Eugenio Lascorz

Eugenio Lascorz y Labastida was born in Zaragoza on 26 March 1886[3] and as per Spanish naming customs, took the surnames of both of his parents, Manuel Lascorz y Serveto (born in 1849) and Carmen Labastida y Pascual (born in 1857).[4] He was baptised two days after his birth in the Basilica of Our Lady of the Pillar. His paternal grandparents were the labourer Victorián Lascorz and his wife Raimunda Serveto; his maternal grandparents were Manuel Labastida and Ramona Pascual.[3] His great-grandfather (Victorián's father) was a man named Alonso Lascorz y Cerdán.[2] The surname Lascorz is not uncommon in High Aragon, and there is a village of that name in the province of Huesca.[lower-alpha 2] The name is probably of Basque origins.[6] The Lascorz family emigrated from the village of Plan to Zaragoza in the third quarter of nineteenth century, part of the large influx of immigrants from rural Aragon to its capital at around that time.[3]

The Lascorz family enjoyed significant wealth and social status in Zaragoza. Eugenio's father, Manuel, was a lawyer as well as a doctor of philosophy and letters, who served as secretary of the local provincial council.[7] Manuel and Carmen had three children, Eugenio being the youngest. He had an older brother, Lorenzo (1877–1900), and sister Josefina (1881–1956). Both Eugenio and Lorenzo studied at the University of Zaragoza.[8] Lorenzo studied medicine while Eugenio studied law.[9] At the university, Eugenio discovered and became fascinated by Byzantine history.[10] Lorenzo died in 1900 at the age of 22, making Eugenio the "heir" to Manuel.[9] Eugenio began his professional career as an attorney in 1917.[4] Exactly when Lascorz began his Byzantine claims is unclear. Later family tradition is that his father "revealed" their family history on his deathbed on 5 August 1906, declaring to Eugenio and Josefina that he was not just Manuel Lascorz y Serveto, but Prince Alexios Manuel Lascáris-Comneno, who had arrived with his father Prince Andronikos in Spain after fleeing from Ottoman persecution.[11] Manuel's obituaries stated that he was a "descendant and heir of the ancient Greek imperial family of the same surname, fleeing from the ruins of his homeland".[12]

Eugenio was a brilliant student, and he received his doctorate in law from the University of Zaragoza in 1911.[13] In 1917 he was admitted as Procurador de Tribunales ("Procurator of the Courts"), which in the Spanish legal system is a legal professional who specializes in court procedures and who is licensed to represent clients before the courts.[14] From 1933 to 1937 he would serve as Dean of the College of Procurators of Zaragoza.[7]

Lascorz, possibly inspired by his father, believed that his last name was a corruption of Laskaris, the name of a medieval Greek dynasty which had ruled the Byzantine Empire in Nicaea from 1204 to 1261.[2] Explicitly proclaiming his desire to restore the ancient glory of the Byzantine Empire, Lascorz was a proponent of the Greek Megali Idea: the Greek aspirations of conquering former Byzantine territory, including Constantinople, and restoring the borders of Byzantium.[15] He embarked on a campaign attempting to secure recognition of his royal descent by changing his legal identity substituting "Lascorz" for "Láscaris" and seeking approval in Spanish courts. Lascorz believed his descent from the Laskarids could give him a claim to the throne of the Kingdom of Greece, an idea which he dedicated the rest of his life to.[4] Eugenio had his paternal surname legally "corrected" from Lascorz to Láscaris, and later began to style himself "Eugenio Láscaris Comneno".[16] At the time, Greece was embroiled in a succession crisis; social tension and the abdication of King Constantine I put the future of the ruling House of Glücksburg in doubt.[14]

