs in order to offset the ongoing labor shortage.[80] Trade schools and apprenticeship programs have seen significant increases in enrollment[30][31][90] while about a third of college graduates, including 38% of recent graduates, work in jobs that do not require a university degree, according to data from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.[91] Although the previous Democratic administrations of Bill Clinton and Barack Obama had focused on higher education and high-skilled jobs, the Joe Biden government has been emphasizing blue-collar jobs that do not require a college degree, as part of Biden's infrastructure initiative and efforts to boost domestic manufacturing.[92] Before Biden, President Donald Trump signed an executive order to expand federal funding for apprenticeship programs with bipartisan support in 2017.[90] In 2022, President Biden announced an initiative aimed at expanding apprenticeship and work-based training programs in K-12 public schools in order to create a competitive and skilled workforce.[93] On the other hand, Biden's student loan relief plan worth $400 billion was struck down by the Supreme Court of the United States.[94]

In 2019, a report from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis using data from the 2016 Survey of Consumer Finances demonstrated that after controlling for race and age cohort, families with heads of household with post-secondary education who were born before 1980 have benefited from wealth and income premiums, while for families with heads of household with post-secondary education but born after 1980 the wealth premium has weakened to point of statistical insignificance (in part because of the rising cost of college). Moreover, although the income premium remains positive, it has declined to historic lows (with more pronounced downward trajectories with heads of household with postgraduate degrees).[27]

In the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, colleges and universities saw an increase in the number of faculty members leaving academia, citing low pay, stressful work environments, heavy workloads, lack of administrative support, and occupational burnout.[33] Moreover, lecturers and professors in the humanities face a highly precarious job market.[34] Graduates who majored in the humanities and the liberal arts in the 2010s were most likely to regret having done so and had lower expected incomes than their counterparts in STEM.[95]

Between the early 2000s and the late 2010s, the number of students from emerging economies going abroad for higher education increased,[96] and the United States was the most popular destination for international students, many of whom were from mainland China.[97][98] In fact, the United States was the single most popular destination for Chinese students; among children of the ruling class ("princelings"), attending elite institutions was commonplace and seen as a status symbol.[98] However, deteriorating Sino-American relations and the COVID-19 pandemic reduced the number of Chinese students enrolling in many U.S. colleges and universities.[96][99] Dependency on foreign students threatens the future of many American schools, which have hitherto been assuming that the number of international applicants would keep growing.[100] In reality, international enrollments have been falling since 2015.[68]

Falling demand for higher education in the United States will force this industry to become more innovative, which is something it has not been traditionally good at. Moreover, as the birth rates of teenagers and the lower classes continues to fall while women with higher incomes and education are having more children, students in the future will be less likely to have to rely on loans.[68]

Controversy
College Degree Returns by Average 2011 Annual Out-of-Pocket Costs, from B. Caplan's The Case Against Education
First-year U.S. college degree returns for select majors, by type of student.
Study comparing college revenue per student by tuition and state funding in 2008 dollars[101]

The view that higher education is a bubble is debated. Some economists do not think that returns to a college education are falling but instead believe that the benefits far outweigh the costs.[17][18][19][102] Yet, the returns for marginal students or students in certain majors, especially at costly private universities, may not justify the investment.[103] It has been suggested that the returns to education should be compared to the returns to other forms of investment such as the stock market, bonds, real estate, and private equity. A higher return would suggest underinvestment in higher education, but lower returns would suggest a bubble.[104] Studies have typically found a causal relationship between growth and education, although the quality and type of education matters, and not just the number of years of schooling.[105][106][107][108]

