Living with War

Young began writing songs for Living with War in a Gambier, Ohio, hotel room while visiting his daughter at her college.[11] While retrieving coffee from a vending machine early one morning, Young saw the front page of a USA Today issue documenting a surgery room on an airplane flying seriously wounded US soldiers from Iraq to Germany.[11] He later told Charlie Rose that the combination of the vivid picture and the headline (which focused not on any suffering and death depicted, but rather on medical breakthroughs made during the war) moved him: "For some reason, that was what did it to me. I went upstairs after that. I wrote this song, 'Families'; I started writing another song, 'Restless Consumer'; I started writing all these songs all at once; I had like four songs going at once."[11] Young has said that after writing the songs, he quickly began "coming apart."[11] He called his wife Pegi back to their room, and "I held on to her, and I was sobbing. I was sobbing so hard, that things were coming out of my face."[11]

The rhythm section of Rick Rosas and Chad Cromwell, and Young's "Volume Dealers" co-producer Niko Bolas were also at the core of Young's 1989 album Freedom, which contained an angry criticism of Reagan-George H. W. Bush America. There are other links between the albums: Bray also performed on Freedom and Freedom's hit single "Rockin' in the Free World" also contained a quotation of a President Bush: "a thousand points of light".

The sessions were recorded on 16-track analog tape and mixed to a half-inch analog two-track master, then transferred to high-resolution digital media for CD and DVD manufacturing.[1] The vinyl pressing was on 200 g discs.

On April 28, 2006, the album was given a pre-release premiere in its entirety on the Los Angeles radio station KLOS (95.5) by Jim Ladd.[1][12] The album was released onto the Internet on May 2, 2006, before entering retail in May 2006.[1] Young has expressed that his intent is that the work be considered as a whole, and the streaming-audio internet release was the whole album, rather than individually selectable songs.

That first impression is so important" ... "Instead of just going to "Let's Impeach the President", people will have to absorb the whole thing. To understand the songs, you need to understand where the whole album's coming from. It protects my right as an artist to have the work presented the way I created it.

— Neil Young

The rush release and the political nature of the tracks are also comparable to Young's 1970 song "Ohio". In a May 2007 interview with Rolling Stone's David Fricke, Young rejects the comparison:

"When I wrote "Let's Impeach the President," a lot of people criticized it as a crappy song, that it was such a terrible melody. What am I going to do, write a song like that and use a good melody? That doesn't make sense. You want a melody that pisses people off, that's so stupid and repetitive that it aggravates people. 'Ohio' is about kids getting killed. It's about people you cared about personally, your own brother and sister. That's when you put everything you have, poetic, musical, performance-wise, at your command. Because you believe in it so much. "Let's Impeach the President" is a political song about something that's so wrong that the only way to point out how wrong it is by doing a song that's wrong: smashing and pounding away at it. It was very successful in that respect."[13]

In November 2006, Young released a stripped-down version of the album, Living with War: "In the Beginning", without the backing instrumentation and choral accompaniment found on the original release.

The lyrics in "Living With War" are in line with the early 1960s albums of folk artists such as Phil Ochs and Bob Dylan, although they are set to what Young calls "metal folk protest music".[14] Time Out London similarly proclaimed the record to be an "anti-Bush folk-metal tirade".[2]

The albums songs were performed live on Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young’s 2006 Freedom Of Speech Tour. Selections from that tour can be heard on the “CSNY/Deja Vu (Live) album.

Reviewing the album for Mojo magazine, Sylvie Simmons described the songs as "Urgent, instant, bolshie mostly, with a stronger individual melodic sense than, say, Greendale, but without the intense beauty of, say, Ohio … though definitely an improvement on Let's Roll".[5] Living with War was nominated for three 2007 Grammy Awards in the categories of Best Rock Album, Best Rock Song and Best Solo Rock Vocal Performance (both for "Lookin' for a Leader").

Despite the album's content and criticism from right wing blogs leading up to the release, Young stated that he considers the album nonpartisan.[15] He said in an interview with The New York Times: "If you impeach Bush, you're doing a huge favor for the Republicans … They can run again with some pride."[15]

Commenting on the lack of artists writing songs critical of American policy at the time, Young said, "I was hoping some young person would come along and say this and sing some songs about it, but I didn't see anybody, so I'm doing it myself. I waited as long as I could."[16]

• Neil Young – guitars, harmonica, vocal, producer
• Rick Rosas – bass
• Chad Cromwell – drums
• Tommy Bray – trumpet
• Rosemary Butler - vocal contractor, background vocals
• Michael Mishaw - background vocals

• Living with War Today: page devoted to this album on Young's official website
• Living with War lyrics