In 1923, Lascorz issued a manifesto to the Greek people, proclaiming himself "Prince Eugene Lascaris Comnenus, heir to the Emperors of Byzantium and Pretender to the Throne of Greece".[2] Lascorz believed that his supposed Byzantine ancestry went well with Greek dreams of past glories such as the Megali Idea.[17] The Greek monarchy was abolished in 1924 in favour of the Second Hellenic Republic. The abdication of George II of Greece saw the momentary end of the rule of the House of Glücksburg over Greece. Lascorz took advantage of this interregnum to try to push his claim to the Greek throne, writing to various influential Greek figures. According to Lascorz, he had already received the blessing of the Patriarch of Constantinople, Meletius IV, in 1922, and in 1927 Lascorz and his oldest son Teodoro were supposedly granted some honours by the Greek Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem, Damian I. The Láscaris family archives contain documents which they claim were sent in the early 1920s by Eleftherios Venizelos, the former prime minister of Greece, during his self-exile in Paris, supposedly seriously considering Lascorz as a candidate for the Greek throne. According to contemporary newspapers and radio broadcasts in Spain, several Greek deputies had expressed interest in offering the Greek crown to Lascorz. That nothing came of Lascorz's candidacy for the Greek throne, even after Venizelos became prime minister again in 1928, is explained away by Lascorz's modern descendants as being due to economic crisis and political instability plaguing the country and any potential plans for making Lascorz king being forgotten.[18]

In 1920, Lascorz married a woman named Nicasia Justa Micoláu Traver, with whom we would go on to have six children. Each received names of ancient Byzantine royalty, such as Teodoro, Constantino, Alejandro and Juan Arcadio.[2] The maternal surname was altered first to Micolav and then to Micolaw, apparently to give the impression that it was Slavic. In fact, Nicasia's father and grandfather had been confectioners in small towns of Lower Aragon, in the province of Teruel.[19] In 1935, Lascorz also invented an elaborate genealogy for himself,[lower-alpha 3] which notably altered his own familial history. His grandfather Victoriano was substituted by "Prince Andronikos Theodore Laskaris", supposedly described by his father on his deathbed. Eugenio's paternal great-grandfather, Alonso, was substituted by a "Prince Theodore Laskaris, Porphyrogenitus".[2]

As a lawyer, Lascorz was principally concerned with practical tasks and he did not make intellectual contributions to legal studies.[25] During the Spanish Civil War (1936 – 1939), Lascorz served as honorary captain of the Aragonese Requeté, an armed group that fought alongside General Francisco Franco's Nationalist faction and which was directly tied to the traditionalist and legitimist movement known as "Carlism".[26] Lascorz served as a military judge under the Nationalist faction, and after the Nationalist victory of 1939 he was appointed as judge in San Sebastián under the terms of Franco's draconian Law of Political Responsibilities.[27] In 1942 he moved to Barcelona, taking up another position in Franco's system of military justice.[28] A strong supporter of the new regime, Eugenio, his wife, and his son, Teodoro, wrote to Franco several times. Franco's office responded, addressing Eugenio and his family with their self-proclaimed titles.[29]

Known at this stage as the "Prince Eugenio Flavio Láscaris-Comneno",[27] Eugenio resigned his military judgeship in 1943 and moved to Madrid, where he dedicated himself to promoting his dynastic claims and his orders of chivalry.[30] He was also devoted to the study of Ancient and Byzantine Greece, and he wrote several works on Greek history. His publications on Byzantine themes were not restricted to historical works. In 1943, he published Calígrafia griega y bizantina ("Greek and Byzantine Calligraphy"), a collection of calligraphic exercises, beginning with tracing and then moving to reproductions of real ancient Greek and Byzantine initials, manuscripts and signatures.[25] In 1956, Lascorz published "Caliniki: Evocación histórica", a short story centering on a fictional Lacedaemonian girl named Cali Cabasileas who falls in love with Andrónico, a courtier of Despot Manuel Kantakouzenos.[31]

In 1946, Eugenio attempted to expand his "Sovereign and Imperial Order of Constantine the Great" and his own order of Saint Helena into international organisations. In 1948, he began publishing his own magazine, Parthenon, with the Asociación Cultural Greco-Española (the Greco-Spanish Cultural Association, an organization based in Madrid) and on 15 September 1950 he founded the International Philo Byzantine Academy and University (IPHBAU), a "cultural extension" of his self-proclaimed chivalric orders, which also had its own magazine.[32]