In a financial bubble, assets like houses are sometimes purchased with a view to reselling at a higher price, and this can produce rapidly escalating prices as people speculate on future prices. An end to the spiral can provoke abrupt selling of the assets, resulting in an abrupt collapse in price – the bursting of the bubble. Because the asset acquired through college attendance – a higher education – cannot be sold but only rented through wages, there is no similar mechanism that would cause an abrupt collapse in the value of existing degrees. For this reason, this analogy could be misleading. However, one rebuttal to the claims that a bubble analogy is misleading is the observation that the 'bursting' of the bubble are the negative effects on students who incur student debt, for example, as the American Association of State Colleges and Universities reports that "Students are deeper in debt today than ever before.... The trend of heavy debt burdens threatens to limit access to higher education, particularly for low-income and first-generation students, who tend to carry the heaviest debt burden. Federal student aid policy has steadily put resources into student loan programs rather than need-based grants, a trend that straps future generations with high debt burdens. Even students who receive federal grant aid are finding it more difficult to pay for college."[109]

However, the data actually show that notwithstanding a slight increase in 2008–2009, student loan default rates have declined since the mid-1980s and 1990s.[50][51] During both periods of growth and recession, those with college degrees are much less likely than those without to be unemployed, even though they earn higher wages.[60]

Ohio University economist Richard Vedder has written in The Wall Street Journal that:

A key measure of the benefits of a degree is the college graduate's earning potential – and on this score, their advantage over high-school graduates is deteriorating. Since 2006, the gap between what the median college graduate earned compared with the median high-school graduate has narrowed by $1,387 for men over 25 working full time, a 5% fall. Women in the same category have fared worse, losing 7% of their income advantage ($1,496). A college degree's declining value is even more pronounced for younger Americans. According to data collected by the College Board, for those in the 25–34 age range, the differential between college graduate and high school graduate earnings fell 11% for men, to $18,303 from $20,623. The decline for women was an extraordinary 19.7%, to $14,868 from $18,525. Meanwhile, the cost of college has increased 16.5% in 2012 dollars since 2006, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics' higher education tuition-fee index.[110]

Alternatives to bubble hypothesis

A different explanation for rising tuition is the reduction of state and federal appropriations to colleges, making them more reliant on student tuition. Thus, it is not a bubble but a form of shifting costs away from state and federal funding over to students.[111] This has mostly applied to public universities which in 2011 for the first time have taken in more in tuition than in state funding[111] and had the greatest increases in tuition.[101] Implied from this shift away from public funding to tuition is privatization, although The New York Times reported that such claims are exaggerated.[111]

A second hypothesis claims that as a result of federal law that severely restricts the ability of students to discharge their federally guaranteed student loans in bankruptcy, lenders and colleges know that students are on the hook for any amount that they borrow, including late fees and interest (which can be capitalized and increase the principal loan amount), thus removing the incentive to only provide students loans that the students can be reasonably expected to repay.[112][113] As evidence for this hypothesis, it has been suggested that returning bankruptcy protections (and other standard consumer protections) to student loans would cause lenders to be more cautious, thereby causing a sharp decline in the availability of student loans, which, in turn, would decrease the influx of dollars to colleges and universities, who, in turn, would have to sharply decrease tuition to match the lower availability of funds.[114]

Economic and social commentator Gary North has remarked at LewRockwell.com, "To speak of college as a bubble is silly. A bubble does not pop until months or years after the funding ceases. There is no indication that the funding for college education will cease."[115]

Azar Nafisi, Johns Hopkins University professor and bestselling author of Reading Lolita in Tehran, has stated on the PBS NewsHour that a purely economic analysis of a higher education bubble is incomplete:

Universities become sort of like canaries in the mine for a culture. They become the sort of standard of where culture is going. The dynamism, the originality of these entrepreneurial experiences, the fact that society allows people to be original, to take risks, all of it comes from a passionate love of knowledge. And universities represent all the different areas and fields within a society. And the students and faculty come from all these fields. This is a community that represents the best that a society has to offer. And there was a mention of our universities being the best in the world.[116]

