George Lamar Jones

From 1986 to 2007, a number of young women and teenagers, most of whom were either prostitutes or drug addicts, were raped and strangled to death in Milwaukee. Suspecting that this might be the work of a serial killer, the local police department partnered up with the FBI to seek for potential links between the cases.

One of the cases put under investigation was that of 24-year-old Shameika Carter, a prostitute whose body was found dumped on a pile of garbage on November 19, 1997. Five days later, Jones was identified as the prime suspect in her killing and was arrested for her murder, but police refused to disclose his identity for the first two days as they were investigating him for any potential links to the other murders.[4] Investigators determined that since his release from prison on November 14, Jones had managed to assault two other women in addition to killing Carter, but ruled him out as a suspect in some of the other murders due to the fact he was imprisoned at the time.[5]

When interviewed by investigators, Jones claimed that he first met Carter at the house of a drug dealer where he usually bought crack cocaine. He claimed that she offered to accompany him to a place where they could buy some marijuana, and that the pair later returned to his house to smoke it.[6] Jones then claimed that after refusing to have sex with her, the two started smoking the marijuana mixed in with the cocaine, which made him have a headache. This, coupled with the fact that Carter supposedly mocked him for his apparent inability to get sexually aroused, made him snap and attack her, resulting in Carter being choked to death. Following these confessions, Jones was charged with first-degree murder, and his bail was set at $500,000.[6]

Before he was put on trial, Jones' court-appointed attorney announced that he intended to plead insanity on his client's behalf, citing his client's lifelong epilepsy and its success in the manslaughter case as his reasoning to do so.[2] This was contested by the prosecutors, who pointed out that Jones was intelligent enough to lie when he took a lie detector test. In order to determine whether he was capable of standing trial, he was ordered to undergo a psychiatric evaluation, with one of his examiners being George Palermo, who had also examined Jeffrey Dahmer.[2] After being deemed sane, both Jones and his attorney were prohibited from discussing the case with the media, as Justice Diane Syes claimed that the publicity would make jury selection difficult.[7]

While he awaited charges for Carter's murder, authorities revealed that Jones was considered a possible suspect in three additional murders: the February 1990 murder of Vernell Jeter; the September 1993 murder of Mary Lee Harris and the 1992 murder of Joyce Mims.[8] Unsealed documents showed that Jones acknowledged his sexual encounters with Jeter and Mims, but denied killing them or meeting Harris, whose body was found in a trash container near his house.[8]

In July 1998, Jones pleaded no-contest to the murder charges, claiming that he "[would] not make it through trial" and just wanted to get it over with.[9] As a result, he was subsequently sentenced to life imprisonment without parole.[10] He later appealed the decision on the grounds that the arresting offices had supposedly detained for an unreasonable length of time following his arrest, but this was promptly dismissed by the courts in 2001.[11]