Eugenio published new genealogies in 1947 and 1952, changing the names of some of his ancestors, adding more supposed princes, and altering their relationships relative to the original genealogy of 1935. The 1952 version, the first to refer to Eugenio's father as "Alexios Manuel", explicitly contradicts Eugenio's earlier versions, which he had attempted to have validated by the Spanish courts. He did obtain "recognition" from several courts in Italy. Those courts did not investigate his genealogy, nor did they have the competence or authority to validate claims to the throne of the Byzantine Empire or the Kingdom of Greece.[2]

Lascorz's dynastic claims attracted some support, especially in Spain. Among his most notable advocates was Norberto de Castro y Tosi, a Costa Rican genealogist and diplomat who in 1959 published a biography, written in French, of le Prince Eugène Lascaris Comnène.[33] Castro was very favourable to Lascorz and did not mention episodes that might have caused controversy, such as Lascorz's role as military judge in the immediate aftermath of General Franco's victory in the Spanish Civil War.[34] Castro's biography was re-issued in Spanish in 1989, after the deaths of both the author and his subject, under the title Eugenio II, un príncipe de Byzancio ("Eugene II, a Prince of Byzantium"), in an edition prepared by Eugenio's son Juan Arcadio.[35]

In 1953 and 1954, Lascorz and his family became the focus of what commentators have called the "Hidalguía controversy".[36] This had its roots in a campaign launched in 1952 by the Holy See to root out what it regarded as fraudulent orders of chivalry.[37] This campaign had been publicised by the Spanish press by 1953, at a time when negotiations between the Vatican and the Spanish government were about to culminate in the Concordat of 1953.[32] Lascorz was head of the "Sovereign and Imperial Order of Constantine the Great", which the official Vatican newspaper, L'Osservatore Romano, listed among the false orders.[32] Lascorz also granted many noble titles to his family members, friends, and supporters.[lower-alpha 4] Those activities had attracted the attention of the Spanish government and the official Spanish aristocracy.[37] On 23 April 1953, an article in the ABC newspaper, "False chivalric orders and false titles of nobility", identified Lascorz as a forger and his orders and institutions as fake, stating that Lascorz violated "not only the principles of Church law, but also the sovereignty of the Spanish state". In later issues the newspaper also published and rebuked Lascorz's responses to the article, pointing out that the Spanish government had not approved his orders.[38]

At the start of 1954, José María de Palacio y de Palacio, the 3rd Marquess of Villareal de Álava, published a long and carefully documented article in Hidalguía (a learned journal of genealogy, nobility, and heraldry), showing that Lascorz's dynastic claims were fraudulent and even internally contradictory. Translated into English, the title of this piece was "The False Orders of Chivalry. Reflections upon a Porphyrogenitus and Emperor of Byzantium of... narrow gauge, Grand Master of the Sovereign and Imperial Order of Constantine the Great and of the Royal Slavic Crown of the Wends (The Curious Case of Doctor Lascorz)". The phrase "narrow gauge" (in Spanish, vía estrecha) in the title alludes to the narrow-gauge railways that served towns on the Spanish Pyrenees, including the region of High Aragon in which Palacio argued that the Lascorz family actually originated.[39] The "Sovereign Order of the Royal Slavic Crown of the Wends" was another self-styled order of chivalry that had been united with the Láscaris orders from 1946 until 1952, when their respective founders fell out with each other.[40] In his article, Palacio included a facsimile of Eugenio's "grand title of nomination", which ran over four printed pages and included such appellations as Caesar, Augustus, Basileus, Despot, Paraspondylos, and Megaskyr, as well as many dukedoms and princedoms.[41]

Palacio alleged that Lascorz had used his knowledge of the Spanish legal system and the complicity or ignorance of certain officials in order to alter his name and present himself as a descendant of the Laskaris dynasty and, consequently, as a legitimate claimant to the Greek throne.[42] On 13 March that same year, the Láscaris family responded through Teodoro (Eugenio's oldest son and family spokesman because of Eugenio's advanced age), who gave an interview to Informaciones, a daily newspaper in Madrid, in which he denounced Palacio was an "old enemy" of the family and was actively attempting to "persecute" them.[43]

