Harlan Roulette

In January 2012, it was reported that the second episode of the third season would be titled "Harlan Roulette", and was to be directed by Jon Avnet and written by co-executive producer Dave Andron.[2]

The line that Raylan tells to Wade Messer about entering uninvited to the house is a callback to the first episode, establishing the theme of the season as "crossing the line."[3]

Series developer Graham Yost explained the decision to keep Wade Messer and Dewey Crowe alive despite their many missteps, "a lot of it has to do with just us seeing the performance. We had so much fun with Damon Herriman playing Dewey on the pilot. We just thought it'd be cool to bring him back. We always want to make sure when we use him that we remind ourselves and the audience that he's a bad guy capable of bad stuff, but at the same time, not lose sight of the Elmore Leonard humor that's involved with a character like that."[3] Yost revealed that inspiration for the Oxy storyline came from Harlan citizens, who viewed Oxy as "the great destroyer" as well as hearing from Kentucky about pill mills, "So we knew as a subject area we wanted to explore it. And then we heard about this possible scam of mobile Oxy clinics where you'd set up doctors to be quasi legal, and if the heat got too hot, you would just move."[3]

Yost previously referred Quarles as the "Carpetbagger".[4] He further elaborated, "in our twisted Justified world, the natural resource down there is Oxy addicts. We just thought that becomes an Elmore-like scam. Elmore's bad guys are always looking for that little gap, that little thing that no one else has tried, that makes some kind of sense." Regarding the final scene where he smiled when Raylan took a picture of him, "that was something I thought of. I thought it would be nice if Raylan had a picture of him, so that then in subsequent episodes he could maybe find out more about him as their two stories start to come together. At this point, at the end of episode 3, Raylan doesn't know that Quarles is going to be his main adversary this season."[3]

Questioned about the man that Quarles had bound and gagged in the house, Yost said, "we're not supposed to know who that guy is", explaining that the man would be revealed in the subsequent episodes.[3] "Guy Walks into a Bar" revealed the identity of the man as Brady Hughes.[5]

Raylan's line when he threatens Duffy, "the next one's coming faster", was based on a story that Yost claims to have heard on The Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson.[3] The line would eventually become a favorite among critics and fans of the series.[6]

Series developer Graham Yost viewed Glen Fogle as a "modern-day Fagin", a character in Oliver Twist.

In November 2011, Pruitt Taylor Vince was announced to play a guest role in the episode as Glen Fogle, "a 'modern-day Fagin', Fogle deals in stolen goods and pays his hired thieves with painkillers."[7] Yost added, "We called him Fagin in our breaking of the story because we thought of him as this Oliver Twist-like character who has these addicts going out and robbing for him. We just wanted to see, like Fagin or Sikes to an extent, how bad he could be."[3] For his death scene, Yost expressed sadness at killing him, "That's kinda hard. But at the same time, he's so wonderful, it just makes the episode work."[3]

In its original American broadcast, "Harlan Roulette" was seen by an estimated 2.71 million household viewers and gained a 1.1 ratings share among adults aged 18–49, according to Nielsen Media Research. This means that 1.1 percent of all households with televisions watched the episode.[8] This was steady in viewership from the previous episode, which was watched by 2.71 million viewers with a 0.9 in the 18-49 demographics.[9]

"Harlan Roulette" received very positive reviews from critics. Seth Amitin of IGN gave the episode a "great" 8.5 out of 10 and wrote, "The writing has taken a very sharp turn toward excellent. This is way better than I remember it being. The dialogue is crisp and has even taken on a funnier edge. The characters seem a little more well-rounded, too (think about Dickie with a knife to his throat vs. Dickie talking to the prison guard). Boyd's vocabulary has improved. This is going to be a very fun season."[10]

Scott Tobias of The A.V. Club gave the episode an "A−" grade and wrote, "This week, we saw multiple parties getting prepared for business in Harlan — and in the Darwinian scramble for territory, the clearest, most organized thinkers win out and the merely organizized are left to the wolves. As with last season, the show isn't wasting much time bringing order to its own universe."[11] James Queally of The Star-Ledger wrote, "I'm afraid I don't have a whole lot else to say about 'Harlan Roulette'. Justified can sometimes be a tough show to review, because Graham Yost and company don't really do a whole hell of a lot wrong. They also haven't done a whole hell of a lot different over the past 16 or so episodes (since the beginning of Season 2). That's perfectly fine by me, the show works. There are only so many ways I can tell you it's awesome. Perhaps as we get to know a little more about some of the new faces around Harlan, I'll be a little more loquacious."[12]

Alan Sepinwall of HitFix wrote, "Strong episode, and, like last week, an example of how the show has become much better at mixing serialized and standalone. Much as I like most of the actors involved in the Fogel story (more on them in a minute), that plot alone wouldn't have been interesting enough to carry a full hour. But as one story of many – and tied back in to the larger Dixie Mafia plot – it worked out just splendidly."[13] Luke de Smet of Slant Magazine wrote, "With 'Harlan Roulette', the full potential of season three is starting to show itself. The coming mayhem is fairly clear, as Raylan, Boyd, Limehouse, Quarles, and even Dickie all move slowly toward each other. Something is certainly going to change in Harlan, but the only way to find out if that change will be any good is to pull the trigger and find out."[14]

Ben Lee of Digital Spy wrote, "Another week, another awesome episode of Justified."[15] Joe Reid of Vulture wrote, "But I do know television, and my years of watching it have taught me that the most dangerous time for both criminals and law enforcement is when there's a power vacuum at the top of the criminal food chain. And that's clearly where we're at this week on Justified."[16]

Todd VanDerWerff of Los Angeles Times wrote, "The more that the show is able to introduce compelling figures and the more it's able to do fascinating things with people we already know, the healthier it will be, and if 'Harlan Roulette' is any indication, this show is very healthy indeed."[17] Dan Forcella of TV Fanatic gave the episode a perfect 5 star rating out of 5 and wrote, "What Justified has become so wonderful at recently is not only mixing serialization with episodic stories so well, but also creating episodic plots that - in and of themselves - are integral to the seasonal arc. That was never more evident than in 'Harlan Roulette'."[18] Jack McKinney of Paste gave the episode a 8.5 rating out of 10 and wrote, "This week's episode was about two things, storytelling and what the stories we choose say about the teller. There were (at least) three story monologues tonight, and each one was illuminating not only in showing where each storyteller thinks they fall on the spectrum of right and wrong, but also how mistaken they may be about that. Often our best stories are the ones we tell ourselves."[19]