See also

References
  1. Archibald, Robert B.; Feldman, David (David H.) (2006). "State Higher Education Spending and the Tax Revolt" (PDF). The Journal of Higher Education. 77 (4): 618–644. doi:10.1353/jhe.2006.0029. ISSN 1538-4640. S2CID 154906564.
  2. Barshay, Jill (August 4, 2014). "Reflections on the underemployment of college graduates". Hechniger Report. Teachers College at Columbia University. Retrieved March 30, 2015.
  3. Coates, Ken; Morrison, Bill (2016), Dream Factories: Why Universities Won't Solve the Youth Jobs Crisis, Toronto: Dundurn Press, p. 232, ISBN 978-1459733770
  4. Epperson, Sharon (September 11, 2014). "A higher-ed bubble even bigger than student loans". CNBC. Retrieved April 11, 2023.
  5. "The university lottery". The Economist. April 5, 2023. Archived from the original on April 5, 2023. Retrieved April 11, 2023.
  6. Burke, Lilah (January 21, 2023). "What's a college degree worth? States start to demand colleges share the data". Hechinger Report. Retrieved April 11, 2023.
  7. "U.S. Republican budget cuts social spending, boosts military". Reuters. March 17, 2015. Retrieved May 9, 2016.
  8. "Should the U.S. cut spending on education (yes) or the military (no)?". www.debate.org. Retrieved May 9, 2016.
  9. "Gov. Sam Brownback cuts higher education as Kansas tax receipts fall $53 million short". kansascity. Retrieved May 9, 2016.
  10. "Changing Priorities: State Criminal Justice Reforms and Investments in Education | Center on Budget and Policy Priorities". www.cbpp.org. Retrieved May 9, 2016.
  11. Turchin, Peter (December 27, 2016). "Social Instability Lies Ahead, Researcher Says". UConn Today. Retrieved September 16, 2022.
  12. Smith, Noah (January 4, 2021). "America Is Pumping Out Too Many Ph.D.s". Bloomberg. Archived from the original on January 13, 2021. Retrieved September 23, 2021.
  13. Packer, George (June 8, 2021). "How America Fractured Into Four Parts". The Atlantic. Archived from the original on June 8, 2021. Retrieved June 10, 2021.
  14. Hobsbawn, Eric (1996). "Chapter Ten: Social Revolution 1945-1990". The Age of Extremes: The Short Twentieth Century 1914-1991. Abacus. ISBN 9780349106717.
  15. Gaddis, John Lewis (2005). "IV: The Emergence of Autonomy". The Cold War: A New History. Penguin Books. ISBN 978-0143038276.
  16. Suri, Jeremi (February 2009). "The Rise and Fall of an International Counterculture, 1960-1975". American Historical Review. 114 (1): 45–68. doi:10.1086/ahr.114.1.45. JSTOR 30223643.
  17. Michael Simkovic, Risk-Based Student Loans (2012)
  18. Thomas Lemieux, Postsecondary Education And Increasing Wage Inequality, 96 AM. ECON. REVIEW 195 (2006)
  19. Sandy Baum and Michael McPherson, Job-Skill Trends and the College-Wage Premium, Chronicle of Higher Education, Sept. 21, 2010
  20. Singletary, Michelle (January 11, 2020). "Is college still worth it? Read this study". The Washington Post. Retrieved January 12, 2020.
  21. "Expert predicts 25% of colleges will "fail" in the next 20 years". CBS News. August 31, 2019. Retrieved August 28, 2019.
  22. Belkin, Douglas (September 6, 2021). "A Generation of American Men Give Up on College: 'I Just Feel Lost'". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved September 11, 2021.
  23. Cohn, Scott (December 3, 2019). "The other college debt crisis: Schools are going broke". Education. CNBC. Retrieved January 29, 2020.
  24. Solman, Paul (March 28, 2019). "Anxious about debt, Generation Z makes college choice a financial one". PBS Newshour. Retrieved May 12, 2019.
  25. Brenan, Megan (July 11, 2023). "Americans' Confidence in Higher Education Down Sharply". Gallup. Retrieved July 12, 2023.
  26. Krupnick, Matt (August 29, 2017). "After decades of pushing bachelor's degrees, U.S. needs more tradespeople". PBS Newshour. Retrieved May 17, 2019.
