The Nest Club
The Nest Club was a cabaret in Harlem, more specifically an afterhours club, at 169 West 133rd Street – a street known then both as "Swing Street"[Note 1] and "Jungle Alley" – two doors east of Seventh Avenue, downstairs. The club, operating under the auspices of The Nest Club, Inc., was founded in 1923, co-owned, and operated by John C. Carey (né John Clifford Carey; 1889–1956) and Mal Frazier (né Melville Hunter Frazier; 1888–1967).[Note 2] The club flourished through 1933. The U.S. Prohibition — a nationwide ban on the sale of alcoholic beverages — ran from 1920 to 1933. The club faced a formidable challenge to its viability following the Great Crash of October 1929, followed by the Great Depression that bottomed around March 1933.[1]
History
The Nest Club, 100 feet (30.48 m) east of Seventh Avenue, opened in 1923 with a Leonard Harper revue and Sam Wooding's band. Performers, dressed in bird costumes, did a routine in the theme, "Where do the birds go every night? To the nest! To the nest!" Dance historian Jacqui Malone, in her 1996 book, Steppin' on the Blues: The Visible Rhythms of African American Dance, explained that, at the Nest Club, floor shows were less elaborate than those of larger venues while the emphasis was on the music.[2]
Johnnie Cobb managed the Nest Club from about 1923 to about 1926. Jeff Blood managed it beginning 1927. James Sampson (né James Thomas Sampson; 1876–1948) was business manager. A barbecue restaurant, owned and operated by Carey and Frazier, occupied the ground floor. In 1924, Carey and Frazier also opened on October 23, 1924, and operated the Bamville Club in Harlem at 65 West 129th Street, 2 doors east of Lenox Avenue – where blacks and whites danced in mixed couples.[3][4]
In 1932, the Rhythm Club, which had been located at 168 West 132nd Street, moved to a room behind the Nest Club. The Nest Club itself closed in 1933.[5]
In 1933, Dickie Wells (né Richard Wells; 1907–1949)[Note 3] (not the trombonist by the same name) took over the lease and opened the Shim Sham Club.
Carey and Frazier, later, owned and operated the Saratoga Club, on Lenox at 140th Street, which had been founded by Casper Holstein (1876–1944).
Selected musicians, including houseband members
- 1923–1925: Sam Wooding (1905–1985), piano, director. On May 6, 1925, Wooding, his band, and revue performers sailed for Germany aboard the SS Arabic, arriving in Hamburg May 17, 1925, traveling to Berlin, arriving May 18, and opened May 25 at the Admiralspalast, where they performed 8 weeks. During this time, they recorded at Vox Records. On July 28, their revue opened in Hamburg at the Thalia Theater for 32 performances, ending August 24. Then Stockholm, opening August 25, and closing September 14. The Stockholm performances included a benefit for the Swedish Red Cross, for the brother of the King.[6] Then they performed in Copenhagen in the Circus Building, opening September 15, closing September 25.[7][8]
- 1923–1925: Willie Lewis (1905–1971), clarinet
- 1923–1925: Herb Flemming (1898–1976), trombone
- 1923–1925: Eugene Sedric (1907–1963), clarinet, tenor sax
- 1923–1925: Bobby Martin (1903–1983), trumpet
- 1923–1925: Garvin Bushell (1902–1991), clarinet, alto sax, oboe
- 1925: Elmer Snowden (1900–1973), banjo, director
- 1925: Demas Dean (1903–1991), trumpet, played when Butler was director[13]
- 1927–1928: Teddy Hill (1909–1978), saxophone, clarinet
- 1927: Luis Russell (1898–1962), piano, director
- 1928: Barney Bigard (1906–1980) played clarinet for Russell at the Nest Club and Duke Ellington first heard him there[16]
- 1926–1928: Charles Holmes (1910–1985), alto sax, played under George Howe and Louis Russell
- 1928: Harry White (1898–1962), trombone, director
- 1929–1930: Hannah Sylvester (1903–1973), blues singer[17]
- 1927–1927: Ed (aka "Andy") Anderson (né Donnell Edward Anderson; 1903–1983), trumpet
- Mattie Hite (1890–1935), singer
- Johnny Hudgins (1896–1990), vaudeville performer
- 1920s: Lizzie Miles (1895–1963)
- 1932: Lorenzo Tio, Jr. (1893–1933), clarinet, alongside Sidney Bechet
- 1932: Sidney Bechet (1897–1959), saxophone
Billie Holiday
In the late 1920s, Billie Holiday, under her birth name, Eleanora Fagan, sang for tips at small Harlem venues, namely the Nest Club, Pod's and Jerry's, the Yeah Man (1925–1960)[Note 6] at 2350 Seventh Avenue at 138th Street, and Monette's at 148 West 133rd (1926– ). Microphones to amplify vocalist were not yet used in Harlem nightclubs.
