George P. Raney

In the controversy following the contentious 1876 elections, it was unknown who had won the presidential and gubernatorial elections in the state of Florida. For the presidential election, both of the candidates, Democratic New York Governor Samuel J. Tilden and Republican Ohio Governor Rutherford B. Hayes, were declaring victory in the state. In addition, both candidates for governor, incumbent Republican Marcellus Stearns and Democrat businessman George Franklin Drew, also declared victory. Raney was appointed as Drew's counsel to the Florida Supreme Court.[7]

Stearns created a three-member body, the Florida Board of State Canvassers, to investigate the election. The board, which was mostly Republican, however, began throwing away Democratic votes and declared victory for both Hayes and Stearns in the state. Seeing as the Florida Legislature was deadlocked, Drew and Raney petitioned the Florida Supreme Court to decide on the matter. The court came to a compromise, with Hayes winning the state's electoral votes and Drew winning the governorship.[7]

In part due to his support during the election, Drew appointed Raney as the 14th Florida Attorney General on January 3, 1877.[8] He also became the counsel for the Florida Internal Improvement Fund. Raney maintained his position as Florida Attorney General following the election of Governor William D. Bloxham in 1880. As a result of Governor John Milton bankrupting the state during the Civil War, there were many pending lawsuits between the railroad and canal companies and the state concerning land grants that could not be resolved.[9] In 1881, Raney negotiated the sale of 4,000,000 acres (16,000 km²) of public land to real estate magnate Hamilton Disston to relieve the debt.[2]

On January 13, 1885, following the completion of Raney's second term as Florida Attorney General, Governor Edward A. Perry appointed him to the Florida Supreme Court, following the resignation of James Westcott, III.[10] In 1888, as a result of the Constitution of 1885, which required justices to be elected by popular vote, Raney was reelected to the court. In January 1889, he became the chief justice of the Florida Supreme Court.[11][12]

During his tenure as Chief Justice, the Florida Supreme Court oversaw some of the most important cases regarding expanding infrastructure and industrialization in the mostly rural state. Most notably was the case Pensacola and Atlantic Railroad Company v. Florida, in which the court decided in favor of the railroad, ruling that the state placing railroad tariffs is an abuse of discretion and constitutes the taking of the railroad company's property without due process of law.[2] This case set a national precedent, as was reaffirmed by the U.S. Supreme Court in their decisions in Wilcox v. Consolidated Gas Company of New York and Knoxville v. Knoxville Water Company, both decided early in 1909 in favor of the companies. Raney retired from the court on June 30, 1894.[13][14]

After returning to private practice, Raney was elected to the Florida House of Representatives, representing Leon County for one term. In 1902, he was elected to the Florida Senate from Leon County. While in the Senate, he also served as the counsel of the Seaboard Air Line Railroad, negotiating agreements between the railroad and the state government to improve passenger service in the Tallahassee area.[6] Raney did not run for reelection in 1906, opting to return to private practice. While in private practice, Raney was regarded as a champion of the railroads.[2]