  27. Emmons, William R.; Kent, Ana H.; Ricketts, Lowell R. (2019). "Is College Still Worth It? The New Calculus of Falling Returns" (PDF). Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. 101 (4): 297–329. doi:10.20955/r.101.297-329. S2CID 211431474.
  28. Nadworny, Elissa (May 25, 2018). "Why Is Undergraduate College Enrollment Declining?". Education. NPR. Retrieved November 28, 2019.
  29. Moody, Josh (May 26, 2022). "A 5th Straight Semester of Enrollment Declines". Inside Higher Education. Archived from the original on August 17, 2022. Retrieved August 21, 2022.
  30. Steinberg, Anya; Nadworny, Elissa (March 28, 2022). "Community college enrollment is down, but skilled-trades programs are booming". NPR. Retrieved May 2, 2023.
  31. Sanchez, Olivia (April 17, 2023). "While some students skip college, trade programs are booming". Associated Press. Retrieved April 17, 2023.
  32. Boatman, Liz (June 15, 2023). "As Undergrad Physics Enrollment Stumbles, Departments Look Inward". APS News. Retrieved July 26, 2023.
  33. Flaherty, Colleen (July 5, 2022). "Calling It Quits". Inside Higher Education. Archived from the original on July 5, 2022. Retrieved August 21, 2022.
  34. Hamilton-Honey, Emily (August 10, 2022). "The Humanities' Scholarly Infrastructure Isn't in Disarray -- It's Disappearing". Inside Higher Education. Archived from the original on August 21, 2022. Retrieved August 21, 2022.
  35. Dickler, Jessica (November 12, 2022). "The top 10 most-regretted college majors — and the degrees graduates wish they had pursued instead". CNBC. Retrieved February 5, 2023.
  36. Van Dam, Andrew (September 2, 2022). "The most-regretted (and lowest-paying) college majors". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on September 16, 2022. Retrieved February 5, 2023.
  37. Marcus, Jon (March 7, 2013). "In era of high costs, humanities come under attack". Hechinger Report. Retrieved April 20, 2023.
  38. "Was your degree really worth it?". The Economist. April 3, 2023. Archived from the original on April 8, 2023. Retrieved April 14, 2023.
  39. Barshay, Jill (November 21, 2022). "PROOF POINTS: 861 colleges and 9,499 campuses have closed down since 2004". Hechinger Report. Retrieved January 16, 2023.
  40. Marcus, Jon (April 2, 2023). "Community colleges are reeling. 'The reckoning is here.'". Associated Press. Retrieved April 3, 2023.
  41. Thompson, Derek (July 26, 2017). "This Is the Way the College 'Bubble' Ends". The Atlantic. Archived from the original on July 26, 2017. Retrieved May 5, 2023.
  42. Belkin, Douglas (July 19, 2017). "More Colleges Drop Out". The Wall Street Journal. Archived from the original on July 20, 2017. Retrieved May 5, 2023.
  43. "Should more kids skip college for workforce training?". PBS Newshour. January 26, 2016. Retrieved October 2, 2019.
  44. Bennett, William J. (February 18, 1987). "Our Greedy Colleges". The New York Times.
  45. "How U.S. News Calculates the College Rankings". U.S. News & World Report. 2010. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  46. "Estimating the Payoff to Attending a More Selective College: An Application of Selection on Observables and Unobservables" (PDF). Dale, S. B. and Krueger, A. B., NBER. 1999. Archived from the original (PDF) on July 16, 2011. Retrieved May 3, 2011. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  47. Ley, Katharina; Keppo, Jussi (2011). "The Credits that Count: How Credit Growth and Financial Aid Affect College Tuition and Fees". Ley, K. and Keppo, J., SSRN. doi:10.2139/ssrn.1766549. S2CID 154146898. SSRN 1766549. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  48. Eichler, Alexander (August 30, 2011). "Hiring Is Up For The Class Of 2011, But Previous Classes Still Struggle". Huffington Post.
  49. Johnson, Lacey (November 17, 2011). "Job Outlook for College Graduates Is Slowly Improving". The Chronicle of Higher Education.