Mae Barnes, a singer and dancer, reminisced about the first time she heard Eleanora sing. Both she and Eleanora had been performing at the Nest. Barnes said, "Billie wasn't doing her own style. She was doing everything that Louis Armstrong was doing. She knew his records backwards ... She wasn't imitatin' his style, she was using all his numbers. That was her beginnin' of changing Louis's style to her own ... "
She had this heavy voice, this gravelly tone. While at the Nest Club, Eleanora changed her name to Billie Holiday, drawing on the pseudonym of one her favorite actors, Billie Dove, and the surname of her father, Clarence Holiday. Side note: Music writer Donald Clarke avers that Holiday adopted her first name from a jazz vocal team, Billie Haywood (1903–1979) and Cliff Allen who, had been singing at a Harlem venue. Haywood was, according to Barnes, a hell of a rhythm singer.[16][Note 7]
Radio broadcasts
In 1925, the Nest Club Orchestra, directed by Billy Butler, nationally broadcast their performances Tuesday and Saturday evenings, 11:30 to midnight, from host WFBH, a short-lived Manhattan radio station in existence from July 15, 1924, to November 6, 1926.[20][21]
Prohibition
During the Prohibition, many cabarets across the country were speakeasies. And, at the time, many in Harlem's Swing Street district have been chronicled as having been controlled by organized crime.The extent to which the Nest Club operated (i) as a speakeasy or (ii) under the duress of organized crime is not well-chronicled.
However, Michael Aloysius Lerner, in his 2007 book, Dry Manhattan: Prohibition in New York City, pointed out that the Amsterdam News and the New York Age both argued that cabarets in Harlem had been unfairly targeted by prohibition enforcement officers. Yet, not a single venue in Harlem had been padlocked until September 1928, when the Nest Club was closed for violating the Volstead Act. When Police Commissioner Grover Whalen ordered a massive citywide crackdown on speakeasies in 1929, 45 of the 786 clubs were in Harlem, a ratio that, according to Lerner, "suggests Harlem was neither ignored nor specifically targeted."[22]
Building demolished
The building at 169 West 133rd Street, a 2-story structure with a basement, was demolished in 2012. In 2009 and 2012, the fabric awning over the front door – dark brown with white lettering – had the words "Brown's Palace."[23]
New building
In 2015, on the same lot with the same address, a newly erected six-story, 10,385 square feet (964.8 m2), healthcare clinic named "The Nest" opened under the auspices of Harlem United, a New York non-profit founded in 1988 during the throes of the HIV/AIDS epidemic in New York. The Nest has exams rooms, dental operatories, a floor dedicated to behavioral health, and a floor for pediatric care. The staff uses the facility to offer primary care for the lesbian, gay, bisexual, queer, and transgender community as well as provide treatment and care for individuals with viral hepatitis. As of April 2020, leadership of Harlem United included Jacquelyn Kilmer, Chief Executive Officer; Marvin Griffith, Chairman; and Douglass J. Dukeman, Chairman of HU's Upper Room AIDS Ministry, Inc.
Other notable occupants, later
In the 1970s, the LaRocque Bey Dance Company, founded in 1960, was listed at 169 West 133rd Street. Bey (né LaRocque Norvel Wright; 1937–1990) was an African American choreographer, dancer, percussionist, composer, and founder of the Harlem dance school and theater bearing his name that, as of 2023, still endures, currently located at the Malcolm Shabazz Cultural Center at 102 West 116th Street at Malcolm X Boulevard (Lenox Avenue).[24][25]'[26]
Anecdotes
In the early days at the Nest Club, gangsters would come in at three o'clock in the morning and they'd hang there until 10 or 11 o'clock in the next day . . . sitting there and requesting numbers and passing out money.
The sole purpose of these clubs, according to Malcolm X, was 'to entertain and jive the white night crowd to get their money'[28]
Gallery
- 1925 photo taken at the Vox Phonograph Studio, Berlin — Sam Wooding and His Orchestra; seated, left to right: Tommy Ladnier (trumpet), John Warren (tuba) (behind), Sam Wooding (piano/leader), Willie Lewis (alto sax, bari sax, vocals), George Howe (drums). Standing, left to right: Herb Flemming (trombone), Eugene Sedric (clarinet, tenor sax), Johnny Mitchell (banjo), Bobby Martin (trumpet), Garvin Bushell (clarinet, alto sax, oboe), Maceo Elmer Edwards (1900–1988) (trumpet).