Palacio's detailed and well documented critique of Eugenio Lascorz's dynastic pretensions was particularly damaging to his social prestige and that of his immediate family.[44] The International Institute of Genealogy and Heraldry, whose founder Vicente de Cadenas y Vicent was also the director of the journal Hidalguía, appointed a commission to resolve the controversy. That commission was presided by Miguel Gómez del Campillo, director of the Spanish National Historical Archive. Its final report, issued on 18 June, vindicated Palacio and concluded that the Lascorz family's dynastic claims were deliberate fabrications.[45]

His son and heir Teodoro Láscaris, argued that the campaign against Eugenio carried out by Cadenas, Palacio, and others associated with Hidalguía had a political motivation. Eugenio had been closely associated with Carlism during the Civil War and its aftermath. According to Teodoro, leading figures behind Hidalguía were part of a rival current within the National Movement supporting General Franco, namely Falangists. In that interpretation, the Hidalguía controversy was an opportunity for them to discredit a prominent figure of a competing faction in Francoist Spain. Teodoro also alleged that the campaign against his father was precipitated by the death of Carlist claimant Archduke Karl Pius (known to his supporters as "Carlos VIII") on 24 December 1953.[46] In any case, the consensus of modern historians is that the evidence presented in Hidalguía against Eugenio's genealogical claims was factually accurate.[47]

Despite the negative press, Lascorz continued to push his claims. On 29 October 1955, he issued a proclamation to the people of Cyprus, then a British colony and not yet an independent country, in the hopes that they would liberate themselves and proclaim him as their monarch. In his proclamation, Lascorz stressed his supposed descent from "Prince Andronikos Theodoros Laskaris", "hero of the Greek War of Independence", and he ended the text with "Long live Greece! Long live Cyprus! Long live the Megali Idea, neither dead nor forgotten!". The proclamation attracted little attention in Cyprus.[48]

In 1956 a municipal court in Zaragoza ruled that the previous change of surname from Lascorz to Láscaris had been invalid. This judgment was registered in 1957, whereupon Eugenio legally reverted to the surnames that he had at birth: Lascorz y Labastida.[49] In 1961, the corresponding change was inscribed on the margins of the birth registries of Eugenio's six children in the Spanish Civil Registry.[50] That decision, which probably resulted from the earlier Hidalguía controversy, marked a complete official rejection by the Spanish authorities of Eugenio's genealogical claims, but it did not cause Eugenio or his children to abandon them. Several of Eugenio's children emigrated to Hispanic America, where they continued to promote their family as heirs to the Byzantine throne. As of 2017, Carlos Sancho reported that all of Eugenio's thirteen grandchildren bore the surname Láscaris.[51]

Eugenio is mentioned by the English travel writer Patrick Leigh Fermor in his book Mani: Travels in the Southern Peloponnese, published in 1958. There the author, who was a great enthusiast of Byzantine history, alludes, among other pretenders to the vanished Byzantine throne, to "a Lascaris maniac from Saragossa".[52]

Eugenio Lascorz died in Madrid[4] on 1 June 1962, at the age of 76.[53] His death garnered some media attention, for instance being reported in the 26 July issue of the Colombian newspaper Diario de Boyacá and in the 15 August issue of the French newspaper Lyon-Information (also known as Independance), there under the article title L'Hellénisme en deuil: Son Altesse Impériale et Régent le Prince Flavius Eugène II Láscaris Comnène ("Hellenism in mourning: His Imperial and Royal Highness Prince Flavius Eugene II Lascaris Comnenus").[54]

