Homecoming (2023 film)

On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of 75% based on 12 reviews, with an average rating of 5.5/10.[15] On Metacritic, the film has a weighted average score of 63 out of 100, based on 8 critic reviews, indicating "generally favorable reviews".[16]

Reviewing the film following its Cannes premiere, Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian praised the "very strong" performances but criticised the "melodramatic incidental action" for making the film fail to deliver on its "tacit promise of showing us Khedidja's inner life, and what this place and her homecoming means to her."[4]

When minors under the age of 15 participate in filming in France, the screenplay is sent for validation to the prefect and the Commission des Enfants du Spectacle, which oversees the safeguarding of minors on film sets. However, the production team introduced a scene in which a female character, played by Esther Gohourou, caresses a male character, played by Harold Orsini. The actors were aged 15 and 17, respectively.[18] The scene was not included in the validated screenplay and was therefore unauthorised. Following this violation of the law, the government agency Centre national du cinéma et de l'image animée (CNC) withdrew its financial support of €580,000, minus the minimum sum paid to the cast and crew,[18][9] out of an overall budget of €4.7 million.[8] The CNC later reduced the fine to €330,000.[19]

Perez said her company made an administrative error by not declaring the scene, which she said was "played in a totally consented and fully simulated manner" with only the actors' faces filmed and without actual touching.[18] Corsini said, "I wanted to capture with this small sequence between these two young actors, the awkwardness of the first emotions of love ... it suggested something of a sexual nature, but we didn't show anything since the camera was centered on the faces." Corsini said that she "took every necessary precaution to film that scene" and offered the actors an intimacy coordinator for the scene but that "since they were dressed and didn't touch each other, and since they trusted each other, they decided that it wasn't necessary". Gohourou has released a statement corroborating that they declined an intimacy coordinator.[20] Corsini and Perez stated that body doubles were also offered but declined by the actors.[21]

Corsini said she cut the scene during editing, at the request of France 3 who considered it unnecessary,[8] and "to calm everyone down and especially so that people would stop bothering the actors".[20]

During the production, a complaint was filed with the Central Committee on Health and Safety and Working Conditions of Film Production (CCHSCT) accusing Corsini of harassment, and two other crew members of "inappropriate gestures" towards two actresses. The CCHSCT visited the set and made a report to the prosecutor.[18] According to Corsini and Perez, the CCHSCT found no wrongdoing.[21]

On 3 October 2022, a young actress originally cast to play Jessica filed a police complaint alleging that, on 24 August 2022, during the rehearsal of a dance scene, a coach grabbed her "by the hips" and rubbed "his genitals against hers by initiating vigorous back-and-forth movements", and that she was fired after telling Corsini about the incident. According to Libération, the coach was not fired but only asked to obtain permission from anyone before making any physical contact with them after the incident.[8] According to Mediapart, after the firing, Chaz Productions offered the actress a compensation of €2,500 in exchange for promising not to speak publicly against the company or Corsini, which she declined.[19] Corsini said that the recasting of the actress had nothing to do with the complaint and it was only because she was not "a good match for this role, as it can often happen during the early days of rehearsals".[20]

On set, Gohourou accused a stuntman of touching her buttocks repeatedly during a scene in which she was pressed against a wall.[8] Perez and Corsini conducted an internal investigation, which found it inconclusive. Since Gohourou was a minor, it was also reported to the prosecutor. A social worker then interviewed Gohourou and her mother, who decided not to press charges.[20]

Libération reported that, despite the production taking place during the school term, Gohourou was not accompanied by a parent or guardian, and was not subject to an educational follow-up. The film's COVID-19 specialist, who had been assigned this task, quit during the filming, opposed to the conditions of filming of the minor. It also reported that a casting assistant in charge of extras, a grip, and the second assistant director also resigned mid-production "due to repeated humiliations". It also reported that a letter signed by 16 crew members and two actresses—Lomane de Dietrich and Suzy Bemba according to Mediapart[19]—complaining about working conditions was read to Corsini ten days before the end of the filming, and that the actresses' scenes were reduced in retaliation.[8] Corsini refuted this and said that scenes were cut in order to reduce working hours in response to the complaint.[19]

According to Libération, two actresses requested, without success, the presence of an intimacy coordinator on the set.[8]

On 25 April 2023, Corsini and Perez published an open letter stating, "Anonymous and defamatory emails have been sent to the profession and the press, generating a rumor that was very damaging for the film." They acknowledged they made an administrative error by not declaring an intimate scene, but stressed that the actors were clothed and only their faces were filmed. They said internal investigations were conducted into the two incidents of alleged sexual misconduct and the CCHSCT "could see it had been dealt with correctly".[22][23][21][12]

Testimonies of actors Esther Gohourou and Denis Podalydès denying poor working conditions were attached to the letter. Gohourou said she and Orsoni declined an intimacy coordinator and the shooting of the undeclared scene was not uncomfortable. Podalydès said, "I've participated in over one hundred shoots, and I know what it means to be on a set riven with disagreements, things left unsaid and harassment. ... At no point during my time on the set did I witness a problem or feel ill at ease, quite the contrary."[22][23][21]

On 28 June 2023, Jean Labadie, CEO of Le Pacte, the French distributor of Homecoming, sent out a press release criticising the French press for failing to conduct a proper investigation and disseminating "unfounded, unjust and defamatory" allegations.[24] In response, Libération published an editor's note defending its reporting.[25] Labadie also accused the CNC of pressuring the filmmakers to cut the undeclared scene, which the CNC denied in a statement released on 29 June.[24] He also revealed that Mediapart was conducting an investigation to be published around the time of the film's release, and attached to the press release statements Corsini and Perez had given to Mediapart.[26] Mediapart criticised Labadie for releasing the statements, saying, "What precedes the publication belongs to the journalists, and breaking this principle likely exposes our sources and makes our work impossible."[19]

Denis Gravouil, secretary general of the CGT Spectacle, said about the sexual assault on a young actress: "The denial of the facts by the director and producer, who sought to minimise the incident, created conflict on the set and aggressive behaviour on the part of Catherine Corsini, leading to the departure of the two technicians" who denounced the assault.[27][28]

The selection of the film by the Cannes Film Festival was criticised by Collectif 50/50, a French NGO promoting equality between men and women in the film industry. The organization wrote, "It is obviously a devastating signal sent to the victims of gender-based and sexual violence, and it is also a way of reinforcing the collusion that prevails in our industry, and which prevents the peaceful release of speech on this crucial subject."[27] Collectif 50/50 admonished the production about the importance of taking steps to prevent violence, such as the appointment of an intimacy coordinator to plan and structure sexual scenes.[29]

In April 2023, Pierre Salvadori, a longtime friend of Corsini, suggested to the Society of Film Directors (SRF), the guild behind the Directors' Fortnight sidebar at the Cannes Film Festival, that it release a statement about its position on the allegations. Although Salvadori said his intention was not to publish a statement defending Corsini, his proposal received criticism from colleagues, leading him and Corsini to resign from the SRF.[9][12][30]

In April 2023, producer Marc Missonnier criticised Cannes for selecting the film and called for boycotting the festival on Twitter.[21] On 17 May, he said he discovered, after arriving in Cannes, that his accreditation for the film market had been revoked in retaliation to his call for a boycott.[31] On 18 May, the European Producers Club issued a statement denouncing the revocation, saying "it can be seen as a restriction on freedom of expression".[32] On 22 May, Missonnier reported that his accreditation had been restored.[33]