Other music venues in the area
- Gee-Haw Stables (1940–1945), 160 West 132nd Street, between Seventh Avenue (Adam Clayton Powell, Jr., Boulevard) and Lenox Avenue (Malcolm X Boulevard)
- Pod's and Jerry's (1925–1948), 133rd Street
- Renaissance Ballroom & Casino (1924–1979), 2341–2349 Adam Clayton Powell Jr. Boulevard, on the east-side of the boulevard between 137th and 138th Streets
- Savoy Ballroom (1926–1958), 596 Lenox Avenue, between 140th and 141st Streets
- Smalls Paradise (1925–1980s), 2294 Seventh Avenue, at 135th Street
- St. Nick's Pub (1930s–still operating), 773 St. Nicholas Avenue, at 149th Street, in the Sugar Hill neighborhood of Harlem
Notes and references
Notes
- Following the repeal of prohibition in the United States, 52nd Street in Midtown became known as "Swing Street."
- One of Mal Frazier's sisters, Hattie Naomi Frazier (1890–1974) was married to Russell Eccles Talmadge Walker (1890–1923), a son of Maggie L. Walker (1864–1934), the first African American woman to charter a bank and serve as its president in the United States.
- Dickie Wells (né Richard Wells; 1907–1909) had been a dancer in a trio known as Mordecai, Wells, and Taylor – Jimmy Mordecai and Ernest Taylor (died 1934).
- George Howe (aka George Washington Howe; né Robert Washington Howe; 1892–1936), drummer, led the house band at the Nest Club beginning 1927, when Teddy Hill was in the band. Luis Russell replaced Howe in 1928. Howe had been the drummer for Sam Wooding. Howe and fellow musician George E. Dyer (1884–1936), both, in the mid-1930s living in Glens Falls, drowned November 23, 1936, in the Champlain Canal, near Fort Ann, after a car driven by Howe submerged in the canal as a result of side-swiping a 10-ton truck (U.S. Class 6) towing another 10-ton truck on Comstock Road. They were returning from a gig at a nightclub operated by Maxie Gordon (né Maxime Godon Gordon; 1891–1956) – two miles from Whitehall. They had left Hudson Falls at 1:30 am and were followed by Jimmie Gillespie and banjoist Percy Richardson. Trombonist Benny Morton (1907–1985), also at the gig, decided at the last minute not to ride with Howe and Dyer. Howe was buried at Cypress Hills National Cemetery, Brooklyn.
- Marjorie Sipp (1889–1944) was a singer, acclaimed by the black press, and also by Carl Van Vechten and Donald Angus (né Evan Donald Angus; 1899–1988). Sipp made no recordings and appeared only at The Nest.
- Yeah Man, a jazz venue at 2350 Seventh Avenue, between 137th and 137th Street, across the street from the Renaissance Ballroom & Casino, became Jock's Place in the late 1930s.
- The term "rhythm singer" is more apropos with the Swing era, which began around 1933. During that period, bands commonly featured a female and male vocalist; generally one singer primarily sang straight renditions of ballads, while the other was more of a rhythm singer, someone who swung tunes. It's not clear whether Mae Barnes meant that Billie Haywood was a "hell of a rhythm singer" in the late 1920s or early 1930s, or later. [Yanow, Scott (2000). Bebop. Miller Freeman, Inc. p. 172. Retrieved April 22, 2020 – via Google Books. OCLC 47008488 (all editions)].
References
- Jazz From the Beginning, Garvin Bushell and Mark Thomas Tucker, PhD (1954–2000)
- University of Michigan Press (1989); OCLC 7380686009, ISBN 978-0-4721-0098-9
- Da Capo Press (1998); OCLC 1086479014, ISBN 0-472-10098-X (paperback)
- Steppin' on the Blues: The Visible Rhythms of African American Dance, by Jacqui Malone, University of Illinois Press (1996), p. 89; OCLC 470404456
- Locations of Literary Modernism: Region and Nation in British and American Modernist Poetry, Alex Davis, Lee Margaret Jenkins (eds.), Cambridge University Press (2000), p. 236; OCLC 7334295789, ISBN 0521780322
- Rhythm For Sale, by Grant Harper Reid, CreateSpace (self published) (2013); OCLC 851536101, ISBN 978-0-6156-7828-3
- "Selected Observations From the Harlem Jazz Scene" (masters thesis – Jazz History and Research: Lewis Porter, PhD, academic advisor), by Jonah Iyeli Jonathan (born 1987), Rutgers University (May 2015); OCLC 957473268
- Voices of the Jazz Age: Profiles of Eight Vintage Jazzmen, by Chip Deffaa, University of Illinois Press (1990, 1992), p. 17; OCLC 985530584
- "Denne Bande Frække Sorte Slubberter – Sam Wooding i København, 1925" (in Swedish), by Erik Wiedemann (de) (1930–2001), Musik und Forskning, 3, København 1977, pps. 113–127; ISSN 0903-188X