  50. Pope, Justin (September 12, 2011). "Student loan default rates jump". Phys.org. Science X network.
  51. Kirkham, Chris (September 12, 2011). "Led By For-Profit Colleges, Student Loan Defaults At Highest Level In A Decade". Huffington Post.
  52. McKinsey Global Institute, An Economy that Works: Job Creation and America's Future, June 2011
  53. Reynolds, Glenn H. (2012). The higher education bubble. New York: Encounter Books. p. 1. ISBN 978-1594036651.
  54. Will, George F. (June 8, 2012). "Subprime college educations". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on May 7, 2023. Retrieved May 7, 2023.
  55. Foroohar, Rana (April 26, 2020). "Coronavirus bursts the US college education bubble". Financial Times. Archived from the original on April 26, 2020. Retrieved May 5, 2023.
  56. Campos, Paul (January 8, 2015). "How a Louis Vuitton bag can explain the higher education bubble". The Week. Archived from the original on May 6, 2023. Retrieved May 5, 2023.
  57. "Modern American elites have come to favour inconspicuous consumption". The Economist. August 5, 2017. Archived from the original on May 9, 2019. Retrieved September 11, 2021. Rather than filling garages with flashy cars, the data show, today's rich devote their budgets to less visible but more valuable ends. Chief among them is education for their children: the top 10% now allocate almost four times as much of their spending to school and university as they did in 1996, whereas for other groups the figure has hardly budged.
  58. Currid-Halkett, Elizabeth (June 14, 2017). "The new, subtle ways the rich signal their wealth". BBC Future. Retrieved September 11, 2021. Inconspicuous consumption – whether breastfeeding or education – is a means to a better quality of life and improved social mobility for one's own children, whereas conspicuous consumption is merely an end in itself – simply ostentation. For today's aspirational class, inconspicuous consumption choices secure and preserve social status, even if they do not necessarily display it.
  59. William R. Emmons; Ana H. Kent; Lowell R. Ricketts (January 7, 2019). "Is College Still Worth It? The New Calculus of Falling Returns" (PDF).
  60. "Education pays..." Bureau of Labor Statistics. U.S. Department of Labor. May 4, 2011. Archived from the original on December 20, 2011. Retrieved February 22, 2023.
  61. Marcus, Jon (January 22, 2016). "Facing skepticism, colleges set out to prove their value". PBS Newshour. Retrieved October 2, 2019.
  62. Jones, Laura (June 9, 2021). "The fight to find work: 'I've applied for 200 jobs'". BBC. Retrieved June 29, 2023.
  63. Dutt-Ballerstadt, Reshmi (March 1, 2019). "Academic Prioritization or Killing the Liberal Arts?". Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved March 1, 2021.
  64. Berlatsky, Noah (October 8, 2018). "Are millennials to blame for the decline in English majors?". NBC. Retrieved April 20, 2023.
  65. Jaschik, Scott (February 27, 2017). "Professors and Politics: What the Research Says". Inside Higher Education. Archived from the original on November 21, 2021. Retrieved April 20, 2023.
  66. Langin, Katie (June 13, 2022). "As professors struggle to recruit postdocs, calls for structural change in academia intensify". Science. Retrieved May 19, 2023.
  67. Wosen, Jonathan (November 10, 2022). "'The tipping point is coming': Unprecedented exodus of young life scientists is shaking up academia". Stat News. Archived from the original on November 14, 2022. Retrieved May 19, 2023.
  68. Marcus, Jon (May 22, 2021). "Colleges face reckoning as plummeting birthrate worsens enrollment declines". Hechinger Report. Retrieved May 26, 2023.
  69. Marcus, Jon (April 18, 2023). "In Japan, plummeting university enrollment forecasts what's ahead for the U.S." Hechinger Report. Retrieved July 12, 2023.
