Natural Disaster (album)

Cosentino had been a member of the duo Best Coast for over a decade when she decided to put the group on hiatus, announced the same day as the album.[1] Cosentino said the hiatus was inspired by her need to find her own identity outside of the group.[2][1]

Natural Disaster was announced on May 3, 2023, with its release date set for July 28 by Concord Records. With the announcement came the album's lead single, "It's Fine", and a music video directed by Janell Shirtcliff.[2] The second single, "Easy", was released on June 16.[3] The third single, "For a Moment", was released on July 6, featuring vocals from her cowriters Madi Diaz, Kate York, and Sarah Buxton.[4] The fourth single, the title track, was released on July 25, with a music video directed by Aaron Preusch which depicts Cosentino dancing in front of projected footage of landscapes and fires.[5]

Cosentino wrote the album in Nashville and Los Angeles. The album was produced by Butch Walker,[2] and recorded in his Nashville studio.[1] "It's Fine" was the first single written for the album, inspired by Cosentino having "seen something on the internet that really pissed me off" and deciding to write a song on her guitar rather than respond angrily on Twitter.[6] Cosentino was originally planning on working with Carlos de la Garza, who had produced Best Coast's last album Always Tomorrow, but determined that Walker's background in alt country and Americana would fit better.[6] Cosentino sent Walker a demo of "It's Fine" which Walker produced into the version that made the final album.[6]

Cosentino made a mood board for the album which included numerous elements from the film Thelma & Louise.[7] She was also influenced by the film Defending Your Life.[7]

The album combines pop rock,[1][8] folk rock,[1] and Americana,[1] with additional influences of country.[9][8] Influences on its sound include Bonnie Raitt,[1][2] Sheryl Crow,[1][2] and Jewel.[1]

The album's lyricism is more direct than her usual work with Best Coast.[10] One of the album's major lyrical themes is climate change,[9][11] involving frequent references to fire and drought juxtaposed with "girl group sha-la-las" and "descriptions that evoke a vaguely pre-apocalyptic landscape" on the opening track.[9]

Natural Disaster ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
AnyDecentMusic?	7.1/10[12]
Metacritic	74/100[13]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[14]
Clash	6/10[15]
DIY	[16]
Dork	[17]
Exclaim!	7/10[9]
The Guardian	[8]
The Line of Best Fit	8/10[11]
NME	[1]
Pitchfork	5.9/10[18]
Riff	8/10[10]

According to the review aggregator Metacritic, Natural Disaster received "generally favorable reviews" based on a weighted average score of 74 out of 100 from 10 critic scores.[13]

Exclaim!'s Kate Shepherd wrote that with the album, Cosentino had "crafted an artifact that will feel at once familiar to those who followed her work with Best Coast and also distinctly her own, merging vulnerability with a dry sense of humour, and deploying to full effect her well-honed skill for blending sincere nostalgia with her own brand of millennial irony."[9] The Line of Best Fit's Joshua Mills wrote that while the "downtempo tunes" such as "It's a Journey" "are a little hit-and-miss", the album "brims with the artist's personality and is a delight to connect with."[11] Mills highlighted Cosentino's ability to know "exactly what kind of sparkling, big-hearted album she wanted to make", and the combination of her "acidity" with Walker's "polish" which "delivers way more often than not."[11]

• Bethany Cosentino – lead vocals, backing vocals
• Butch Walker – producer (1–11), recording engineer (1–11), bass guitar (1–11), guitar (1–11), keyboards (1–11), percussion (1–11), piano (1–11), drums (1, 3, 4, 6, 9, 10)
• Davis Naish – producer (12), recording engineer (12), piano (12)
• Lars Stalfors – mixing engineer
• Pete Lyman – mastering engineer
• Mark Stepro – drums (2, 4, 8, 10, 11)
• Billy Justinau – Hammond B3 (2, 8)
• Val McCallum – guitar (4)
• Mickey Rafael – harmonica (4, 5)
• Ellen Angelico – baritone guitar (5, 7), mandolin (5, 7), pedal steel guitar (5, 7)
• Jeff Trott – guitar (5)
• Nick Bockrath – guitar (5, 7)
• Eric Slick – drums (5, 7)
• Madi Diaz, Kate York, and Sarah Buxton – backing vocals (7)