- "Sam Wooding and the Chocolate Kiddies at the Thalia-Theater in Hamburg 28th July, 1925 to 24th August, 1925," by Berhard H. Behncke, Storyville, Vol. 60, August–September 1975, p. 217–219 (accessible via National Jazz Archive at link)
- Hear Me Talkin' to Ya: The Story of Jazz by the Men Who Made It (Section III, Chapter 11, "Danny Barker" and "Rex Stewart"), Nat Shapiro (1922–1983) and Nat Hentoff (1925–2017) (eds.), Rinehart & Company (1955), pps. 196–197, 207–208; OCLC 910397413
- The Duke Ellington Reader, by Duke Ellington, edited by Mark Tucker, Oxford University Press (1993); ISBN 0-1950-9391-7
- "People You Should Know . . . Billy Butler," by Marguerite P. Cartwright (1910–1986), Pittsburgh Courier, January 14, 1956, p. 13 (accessible via Newspapers.com; subscription required)
- "Obituary: William H. Butler," New York Daily News, March 25, 1981, p. 70 (accessible via Newspapers.com; subscription required)
- "Willie Lynch, Drummer – Biography and Discography, 1899–1930," Americana Music Productions, January 28, 2019 (retrieved April 20, 2020)
- "William H. Butler papers, 1917–1982," New York Public Library, Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture, Manuscripts, Archives and Rare Books Division; OCLC 122363992
- New York Age, Vol. 51, No. 14, December 5, 1936
- "Brother of Cop Drowns Upstate – Two Musicians Die When Car Runs Into Canal After Accident," by Elsie M. Chambers, p. 3, col. 6 (of 8)
- "Out of Town News and Other Personal Items – Albany: Deaths," p. 12, col. 5 (of 8)
- Billie Holiday: Wishing On the Moon, by Donald Clarke, Da Capo Press (2000, 2002); OCLC 818854801, ISBN 978-0-3068-1136-4, ISBN 978-0-7867-3087-2 (e-book)
- Black Women of the Harlem Renaissance Era (re: "Sylvester, Hannah"), Lean'tin L. Bracks, PhD, Jessie Carney Smith, PhD (eds.), Rowman & Littlefield (2014; 2017), p. 211; OCLC 1005905093
- "Danny Barker, Nea Jazz Master (1991)" (transcript of oral interview); Danny Barker (interviewee); Michael White (born 1954) (interviewer), Archives Center, National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution, Date: July 21–23, 1992, pps. 48–49 (of 114 pps.)
- The Splendid Drunken Twenties: Selections From the Daybooks, 1922–1930, by Carl Van Vechten, University of Illinois Press (2003), p. 87, note 2; ISBN 0-2520-2848-1
- The Airwaves of New York: Illustrated Histories of 156 AM Stations in the Metropolitan Area, 1921–1996 (re: "WFBH"), by Bill Jaker, Frank Sulek, Peter Kanz, McFarland & Company (1998) p. 70; ISBN 978-0-7864-3872-3
- "Cabaret News," by John E. Frazier, New York Age, April 11, 1925, p. 6 (accessible via Newspapers.com; subscription required)
- Dry Manhattan: Prohibition in New York City, Michael Aloysius Lerner, PhD, Harvard University Press (2007), p. 223; OCLC 436296861, ISBN 978-0-674-02432-8Note: Lerner's book was the subject of his PhD dissertation, "Dry Manhattan: Class, Culture, and Politics in Prohibition-Era New York City, 1919–1933," New York University (1999); OCLC 914809119; Lerner, since 2010 (and as of April 2020), has been the Principal of Bard High School Early College, Manhattan
- Automats, Taxi Dances, and Vaudeville: Excavating Manhattan's Lost Places of Leisure, by David Freeland, New York University Press (2009); OCLC 929271524
- "On & Off Broadway," Routes, Vol. 1, No. 4, January 1978, p. 22
- Directory of Blacks in the Performing Arts (1st ed.), by Edward Mapp, Scarecrow Press (1978), p. 28; OCLC 644261985 (borrowable online via Internet Archive)"Bey, La Rocque – 'Harlem's Godfather of Dance,'" p. 28
- "Larocque Norvel Wright (1937–1990)," U.S. Social Security Applications and Claims Index, 1936–2007 (accessible via Ancestry.com)
- Ride, Red, Ride: The Life of Henry 'Red' Allen, by John Chilton, Cassell (1999); Bloomsbury Publishing (2000), pps. 35, 49; OCLC 1058225868
- The Birth of Bebop, by Scott DeVeaux, University of California Press (2009), p. 228; OCLC 552432091
External links
- Collage of Images From The Nest, a Club at West 133rd Street, New York City at the New York Public Library, Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture – Archives and Rare Books Division (alternate source – Internet Archive), original Hotel Tattler
- "Interior of the Nest Club," New York Public Library, Digital Collections