  70. Turchin, Peter (August 16, 2012). "Cliodynamics: can science decode the laws of history?". The Conversation. Retrieved September 22, 2021.
  71. Mitchell, Josh (May 31, 2012). "Student Debt Rises by 8% as College Tuitions Climb". The Wall Street Journal. Archived from the original on May 7, 2023. Retrieved May 7, 2023.
  72. "A look at trends in college and university consolidation since 2016". Education Dive. November 1, 2019. Retrieved November 28, 2019.
  73. Chapman, Jeff (December 5, 2022). "The Long-Term Decline in Fertility—and What It Means for State Budgets". Pew Trusts. Retrieved May 6, 2023.
  74. Marcus, Jon (December 16, 2022). "Rural universities, already few and far between, are being stripped of majors". Hechinger Report. Retrieved May 26, 2023.
  75. Dickler, Jessica (February 22, 2023). "More colleges set to close even as top schools experience application boom". CNBC. Retrieved April 1, 2023.
  76. Kirshner, Jodie Adams (January 8, 2023). "Why Some Students Are Skipping College". The Atlantic. Archived from the original on January 8, 2023. Retrieved May 26, 2023.
  77. Petrilli, Michael J.; Enamorado, Pedro (March 24, 2020). "Yes, It Really Is Harder to Get into Highly Selective Colleges Today". Education Next. Archived from the original on October 24, 2020. Retrieved February 19, 2021.
  78. "Could a fifth of America's colleges really face the chop?". United States. The Economist. May 28, 2020. Retrieved July 13, 2020.
  79. Dickler, Jessica (March 14, 2021). "Fewer kids are going to college because they say it costs too much". CNBC. Retrieved September 19, 2021.
  80. Binkley, Collin (March 9, 2023). "Jaded with education, more Americans are skipping college". Associated Press. Retrieved March 9, 2023.
  81. Watney, Caleb (July 19, 2020). "America's Innovation Engine Is Slowing". The Atlantic. Archived from the original on July 23, 2020. Retrieved February 1, 2023.
  82. Aspegren, Elinor (January 28, 2021). "These colleges survived World Wars, the Spanish flu and more. They couldn't withstand COVID-19 pandemic". USA Today. Retrieved March 1, 2021.
  83. Korn, Melissa (December 29, 2020). "Pandemic Leads Dozens of Universities to Pause Ph.D. Admissions". Education. Wall Street Journal. Retrieved September 23, 2021.
  84. Paterson, James (July 3, 2018). "Yet another report says fewer Americans value 4-year degree". Education Dive. Retrieved August 2, 2019.
  85. Wellemeyer, James (August 6, 2019). "Half of young Americans say college is no longer necessary". Market Watch. Retrieved August 6, 2019.
  86. Stanford, Libby. "College Readiness Shouldn't Be a Top Priority for K-12 Anymore, Survey Shows". Education Week. Archived from the original on February 25, 2023. Retrieved January 20, 2023.
  87. Knott, Katherine (August 12, 2022). "Gen Z's Distrust in Higher Ed a 'Red Flag'". Inside Higher Education. Archived from the original on August 12, 2022. Retrieved August 21, 2022.
  88. "Can Gen Z Save Manufacturing from the 'Silver Tsunami'?". Industry Week. July 24, 2019. Retrieved July 27, 2019.
  89. Shugarman, Emily (August 14, 2021). "The Fight to Save Women's Colleges From Extinction". U.S. News. The Daily Beast. Retrieved September 8, 2021.
  90. Wagner, John (June 15, 2017). "Trump touts apprenticeships, turning to an issue with bipartisan support". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on February 20, 2021. Retrieved July 12, 2023.
  91. Will, George F. (April 19, 2023). "As enrollment plummets, academia gets schooled about where it went wrong". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on April 21, 2023. Retrieved July 13, 2023.
  92. Brownstein, Ronald (January 5, 2023). "Biden's Blue-Collar Bet". The Atlantic. Archived from the original on January 16, 2023. Retrieved March 29, 2023.