• Angelov, Dimiter (2019). The Byzantine Hellene: The Life of Emperor Theodore Laskaris and Byzantium in the Thirteenth Century. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-108-48071-0.
• de Cadenas y Vicent, Vicente (1957). "Comunicados de la dirección: Lascorz, Láscaris, Lascorz" [Communications from the director: Lascorz, Láscaris, Lascorz]. Hidalguía: La Revista de Genealogía, Nobleza y Armas (in Spanish). 5 (22): 292–293.
• Fermor, Patrick Leigh (2006) [1958]. Mani: Travels in the Southern Peloponnese. New York Review Books. ISBN 1590171888.
• Gómez del Campillo, Miguel; Mariscal de Gante, Manrique; Zamora Lucas, Florentino; Val Latierro, Félix; de Codes, Miguel; Menéndez-Pidal, Faustino (1954). "Informe del Instituto Internacional de Genealogía y Heráldica sobre la polémica Marqués de Villarreal de Álava–Señores Láscaris" (PDF). Hidalguía: La Revista de Genealogía, Nobleza y Armas (in Spanish). 2 (6): 441–448. Retrieved 15 October 2023.
• Guilland, Rodolphe (1959). "Recherches sur l'histoire administrative de l'Empire byzantin: Le despote, δεσπότης". Revue des études byzantines (in French). 17: 52–89. doi:10.3406/rebyz.1959.1199. Retrieved 28 May 2011.
• Hernández de la Fuente, David (2019). "El fin de Constantinopla y las supuestas herencias nobiliarias bizantinas". In Barrios, F.; Alvarado, J. (eds.). Aires de grandeza: Hidalgos presuntos y Nobles de fantasía [Appearance of Greatness: Alleged Noblemen and Fantasy Nobles] (in Spanish). Madrid: Dykinson. pp. 245–262. ISBN 978-84-1324-092-3.
• Feldman, Ruth Tenzer (2008). The Fall of Constantinople. Twenty-First Century Books. ISBN 978-0761340263.
• de Palacio y de Palacio, José María (1954). "Las falsas Órdenes de Caballería. Reflexiones en torno de un Porfyrogénito y Emperador de Byzancio de... vía estrecha, Gran Maestre de la Soberana Orden Imperial de Constantino el Grande y de la Corona Real Eslava de los Wendos (El curioso caso del doctor Lascorz)" [The False Orders of Chivalry. Reflections upon a Porphyrogenitus and Emperor of Byzantium of... narrow gauge, Grand Master of the Sovereign and Imperial Order of Constantine the Great and of the Royal Slavic Crown of the Wends (The Curious Case of Doctor Lascorz)] (PDF). Hidalguía: La Revista de Genealogía, Nobleza y Armas (in Spanish). 2 (4): 73–102. Retrieved 18 October 2023.
• Panillo, Alberto (1910). "Ricos Hombres de Aragón: Los Lascorz". Linajes de Aragón (in Spanish). 1 (12): 181–186. Retrieved 18 October 2023.
• Polemis, Demetrios I. (1968). The Doukai: A Contribution to Byzantine Prosopography. London: The Athlone Press. OCLC 299868377.
• Sancho Domingo, Carlos (2017). Eugenio Láscaris-Comneno: el aragonés que pretendió el trono de Grecia [Eugenio Láscaris-Comneno: the Aragonese who Claimed the Throne of Greece] (PDF) (in Spanish). Institución "Fernando el Católico". ISBN 978-8499114651.
• Trapp, Erich; Beyer, Hans-Veit; Walther, Rainer; Sturm-Schnabl, Katja; Kislinger, Ewald; Leontiadis, Ioannis; Kaplaneres, Sokrates (1976–1996). Prosopographisches Lexikon der Palaiologenzeit (in German). Vienna: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften. ISBN 3-7001-3003-1.
• Varzos, Konstantinos (1984). Η Γενεαλογία των Κομνηνών [The Genealogy of the Komnenoi] (PDF) (in Greek). Vol. A. Thessaloniki: Centre for Byzantine Studies, University of Thessaloniki. OCLC 834784634.

• "The Great Seal of the Lascaris Comnenus". www.new-byzantium.org. Retrieved 2 March 2020.
• Sainty, Guy Stair. "The Pseudo Lascaris Princes and Their Fantastic Claims". European Royal Houses. Archived from the original on 12 February 2005.