Gotham!

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	74/100[1]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[2]
Alternative Press	9/10[3]
Blender	[4]
The Boston Phoenix	[5]
Drowned in Sound	6/10[6]
Pitchfork	6.1/10[7]
Q	[8]
Rolling Stone	[9]
Stylus Magazine	B[10]
Uncut	[11]

Gotham! received positive reviews from music critics who saw it as an improvement from their debut album The New Song & Dance, praising the post-punk production and politically minded lyrics. On Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album received an average score of 74, based on 14 reviews.[1]

Peter J. D'Angelo of AllMusic praised the album for its production and lyrics, comparing them positively to The Clash, Mission of Burma and Gang of Four, saying that "Half dance party, half political rally, Gotham! is a rock record for a new era."[2] Leslie Gilotti of Playlouder praised the band for crafting songs that straddle the line between fun dance-punk and political topics surrounding Post-9/11 New York, concluding that "The right-on politics will definitely appeal to lefty sloganeering students, but Radio 4 never get tedious. 'Gotham!' is an infinitely danceable and certainly insightful record that gets better with each listen, on every frequency."[12] Brad Cohan of PopMatters praised the production of Goldsworthy and Murphy for deviating away from the debut album's sound to make it more hook-heavy and body moving, saying that, "Unlike The Rapture and Liars, who share in the movement philosophy but utilize a more angular and anarchic pose, Radio 4’s Gotham! is a near-perfect hybrid of perpetual rhythm, flow and hooks."[13]

The album was met with mixed reviews. While praising the first half of the album for being more nuanced with its sound than its predecessor, Eric Carr of Pitchfork felt that the second half was hampered by Anthony Roman's delivery of the more politically heavy songs being delivered with the "verbal subtlety of an eighth grader with an anarchy symbol stitched onto his backpack." He concluded that, "Gotham! is decent, catchy, and entertaining, but can't keep up the pace it sets from the beginning, which is just too damn bad."[7] Christina Rees of The Village Voice found the production tiring and derivative of bands like Gang of Four and The Clash and felt that Roman's performance failed to match that of John Lydon. She did give the band credit for creating a difficult sound that was a labor of love to them, concluding that, "The younger kids should enjoy the sound for the first time out, while new-wave nostalgiaheads can time travel. It's hard to dismiss such passionate effort. Just do me a favor and switch off the stereo on your way out."[14]

• Anthony Roman – bass, lead vocals
• Tommy Willians – guitars, vocals (lead vocals on "Eyes Wide Open" and "End Of The Rope")
• Gerard Garone – keyboards, guitars
• P.J. O'Conner – percussion, vocals
• Greg Collins – drums
• James Murphy – production, vocals (on "Speaking In Codes")
• Tim Goldsworthy – production, sound engineering