  93. Stanford, Libby (November 14, 2022). "Biden Administration Urges Schools to Expand Apprenticeships and Career Learning". Education Week. Archived from the original on February 25, 2023. Retrieved February 25, 2023.
  94. Sherman, Mark (June 30, 2023). "The Supreme Court rejects Biden's plan to wipe away $400 billion in student loan debt". Associated Press. Retrieved June 30, 2023.
  95. Van Dam, Andrew (September 2, 2022). "The most-regretted (and lowest-paying) college majors". Department of Data. The Washington Post. Archived from the original on September 2, 2022. Retrieved September 21, 2022.
  96. Birrell, Hamish (November 17, 2020). "A golden age for universities will come to an end". The Economist. Retrieved December 31, 2020.
  97. Watanabe, Shin (November 4, 2020). "US visas for Chinese students tumble 99% as tensions rise". Nikkei Asia. Archived from the original on February 6, 2021. Retrieved February 7, 2021.
  98. Higgins, Andrew; Fan, Maureen (May 19, 2012). "Chinese communist leaders denounce U.S. values but send children to U.S. colleges". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on March 25, 2014. Retrieved May 17, 2023.
  99. "Covid-19 will be painful for universities, but also bring change". The Economist. August 8, 2020. Retrieved December 3, 2020.
  100. Seltzer, Rick (September 15, 2016). "The International Bubble". Inside Higher Education. Archived from the original on May 17, 2023. Retrieved May 17, 2023.
  101. "Trends in College Spending 1998–2008 Archived 2013-08-08 at the Wayback Machine" (PDF) Delta Cost Project
  102. Claudia Goldin; Lawrence F. Katz (2008). The Race Between Education and Technology. The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
  103. Caplan, Bryan (2018). The Case Against Education: Why the Education System Is a Waste of Time and Money. Princeton University Press. ISBN 978-0691174655.
  104. Simkovic, Michael (2015). "The Knowledge Tax". University of Chicago Law Review. SSRN 2551567.
  105. Benhabib, Jess; Spiegel, Mark M. (October 1994). "The role of human capital in economic development evidence from aggregate cross-country data". Journal of Monetary Economics. 34 (2): 143–173. doi:10.1016/0304-3932(94)90047-7.
  106. Pritchett, Lant. "Where has all the education gone?" (PDF). Harvard.edu. World Bank & Kennedy School of Government (2000).
  107. Hanushek, Eric A.; Woessmann, Ludger (December 2010). "How Much Do Educational Outcomes Matter in OECD Countries?" (PDF). IZA Discussion Paper No. 5401.
  108. Holmes, Craig (May 2013). "Has the Expansion of Higher Education Led to Greater Economic Growth?". National Institute Economic Review. 224 (1): R29–R47. doi:10.1177/002795011322400103. S2CID 154479251.
  109. Hillman, Nick (2006). "Student Debt Burden, Volume 3, Number 8, August 2006" (PDF). American Association of State Colleges and Universities. Archived from the original (PDF) on December 11, 2010. Retrieved July 13, 2011.
  110. Vedder, Richard; Denhart, Christopher (January 8, 2014), How the College Bubble Will Pop, American Enterprise Institute, retrieved July 12, 2014
  111. "Public Universities Relying More on Tuition Than State Money", The New York Times 2011/01/24
  112. Quinn, Jane (September 24, 2010). "Student Loans: Time to Reform the Law That Treats Debtors Like Crooks". CBS News. Retrieved January 6, 2018.
  113. Weissman, Jordan (April 16, 2015). "How the Bush Administration Pointlessly Screwed Over Student Borrowers". Slate. Retrieved January 6, 2018.
  114. "Why College Prices Keep Rising". Forbes.com. 2012.
  115. Gary North (May 2, 2011). "College: Why It Is Not a Bubble". LewRockwell.com. Retrieved November 15, 2011.
  116. "Is a College Diploma Worth the Soaring Student Debt?". PBS NewsHour. May 27, 2011. Retrieved November 16, 2011.

Further reading
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.